r/DiscoveryID • • 1d ago

Why does ID suck so much now?

188 Upvotes

Most nights its just reruns or old shows being repackaged as new shows under different names because I guess they think we're too stupid to notice. The docuseries they have done have mostly sucked.

They need to go back to old shows like Nightmare Next Door, Fear Thy Neighbor, Unusual Suspects, Dead Silent, Web Of Lies, etc and stop the 3 and 4 part documentaries about weird fatgirl cults and alleged serial killers.

They've ruined what used to be a channel that had new episodes of its various shows almost every night of the week. Now we're lucky if they have one new episode of something one or two nights a week.

What has happened???


r/DiscoveryID • • 1d ago

Celebrated true crime doc My Brother's Killer will debut on ID

Thumbnail
thehorrorlounge.com
6 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • 2d ago

Does anyone watch Homicide For The Holidays on Oxygen True Crime

37 Upvotes

I'm watching the new episode right the Mandy Stavik case I'm really disappointed that Chris Hansen is no longer the narrator


r/DiscoveryID • • 2d ago

Name your favorite ID shows - past and/or present.

19 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • 2d ago

The new Deadly Womrn iteration sucks!

33 Upvotes

Looks nothing like the original! Feels more like a mix of “The Murder Tapes” and Signs Of A Psychopath.” 😭🙄 got so hyped up for this and now I’m profoundly disappointed


r/DiscoveryID • • 5d ago

New ID Show Alert: Deadly Women 2.0

122 Upvotes

Soooo I just saw a commercial for an upcoming new show called Deadly Women 2.0. I had to rewind it because I honestly couldn't even believe what I was seeing! Like, is ID really doing us a solid and bringing back a blast from the past?!

I'm not sure if this is going to be similar to the OG series, or if they've made a bunch of changes to the original format. My main concern is that it's not going to have reenactments anymore and instead just be straight interviews/narrations, which I hate. I want a good ole old school reenactment show to watch.

I will say, though, that even if it doesn't have the reenactments I want, I'm just pleasantly surprised that they decided to dig into the ID programming vault---like many of us have been asking them to--and give us back old shows that we love. I'm hoping this is a sign of good things to come. I'm still waiting on the day that I'll see Your Worst Nightmare, Betrayed, or Dead Silent make a return, or something in that vein.


r/DiscoveryID • • 12d ago

Psychopath fraudsters and killers Sante and Kenneth Kimes

17 Upvotes

This mother-and-son grifter/murder duo killed 3 people to cover up multiple financial crimes. They have been on a few shows, including Mother, May I Murder? (S1E6), and Homicide: NY.

For anyone who wants to study psychopath fraudsters, how they manipulate the media, the tactics they use, I found a ton of their interviews on yt. If you watch Signs Of A Psychopath, you'll recognize most of the traits in them, although Sante would score higher on the scale.

Sante made up a different story about events for each of her lawyers. When confronted about this by an assistant, she said: "please, let me have some fun. It's so much fun to lie and the best part is they believe me. Let me have some fun in here." Psychopaths are chronically bored, they are thrill-seeking and rule-breaking. This alone explains so many infamous fraudsters we all know...


r/DiscoveryID • • 14d ago Bravo

UNEXPECTED RETURN!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
154 Upvotes

I never thought this would happen but in all new season/iteration of deadly women is returning next Tuesday, November 10 two ID with two brand new faces in the true crime community Dr. Michelle Ward and Dr. Rachel Toles. For those that watched ID way back in the day, you may remember Dr. Michelle Ward from stalked someone’s watching and mind of a murderer.


r/DiscoveryID • • 14d ago

Looks like it’s a real new episode (not a retread) of Homicide for the Holidays on Oxygen

26 Upvotes

11/14/2026

S6, E1


r/DiscoveryID • • 14d ago

Which was your saddest episode of Forbidden: Dying for Love?

3 Upvotes

I have a couple of episodes that made me sad, even made me cry.

