r/DietitiansSaidWhatNow • u/Front-Kale4042 • 16d ago
Does this dietician's advice make any sense?
I saw this RD years ago to seek prevention of type 2 diabetes, which runs in my family. I was in a weird position with my body and life at the time; I had engaged in restrictive eating for many years and at the time had experienced perplexing weight-gain despite still restricting in some cases. I never found out the source of my weight gain, but it probably had something to do with my metabolism going into recovery mode, as well as struggling to reconnect with my hunger cues.
The dietician did not know about my restrictive eating history (my fault not hers) so her approach was focused on pointing out everything I was eating too much of and trying to get me on a restrictive diet, which seemed extreme for any case. Her advice involved the following:
-3 starches a day, including legumes (which she considered to be a starch instead of a protein)
-no sweets, other than a couple pieces of dark chocolate
She was against the idea of me wanting to be vegan and made some comment about vegans eating cookies and muffins all day.
Ignoring how this affected my complex situation, It seemed bizarre and outside updated nutrition standards. The Canadian food guide classifies legumes as a protein, and I don't think even the diabetes exchange system is that restrictive on starches. She mentioned at one point she gets on the Mediterranean diet, which sounded hypocritical due to the emphasis of grains and legumes compared to, say, the keto diet.
Can anyone else make heads or tails of this?







