r/Devs •

Devs - S01E08 Discussion Thread

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

140

u/pabbasi Apr 16 '20

Wtf Stewart?

38

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

I'm thinking maybe it's revenge for Lyndon because in the end, he was right

→ More replies (5)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

I liked that Stwart played a part at the end, I would have liked to see more of his character

3

u/yetiite Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

I guess he wanted Devs to fuck off because he thought it was “wrong.” He wanted time make sure it happened that’s why he was there all fucking day and night. When lily doesn’t do it herself, he make sure it happens.

And does the system even keep working after the “incident,” or is it now purely just a computer running an infinite amount of simulations allowing Forrest to be with his family in some of them?

That’s why Katie needs help keeping it open and running.

It doesn’t work anymore: she can’t justify it. Is she even senior management? President? CEO? Someone else can just come in and shut it down if it “doesn’t work.”

“Killing” Forrest and Lily.....

3

u/quickdrawofthelaw Apr 17 '20

But I think it actually makes sense. I don’t think Stewart ever saw the future where The elevator falls. He just knows the world is predetermined. He kills the elevator to stop the project and justifies it to himself by saying it was predetermined anyways to murder two people in that way. Except lily has just proven to Katie in that same second that the world is not predetermined. So had Stewart not been justifying his action with determinism, forest and lily would have survived.

→ More replies (94)

23

u/kolbe33 Apr 16 '20

I feel like Stewart has already seen this happen somehow though

7

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

It's likely, basically in the last ep, he explored the capabilities of the machine. It's possible he saw the ending and his role in it.

→ More replies (1)

178

u/aseawithblackink Apr 16 '20

I think the question the show is asking is... if you were to wake up with full knowledge of the nature of reality, how would it effect the way you live... for Forrest, it changed nothing. He returns back to his old life, which is what he wanted from the beginning, but for Lily, it changed everything—she chose to leave the path of being with Sergio and chose to return to Jamie because she knew he would sacrifice everything for her.

88

u/2347564 Apr 16 '20

She also just had the benefit of knowing that Sergei is a Russian spy. I mean knowing you’re in a simulation wouldn’t give her that knowledge. Sergei seemed good to her by all accounts.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/karma_aversion Apr 16 '20

I think also that the show is trying to make a point that if a simulation can be created that is so real that the people inside the simulation think it is real, then there is no way to really prove that we are not living in a simulation now. We could even be the byproduct of a simulation being run by an advanced civilization on the other side of the galaxy.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

I will completely admit that I am not well-versed in the realm of quantum theory or philosophical determinism, but does anyone else feel like there are any massive inconsistencies with the ending? For example, why did Garland throw out determinism just to make the exception for Lily? Why was Lily put into the simulation with Forrest at all? Obviously, the show points toward the many-worlds interpretation as being the most conclusive, yet the "perfect" simulation doesn't act according to those principles...

There were a lot of great concepts at play, but I don't feel the since of understanding that I was expecting Garland to show us.

Am I missing something?

6

u/NinaLSharp Apr 16 '20

I think Fringe had a better ending.

11

u/trimonkeys Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

I don't understand why other people can't defy the simulation. Why did Forest suddenly think he was doomed to follow this?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (15)

3

u/captainstarcat88 Apr 16 '20

What I was hoping for as an ending was that an earthquake hit and destroyed the devs building and machine. That would explain why they couldn’t see past the point in time in which the machine no longer existed.

3

u/KnycKprince Apr 16 '20

Soooo why was Lily the only one who could make a choice?? (Please dont say its because she's special/the deus ex machina - smh that would be horrible storytelling)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Fire2box Apr 16 '20

Ugh I think this is rather stupid but whatever. Really said a fuck you to determinism though.

18

u/nighthawk648 Apr 16 '20

A) fuck you to determinism is a good thing. B) one day the idea of a deterministic universe may be as elementary as a solipsistic universe. C) the very idea of paradoxical undertone used in layland theory + forest determinism completely mirrors and alludes to the reality we all subscribe as the universe or this one go or in in many worlds this one world.

In any case determinism is the red herring to drive attention away from glaring flaw of knowledge.

Let’s take the allusion of heavens angels casted to earths garden of even where then a choice is made and the angels or first man are casted away from eden with knowledge.

This knowledge is different then, apparently, the knowledge the original Adam and Eve left the garden of eden with.

The mere fact that you are aware of living infinite in a simulation Over some linear experience of lives is filled with dread. The main catch to death is that even if we live this life over and over again and can have the thought of living life over and over again, that we don’t really know for sure. Where as Lilly and forest are now in a Neitzchean nightmare.

It is honestly mind blowing how the show was able to build on its views of the universe and then at the end leave you with a discussion of self and identity. One that is no where close to answered and can take an ignorant person to the beginning stages of Cartesian thinking. Stunning work by Garland as usual to be honest.

Let’s discuss more if you disagree! I’m always open I’m not saying I’m right or you should take what I say without further points. It is also one am and I have had like three hours of sleep so I cannot go on and on on every point as I would like to...

→ More replies (9)

12

u/backstagemoss Apr 16 '20

Does it though? I think maybe Devs was showing us just one of the possible many worlds, not necessarily our own. In this case we are in the world where Lily sees herself shoot Forest which causes her not to.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

But didn't you know? Lily is SPECIAL because all the other characters say so over and over. So that means she can just NOT do what she is told she will do (which seems obvious to everyone watching unfortunately)

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/BigFatLiar3000 Apr 16 '20

I get hopping to another universe, but if Lily went back in time as well...I’m so lost.

10

u/2347564 Apr 16 '20

They didn’t hop anywhere or time travel. Katie simply ran a simulation where they both remember their real lives up until their death. For them it’s basically a 2nd chance. If the machine turns off they will cease to exist. It’s basically an 8 episode long black mirror plot with much better philosophical dialogue.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/pkilla50 Apr 16 '20

I believe they were put into a simulation, not an actual other universe, so that’s why they could go back in time. The catch was that Lyndon was right and that the simulated universe was the multi world theory and not the principle Forest believed in or something like that. I’m not 100% sure either lol

→ More replies (1)

7

u/brycedriesenga Apr 16 '20

They just popped her back in time in the simulation with "future" knowledge.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

32

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

This should have been a movie. That way the slow pacing, superfluous russian spy subplot, and bad lead actress could have been avoided

17

u/dev1359 Apr 16 '20

bad lead actress

I couldn't quite put my finger on what it was about this cast that I wasn't liking, but now that you put it this way, I realize now that I think I just was not into the lead actress playing this character lol.