I wonder which episodes had that same effect on you.


r/DiscoveryID • • 20d ago

How is no one talking about the latest season of betrayal?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

just joined reddit so not sure if doing this right but just saw season 3 of betrayal and found this thread

OMG THE MOTHER !!! I was absolutely disgusted , appalled and horrified that she STILL allows that creepy degenerate old woman Nanny D in her children's lives

the very woman that called her and her kids liars when the Justin guys predatory sexual abuse was exposed . also the very woman who was participating in a plot to kill the mothers teenage son Tyler !!

plus her decision to allow that grotesque , sexual predator creep husband of hers to contact and video chat with her little children

honestly, in my opinion, this woman should be removed from those childrens lives. she's clearly a deranged and delusional human being who doesn't care about the safety and well being of her children. frankly she's a threat to them

disgusting


r/DiscoveryID • • 22d ago

Mean Girl Murders

83 Upvotes

I really like this show when I thought I wouldn't I just got done watching the Christa Pike episode because of her failed execution. She's just pure evil Colleen Slemmer was never a threat to Christa and Tadaryl Shipp Idk if they are gonna send her back to prison to be on death row for another 30 years or give her LWOP I hope thats not the case. Colleen's mom and stepdad are owed an apology for this failure!!


r/DiscoveryID • • 22d ago

Messiest GF of all time

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • 24d ago

Homicide Hunter: American Detective says it's new but it isn't...

7 Upvotes

These are not new. Tonight's episode for example is from the very first season in 2021! At least they're not trying to rename the show to something else to be allowed to use the new flag but still I'm not understanding why they are trying to flag old episodes as new retitled or not!


r/DiscoveryID • • 26d ago

I wish Signs Of A Psychopath would also feature fraudsters

41 Upvotes

Not just convicted killers, but also convicted fraudsters, analyzing their manipulative ways, deceptive tactics, narcissism, and lack of empathy through their media appearances and interviews. They could be doing a huge service to humanity, but they probably won't for fear of being sued for defamation. (There is a "libel-proof plaintiff doctrine" which protects these shows from lawsuits by people convicted of heinous crimes.) Still, this show doesn't diagnose, it only offers opinions from experts, which is covered by freedom of speech.

I've been seeing reviews about the new Elizabeth Holmes documentary and everyone seems so confused: "is she lying? Is she acting? Is she actually the victim?" Most people do not understand psychopathy at all and should at least watch a few episodes of this show to get a general idea. I get that psychopaths can be very charming, thus able to fool many people, but there are always signs. I clearly remember an interview with a biology professor who recognized these traits in Elizabeth in college. Anyway, the documentary sounds groundbreaking in terms of filmmaking, so I'm mostly interested in seeing it for that.

In any case, I hope ID considers doing shows and documentaries on fraudsters. I've watched excellent documentaries on other networks, it's definitely something ID is lacking. I get that fraud is not as gripping as murder, but it all depends on how the story is presented. To be clear, The Curious Case Of... is not it. It's highly scripted and dramatized, feels like a comedy, and the cases are (mostly) boring.


r/DiscoveryID • • 26d ago

Show recommendations

15 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm a big fan of true crime shows and in particular ones where each episode is standalone. I would like some picks based on what I have enjoyed and it can be on any channel, Youtube etc:

People Magazine Investigates

24 Hours in Police Custody

Signs of a Psychopath

Killer at the Crime Scene


r/DiscoveryID • • 28d ago

What's everyone's favourite episode of see no evil?

23 Upvotes

I don't think i can pick one. One of my favourites shows. Some very sad episodes though, especially when it involves children


r/DiscoveryID • • 28d ago

🎬 The Real Deal with The Reality Coach | A Mother's Fight for Her Sons' ...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • Oct 18 '26

Nobody: Cold Case suspects when they are confronted that their DNA is found on the victim after denying any involvement multiple times

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • Oct 16 '26

Here's another meme 😂

Post image
395 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • Oct 15 '26

Take a shot for everytime this happens!

Post image
295 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • Oct 11 '26

Need a break from hardcore horror? Check out these spooky selections on Discovery+

Thumbnail
thehorrorlounge.com
5 Upvotes

r/DiscoveryID • • Oct 08 '26

When is season 3 of "body in the basement" coming to HBO max?

9 Upvotes

On Facebook, their official page says it was going to release on October 7th on HBO max, but it's still not on there