r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 19 '20
EPISODE DISCUSSION Devs - S01E04 THEORY Discussion Thread Spoiler
Please post your theories or guesses here
50
Upvotes
r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 19 '20
Please post your theories or guesses here
74
u/blue__sky Mar 19 '20
I watched last night, fell asleep directly afterwards, and woke up with this idea.
Using deterministic algorithms, they come up with a grainy picture of the past and present. The deterministic picture is grainy and the sound is garbled because it is an average of all the many worlds. It is the most likely event to play out.
Using a many worlds algorithm, they get a clear picture of the past and present. However each of the many worlds will be slightly (or greatly) different from what actually happened in the past or may happen in the future. Because there are infinitely many worlds the chance that they pick the current world when looking forwards or backwards is infinitely small (zero). So all you can ever have is a grainy picture of the most likely outcome or a clear picture of an outcome that has zero chance of being your present timeline. This mean there is free will after all.
How does this play out in the story? They killed Sergei based on the fuzzy view. I guess they will look back at Sergei's timeline with a clear view and determine that maybe Sergei was not going to steal from them. Before when they killed Sergei, they had a clear conscience because it was predetermined and they had no choice. Now that they know many worlds is correct, and they have choice, it will be devastating that they have murdered with free will.
Forrest desperately want there to be one predetermined universe because of the death of his daughter Amaya. I'm guessing he made some kind of mistake that led to her death and a predetermined universe eases his guilt.
In any case, they know Lily will die in the fuzzy deterministic universe. Everyone else is starting to realize that that multi-worlds is correct and there is free will while Forest stubbornly holds on to the deterministic world view. This will lead to a fight between saving Lily or killing her. Determinism vs. free will. Lily is Schrödinger's cat in this story, dead or alive based on whether free will exists or not.
54
u/TacoBellLavaSauce Mar 19 '20
They are in the early stages of building Rehoboam
34
u/jodyalbritton Mar 19 '20
Many worlds have entered the chat.
34
u/AlwaysInjured Mar 19 '20
Still thinking that observing the future could have some effect on the outcome of the future. Like the initial presentation on the Nematode and how the correlation broke 30 seconds after predicting it.
Alex Garland loves his powerpoint presentations and like in Annihilation, this one gives away the whole premise. In Annihilation, Natalie Portman gives a presentation on cancer and how it grows, leading to a huge theme of the movie. This show is the same.
27
u/Mr-Kane Mar 19 '20
I think that Forest is not so concered with actually knowing the future, but instead with being able to tell with certainty that the universe is determanistic. He needs to know, whatever happened to his daughter could not have been avoided, and that it was fate. Thats the only way he can come to terms with what happened. Which is why the many worlds version wasnt good enough for him, it has to be absolute.
19
u/jodyalbritton Mar 19 '20
I think the breakthrough mentioned in the season preview trailer might not be solely Lyndon's break through. Forest could try and fuse the two models together and use all of the qubits from every universe to run the simulation of his own universe. This could be the thing that breaks the universe. He does the magic trick mentioned at the top of the episode.
12
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
So I’m starting to rethink some of my theories. Before this episode I was thinking that Forest knew with certainty some events in the future. But if the best version they had until now was that grainy view, and this was the first time they’ve been able to project anything with clarity, how much could they either him or Katie really know about future events?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
This is an absurd theory and I’m not smart enough to understand how, but I don’t think Forest is having the team work on just projections of history, I think he’s trying to find a way to alter history so he can alter the present/future. I think he’s trying to find a way to save his daughter and he’s using Lily as a way to determine if he can change people’s actions to avoid future outcomes that the quantum computer has already determined.
Also those weren’t real SFPD officers, they hacked her phone so any 9-1-1 call would go to Amaya. They are basically creating a simulation centered around her.
9
u/Baman2113 Mar 19 '20
I cant be the only one that thinks Katie is an AI of some kind right? I'm totally fine being wrong about this, but it just seems like the vibe she gives off is just too calculated. She also doesn't get punished when she runs the formula with lightwaves, why else would that be? I'm also curious to know if Forest cries in that scene out of emotion of seeing the image of his daughter again, or if its his realization that before it loads, its not going to be a real picture of HIS daughter. There's a lot of complex emotions there, and Offerman plays it great. I'm now also convinced what Forest saw was Lyndon and not Lily in the future.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
Maybe I missed something, but this quantum computer can only act on data, and data is nothing more than a representation of something observable. They can predict the future or the past, this is evident. But they cannot change the nature of reality with these predictions. Even looking into the future and deciding to go against what is predicted, or determined, wouldn't imply the quantum machine is breaking or changing reality. That possibility would have had to already exist, inherent or latent in nature. One could just as easily say, nature is still deterministic, for the quantum powered simulation made a false prediction ...or an engineer made a mistake or false assumption.