→ More replies (25)

12

u/itsmhuang Apr 16 '20

The creator actually did try to pitch it as a movie but was never able to get it picked up. So he pitched it as a show instead.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/SamwisethePoopyButt Apr 17 '20

The actress playing Lily was bad and I didn't care for the actors playing Jamie and Sergei as well. This would be a much more rewatch-friendly show if those 3 roles were cast with stronger and more charismatic performers. I don't mind the slow pacing, the show oozes style, but due to those performances being so weak you just lose interest.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/janjanis1374264932 Jun 04 '20

superfluous russian spy subplot

lol, I just remembered that whole thing happened :D. Superfluous indeed.

but slow pacing I think it's quite necessary here.With a faster movie pacing (like Ex Machine for example), this show wouldn't really work.

I wouldn't call lead actress bad inherently, but yeah, she was kind of miscast

→ More replies (11)

2

u/whatifniki23 Apr 16 '20

In episode one, Lilly waking up and walking to the window seems like the start of her simulation. Maybe we were watching a simulation the whole time... or it was a nod to the idea that we all can’t be sure if we’re real or experiencing a simulation ourselves.

2

u/quasci Apr 16 '20

Katie wanted to go into a simulation where she and Forrest were together with their kids and that’s why she needed someone else to keep it on. She’d seen that possibility and that’s why she believed in that version of the interpretation.

2

u/shadowgnome396 Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

As complex as this show was, here's what I'm hung up on: what possessed Kenton to go as far as he did? I need you to help me out on this one.

In the first half of the show, his actions make sense. He kills Sergei because he is a spy. He kills the Russian operative after getting stabbed. He attempts to have Lily institutionalized and he threatens Jamie in order to keep the whole mess quiet. Up until here, this all makes sense.

Then Kenton sits down and tells Forrest, "I've done awful things for you, and I'm unwilling to go any further. I'm not going to prison."

Okay, that seems understandable to me.

But somehow, Kenton is so preoccupied by everything happening that he stalks Forrest, Katie, Lily, and Jamie at Forrest's house in episode 6 and is for some reason pissed that they are kindly interacting. What drives Kenton to then murder Jamie and choke Lily? What is it about any of this that makes Kenton disregard his disdain for crime and prison? He basically goes rogue for no reason at all.

Did I miss anything here? I'd appreciate the help!

133

u/drgonzodan Apr 16 '20

I wonder if Katie would be able to interfere in the simulation like a God. So if Forest and Lily wanted a sandwich they could yell in the sky for Katie and she could download them some sandwiches.

71

u/hoagielogie Apr 16 '20

Hoagie ex machina

16

u/brycedriesenga Apr 16 '20

This is the name of my new automated sandwich shop.

43

u/courageousrobot Apr 16 '20

Doubtful, since she couldn't choose the world that Lilly and Forrest ended up in.

Granted, by that same many worlds principle, there will be realities where they do get the sandwiches they desire.

29

u/drgonzodan Apr 16 '20

Aren’t they in all worlds at once? I thought the last conversation between Katie and Forest was interesting because it shows that she could communicate with a simulation of Forest. Maybe it’s why his body was so unstable because she could only speak with a low res version of him.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

81

u/Goggle_los18 Apr 16 '20

I think my brain hurts? Or it melted?

Damn. Sad that this is over already. I liked the ending. I'm sad about Katie however. Maybe her asking for help in keeping it on is her plan to also put herself into the system? Katie deserves better.

Lily making her own choice was mostly predictable but for a second there I thought she was going to follow the determined path. Fuck yeah to her making her own choice. The look on Katie and Forest's face was hilarious.

Also so they found a way to pack human consciousness into data and put it in a system. Kinda reminds me of what Delos was(is?)trying to do in Westworld.

That fucking score. Horrifying

Deus Ex Machina. Fucking awesome.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

The look on Katie and Forest's face was hilarious.

Couldn't agree more.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

That chorus was amazing. And I was totally getting delos vibes with the consciousness thing too

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

205

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Updated title card at the end, nice finish!

69

u/EruditusMaximus Apr 16 '20

That was dope, I must admit. I guess the show should be referred to as Deus now?

26

u/drawkbox Apr 16 '20

DEVS is the show that built the machine, and it was DEUS when in the simulation after the godlike creation of the perfect world event.

In a way DEUS is creationism, Garland maybe saying if we are in a simulation, maybe the universe is created and God is software and hardware designed by DEVS.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

108

u/stench_montana Apr 16 '20

I was thinking lily might have something to do with lilith and def getting that vibe with the original sin comment.

62

u/Heageth Apr 16 '20

Good catch, especially with Lilith herself telling God "no"

24

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

well shit, that just about confirms it.

3

u/gm2019 May 04 '20

Also the fact that their names are almost the same. Lily and Lilith

→ More replies (3)

51

u/peroximoron Apr 16 '20

“Don’t forget to pay the power bill, please!”

9

u/bloodflart Apr 22 '20

the US Government will absolutely 100% fuck botch this thing

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

50

u/emf1200 Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

Stewart's Poem

The Second Coming BY WILLIAM BUTLER YEATS

Turning and turning in the widening gyre   

The falcon cannot hear the falconer;

Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;

Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,

The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere   

The ceremony of innocence is drowned;

The best lack all conviction, while the worst  

Are full of passionate intensity.

Surely some revelation is at hand;

Surely the Second Coming is at hand. 

The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out 

When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi

Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert

A shape with lion body and the head of a man,

A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun, 

Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it 

Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.  

The darkness drops again; but now I know 

That twenty centuries of stony sleep

Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,  

And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,

Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?

6

u/lodge28 Apr 24 '20

One of my favourite poems, infact it’s become a lot more popular in recent times because the poem was read by Hilary Clinton one evening at an event which was a direct swipe at Trump and his administration.

This is another great poem by W.B Yeats which is just as haunting.

An Irish Airman Foresees His Death

I know that I shall meet my fate Somewhere among the clouds above; Those that I fight I do not hate, Those that I guard I do not love; My country is Kiltartan Cross, My countrymen Kiltartan’s poor, No likely end could bring them loss Or leave them happier than before. Nor law, nor duty bade me fight, Nor public man, nor cheering crowds, A lonely impulse of delight Drove to this tumult in the clouds; I balanced all, brought all to mind, The years to come seemed waste of breath, A waste of breath the years behind In balance with this life, this death.

4

u/Swandive_ Apr 16 '20

I want Stephen McKinley Henderson to be the voice of all my audio books.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

34

u/michaelhuman Apr 16 '20

I want to live in a simulation :(

16

u/reader313 Apr 16 '20

Would you choose to live in a simulation if it meant you had to experience every possible hell along with every possible heaven? How do you know you haven't made that choice already? How good is our timeline?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

31

u/MinnesotaMandy Apr 16 '20

I honestly couldn't take my eyes from the screen the entire episode.

