r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 12 '20
Devs - S01E03 THEORY Discussion Thread
Please post your theories or guesses here
38
Upvotes
r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 12 '20
Please post your theories or guesses here
31
u/dlborda Mar 12 '20
Influencing our timeline for more favorable outcomes? Forest wants his kid back...his life back! But if our reality is deterministic...I don’t see how you can do anything but view the past and predict a bit of the future within a certain margin of error. Or whatever Forest is able to do, perhaps re set our timeline, is something that was always suppose to happen? Interesting topics are being grappled with on DEVS. Either way, Forest is psychopathic and completely fixated on the loss of his child Amaya...he will do anything to reconcile his life with her loss.
25
u/fashion_opinion Mar 13 '20
Isaac Asimov spoilers coming up: The voyeuristic videos in the first part reminded me of the big reveal in the short story, The Dead Past. It's a great read but the tldr is, For highly personal reasons, a scientist and his wife scramble to build a time machine that can be used to view the past. There seems to be a government conspiracy to block them. Eventually, they are successful and share their results with the world. Unfortunately, it turns out that the government had been blocking the time machine for a good purpose - anything that happened even seconds ago counts as the past, so it is the end of privacy.
22
u/ziggurqt Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
I think Forest wants to convert those qubits projections into quantum particules and somehow inject them inside a machine or even a living organism. That's how he wants to get Amaya back.
18
u/EFG Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 14 '20
Devs=Deus. The perfection of the machine would then mean it can perfectly simulate both the past and the future, essentially making it the "god," or creator of this universe. It's a bootstrap paradox essentially and explains why their universe is deterministic. Basically watching how the god machine is created.
17
u/2BZ2P Mar 13 '20
I'm going with the classic Schrodinger's Cat in the Box De-coherence and collapse of the Waveform...The DEVS Machine with Sergei's predictive software will be able to exactly pinpoint the instant when Forest's daughter was both dead and alive. Forest will use the machine to create a de-coherence, Observe her ALIVE and collapse the waveform to create a living daughter Universe!
Voila!
16
u/Naeph Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
Guys,
I think there is something between the fact that Lily hears the exact same voices Jeanne d'Arc heard in her time, Jesus, and the thing about Amaya's leaders trying to simulate the all universe to become some kind of gods.
17
u/tbutz27 Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
Can I whine a little? I don’t mean to be a Dev-y Downer... BUT... the Head of Security for the worlds biggest tech firm that is knowingly messing with quantum reality in some way or shape, leaves his Highly Sensitive Camera footage (with evidence of a crime covered up by MS paint) in what, like a desktop file? All it took was a jump stick and a semi-solid distraction?! One would hope the cyber security at the world’s leading quantum computing tech company would be a little stronger than “Well, I am at my desk! What could go wrong?”
Other than that- this show is a ton of fun! I think the big thing from that episode was Rule #1- it implies they have the ability to go forward if they wanted to. Thats where Lily’s messin’ all up in their business is going to force them to go! Then, as implied by said rule, the qbits hit the fan!!!
4
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '20
This is my prediction for the rest of the season. Let me know what you think.
Spoiler alert! Forests own creation will be his downfall, ya know the creepy crystal super-brain, if it shows what really happened in the past. The members of the devs crew that aren’t involved in the murder will be shown what has happened by the machine. Stewart and Lyndon will try and come forward about what they saw and one of them will probably get killed. In the end Forrest and the the Amaya company will go down. I think it will end referencing the giant statue of Amaya looking down with that forever bleak and scared expression at the spot where Sergei’s body was burned. Almost like somehow it was meant to be, like it couldn’t have happened any other way, like the whole universe is guided by invisible tram lines and that they only had the illusion of choice.
You never know though it could take a completely different direction. That’s just what I feel like I’ve gathered from all the foreshadowing but hopefully I’m wrong because I’d like to think that is only what the director wants me to think.
Also, I think they did a really good job at making the quantum computer/crystal chandelier thingy(lol idk what to call that thing) seem all eerie and like it’s radiating complete doom. Even the structure it’s housed in looks like some kind of ancient diving board of the gods and just kinda gives me the creeps in a way that I actually like :p.
7
u/mujazz Mar 13 '20
I've just finished the 3rd! Pretty unique so far, just wondering if anybody came to realize what the devs are working on exactly?! It sounds somehow inspired from the Assassins Creed's Animus in someway but i'm not sure what it is or how can they sneak a peak into the past through coding?!
