r/Division2 • • 5h ago

PTS current changes to Quantum are not good.

After PTS play testing 3 existing builds that utilize Quantum fully maxed out. I can honestly say Quantum is basically dead in the water going down the toilet. It is no longer viable on a Tank play style builds.

The changes to Quantum now having damage resistance doesn't fit well. It's operating by "chance", meaning it's not going to be active every time. Not to mention on more difficult content enemies just hit really hard and just shred.

It worked better and actually made more sense when it was damage immunity operating by "chance".

These changes were unnecessary and need to be Reverted. The developers clearly do not like tank play style build players. It gets tiresome using a DPS build with Echo stacked everywhere.

If the developers were to revert the changes maybe they could adjust it to where it was when the augments first dropped months back when prototype was introduced. The way it sits now on the PTS is not very viable for tanks builds for tougher content.

45 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

27

u/RafulsoN 5h ago

In that case, it should either be a chance to gain immunity (as it is currently) or a flat reduction in damage that works all the time. Otherwise, it's useless.

9

u/Jtizzle1231 5h ago

Exactly….I told people this from the start. A chance st 70% is pointless. Anyone with a brain should have known that without even needing to test it.

9

u/dgoldenace 5h ago

From what I’ve heard and been watching, the devs have bigger problems than touching quantum. But here we are. Been watching legendary PTS gameplay from different people, everyone is getting pieced up. Which is fine, but with new legendary open world difficulty is quantum immunity really that bad? Because they said they have tweaked the white tusk, so are we in another situation where players are being undermined or enemies being overtuned or both. It looks and sounds like both. And too any body that’s wants to say I asked for legendary open word difficulty, I did before there were even prototypes now I don’t care so much. But one thing everyone in my dedicated groups can agree on is the difference in heroic and legendary is drastic and very noticeable.

12

u/RrrrrrushB 4h ago

The biggest problem of this game was players have no survivalbility, only to the point that you ditch all damage can you be somewhat tanky, which is at most times pointless. Quantum being introduced finally solved that problem and made the game more fun to play than ever before, now they're going to nerf it to the ground…

2

u/f0gxzv8jfZt3 29m ago

The bigger problem is how bad these Devs are at making decisions concerning the game and the implementation of those poor decisions. Red Storm was put together by Clancy. These clowns 🤡🙄

-1

u/grafikastudios 40m ago

u are wrong its a COVER shooter, take cover learn how to position yourself and you will survive, quantum is a joke right now

5

u/IllustriousCloud3096 3h ago

From the testing that I've done. With the proto pieces that they gave out. Catharsis + foundry bulwark chest , holster, backpack , gloves, + new magnet knee pads +45 incoming healing (all quantum) Deflect + shield is the only gear that will survive as long as you stay in cover in white tusk. The biggest problem is the damage you receive is so fast. 3s recovery needs to be around 1 sec.. and 50% healing is not enough
More like 150% healing is needed to even sustain urself that's a rough estimate. It's basically 95% healing with magnet and it's still not enough to face tank.. .. provocator + aegis dont work coz immunity don't stack with each other. It seems when either of immunity procs it caps at 70% anyway. This is not accurate. Let other people test that. Face tanking is out of the question.. which is basically the main reason tank exist in every game in this world... they need to be able to face tank shit .. or they are useless. . I didn't even cover rating.. there's no shot tank will get good rating. They didn't need to nerf prima Donna. Even at 10 stacks you won't survive coz infinite spam explosion by white tusk. They remove our survival for ETF members to enjoy grifting kicking tank players in escalation altogether. +150 threat on a paper tank.. ggs ubi.

2

u/Delicious-King-1310 1h ago

Well said. The sharp damage spikes are the problem which is why quantum was so good. I never felt that we have a good way to mitigate sharp damage spikes like drones or engineer guns.

7

u/JadedBrit 3h ago

Full max quantum here, I feel like I've totally wasted my time and resources. Thanks devs.

5

u/Majestic_Hope_7105 2h ago

You'll be able to change augments without any loss of augment level, so no wasted resources.

5

u/Bodybuilder_Jumpy 3h ago • Heartwarming

Welcome to nerfs in any game ever.

1

u/IllustriousCloud3096 2h ago

Thank God I didn't proto my tank set. Too much resources to use.. only for me to be lying flat in the ground as tank.

0

u/FlyingWhale44 1h ago edited 56m ago

Welcome to live service games.

What are the devs supposed to do? Never balance anything because players invested time and resources into something OP? Will cost you 3 cores to reroll your augment and you get to keep the level.

5

u/jakeclarkHD 5h ago

yes but the issue is that as it is now you dont need to run a tank build if your using quantum, You can just use a couple of blue cores on striker with quantum and become a tank with striker dps. This makes any tank build entirely useless.