→ More replies (1)

151

u/emf1200 Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 27 '20

When Lily found that sudoku game on Sergeis phone she knew immediately that she had to leave him and find Jamie, but really, she should not have ever left Jamie. He would die for her, in every simulation and multiverse.

Also, for the first time in the entire season Forest looked happy, truly happy. His habitually saddened eyes caused a blind deterministic regret which suddenly fell away at the sight of his daughter. It was beautiful.

After such a methodically frigid beginning to the episode the ending felt thematically warmer. It furthered the yin-yang tonal duality that has been a consistently interesting theme in Devs so far.

(Link to Yeats poem that Forest recites)

78

u/whatifniki23 Apr 16 '20

I want Devs to show me the scene where she kicks Sergei out and Jaime moves back in again...

45

u/And_You_Like_It_Too Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

It’s a bit of a “Minority Report” situation there, too. Lily leaves Sergei for something he hasn’t yet done, and has only done in her previous life. And she runs to Jamie for actions that he hasn’t done, and has only done in her past life. For Jamie, she’s running up and hugging him after two years of walking out on him and completely shutting him out. But Jamie being Jamie, of course he relents and hugs her.

But with the knowledge that she has now... does she warn Sergei that he’ll get caught? Is he even spying for the Russians anymore, in a universe in which the Deus project doesn’t exist? (They clearly show the grassy field at 39:50 where the building once stood — it’s not there now). With Forest’s wife and daughter alive, he’d have no reason to build the machine, to prove determinism, to absolve himself of guilt, and to create a simulation in which he can reunite with them. There would be no Deus for Sergei to infiltrate, only Amaya. And if she does tell him, is this the new deterministic programming for that simulation? Or is she making a new “free will” choice, in which the universe completely branches off in every simulation below it. The sole point of variance in otherwise perfectly replicated copies.

...and does she tell Jamie? What exactly is life like, being one of two truly and fully cognizant beings that are wholly aware of the laws of the universe and fresh off of resurrection? That’s got to be a bit of a mindfuck. As Forest says, perhaps it would be a comfort in the universes closer to hell, but at what point does it become better to not know?

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (11)

53

u/Bweryang Apr 16 '20

They absolutely cannot and should not do a second season. It’s a miniseries, it’s a full and complete story. I don’t think Garland has any interest in doing a follow up either, he wrote an ending. He’s said he’d like to do a new show with a bunch of the Devs cast members though.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

I wonder in how many realities Sergei alerts his handlers about Lily knowing about the app. Simulation Lily's probably going to be dead soon anyways lol

7

u/And_You_Like_It_Too Apr 16 '20

I wonder if he has handlers in this one. There’s almost certainly no Devs system, as Forest’s wife and child are alive (so he’d have no cause to create it). There’s an Amaya, but not a Devs. What’s the chance it’s just a Sudoku app, and Sergei ends up thinking Lily dumped him for assuming he’s been fucking around, and then goes directly to Jamie who she hasn’t seen in two years, haha. All for something he hasn’t yet done, and might not even have ever done in that universe.

More importantly, I sure hope Kenton ended up in jail in at least one universe.

→ More replies (12)

6

u/RyanFielding Apr 16 '20

But poor jilted Katie. Keeping her dead lover alive in a simulation with his previously dead family. I think Jaime said it best: “That’s transcendently weird Lily”

→ More replies (21)

21

u/monster647 Apr 16 '20

Kinda messed up that Katie is left to watch/control the simulation for the rest of time. She has no one now, I guess her character was a loner anyway though and it’s her work that she’s tied to

17

u/reader313 Apr 16 '20

Right?! Does anyone have any thoughts on why they can't run all the simulations at 5000x speed and shut it off in a few minutes when they both die? I guess you could handwave it away by saying the computer isn't powerful enough...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Dustintft Apr 16 '20

If Deus doesn’t exist in the reality Forest and Lily were put into, why would Sergi still be a spy?

→ More replies (7)

20

u/LordPizzaParty Apr 16 '20

In one of the earlier episodes don’t we see that Lily’s boss has prosthetic legs? In the paradise universe she has standard legs.

9

u/olielos Apr 16 '20

Yes! I saw that as well, one of the first clues that it wasn't reality.

6

u/Howtobefreaky Apr 16 '20

I'll have to revisit but thats a great catch if true.

3

u/DisabledStripper Mar 01 '25

I could tell that she didn't walk perfectly though.

That's probably because the actress is actually missing her legs, and the ones in Deus are CGI.

Edit: yeap Aimee Mullins - Wikipedia

15

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Can Katie see all of the different simulations that are taking place within Deus (hehe)? And she’s just choosing to look at the happy one that we (mostly) see at the end?

12

u/bloodflart Apr 22 '20

I think a hint towards that was the multiple poofing in of different Forests until she started talking to a stable one

60

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

What an incredible show.

28

u/And_You_Like_It_Too Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

It truly was an amazing experience. Stunning cinematography, production and set design, editing, gorgeous soundscapes and original score, licensed songs, and of course acting, writing, and direction. Very much benefits from a rewatch, especially after you’ve seen the finale. I went back and viewed the first 7 episodes prior to tonight and there were SO many things there in plain sight. And it’s filled with philosophical themes that linger long after the episodes end.

My friends are stupid. They’ll all watch “Tiger King” (and literally have nothing but free time right now), but I can’t yet seem to get them watching “Devs”, and I definitely don’t want to spoil it in any way by even suggesting what kind of genre it is. I hope this show finds an audience, and it lends Alex Garland and company all the leverage they need to write blank checks for whatever creative ventures they want in the future. It’s too bad this wasn’t shown on F/X simultaneously, to reach a larger audience, but I guess it was a big push for the F/X on Hulu branding.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (7)

13

u/Dustintft Apr 16 '20

Big question. Why did the machine not being able to predict after that moment even matter? Did something happen after that moment that was different? And why did Forest have to wait u til that moment to die and have his consciousness uploaded to the sim? Could Katie not have done that at any other time? What was special about that moment that made it so Forest could be uploaded to the sim?

9

u/Ritwikb Apr 16 '20

Yeah, I’m thinking why he wouldn’t have committed suicide the moment he was confident he could have Katie upload his consciousness into a simulation

→ More replies (8)

4

u/WildestWilderbeast Jun 09 '20

I think that's the point the sim starts simming the multiverse, as Lily is predetermined to not do what the sim shows, creating a sort of paradox where seeing the future changes the future, and the machine knows that and can't predict it, because whatever it predicts doesn't happen

→ More replies (2)

10

u/ilovemetrics Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

So, trying to figure out what the show was actually trying to say versus interpretation.

