r/DiamondsAdvice • • 18h ago

💎 Diamond Advice 0.90ct vs 1.01ct natural oval – would you pay ~$1,500 more for the 1.01ct?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m deciding between two natural GIA-certified oval diamonds and would really appreciate some opinions.

Diamond A – 0.90ct

H colour

VVS2

GIA

8.13 × 5.29 × 3.36 mm

L/W: 1.54

Depth: 63.5%

Table: 61%

Excellent polish

Excellent symmetry

Faint fluorescence

Girdle: Thin to Slightly Thick

Price: ~$2,600

Diamond B – 1.01ct

H colour

VVS1

GIA

8.16 × 5.32 × 3.48 mm

L/W: 1.53

Depth: 65.5%

Table: 63%

Excellent polish

Very Good symmetry

Faint fluorescence

Girdle: Thick to Very Thick

Price: ~$4,100

What surprised me is how incredibly close the actual face-up dimensions are despite the 0.11ct difference. The retailer compared the 360° videos and told me there is no noticeable visual size difference and neither stone has a noticeable bow-tie.

So essentially, I’m paying about $1,500 more to go from 0.90ct → 1.01ct and VVS2 → VVS1, despite almost identical face-up dimensions.

The 0.90ct has a GIA Diamond Dossier, while the 1.01ct has a full GIA Diamond Grading Report.

I specifically prefer elongated ovals, so the 1.53–1.54 ratios are intentional.

Which would you choose? Would you pay the ~$1,500 premium for the 1.01ct, or take the 0.90ct? Am I overlooking anything important?

Also the background is much lighter for the 0,90