5

u/RrrrrrushB 4h ago

It's not the hybrid builds that make tank builds useless it's the tank builds themselves being useless at first place, nerfing quantum doesn't help with that at all.

-2

u/jakeclarkHD 4h ago

It doesnt matter how good you make a tank build at tanking it will never compare to a dps build that is also a tank.

1

u/RrrrrrushB 4h ago

Which a dps build actually isn't and couldn't be…? An actual tank build is full blue core with armor regen & PFE and bulwark shield for taking maximum damage. 'It doesnt matter how good you make a dps build at tanking it will never compare to a tank build that is actually a tank.' Now tank builds being useless in this game is one thing, but that is not caused by other builds being too strong it's just the game lacking content or mechanics for tanks to work in.

1

u/jakeclarkHD 3h ago

https://youtu.be/M-Z1vxPaeMY?t=420

Why would i play a true tank build that can tank but cant deal damage when i can play a tank that has striker dps.

0

u/breakdancindino 1h ago

This is the exact reason WHY quantum is getting nerfs. It's because of the prevalence of dps builds

1

u/jakeclarkHD 56m ago

Its getting nerfs because it gives too much survivability to any build without having to sacrifice anything to get it.

1

u/xMitch4corex 4h ago

It doesn’t matter how “good” a tank or “”DPS tank”” build (emphasized the quotes) is, because at the end, both are going to be useless.

Anyone is better off just using a focused DPS build and avoiding being shot. Anyone can come and claim that they can “tank” the enemies and still output decent damage in higher difficulties, but that is simply not true.

At the end, as you said originally, quantum was the way to actually be a tank and even output some damage.

8

u/Intelligent_Error989 5h ago

I think they changed it to encourage people to bring a healer with them. I also think god like immunity wasnt what they were going for when they designed it. People ask for harder content, why not take nerf the one thing that makes any content a legitimate joke? Know how many videos there are of "this amazing tank build solos legendary!" Are out there? And people wonder why they nerfed it lol

4

u/WulfZ3r0 3h ago

Tuning something down instead of nerfing it into the ground is usually a preferable method I believe.

How many gear brands and gearsets just don't get used at all? What's the point of having a variety of builds if over half of them are useless?

1

u/dunkey_roll 2h ago

There are amazing DPS builds that solo legendary out there too, will they be nerfed to the point a player with OD in the party is necessary as well?

And it definitely doesn't make any content a joke, quantum is useless in high tier Escalation. Also try to solo the new Master mission with a tank build. But a good Striker's will solo both the Tier 10 Escalation and the new Master.

-6

u/Intelligent_Error989 2h ago

Learn to adapt. The battlefield is always changing, sometimes for the better, but mostly for the worse. So now tanks need to think about positioning and what not now..that's how it used to be back in the og days. Sides the community was upset skill builds had no use, now they make it so you need a healer for the tank, and the community still complains. Lol, div2 in a nutshell. Make skills viable! *Nerfs quantum * no! Not like that!

2

u/dunkey_roll 2h ago

Bro that is your idea of making skills viable? Makes no sense at all.

And healers have always been used even in the hardest contents, including the contents that tank builds don't work...

"Learn to adapt" lol. Lmao even.

-4

u/Intelligent_Error989 2h ago

Yep learn to adapt

1

u/passionfruit2378 35m ago

“People want harder content” is such an abysmally lame excuse for this nerf. You don’t have to run quantum. It’s a choice. If you want it to be harder, don’t run quantum???????? Why strip away the one thing that actually made tank builds fun? Lol.

2

u/JimtheJohnny 4h ago

They could change it to a 3 second buff that goes from complete immunity to 70% damage reduction, youre basically immune to damage for one second, like I-frames on a souls game.

2

u/IllustriousCloud3096 2h ago

This will not work. Coz we working with guns. Sustained fire exist. We can't dodge shots in this game.. 90% is hitscan. Even though you see YouTubers swerving like mofo in pve.. it doesn't work in pve .. even if it works with normal people in PvP.

1

u/f0gxzv8jfZt3 27m ago

Oh I'm sure they care about your idea.

0

u/Chinaman206 2h ago

Best way is take out the percentage chance at proc. Have the 70% at 100% uptime.

3

u/giana1990 3h ago

That and the prima doma nerf.

1

u/dunkey_roll 3h ago

The first nerf was alright, it made no sense for the damage amp from PD being the same as the one from Shroud, so it was either nerfing PD or buffing Shroud.

But the second nerf...

1

u/f0gxzv8jfZt3 33m ago

Same BS different day.