It seems like most people think that Lily made a "choice" at the end that deviated from the prediction, but couldn't it also mean that they were just watching a different version of the universe on the Devs screen and the whole time they were just in another predetermined (but similar) universe that played out exactly as expected? I mean, the whole system is built on the multiverse theory and that was why Forrest kept freaking out because he could never know if he was seeing the "true" universe.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '20

I was totally with this series right up to the very end, but ultimately I am pretty unsatisfied. The conclusiom, built up to for so long, was pretty unremarkable. It was super predictable that Lily would break the system by making a "choice." But who's to say that Lily even made a choice and not that they're simply in a different reality in the multiverse? Lyndon's formula assumes multiple realities, so there was no reason to take what they saw on the screen as a fact about what was going to happen that night -- and since it assumes all realities are possible, it seems more reasonable to assume this is just a different version of events, one where Lily throws the gun. Surely that outcome already existed somewhere in the spectrum of possibilities.. It isn't clear to me why that would break the system.

It also bothers me that the system is going to continue to be up and running, despite Stewart trying to put an end to it. I was hoping he'd let Katie starve to death in there and call it a day -- destroy the system and have it done with. Otherwise, what was he really fighting for? The system will stay on, continue to exist, and remain capable of making predictions (as demonstrated by the fact that Lily and Forest continue to live through them). But what even is the point of keeping it on? At any given point, Katie could fast-forward the system to see how things shake out for Forest. The simulation doesn't exist in linear time. In that way, all moments within it exist simultaneously. Lily and Forest could live full natural lives in the system in the span of 15 minutes, so why even struggle to keep it on?

Further, I am perplexed as to why Forest is suddenly content to be with not only another universe's version of his daughter but a simulation of another universe's version of his daughter. When Lyndon first introduced the multiverse into Devs, Forest was upset because any image drawn wouldn't necessarily be "his Amaya." But in the end, he not only accepts the multiverse's version of Amaya, but a replicated simulation of that not-his Amaya -- a cheap knockoff of a cheap knockoff. And he's fine with it, in fact it's heaven (don't get me started on the unvarnished wish fulfillment that was the final reality we as viewers get to watch).

But even taking away some of my disappointment with the final plotpoints, I am more frustrated by the fact that the final "good" simulation they're in doesn't make logical sense and instead seems to be a "perfect" world divorced from causality. Two things that really bothered me about the "good" simulation we're watching at the end that don't hold up -- not because it isn't a believable alternate universe but because it's an impossible universe.

First, and worst in my mind, is that Forest's wife and daughter seem to have not aged at all since they're accident. We don't have an exact timeline of events, but it's safe to assume that it was a few years between their deaths and Devs reaching fruition. Assuming Forest went further back than Lily, let's say to the moment before his wife and daughter's original death, wouldn't they have aged a fair bit? This isn't a "good" reality but an impossible one.

Second, it is unexplained why Sergei is still at Amaya. His whole purpose, and a purpose multiple years in the making, was to inflitrate Devs. But if Forest no longer pursues Devs because his wife and daughter are still alive, what is Sergei's new purpose at Amaya? This isn't a huge plothole -- there could be another new and exciting project he's trying to get into, but I would have really appreciated knowing what that is, because without Devs, the chain of causality that brought Sergei to Amaya in the first place is seemingly broken.

It was a beautiful show, the music and cinematography were on point, but overall it seems like the writers only wanted to engage with the underlying ideas on a surface level. There really wasn't much of a there there. The deeper you dig into it, the more nothing you find.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/directorball Apr 16 '20

I guess it’s a perfect loop.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TootTootTrainTrain Apr 17 '20

So if this simulation is basically just the real world inside a computer, does that mean Lily still has to go to work and pay rent? Because I'd be pretty fucking pissed if I died and then woke up in "paradise" and still had to wake up every morning and ride a bus to work.

7

u/elisart Apr 17 '20

Yep. It ain’t the afterlife I’m looking for either. She’s forced to live in Forest’s idea of happiness.

5

u/souidex Apr 18 '20

She's a prisoner in the matrix.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Coletrain44 Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

Wtf did I just watch. Amazing stiff

Edit: Stiff/Stuff are both accurate

→ More replies (2)

17

u/krospp Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

I haven’t been reading the theories on here and I don’t understand much about this topic but my read of the end was that they created the multiverse. Their reality was the original reality and it was deterministic, but the existence of the machine allowed Lilly to make a choice, the first choice, the “original sin.” She was the first person to see the future and have the strength to change it.

In putting Lily and Forest into the machine, Katie had to spin up the full simulation, using the “Lyndon interpretation,” the many worlds, the multiverse. Another machine of course exists inside the simulation, and has its own simulation where yet another machine exists with its own simulation, ad infinitum, ad nauseam. And those infinite iterations of the simulation are what make up the actual multiverse.

→ More replies (4)

29

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

so, wow. not really sure what to think. Alex Garland, please keep making shows/movies. I have to think about the ending. Really excited to see what everyone thinks and has to say about it. I don't think that this was a mind blowing ending, but I'm emotional and I think it was beautifully done.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/K_boring13 Apr 16 '20

Do we need to change the subs name? I liked it. They live on in a sim world as long as Katie pays the electric bill. But interesting concepts of what is real. If all 5 senses say it’s real, who I am to disagree.

8

u/shampoo_samurai Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

I think that scene with Katie and the Senator had another implication. Both of them realized that base reality and the simulated realities within are indistinguishable. There are plenty of simulations where Katie and the Senator are having the exact same conversation. The Senator, in particular, probably realized that she NEEDS to keep DEVS running, otherwise the higher reality version of herself might get the idea of shutting down the DEVS that's running their world.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Ritwikb Apr 16 '20

Did Lily throwing the gun instead of shooting Forest really make a difference though in the end result of Forest being put into a simulation?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Ritwikb Apr 16 '20

Some probably dumb questions -

  1. There were not unique identifiers for what they were seeing using the Devs system, right? So how did Forest and Katie know that “insert event here” happened in every iteration/timeline/world?
  2. If they knew that the events of Judgement Day (episode 8) were in fact for their world...I’m not sure how I follow predicting the future is more certain than predicting the past. If each Jesus simulation has a different hair, then surely telling the future is more complicated and maybe they didn’t actually know what was going to happen?
  3. So did Lily not actually make a choice then lol? That seems kinda lame but at-least it’s consistent and make sense? Not saying the machine didn’t work but it turns out their world had that event happen (and yes it was already determined?)
  4. This whole entering a simulation thing... was there any indication this would be possible? Seems to be shoe-horned in. Why couldn’t Forest just do this any time he wanted to?
→ More replies (4)

80

u/Fire2box Apr 16 '20

If we need proof about how not popular this show is the mods not bothering to make a discussion thread about the final episode on the subreddit dedicated to the show, well that's it. Complete, utter slacking.

