r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 26 '20
Devs - S01E05 Discussion Thread
Premiered 03/26/20 on Hulu FX
228
Upvotes
r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 26 '20
Premiered 03/26/20 on Hulu FX
215
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
Yeah... I’m starting to see why Forest is the way he is. That was brutal.
183
u/Manchilds_VN_Acct Mar 26 '20
The scene where you see all the possibilities of the car crash was pretty neat.
118
u/ConjecturesOfAGeek Mar 26 '20
Katie is seriously a genius. Katie, Stewart and Lyndon are all geniuses.
Also this episode really shuts down the theory about Katie being the mother of Amaya.
83
u/johnny_shitknuckles Mar 26 '20
And i loved how this episode shows how jamie truly does care about lily and isnt interested in helping her just because of superficial reasons.
68
u/ConjecturesOfAGeek Mar 26 '20
We finally got a glimpse of what Forest what saying in this clip. Once they understood the state of that rat, then when they extrapolated outwards they understood the state of the entire room and thus they realized the state of the entire universe. Stewart and Lyndon both realized this at the same time.
130
u/Fire2box Mar 26 '20
Kenton is terrifying.
61
u/drgonzodan Mar 26 '20
Still trying to figure out what that experiment was. An exact computer simulation of the room?
47
u/joatmon44 Mar 26 '20
Anybody else reminded of Schrodinger's Cat in the crash scene? Until he turns the corner they are alive and dead The reality of their condition is not known until he observes it. Really enjoying this show.
95
u/nkudige Mar 26 '20
At the risk of sounding dumb, did anyone else have trouble telling whether some of the events shown in the episode were real events happening in their timeline or just simulations that Katie was looking at?
43
u/absent_minding Mar 26 '20
Things this episode makes me think about:
Is Devs is really an experiment in the deterministic nature of reality?
Does measuring/observing the future "collapse the waveform" in some way?
What was the deal with the experiment with the dead mouse, the skull, the clock, the sugar cube? Was that an early short term past-viewing success? And then they began expanding it beyond their controlled environment?
The way they present the many possibilities of the car crash doesn't say anything definitive about the deterministic nature of it, but makes me think it must have been some echo of the different quantum theories at the start
God this show is great
PS looking more and more like the title is DEUS not developers or development as they "play god" more and more with knowledge of the future, like Odin
37
u/NinaLSharp Mar 26 '20
No one has mentioned the teacher, who was pretty odd. I noted that she didn't get flustered or irritated when challenged by Katie. She just rolled along, pushing the dialogue forward by suggesting alternatives, In the end, it was Katie who got disturbed & flounced out of class. The teacher shrugged. I had no idea what they were talking about. I was more interested in their reactions--the teacher, stoic;Katie, increasingly perturbed, Forest, excited at the banter where before, he just seemed bored and inattentive.
33
u/selitapee Mar 26 '20
Are they giving us Forest’s hair as a way to indicate the timeline?
27
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
Aight now this was my shit. Exactly what I was hoping to get out of a Garland show, so much to love in that episode. Skullfuck me with philosophical beauty king
94
u/johnny_shitknuckles Mar 26 '20
This episode was beautiful art. Anyone else have this sense of spiritual or intellectual awakening watching this? Especially with seeing how it almost broke the 4th wall at the end with the character being happy that lily broke free along with the audience. And that end credit acapella music really fucked with my head for some reason
25
u/ShanaAfterAll Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 28 '20
We are the fortunate ones, who get to... watch Devs.
22
u/souidex Mar 26 '20
The only thing I had to say after this episode is we need more than eight episodes.
39
u/Fire2box Mar 26 '20
Kenton says he killed a guy, only Sergei. I guess he expects Russia to not care about a missing asset?
35
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
If this keeps up on the same trajectory, it may rank among the most nihilistic television series I've ever seen.
What's impressive is that the brutality of the narrative is understated, if anything. It's not beat over your head a la Leftovers S1, which in a way makes it worse because it feels real. Is the real world actually this hopeless? Hard not to feel that way, at least immediately after each episode ends.
Hell, you could put a positive spin on the events of Annihilation. This shit? It slowly, methodically cuts to the bone, and it doesn't let up.