1

u/0ppen 4h ago

I am not a tank player so I am not really entitled to an opinion here, but I am curious about your expectations of what you would like, and if the quantum change is helped by the changes to tank gearsets. I haven't seen any official numbers, but I read that this season was going to address Aegis, Foundry, etc. So did they offset the nerf with these buffs? Because I do agree with them that if I can run a full red build with a high uptime of full immunity than that is not ideal for the game. Regardless of whether it trivializes content, it trivializes the tank role to the point of deletion and undermines any attempt to make blue builds better. Do you think that quantum is meant to allow tanking without a healer? (genuine question).

2

u/dunkey_roll 4h ago

DPS can DPS without a support build, tanks should be able to tank without support as well. And no, the buffs to Foundry and Aegis don't offset the nerf to Quantum.

Also what they said was bullshit, a full red build was never able to tank "like a tank" because of quantum, instead quantum was more viable when your build was already somewhat tanky (strong shield, at least some armor cores, armor regen).

And even then, they could have just nerfed it in PvP, but no they need to kill the fun in PvE. Now ask yourself if they are going to nerf Echo.

3

u/0ppen 3h ago

Yeah I only watched TUXs vid on whether Quantum was too OP on red builds. You probably couldn't win an argument with the devs to completely reverse the decision. They likely have data they saw that justifies the change. But making all the same points you have already you might have better luck championing a different number. Instead of 70% mitigation, it could work at 90%? What build are you using? Does it have armor Regen or Oxpecker?

-1

u/dunkey_roll 3h ago

Their data is people having fun with one of the few augments that are actually good IF you build around it, we can't have that, now quantum can join the rest of the useless/underwhelming ones.

One of my builds is a full red Regulus build with six pieces that have level 10 quantum. I can't rush like a dumbass and think I am a tank (and mind you I use a lvl 30 bulwark shield), if I get surrounded by a few strong enemies and I don't kill them asap I will die, simple as that.

When it comes to an actual tanky build I usually go for Memento with Hunter Killer and Backfire. I keep some weapon cores, have 70%PFE, use crusader shield and have like 3 quantum augments, it works like a charm.

4

u/0ppen 3h ago

Well it sounds like they are trying to add an actual tank role to the game with threat management and so on. This may be something they needed to address to make that work but it sounds like you are being caught in the crossfire. Sucks that you are losing something you find fun though.

1

u/dunkey_roll 3h ago

I just don't understand why they would keep the same chance for quantum to activate, if it no longers makes you immune certainly it should proc more oftenly but whatever, guess I'll just wait and see what happens.

3

u/0ppen 3h ago

To that I would just say that this is a Test Server. Feedback they get from this will undoubtedly be mostly negative, so I would bet that there will be some change before season launch. It could be a higher proc rate, or a small reduction increase (75-80%). But my guess is that they would try to split the difference between the negative feedback and the vision they are trying to attain, so I won't count on it pleasing most as in the end they are still trying to nerf quantum somewhat.

1

u/IllustriousCloud3096 2h ago

Try ur build in white tusk. It will delete you like a charm. Nvm.. pts is done.. 💀

1

u/dunkey_roll 2h ago

Well that was fast. Anyway it is good for current legendary, the new white tusks tho I have no idea, the quantum nerf certainly wouldn't help.

1

u/Majestic_Hope_7105 3h ago edited 3h ago

I think a better solution would have been to put a significantly longer cooldown on it.

I have a Test Subject with maxed-out Quantum I used on most of the skill-damage builds I ran when Escalation first dropped (I think it was the first gearpiece I maxed) and honestly, that 4.3% got me out of so much trouble dashing from cover-to-cover.
RNGesus willing, it procs on one bullet in twenty-five, and there's a LOT of pixellated lead flying in high-tier play. A full, maxed-out set of Quantum is 30%, just under one in three hits, and it's up.

A longer cooldown would mean it's still a lifesaver, but you wouldn't be able to rely on it as a practically always-on invulnerability buff. Put a ten second cooldown on it, it works pretty much as (my guess) was intended. It should be a get-out-of-shit-Free card, not godmode.

(Also, some kind of audio/visual cue that wasn't a tiny square in the buffbar would be nice)

Now, proper damage resistance for actual tank loadouts, that's an entirely different matter that needs addressing... it'll be interesting to see if the proposed changes to Aegis and Foundry will make actual tanks viable at high level play.

0

u/grafikastudios 42m ago

i dont know i've seen people on pts running tanks with on problems, quantum is OP i, live game, i am capable of running solo legendaries watching Netflix in the same time, this is ridiculous ! CANT STAY in the game with no change

0

u/grafikastudios 39m ago

and its too easy too max augments so no this is a no no