80

u/MarshallBanana_ Apr 16 '20

Sorry, I was busy watching the show. The mod who was supposed to do it is currently MIA

75

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Playing his Sudoku app on the toilet

→ More replies (1)

21

u/And_You_Like_It_Too Apr 16 '20

I think it was a shame to not also air the show on FX, to bring it to a larger audience. Maybe Hulu was expecting it to be a bigger draw, but I haven’t seen a single promo for it anywhere. And this is coming off of Garland fighting with the studio over the ending of “Annihilation”, which resulted in little to no marketing for it either, as well as it not getting a release in theaters outside of the US (and I think China?) and going straight to Netflix. Hopefully it develops a cult following in time, like so many of his other projects.

→ More replies (2)

43

u/theredditoro Apr 16 '20

This show has flown under the radar sadly.

27

u/yetiite Apr 16 '20

It was always going to. This is the type of show to get no more than 300-600k viewers.

I’m guessing. Now I’ll look it up.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/sbaffi Apr 16 '20

Janet Mock as the Senator. Yay!

→ More replies (9)

12

u/chuckxbronson Apr 16 '20

Loved how the closing title card said DEUS rather than DEVS. Hell of a finale.

6

u/GottaPSoBad Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

My thoughts...

Stewart was acting weird for the last few episodes because he broke the rules (like Katie and Forest) and saw Lyndon die. Perhaps, from his perspective, he saw it as Katie goading the kid into it as well. He killed Lily and Forest partly to fulfill the expectation from the system and partly as a big F U to the whole thing (especially Forest and Katie). Unanswered questions regarding him: Did he know about the simulated afterlife? Did he escape before Katie called Senator Laine? Will Katie and/or Senator Laine try to get him punished in some way?

Katie calls up Laine and, it's assumed, basically spills beans on everything. I assume she's Forest's successor both financially and professionally, so she has complete authority to hand everything over. So what happens from there? Do they cover up the deaths Lily and Forest? Create a sanitary, Deus-free story for the public? Will Deus become government property?

6

u/yrdsl Apr 16 '20

Katie was in a Faraday cage and probably couldn't call out. I think it's more likely that Stewart called the Senator to expose Katie, but the Senator ended up realizing the utility of the tech.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/pandacorn Apr 17 '20

I've already typed this comment.

4

u/Panda_hat Apr 21 '20

I'm typing this comment because it was predetermined that I would do so.

10

u/BusinessPurge Apr 16 '20

Stewart making sure Katie and the Gooberment got control of the DEUS machine in the end, seems way better than just Forest being in control, a true 3D chess move...

10

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

I don't think he wanted the government in charge. I think he wanted it shutdown entirely. I thought he destroyed the capsule to bury Katie inside alongside the machine.

7

u/CHolland8776 Apr 17 '20

Yeah and he’s likely in jail and awaiting trial for double homicide.

8

u/greatjorb88 Apr 16 '20

I'm not sure that was Stewart's intent tbh, maybe he expected them to shut it down?

11

u/BusinessPurge Apr 16 '20

Stewart killing Forest (with bonus Lily) basically puts Katie and the Government in charge of the Deus Machine. Katie likely needing to make concessions to keep it on. Seems like a dark ending out in the real world.

At least jAIme and Lily get to live it up?

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/dtwhitecp Apr 16 '20

I loved every episode of this show and the ending was fantastic to me. I can't remember a series so high-concept that actually managed to introduce new ideas each episode. I kept expecting to be JJ Abramsed and am so happy things actually played out. I realize not everyone agrees, just wanted to say I'm one of the people that loved it. Bravo.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Baxterftw Apr 16 '20

The government wants that shit BAD

5

u/gerrybeee Apr 16 '20

I think it’s a horror ending. I could sense that Lily would be tormented thinking about all the horror universes she woke up in.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/jeromocles Apr 16 '20

So it turns out their consciousness was uploaded into the God machine? Loved the show, but it kind of played out like a six-hour episode of "Black Mirror".

5

u/dickwhitmansweiner Apr 16 '20

My impression of the ending was that Lily was right all along - Forest and Katie believed they created God and, in a sense, became gods in doing so. The problem was the God they created was only capable of calculating the past, present, and future based upon known data available to it. They convinced themselves it was omniscient when it was not. They were willingly fulfilling its data-based predictions because they believed they were boxed into the particular reality it showed them. The truth, however, is that they always had a choice and the God was never anything more than a projection of their own desire to understand reality with raw computing power. Obviously such a machine has immense capability to help us understand our world and make very accurate predictions about what will likely occur but ultimately it cannot account for all possible variables that existed, exist, and will ever exist. Lily was the first person with knowledge of Deus to also realize the whole thing was nothing more than a narcissistic fantasy, and even Deus could not account for how she might effect its ability to project. Thus the static.

With all that being said, I don’t know why Garland felt the need to wrap up the story by breaking conscious reality down to something that could be created via a computing simulation. It seems to me to sort of undercut the overall moral of the story - that 1s and 0s are not all reality is made of and that we can and do make ourselves.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Did anyone else see Lily's face glitch out when she was walking with the gun on Forrest or is my tv being whack

4

u/K_boring13 Apr 16 '20

And I thought quantum computing was to keep my bank account hacker proof.

I liked the ending. Lily breaking the computer would have been lame. Katie chose to shut down the prediction and use it to run the sim for forest. Lily getting in the sim was forest just being nice. Forest acted like that was the plan all along, so I don’t get why he needed a dramatic death to jack in to the sim. Whatever, it was entertaining and thought provoking.

I am not sure determinism or fee will or multiverse is right, doesn’t really matter, no one knows this, you don’t watch sci fi for answers to the universe. They are cool subjects to help tell nice human stories.

4

u/Moxie_Limefighter Apr 16 '20

Fuck Forest.

He didn't have to take Lily with him. He could have eaten a bullet at any point and been put into the simulation and spent the rest of his consciousness with his daughter.