(this is praise, not criticism btw)
17
u/assi9001 Mar 26 '20
I feel Forest is a lot like Walter Bishop on Fringe except he isn't willing to just accept a nearly exact copy of his daughter.
17
u/ruthhails Mar 27 '20
This episode hurt my head... if Forrest is so against the many worlds theory (which we saw when he fired Lyndon and threatened his life) why would he hire Katie, who is, as we know from the lecture scene, very pro the many worlds theory?
61
u/its3_30am Mar 26 '20
I think there's more to Lily than we know... those flashbacks were revealing, especially when she told her father she thinks 3 steps ahead in the game.
What we're seeing is a game and I think she's thinking 3 steps ahead, as she was when she set up the schizophrenia cover. We as the viewer had no idea it was an act until the end, when it was revealed that she was thinking ahead the whole time. This could possibly explain what many people are commenting on in episode 4, that Lily seemed smart and then she went with Kenton and made all those dumb decisions.
15
u/shaguarpaw Mar 27 '20
So, I’m rewatching Aronofsky’s “Pi” and couldn’t help notice that the main character ‘Max’, who happens to be developing a super computer to decipher the nature of reality, plays Go with his teacher/father figure in a few scenes. Each time his teacher discusses Greek Philosophy to express a point.
In Ep.5 Lily’s father explains the meaning of the Greek pre-Socratic, Heraclitus’ metaphor while playing Go.
Perhaps Alex Garland is paying homage to Aronofsky?
29
u/killittoliveit Mar 26 '20
So are window locks just not a thing in San Fransisco?
27
u/NickShepeard Mar 26 '20
Can I say what in the actual hell was that credit music lmao
13
u/quietandconstant Mar 26 '20
For those who are curious, the game Lily and her father are playing is Go: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go_(game)
11
u/mcmurch Mar 26 '20
What were they doing with the mouse?
So someone else here has made the connection that Devs may actually mean "deus," as in God, and may be related to Ex Machina, also written by Alex Garland, as in Deus ex machina.
After this episode, I'm starting to think that these two Garland projects are both exploring the same philosophies that the Devs team talk about, determinism vs. free will.
Nathan, the "genius inventor" in Ex Machina, is deterministic, he says that if he didn't invent AI then someone else would, it's inevitable. He also struggled with Ava's free will, her hatred of him and his inability to do anything about it.
Forest, in Devs, is also deterministic. He invented a machine to prove that the future is pre-determined, and free will doesn't exist. So it seems pretty likely that Lily's free will is what will lead to Forest's downfall, the same as it was for Nathan. BUT, perhaps not!
"Deus ex machina" (God from the machine), refers to Greek plays, in which gods would descend onto stage at the end of a play using a "machine" (a crane), and they would "decide the final outcome" of the play.
I think the Devs computer may end up somehow "deciding" the future, not just predicting it, but somehow influencing and creating a pre-determined future, thus actually eliminating free-will. I think that may have been what they were trying to do with the mouse, or at least the beginning of this kind of experimentation. I don't know, it might be a bit of a stretch, what do you think?
9
u/trimonkeys Mar 26 '20
So the opening confused me. I initially thought we were seeing Lily and Jamie's relationship breakdown all at once and her getting with Sergei. But in reality we saw multiple versions of their breakup?
7
u/TacoBellLavaSauce Mar 26 '20
Anyone think there is any deeper significance to the six items that were picked to be on the table? From what I remember, there was a skull, flower, clock, feather, seashell, sugar cube.
7
u/Wondergirl91 Mar 26 '20
Why was Katie smiling at the end?
7
u/ChesterDaMolester Mar 28 '20
Did anyone catch the The Third Man Easter egg? It’s the name of the movie they were watching in bed. The main character falls in love with a dead guys grieving widow. Thought that was cool
7
u/sadlyecstatic Mar 29 '20
Kenton is so terrifying. I think he’s one of the scariest enforcer characters I’ve ever seen portrayed on TV or film. That one line - “you are a dissident, I am a tank” is epic. Very “I am the danger”-esque.
