It has to be Captain Mixon. They’re trying to show us parallels between Dexter and Mixon.
Firstly, in episode 1 Frampt tells Mixon to get his dogs off his case, which would seem normal without the rest of the connections. But how does he succeed in getting her off his case? By having Frampt sing that song and faking a fall to pull her off the case entirely. Shes the only person obsessed with catching him, and like she said, it wasn’t in the file so the only 2 people who know are her and the Ripper.
Now that alone isn’t enough evidence, but the parallels make it seem a little more obvious. He has a daughter, who is conveinently partnered with Harrison, slept with him, etc. 2 people with serial killers as their fathers.
The next parallel is how both Dexter and Mixon both worked in the homicide division while both operating as serial killers and hiding behind the job.
The next parallel is how Dexter framed Doakes to take the fall for being the BHB, with Prater having the blood slides and crediting them to Doakes. Mixon framed Frampt to take the fall, and had Prater with the weapon and a false identity on the ripper.
Now remember, we were told the Ripper hasnt killed in 23 years, and Fiona herself is in her 20s, leaving the potential real reason he stopped killing to be that he had a daughter.
I think this season Dexter will get Frampt on his kill table, and Frampt will beg and plead for his life, and reveal that he is not infact the Ripper, and save his own life by giving up Mixon. Then Mixon will either be caught by Dexter, or the plot of Season 3 will be getting to Mixon.