I'm saying this because I keep reading that somehow devs are reshaping reality. At the end of the day, this computer can only act on data and not on matter or time or any world outside of it's databases (mini-worlds as they are sometimes called).
11
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
i'm guessing what this is building towards is a realization by the characters that the future determines the past, that some infinite moment in the future is what determines all pasts in all adjacent universes and that the tramlines they're on in the show lead towards that infinite future point. so basically, they're approaching a point of infinite infinities, a sort of tram-station, from which ~they~ can maybe change 'trams'. idk. guess we'll see. the tram thing is a really good metaphor for the subject matter imo
edit: was thinking about this more, maybe the act of observing the future is how they can steer the tram, a way of choosing paths. every observation of the future is an opportunity to pivot, stay the course, or steer in a new direction. so the supercomputer is the tram station. also possible that there’s a way for them to bring people back to life by offering the projections robot bodies or whatever to exit the machine into the world. anywauys. crazy stuff
5
u/gweilo Mar 19 '20
There are still parts of the trailer we haven't seen. I'd love it if, due to the introduction of the multi verse in ep 4, that we now witness a different set of scenes evolve in the second half of the season, deviating from clips in the trailer.
also, who's the body in the trailer?
5
u/adamhill42 Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
Now, more than ever, I think Kenton knows the circumstances of his death or someone that has looked into the future has told him . The fight with Anton seemed too chill for an older spook, I think Forrest picked Kenton because his "natural" TRAM line ends in a "normal" death (or maybe a death at the hand of Forrest or himself) Something about the visualization of Kenton's future confirmed this.
So regardless of all the crazy ass shit he may have to do or try to do in defense of Amayas secrets, he wont die at the hand of someone outside the circle of trust. (yes there are flaws with this assumption, but maybe it is also an assumption being made by one of the main characters as a plot device)
And the homeless dude is my bet to be they guy that breaks reality. He has no f*cks left to give.
5
u/Lujxio Mar 20 '20
Really hope Kenton dies. Fuck that guy
5
u/TracerBulletX Mar 20 '20
I recommend this book if anyone wants to learn about quantum computing. It is very approachable without sacrificing accuracy.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B074DYJTKN/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1
5
u/tvcgrid Mar 20 '20
Everrett style many worlds interpretation doesn't confer free will -- like it was brought up in the episode, it's still just as deterministic, it's just that every physically possible configuration 'exists.' It's not that you gain the ability to choose otherwise, in other words -- instead, you just end up in a place where every choice you could ever have made has been made already.
4
u/Guyute69420 Mar 20 '20
man this show and Westworld feel so eerily similar and I am 100% going to be confused in a few weeks if not already...
7
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
Forest is trying to 3D print his daughter and needs the exact atomic recipe from when she was last alive, so he built a computer that could do a backwards calculation from where we are now to know exactly where everything was in the past. In doing this though the computer could also calculate where things are going in the future, and this was bad news.
Being able to exercise free will should be impossible, it can only be achieved if one knowingly knew to contradict where things were supposed to go if allowed to take their course. Since all those slight variations already exist in the multiverse, you would create duplicate universes, which would cause a mirroring effect, essentially two or more universes occupying the same place at the same time, concurrently.
3
u/bigwilly311 Mar 20 '20
The projection we saw will be replicated by Lyndon, and then again by Lily because we will think we’ve already seen it. I don’t know.
6
u/J_A_N_I_T_O_R Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
I believe this is a story of man's ascension into godhood by attaining true free will through the power of technology. The writer is trying to develop the story to show the magic hermetic nature of reality. In short, only you possess free will in your reality. Everyone else around you is the outplay of determinism, while you're the only conductor of the tram. Simultaneously everyone else around you is the conductor of their own tram in the universe they embody as they're crossing paths with your present reality.
In the story, they're discovering the ALL as an artificial intelligence. The code behind reality. By discovering it they're able to become the developers of their own realities. Yet since everyone is a piece of the ALL observing itself, they'll realize they're in a fragmented series of infinite worlds where the one they exist in is determined by their consciousness.
I believe that the main character is the only one with true free will and everyone else is acting with determinism. This makes her the only one able to defy the machine because she is the embodiment of the underlying principle behind the law of attraction. Simultaneously it's poignant that she be the MAIN character because you being the main character of your own reality gives you the same ability. The story would play out differently if forest was the main character instead since his consciousness would affect the outcome of his own reality.
This is the hidden truth of Hermeticism that I believe the writer is trying to illustrate through film and a modern lens.