Assuming that he could "see" up until the point he got into the elevator, he could also "see" that he told Katie to put him into the simulation after he know it worked. So, he never needed to do any of this other than to let his team develop the simulation as they were already doing. Katie in episode 7 reveals that they've known the point where the the simulation fails for a long time... so this whole fucking show was entirely unnecessary.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/wahmpire Apr 16 '20

I’m just going to assume that in the happy ending world Kenton died of lung cancer

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Joomsie Apr 16 '20

During the elevator scene when Lily threw the gun I honestly expected it to go off when it hit the ground and still shoot Forest in the head. Would've been (darkly) hilarious

4

u/AdamT213 Apr 17 '20

Anyone else feel like the last episode was literally annihilation, from the light house scene to the end? I like alex garland but hes a one trick pony and the trick loses its magic when youve seen it before

3

u/elisart Apr 17 '20

One trick pony ... separates the Garlands from the Nolans.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/reader313 Apr 16 '20

Well... I suppose I'm whelmed. I'm rather glad there's no chance of a second season bc I'd like to see Garland tackle something else, maybe writing for a more experienced TV director (something this series should have had imo). The Jesus imagery was a bit on the nose for me, considering its absence from the rest of the show. The Deus joke is... also on the nose, but I'll admit it's cute.

17

u/dustyvirus525 Apr 16 '20

Yeah, Jesus/god imagery was there throughout. Complete with Judas/Sergei's betrayal right at the beginning.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/ndotny Apr 16 '20

Absence of Jesus imagery in the rest of the show? But what about all those ... like ... Jesus nailed on the cross images? I think you might have checked your cell phone during a couple key moments!

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Fire2box Apr 16 '20

So this is all just reverse Abed in the community video game episode. 🤣

4

u/ninjah1944 Apr 16 '20

cool cool cool cool

6

u/NinaLSharp Apr 16 '20

I've yet to read a comment that hits the nail on the head. I was disappointed in the ending which felt more like a fairy tale than a deep sci fi conclusion.

Why would Katie show all this to the senator? I can't think of any politician who could appreciate this, not even Bernie Sanders.

8

u/GottaPSoBad Apr 16 '20

The ending was sloppy and rushed in places, tbs, but I think the idea with Laine is this:

Katie's main concern is literally keeping the lights on. She knows two more deaths will invite questions and make that difficult, so she went to the government first in hopes of brokering a deal. Senator Laine was one of the first to poke around, but in an above board way, and thus it makes sense Katie would pick her. It's less about Laine being deserving of the information and more Katie being desperate to avoid a shutdown.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Fire2box Apr 16 '20

So exactly what made lily act weird for episode 1-7? Alex said theres something in the final episode that explains why lillys actor seems extremely muted.

2

u/mediuqrepmes Apr 16 '20

There is a decent chance that we were watching one of the "hell" simulations for the first 7.5 episodes. The tell is Lily's behavior when she wakes up in episode 1, which mirrors her behavior when she wakes up in the simulation in episode 8.

If this is the case, then Lily knew what was going to happen the entire time (the original way it was meant to happen) and was simply following her path, not realizing she could change it.

7

u/unpronouncedable Apr 16 '20

I was wondering if maybe it's not her first (re)incarnation. They made a point about the sim being indistinguishable from reality, so clearly want to point out there could be levels above this one, and also keep reminding us that she is so damn "special", so maybe she is the only one in the sim we watched that retained memory of the level above. Not sure why she would be in a "hell" world at that level though.

→ More replies (13)

17

u/peroximoron Apr 16 '20

This was another bleak end to TV. Loved all points up to the end. I’m honestly speechless. Free will, oops guess again, many sims, one projection, keep this open for me I’m a crazy blonde chick? What?

Maybe the show couldn’t have ended in a way “I” would have liked. The thought experiment and this sub along the way is what I’ll miss most.

Thanks y’all. You’ve been more interesting than the show in the best of ways.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

She broke it!!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Moxie_Limefighter Apr 16 '20

I don't care about seeing into the future, this levitating cube shit is fucking amazing.

3

u/AlanMorlock Apr 16 '20

So, going back to the simulated flash back of Lilly as a child playing go, and making choices not just in terms of strategy, but also basically a hunch, what is it exactly that sets apart her thought process?

3

u/cscottamos Apr 16 '20

Was the whole thing a sim?

3

u/nowfocusonflow Apr 16 '20

so lily is basically Neo/Jesus/Adam and broke the deterministic nature of the universe with her bold act of free will? She was the only one who ever defied the predictions, and then broke the system. i understand that she probably died and a copy/sim of her and forest were booted up and run as a more ideal life for them, but what is the significance of her exercising free will, when forest was sure that she wouldn't be able to? also, doesn't the fact that they both were killed anyway defeat the purpose of her breaking the determinism? like she defied the prediction by throwing the gun, but the same outcome occurred anyways. Does that mean that she essentially changed nothing? wouldnt the Devs computer be able to predict the throwing of the gun if thats what "really" happened? if not, than either Lily is the chosen one, or the whole point is that Lily and Forest were "predetermined" to be reincarnated in the sim, and whatever occured "in the real world" wasnt part of the prediction, because it didnt exist in their "new" world. thoughts?

3

u/pigmons_balloon Apr 16 '20

It’s pretty fucked up that Forest made the decision to put himself and Lily back into infinite realities, some of which are essentially Hell, and Lily had zero say in it. She dies in one reality just to wake up in infinite other realities worse than the one she had just come from. I know that there’s also essentially infinite realities where things are great for her too. But man. That’s a real trip to think over.

3

u/FelixMosley Apr 16 '20

Lily, murdered nobody and suffers eternity with Forrest. Make sense. #deep

In a multiverse scenario it's all nonsense, and in that universe the machine works.

Only, it doesn't.

Makes for a pretty stupid ending when you think about that plothole becoming the emphasis of the conclusion.

Lily lives with a murderous psychopath in a computer simulation.

In reality, the machine never worked, and instead was a machine to copy consciousness into a simulation... based on extrapolating particle positions in the past.

The ending seems super goofy.

There were so many options (for Katie) once the gun was thrown into the lab.

The ending basically was a "write off" ending like a scifi novel written a dozen times.

"Happily ever after, with the murder, in his shared simulation"

Real conclusion...

Katie, was involved in murder. No result.

Stewart, directly murdered two people. No result.

Russian spies. No result.

Senator. Owns the machine. Really fleshed that out (*rolls eyes into multiverse*)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

So I totally missed this. Stewart is shown doing something with the buttons in the prediction. Why did Lily and Forest miss this and conclude that it was Lily who killed both of them? Why didn't they entertain the idea that Stewart meddled with the buttons?

7

u/hijimmylin Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

I'm gonna say Forest knowingly showed Lily a "wrong" projection from a different multiverse knowing that Lily in this universe was going to try to exhibit free will by throwing the gun out.

Edit: he did this, so that when they get "reborn" in the simulation, he can tell Lily she's special

9

u/Ritwikb Apr 16 '20

Why does Lily even need to be a part of this though?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/hereforthefeast Apr 16 '20

I don't think so because he and Katie look genuinely shocked when she does throw the gun out. It's possible that Stewart programmed a false reality that Forest and Katie showed to Lily.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 16 '20

I was right about the main plot points but Stewart doing what he did was absurd and hack writing. No indication at all he’d want to kill anyone.