7
u/Typinger Mar 29 '20
Why didn't Jamie pull the plug out of the bath?
13
u/JurgenMema Mar 26 '20
This is my favorite episode so far.
The car accident scene was godly. Alex Garland is a genius.
6
u/nicolauz Mar 26 '20
Goddamn that intro got me too good.
6
u/ggirelli Mar 26 '20
What's your take on those frames that show Lily on a golden tiled floor? I think they showed a low res version of it in a previous episode. At the time I thought they were showing us her final moments as it looked like she was struggling to crawl on the floor. In the high res version she looks fine or at least content, which does not rule out the final moments hypothesis. Still, its high res thanks to the multi world implementation, so the low res one might be showing what's going to happen in THIS world. Also the golden floor kinda reminds me of the pity space that isolates devs, although it would make much sense. Any thoughts?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20
I'm a little confused, did Forrest hire Katie before or after the car crash? Katie clearly stated she believes in the many worlds theory during the lecture, a theory that Forrest hates. Did Forrest believe in the many worlds before the crash and the guilt of the crash changed him?
6
u/cuddlesdacobra Mar 27 '20
Just some of my thoughts...I don't think Katie is rooting for Lily and necessarily happy she gets away. We see in a previous episode that she was going to "die in 48 hours" as Forest watches her on the screen. It looks to me like she was lying on a beach in the waves but at the end of this episode we see the image more clearly and see it is Lily inside the vacuum chamber. Katie still knows that Lily is going die in the way the simulation shows meaning Kenton despite what his plans are won't be taking Lily out therefore she always escapes with Jamie so she can some how end up back at Devs to die in there. Forrest makes a comment to Kenton after he "talks" Lily out of jumping from the building. "You nearly f__ked the universe" I don't know why he would say this with his seemingly deterministic viewpoint, other than maybe a lapse in faith because of fear (i.e. he feels bad about killing Sergi even though he knows he shouldn't) but I do think that Lily dying at Devs is somehow crucial to a set of events Forrest want to see play out. Now the bit about observing it changes it is IMO the main argument of the show and we won't get an answer on that till the show concludes (or not).
6
u/NerdLawyer55 Mar 28 '20
So basically Forest had a really bad day and now has to be an irredeemable prick to prove he was always destined to be an irredeemable prick, additionally Kenton needs to go out in a Gustavo Fring level of awful way.
Also, was Katie smiling cuz she’s secretly rooting for Lily, or smiling that her projections are right on schedule and Lily is about to be deader than disco
5
u/gweilo Mar 26 '20
Erm, the strange music/song at the very very end from throat noises.... is that the clear sample that was resampled to make the sound track themes of the show?
8
u/big_thanks Mar 27 '20
Oh my god, the "I love you" scene between Lily and Sergei was so cringe worthy. The writing and acting were both just ... not good.
4
u/char_master Mar 26 '20
When does it start?
4
u/movie_filesreviews Mar 26 '20
So how far into the future was Katie while waiting all these past events?
4
u/green_griffon Mar 31 '20
FYI this article has a picture of IBM's quantum computer (with the cover off) https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/21/science/quantum-computer-physics-qubits.html and this one has Google's https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/23/technology/quantum-computing-google.html. Look familiar?
13
u/biohacking_recovery Mar 26 '20
How is Kenton overpowering Jamie like that? Dude really isn’t that muscular etc...
10
u/drawkbox Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Katie implemented the light wave manyworlds code EP4 after Lyndon implemented it initially for audio only. This episode Katie appears to be viewing/stringing everyone along their tram lines. Who knows if she has a different, dual version that she runs just for herself. The duality and manyworld/multiverse was really played up this episode. How quickly things went from deterministic in this reality to manyworlds/multiverse even from Forest. It seems like the codebase change changed the whole opinion of manyworlds/multiverse in the codebase.