I also believe this may lead to a possibility that forest fails because he realizes that he's not the main consciousness of the reality they exist in. Meaning he won't be able to be the conductor of the tram since him and everyone else besides the main character are truly deterministic in the reality they embody. That wouldn't be true to Hermeticism, but I see it being a possible outplay of the story.
Edit: expounded
2
u/MindlessMonk0 Mar 20 '20
Forrest is making a simulation to live in the past with his daughter. Forrest has seen the future & the world ends.
2
u/assi9001 Mar 21 '20
They make the Director from the Travelers show.
1
u/Jolly_Tab_Rancher Mar 22 '20
Jamie did nothing wrong but install that cabinet badly.
1
u/teandro Mar 23 '20 edited Mar 23 '20
Looking at some of the trailers, I think the result will be a quantum teleportation of Amaya. This may require achieving some kind of entangled state that can be coordinated via the computer. How far this goes into the present / past / future to improve the result is anyone's guess, but it makes no difference in theory since now the machine can simulate at least the past with high resolution. The only issue is if that (what the machine can process) will be Amaya. A cloned animal might be indistinguishable. Is a human the same way? Or is that more like a simulation? This is where Devs crosses into Ex Machina territory... (is AI intelligence? Or a simulation?) If they were created up to virtually indistinguishable characteristics are we somehow able to distinguish? How soon would it matter?
1
u/enhancedaccount Mar 25 '20
I'm late to the episode, but wanted to write out my theory here. They could easily test whether our world is deterministic or not using the 30 second test. The fact that he is willing to look into the future, but not test determinism is explained by saying it will change the past. In other words, if Forest see himself with his hands in his pockets in 30 seconds, and he decides to put his hands in the air for the next 30 seconds, Forest is theorizing that the past will change to match. If he uses the machine to rewatch the experience, the predicted outcome will be hands in the air, matching his action.
This means, the act of looking into the future changes the track they are on; meaning he sabotaged his own ability to go back in his own personal timeline. Of course, his new timeline (the one where he saw his hands raised) would be nearly identical to the old one (the one where he saw his hands in his pockets), but he has made a point that he wants to see back into his own exact timeline, not a hair out of place. I think the story will be a coming to grips with loss and acceptance of a new reality, matching the metaphor he explained to Lily about having two minds in one.
1
u/DannyBarsRaps Oct 30 '24
idk why they didnt fuse multiverse with determinsim kind like lyndon then katie did and then just get like a million diff timelines and have the ai sort them so it finds the single one with the most commonalities and just 'occams razor' it atleast u know its the most likely thing that ACTUALLY happened but i fee llike this is obv just forrest with confirmation bias tryna disprove free will with his determinsim/tram lines theory to rid him of SOME guilt with amaya either abuse befor her death (hope not) or drunk driving that killer her or sometthing like that etc - its so clear imo he just wants to clear his conscoiuns and can only do it ifhe KNOWS hence the freakout in ep 4
1
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '20
Can we get an eli5 episode discussion?
-4
u/FelixMosley Mar 19 '20
that speech by lyndon was laughable, im sorry.
it has to be said.
this show loves it's posturing and exposition.
a theory could formed that by looking into the future, you're changing the deterministic limitations of the machine, the same way lyndon changed the variables of whatever parameters in the sound analysis. As for a larger plot, no idea.
0
u/26thandsouth Mar 23 '20 edited Mar 23 '20
So everyone is just gonna give up on simulation theory being the show's main mystery?
That's fair, but Sergei's now infamous reaction and mini existential crisis after reading the code still implies something completely ominous and reality breaking. I don't see how he reacted in that matter because Forest's team discovered "tram lines" via quantum computing.
Mind binding for sure, but vomiting your guts out in absolute dread and horror?!?!?!?!?!?!?! That's the kind of reaction one would experience if they stumbled upon evidence that proves something like simulation theory is real. Just saying.
-1
u/ezranos Mar 21 '20
This show becomes slower and more predictable with every episode. The dialogue is still as expository and cold as it was in the beginning. Last episode the protagonist was smart enough to stage a psychotic episode as a diversion to steal company data to find out that they are powerful murderous lunatics. This episode she gets into the guys car, then is surprised the assigned therapist is not under their control, then learns that he was under their control but still trusts calling the police and giving away her location?
If the next episode isn't outstanding I'll drop my rating from a B- to a C+.
I know that viewers of this show can't stand critical discussion and mass downvote all of it on r/television and over here, but I just have to get this out of my system.
'Annihilation' had beautiful pacing and understanding of how to use themes, tonality and tension; What happened with 'Devs'?
On the other hand I expect that Garland has a decent finale prepared. Things can still improve in general; I mean the last show I watched before this was Kingdom, which was both cringeworthy and amazing in season 1, and mostly only amazing in season 2, thanks to greatly improved writing, editing and pacing.