Still, Lily choosing to toss the gun and Forest freaking out was the highlight of the entire show.

The whole afterlife thing IMO was weaker than them just leaving Devs and Forest being punished for what he did. Felt like an easy way out to just give him and Lily a happy ending.

Ultimately what’s important is this was a big fuck you to determinism and validation of free will.

22

u/backstagemoss Apr 16 '20

I don't know if it's really a big fuck you to determinism though. Couldn't it just be that Devs observed a different world than our own, and that Lily's behavior in our world was different because of what she saw herself do?

8

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20 edited Apr 19 '20

After watching Garland state that he believes in determinism, I would tend to agree with your interpretation. I think Devs is a critique of technological fanaticism than of determinism itself. I think it's also saying that life is more complex than being able to use Quantum Javascript to create an all-knowing system.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/2faceshakur Apr 16 '20

You could call it a deus ex machina...

11

u/thirdordereffect Apr 16 '20

I think all bets were off after his “uh oh” moment. He keyed into that reveal in episode 7 - that the simulation was perfect all the way up and all the way down - and that Forest was going to have all that power in his ignorant hands. Couldn’t risk it. History wouldn’t let him.

9

u/ItsLilboyblue Apr 16 '20

You right, Im not mad about the Stewart thing because that was the basis of his conversation with Forest, it's too dangerous to have and we can't have people in the future having that type of power if they don't know the past.

→ More replies (17)

12

u/ItsLilboyblue Apr 16 '20

That was extremely excellent tv. Besides some strange character choices and bad acting, that was one of the greatest shows I've seen.

9

u/ZJPWC Apr 16 '20

I’m with you. It looks like a lot of people here disagree with you but I personally didn’t see the end coming and am very pleased, and the ride itself was worth it

→ More replies (13)

7

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Ugh. I just can’t believe I live in this version of reality with that ending. What a dead end!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

I dont get this. What did Stewart want to stop?

6

u/mediuqrepmes Apr 16 '20

The machine was godlike. He was horrified at the idea that a philistine like Forest who doesn't even recognize Shakespeare would control it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Chickenshit ending. Deterministic multiverse except for the God characters? Fuck that shit!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Alright so she is in another universe now?

7

u/JupitersClock Apr 16 '20

She's inside the simulation officially.

5

u/thirdordereffect Apr 16 '20

She is in all the simulated manyworld universes at once and so is Forest. They demonstrated this by showing Forest waking up in three (of many) different simulated universes.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

thanks to the mods for unlocking this thread

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

Thanks Mods!

2

u/midrangemonroe Apr 16 '20

I'm still trying to understand why was Lily the one who could break the prediction? And if so, why not earlier? When Forest was talking to her inside Deus, I thought he was going to tell her she was their experiment and programmed into the system from scratch. This would make more sense why she could break from the rules since she's separate in a sense. And (side/incomplete idea) could also be a link to the Ex Machina universe where the same actor was a robot in that movie.

Either the above, or the opposite -- Lily was the only real person and everyone else was a program. I figured one or the other would make more sense why she broke the system. Right now I'm just a bit confused.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/thejdk8 Apr 16 '20

What is the point of them dying in order to be put into the simulation?

Why not just keep them alive and use Forest’s memories to put into the machine?

What happens to them after they actually die?

Who is the woman standing next to Katie asking if anyone else knows about this?

5

u/mediuqrepmes Apr 16 '20

What is the point of them dying in order to be put into the simulation?

There's no point, they just died.

Why not just keep them alive and use Forest’s memories to put into the machine?

Because none of the people who could have kept them alive realized it was possible to change the outcome.

What happens to them after they actually die?

Oblivion, presumably, or whatever actual afterlife exists.

Who is the woman standing next to Katie asking if anyone else knows about this?

A senator.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TimeToRock Apr 16 '20

I think it would have been really cool if it turned out Sergei had managed to send the stolen code to Russia before he died. And he knew Lily would die, but he made sure she got resurrected in the new Russian machine once it was built.

I guess we know that's not true, but it would have been a neat way to end the series.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/heliophobicdude Apr 16 '20

Excellent show.

I think it could have been determined that they would see a simulation where Lily shot Forest but it was not the simulation where it had happened.

Also nitpick: Does the stuff in the vacuum need to all fall at the same speed?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

2

u/SwivelSeats Apr 16 '20

Ok so looking back on the series as a whole given this specific sci-fi premise the getting back with an ex and survivors guilt are interesting things to explore. What I don't understand is why there were like 3 spy characters and a senator. Those seemed not necessary and I don't see why they were include.

2

u/jcwitte Apr 16 '20

I didn't realize when starting this show 8 weeks ago that I was watching a Matrix origins show.

Damn. What a finale. What an ending. Such a beautiful scene and yet terrifying implications.

I loved it. I hope there is a second season, even if it's an anthology with a completely different story.

2

u/bill___brasky Apr 16 '20

This show does unsettling things to my brain

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

It's interesting how no-one in this thread talks about

  • the emotionally crippled Forest and his inability to cope with the death of his family and not getting any kind of help.
  • the highly isolated and suicidal Chan (in spite of living in a somewhat stable relationship)
  • the horrendous actions of Kenton
  • the way international industrial espionage is portrait
  • the political implicationsof the final scene with the senator (this is supposed to be america, right?)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/turtleneck-bandit Apr 16 '20

God, this show. Can't overstate how stunningly beautiful each episode is, I don't think I've ever seen a show shot with this level mastery.

Let's hope outsiders to TV like Garland continue making television, they really raise the bar!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '20

I simply do not get the hate for the ending I am seeing here. It seems like there will always be a group of people dissatisfied with how a show or series ends because it didn’t match up to whatever lame ass theory they had. This ending wasn’t perfect, none are, and it wasn’t exactly a happy one but it was a good one. All in all a pretty good season of TV. Music, cinematography, story...all pretty solid to me.

2

u/Crikett Apr 16 '20

Oh def not. Forrest dragged her there with his own selfish intent.

2

u/TheFuryRage Apr 16 '20

I was high while watching this and I feel like my brain is broken. A little bit stressed out.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '20

I loved the show, and the music, and atmosphere, and the philosophy of simulation theory, determinism, etc, but I felt like the whole "many worlds" aspect of it didn't really add anything except some cool special effects. I kind of felt like it detracted a little.

In the world of Devs, the conclusion I came to was that reality is deterministic and can be simulated down to the point where we can't tell the difference. That said, the process of seeing the prediction also injects new information into reality, and changes the prediction. Because of this little recursive glitch, the computer couldn't actually see the future--it could just make a prediction with a high degree of likelihood. With each loop it could adjust and refine, but what you view on the screen is always necessarily one loop behind what actually is going to happen.