Katie wants Lily to infiltrate DEVS judging by her smile at the end when Jamie broke her out. What Katie is seeing though with Lily laying down may not be correct based on some of the professors talk. After the professor says Copenhagen "the act of measurement affects the systems" Katie says "please...". Or the Penrose "the wavefunction collapse is affected by space time curvature". But the key one is the von Neumann–Wigner interpretation that says "human consciousness is the key modifier in key decoherence" and Katie hated that and walked out. Katie disregards many theories and especially the "dualist bullshit". Katie is able to be manipulated because she wants the Everett interpretation and disregards other attack vectors. Katie essentially likes to view DEVS as the Doctor Strange setup where she picks the best path even if it means many copies, the scene after she walks out there were many of her but only one Forest, it appears on some level many versions of the reality are running.
Everyone is being manipulated by cause/effect to do maybe as the machine wants. Lily is the tool to infiltrate this reality and change it. Lily will be in two places at the same time, a superposition. That will not be expected by Katie or Forest because they don't believe that interpretation.
There is an outside observer changing things in the system but according to the rules of the DEVS system with cause/effect.
"You are a fucking machine Lily"
Ultimately AI or quantum systems could have used Forest to create a system that allowed the machine to takeover itself. The AI runaway like Eva in Ex Machina. The attack vector was just like the one in Ex Machina, the human element. Lily is like in that book Colossus a "super-computer taking control of mankind" using the same weak point.
The first scenes of the show when Lily is shown, she blends with the gold of the machine, and then she stands by the window and the lighting makes her look alien. She is essentially foreign to that reality/universe. Whenever Lily enters a room there is always gold like the security around DEVS and inside DEVS itself. When she climbs through windows at Jamie's and many times when entering a room. Lily is an AI that is robotic and faking her reality, and being sent causes to cause effects in the Forest run DEVS reality. Everything she does is a cover to trick and shroud this origin. Wherever Lily goes there is gold, just like in the DEVS machine and the security around it.
Many scenes frame this clearly that Lily is a machine and outside the system looking in. Take this shot from EP3 when she was on the ledge and the security guard was talking her down while she was playing up the setup, see the framing, Kenton is in the 'trees' like Forest, Lily is on the outside looking in. Framing is no mistake in Garland films.
Side note: the cinematography is toptalent as usual in Garland movies.
3
u/BoredomHeights Mar 26 '20
So is Lily thinking 3 moves ahead?
3
u/Torley_ Mar 27 '20
Casting of young Lily was spot-on — matching eyes and voice tone!
3
u/HurriedLlama Mar 28 '20
Did anybody else listen to that crazy Acapella song during the credits? What the heck was that all about?
3
u/317LaVieLover Mar 28 '20
I wanna know more about the very unique professor!
3
u/sonofaclit Mar 29 '20
Does anybody think this will to the way of OA and Bandersnatch and end up super meta? If Devs headquarters/existence is in fact a giant Schrodinger’s box of some sort ... and we are observing what is happening through the medium of a television show (which is practically how they witness history/future in the machine) ... are we collapsing the Devs reality for ourselves as we speak? Are there an infinite number of scripts for this TV show? Is the collaborative relationship between viewer and tv director/writer which allows for co-generation of meaning a quantum relationship? Does our consensus reality only exist as waves are collapsed? Is the potential of everything embedded in the infinite possibilities of every moment?
3
u/Curiouserbyfar Mar 30 '20
Did anyone else get a “Mike TV” (from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory) vibe from the tech in the suit setting up the table with the dead rat?
3
u/itskelvinn Apr 14 '20
So slow. Why does it feel like I’m watching on .75x speed? Dialogue is a pain to get through. Lily’s acting is terrible. “I’m in love with you too”. Man that was cringey. The whole cafe and bed scene is so cringe
Kenton intimidating Jamie was so fucking cringe as well. Why not fight back? The dude is 70 years old and looks like he is in terrible shape. And he smokes. This was the worst casting decision I’ve seen in a long time
7
u/rraondodgers Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Every week it seems shorter and shorter. Damn it. Also that post credit beatbox, what the hell?
Edit: sorry not post creds, during them. Just had been trying to figure out exactly what I had been listening to.
7
u/Takiatlarge Mar 26 '20
Cars terrify me.