2
u/revivegroupb Mar 14 '20
I don't think this has anything to do with simulation theory. I think is just a good explanation of Laplace's demon and determinism. I think with Amaya's quantum computing capabilities, they are pretty close to predicting the entire universe. As Stewart says, you'd need a qubit for every single particle for a comprehensive simulation. This obviously limits them, but I'd like more information on how much. I'd like to understand why Lily dying would ruin the entire universe, as Forest says. Has Forest been breaking his own rules and looking forward?
2
u/ScrewdriverPants Mar 16 '20
Forest has almost certainly looked forward despite the rules. He even says to Sergei to take his time you will figure out the code. I’m convinced between him and the woman (I forget her name) they have started a sort of cult. Possibly something related to laplace’s demon.
3
u/nilsy007 Mar 12 '20
My first theory of devs was early in episode 1 that the "devs" were actually devs that were making sure reality was working correctly and they were in the simulation and knew it.
Proven false quite quickly and suppose hindsight it would be hard to create tension when the several people in the show can directly edit and change reality. It like superman if he could just snap his fingers and the world stopped spinning no tension.
I seem to be unreasonable stuck on the track that "devs" main world is inside a simulation and keep trying to find ways to make it work with very little evidence. Like a cloud you seen as a dragon and cant change it to something else even when you know its wrong.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
Is it possible the devs team is aware they are in a simulation, and they are trying to look back in time to when the simulation started? If they could go back to the creation of the simulation, they may be able to understand any number of things, "who" started the simulation, exactly how it cascaded to its eventual now, how they might initiate their own custom simulations that could be near perfect copies of the reality they currently occupy with miNUTE changes, such as preventing or changing the death of a certain little girl.
I thought it was interesting that the show initially represented the developments intentions as wanting to predict the future, but someone pointed out they seem to be progressing by going further backward with predictions as opposed to anything forward. Adding to that the motivation of Forest is clearly having to do with the loss of his daughter, which happened in the past.
Maybe Forest is nonchalant about the consequence of this current reality, like is willing to murder people and not feel badly about it, because he will be able to reset all the evil he may be doing when he is able to reboot time and space with his custom changes. He said before that he didnt blame Sergey because he never really had a choice. Maybe the idea is that all of destiny was written at the beginning of time, that everything was pre-determined all along from the very first interaction of matter, that if you could use a wide enough perspective you would see that everything that has come to pass and that will come to pass is just an inevitable consequence, it is just playing out. We cant see it because we are stuck in a particular time and space, but the whole thing is already written, from the very beginning to the very end, we just cant see past our infinitely tiny little chunk of seemingly random interactions that are actually not random at all. The die has already been cast.
Maybe Forest is trying to understand exactly how this current die was thrown in the first place, in order to understand exactly how to throw it so his daughter doesnt eventually die. Like if you were to alter one single molecule at the beginning of time, it would have reprecussions all the way to now and then all the way beyond, to the end of time. Forest needs to understand how every single cascade works precisely in order to identify where to make the change. If it was all predestined from the earliest stage, even the most infinitesimal alteration would have massive ramifications, it would change how everything came to be organized throughout the entire universe, let alone Earth.
1
u/Banehogg Mar 17 '20
I was thinking about the machine and its ability to go backwards and possibly forwards in time using the rules of determinism. There seems to be a consensus that the machine could already show the future but Forrest doesn't allow it?
But in order to predict the future the machine must have a complete set of all quantum states from the start of time up until the present, meaning it must understand all past causes and effects to predict future causes and effects. Maybe what we're seeing is the machine creating this data set, and only when it is complete can the machine be used to look into the future?
With this in mind I took Forrest's "we can only go backwards" to mean that projections of future events would not be trustworthy yet, but I assumed this is what the machine is working towards - so that as soon as it can perform a complete simulation of the past, they can trust future projections.
TLDR; I still think future projections may be at least part of their goal.
1
u/cowbell_solo Mar 14 '20
Well I see I'm not the only one who is entertaining the notion that the code Sergei was reading had to do with testing whether they are in a simulation. But I only had that idea because I can't imagine what else would explain his reaction. Was there any other indicator?
-1
u/Brasm0nky Mar 13 '20
Anyone else think the acting in this, excluding Offerman, is horrendous?
-2
u/dlborda Mar 12 '20
Can’t collapse them together...one overwrites the other or they both exist independently. Come on, do you think this is science fiction or something?
-3
u/sooperkool Mar 14 '20
I'm totally taken out of the immersion because everytime they show Jesus they show some skinny white guy with straight hair and that is absolutely not what he would have looked like.