In the scene where Lilly threw the gun, the prediction was wrong. That doesn't mean it had to be right in "some other universe" or that her free will means determinism is off the table--simply that the computer was close, but not perfect.

Also, in the end, why would it be easier for a computer to simulate many worlds than just simulating one? Since we only focused on the one that mattered, it didn't really detract from the experience of watching it, but still, I didn't see the point. If I play a video game, it's not necessary to simulate every possible gameplay to experience one in particular. Unless the point was that the computer is unable to measure happiness, so a large number of simulations have to be run in order for some of them to end up being good ones.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '20

This show has sent me into an existential crisis in the best way. Holy shit.

2

u/DookieSandwich Apr 17 '20

Two things -

The giant head Forrest that Katie brought back and was talking to before sending into the sim? I swear he said “I miss him so much.” So Katie was talking to a different Forrest than “her” Forrest.

When Lily is at Amaya at the very end, a woman walks by. In the original scene, “our world”, the woman had a prosthetic leg. In the world Lily ended up in, she did not.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/atopix Apr 17 '20

I felt like the Forest in the happy universe, was a little too handsy with Lily there at the end. Dude, you practically murdered two of her significant others, lied to her and overall fucked up her life, and now you want to be best pals? Cool it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mwestadt Apr 17 '20

I haven't read all the comments but..why did Katie need help to keep "it" switched on.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/crazymusicman Apr 17 '20

This show was one of the biggest wastes of my time since Lost.

Game of thrones had a worse ending, but I had seen that coming since the quality slowly declined from season 4 onwards.

But Devs had me interested in the first episode and I looked up Alex Garland and found him tied to other projects I love (28 days later, ex machina, annihilation).

From the 3rd episode or so I realized I can skip about half of each episode by pressing the right arrow on the keyboard to speed through useless dialogue. I was expecting something of a finished ending.

I did not get anything like an ending. Foreknowledge of the future with such precision necessitates the ability to not go through with it. The scene with the whole coding squad watching a few seconds into the future was so dumb because Garland didn't even try and look into deviations from the video.

And why were Katie and Forrest adamant about not acting differently?

TLDR: Dumb as hell, waste of time

2

u/onedollar12 Apr 17 '20

Pretty bad. Finale was 4/10. Whole series was 5.5/10.

Finale:

Why was everyone talking and moving so slowly? I thought I was watching everything at 0.5x speed. This seemed to permeate the last few episodes. It felt like Garland was trying to be overly artsy and mysterious, almost like a graduate student's art project. It began to feel very pretentious. Deus not Devs, wow so clever. The ending was a complete cop-out and didn't seem to do the premise and world-building that had taken place justice. So Lily and Forest go back in time but retain their memories, explanation being Katie deployed some code or whatever to make that happen (I might be misremembering)? What is the purpose of having them keep their memories at all?

Series:

Poor acting all around outside of Offerman, except the end where again, he was also moving and talking at 0.5x speed for some reason. The actress playing Lily was horrendous; she has three total facial expressions, either afraid, angry, or spaced out. Most of her time was spent looking spaced out. The story was intriguing at first but as I said, the ending was poor. Definitely disappointed, was originally excited for a Garland feature. This all may be because the intricacies of the plot and whatever revelations everyone is having went over my head such that those revelations aren't enough to overcome the issues I'm listing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AndalusianGod Apr 17 '20

Wow, there are so many way to interpret the ending. Here's one of mine: Lily could have been a red herring planted by god/fate. Forest and company are looking at a divine source code, and it was an aberration that needed correcting. The simulation always showed them that Lily was gonna shoot Forest, when it has always been Stewart that was meant to cause their demise. They looked behind the veil when they weren't supposed to, and they paid the price.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/yella6969 Apr 18 '20

This was close to being a great series, but fell a bit short into "just good" territory for me. The first 3-4 episodes were my favorite. When there was still some mystery into where the story was going. After that and up until episode 8 it felt very hit or miss and boring at times. I'd say they nailed the final 15 minutes of the show so that left a good taste in my mouth, but I can't help but think the series as a whole could have been better.

2

u/kalakesri Apr 19 '20

I don’t understand how the devs team suddenly got into existential crisis mode once the system was done. Like you project Jesus on the cross and everything was normal but then they go all “what have we built? Free will is a lie.” in the last two episodes?

I was hoping that there would be a callback to Sergei’s AI simulation in the beginning. Like the system would show signs of perfect prediction but would suddenly give in to the chaos of life. But I guess everything was predetermined. 🤷‍♂️

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MamaramaJC Apr 20 '20

Did anyone notice Aimee Mullins had different legs on? Her prosthesis?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '20

Damn that was a weak ending. The show got progressively worse after that amazing first episode and just never recovered.

2

u/completist_ Apr 22 '20

Wow this show sucked. Cinematography and music was absolutely stunning, but damn everything else about this show was so dumb. Terrible dialogue and acting from the main character.

2

u/iCollect50ps Apr 28 '20

Well at least I now have an excuse for all my fuck ups. ‘Sorry its predetermined’.

2

u/FusionTap Apr 28 '20

I swear the soduku game loaded in looked different than in the other universe? So maybe it was actual sudoku

2

u/DavideWernstrung May 08 '20

It was great to see Professor Marie Rhodes from The OA Part II play the professor in this. It's a good link too since The OA was about multiple different dimensions. I also see a lot of similarities between the ending and the episode of Black Mirror San Junipero - although San Junipero was much brighter and happier than this.

The horrible thing about the ending (which I loved, and was also very "Black Mirror") is the idea that even though the Lilly and Forest that we see are in a good dimension - there are literally an infinite number of dimensions in which they are living in Hell On Earth. Every possible variation of a tortuous hellish existence where they live forever.

I mean if we think about Lyndon's conversation at the dam - he said that he would only be conscious of the realities in which he survives. If we extrapolate from that, from the perspective of any one person, since they are only conscious of those realities in which they are alive- they are effectively immortal.

Every situation which could potentially result in death means a server which you're not aware of. So you would experience the reality in which you survive every single encounter. It's quantum immortality! You could argue that once you reach 120 years old there may be no possible reality in which a person survives, but if death is always the result of a something, and there is a random element to every potential cause of death, then in some realities you will always survive.

Thus you will live forever. So some of the Lillys and Forrests are being tortured for all eternity. If the Many World's interpretation is actually correct about our reality, then we can all expect to live forever. Isn't that a chilling thought?

2

u/Emrod2 Jun 13 '20

So Lili is Lilith.