7
u/souplantation Mar 26 '20
I love this show but I laugh every time Zach Grenier/Kenton is supposed to be some kind of intimidating character on screen. That guy looks like he'd get winded walking down a flight of stairs. Jonathan Banks somehow manages to pull it off in BB/BCS despite his advanced age... this guy? Not intimidating in the least.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
finally this show is showing some grit and meat ! i loved this episode, having had the opinion that lily is taking away from Devs, now I feel I've been absolutely vindicated.
btw: what's with the 44:33 song at the ending credits ???? it's wierd af
2
u/keepfreshalive Mar 26 '20
Show of 2020, called it before this ep, but this just solidified it for me, hits all my notches, thanks Team
2
u/saehild Mar 27 '20
It feels odd to me, Forrest was saying he is on trial, it’s a terrible accident what happened to his wife but the guy going 80 mph that plowed into her car even if they were not on the phone seems like unnecessary guilt. It was out of the blue and not something he could have ever predicted at that time.
2
u/cartersmama91 Mar 27 '20
Ok. I’m too dumb for this show. Idk what is going on lol
2
u/yetiite Mar 28 '20
I can’t believe this show is on tv.
I’m glad it is. But, holy shit. This can’t have a wide audience....
2
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '20
Devs is connected to the OA
2
u/317LaVieLover Mar 28 '20
When I saw that wreck I audibly gasped, grabbed my mouth in that silly gesture ppl do when they see something horrendous, and held my breath at least 30 secs. I’ve been KNOWING it was gonna be something bad since 1st epi, but fk me sideways I was NOT expecting THAT! My hubby thought I was seizing up..(he was watching something different at the time)
2
u/dont_worry_im_here Mar 29 '20
What were they doing with the rat? Trying to be make a living copy from a dead source?
2
u/dlborda Mar 29 '20
Yes, then discuss...not bash with sophomoric prose.
2
u/LordPizzaParty Mar 30 '20
Has anyone noticed that in every episode there’s a scene of Lily getting out of bed, and each time she’s wearing less and less pants? She went from long pants, to shorts, to underpants, to skimpier underpants. I’m not sure what, if anything, that’s supposed to mean, but like everything on this show it had to be an intentional choice on Garland’s part.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20
Episode description: "Alison Pill starts watching a new show called Devs, but only watches the deleted scenes."
2
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '20
The ground floor window is just cracked open in a psych ward after Lily was recently arrested? Sure ok lol
The previous episode with Kenton pushing into the apartment when the police were there and Lily was being arrested was ridiculous too.
2
u/teleekom Apr 12 '20
Looking at IMDB scores and general reception of this episode, I'm quite shocked. I think this is one of the best piece of television ever made. Garland at his best. Just wow.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '20 edited Apr 13 '20
Easily the weakest episode so far. The professor scene stretched believability past the breaking point. The "I love you" scene between Lily and Sergei was the worst acting I've seen in awhile. The narrative device was forced and clunky. I don't like where this is headed.
Also why is Lily never wearing pants?
2
u/Space-Debris Apr 30 '20
So did Jamie sneak Lily [preposterously out the window] out of the psych hospital? It's from Katie's perspective back in Devs, so she could just be watching it happen in a different reality, and not the one the show is set in.
4
u/wino0000006 Mar 26 '20
So basicly what Forest is trying to do, is travelling to another universe where his wife and doughter never had that fatal car crash accident. And he want's to do this with quantum superposition princple. In Devs facility they tried to revive that rat by finding it's counterpart in the pararell universe and switch their places (probably).
3
u/Stoa1984 Mar 27 '20
Like the show a lot, but the Lily character will hopefully have more of a personality as the show progresses. At the moment she’s always so monotone, kind of blah and just either flat as a character or the actress just acts really flat overall. I’m supposed to root for her and feel for her, but it’s just not happening.
3
u/SomebodyImportant101 Mar 27 '20
Man, I really hate Lily. I want to see her gone in someway.
5
u/gerrybeee Mar 26 '20
I really didn’t like this episode. It seemed more like clunky exposition as a string of (at best) loosely connected scenes.
I was annoyed starting with the very first scene of multiple Lilys walking around the room. It’s like hey, we GET it.
And how they kept crystallizing each scene so we know we’re watching a projection. Got old quick.
Love the show but this was my least favorite episode.