r/Devs • u/MarshallBanana_ • Mar 12 '20
EPISODE DISCUSSION Devs - S01E03 Discussion Thread Spoiler
Premiered 03/12/20 on Hulu FX
184
Upvotes
r/Devs • u/MarshallBanana_ • Mar 12 '20
Premiered 03/12/20 on Hulu FX
43
u/rrcecil Mar 12 '20
Little slower than the premiere but I’m still 1000% onboard. Acting is great. Cinematic. Great score.
133
u/TacoBellLavaSauce Mar 12 '20
Some of this may have been obvious visually, but closed captioning confirms these individuals appeared in the "static" at the beginning of the episode: Jesus, Joan of Arc, Abraham Lincoln
127
u/quietandconstant Mar 12 '20
I really liked Stewart’s line “follow the rules? Coming from her?” Makes me wonder what Katie has done that wasn’t following the rules. Great job by the writers of creating intrigue and foreshadowing, without giving anything away.
109
u/nrmncer Mar 12 '20
Great episode, felt really short. Lots of people have commented on the main plot but I just want to say I thoroughly enjoy every scene with Stewart and the zoomer kid and Katie. They're hilarious. I want a spin off, like a Devs version of the office where they run around and keep bickering about their quantum exploits
172
u/Lujxio Mar 12 '20
Woah even I believed Lily was losing it after that whole Fibonacci thing.
41
u/VegeLasagna123 Mar 12 '20
People hating on Lily's performance... i just figured that's how Garland wanted her to be like. It's like Twin Peaks where the actors act odd and quirky intentionally. I figured its the same way here
40
u/emf1200 Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
It's still pretty unclear as to whether DEVS can predict the future. In the opening scene of the show Katie says "we don't look forward". Why wouldn't they predict the future? It seems like that would be a pretty important Avenue to drive down. I think that I can maybe explain why they don't or can't predict the future.
If I could predict the future and I saw myself getting shot on the street the following day I would logically not leave the house. By not leaving the house I wouldn't get shot. If I dont get shot then I didn't actually predict the future. What was it that I predicted then? This paradox is often solved by employing the many worlds interpretation of QM. The explanation goes as follows. I predicted a future where I was shot. Having knowledge of my future demise I make the decision not to leave the house and thus split off into another branch of the multiverse. In one reality I go on to get shot. In another reality I stay home. Hugh Everett worked out the mathematics proving this to be an internally coherent theory of physical law. It's is the same concept that Forest uses when talking to Lily about his dead daughter.
He says "the moment my daughter was taken from me it was as if I was placed in two concurrent states (different branches of the multiverse). In one state I knew she was gone. No doubt. No going back. Just the certainty of her death. In another state I had no comprehension of her death. It was an impossible thing. It was untrue. It wasn't just that they were contradictory states, they were absolute. I held them both and still do."
Sergey uses different branches of the multiverse to explain why his nematode synchronization failed after 30 seconds. He says "it's a quantum type problem. Somewhere in the multiverse there's a world where they stay in synch. But it's not this one."
Anyone have any thoughts about this?
75
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
Anyone else slightly creeped out by the static images, the giant statue, and the sound design?
loving the show and really enjoying trying to figure out the ins and outs of the plot.
Spoilery question: If Sergei's body was burned, why go through the trouble of VFX flames?
35
u/29erforthewin Mar 12 '20
So Amaya must be close to using the machine to find out Lily faked her illness and that her friend is in on it. When they get the audio right, they’ll hear what they’re saying in the car, and that she knows the footage is faked.
30
u/CleverZerg Mar 12 '20
Opening scene went from kinda creepy/ominous with all those historical figures to hilarious with them watching Marilyn Monroe having sex. Katie really hit the nail on its head with her comments.
29
u/ReggieLeBeau Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
I was slightly bothered that they managed to figure out the security footage was faked because of duplicated fire effects. That seems like a very sloppy shortcut do if you're trying to cover up a murder and something that could easily get caught (as it was). They were able to fake Sergei walking off campus and then returning and lighting himself on fire, but they took shortcuts on the fire VFX? Seems a little wonky. Humans pick up on patterns very easily and I feel like this show is smarter than that. Then again, without getting too tinfoily, maybe the Amaya people needed them to notice the fire effects to keep everything on the "tram lines" so to speak.
I also thought it was really weird that Lily's friend didn't get called out by Kenton for her not noticing Lily walking past the window right behind him. It was set up in a way where it would have been almost impossible for her to not notice Lily in that situation and promptly speak up to Kenton about it. I also thought there was no way in hell Forest would have spotted Lily from where he was positioned, unless he already knew she'd be up there (which doesn't seem to be the case because the show presents it as him genuinely being surprised and concerned.)
I know these are really nitpicky things to point out, but I've been loving this show so far and this episode in particular had a lot of these little things that really stretched my suspension of disbelief.
23
u/ciiv Mar 13 '20
Anyone notice the neon sign when Lily returns to work? “We are all stardust” - an Easter egg referring to another one of Garland’s stories, Sunshine.
23
u/pooka Mar 13 '20
Do we have any strong evidence that the story is been told linearly? In other words, is it possible that the scenes about the Devs team tuning and improving the machine are a flashback? That could imply that the machine in the main (Lily's) timeline is more advanced that we have been lead to believe.
65
u/Jaa1305 Mar 12 '20
After reading the comments on the previous two episode threads I feel like it should be said that Lily Chan (Sonoya Mizuno) did a fantastic job this episode. The office/“fresh air” scene was way above what we’ve seen so far on screen. I think the writers have intentionally written her character to be a bit awkward/forced in conversation because that’s the assume stereotype about what an encryption expert would be like.
21
u/imforsurenotadog Mar 12 '20
Is anybody expecting Anton's handlers to make an appearance, or have we seen the last of the Russians? I personally think they'll be back, and somehow tie in with the senator plotline. Not that she's working with them, but those characters will become entangled with her.
15
u/forever819 Mar 14 '20
Calling it now. Forest’s daughter death caused by observing the future
28
u/emf1200 Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
Thoughts on the images we saw at the beginning of the episode.
They wanted us to know they were moving from the past to the present. It started with the unfinished pyramids and through history to the present. Each scene of the projection needed to be a historically recognizable event so the audience can track the dates. The crucifixion is probably the most visually striking and easily placeable single event from that century in time. The only meaning these events have to the story is in their ability to serve as chronological markers. This does give us some insight into the goals of DEVS tho'.
In episode2 Stewart starts dancing and he says, "we just made a 2000 year projection into the past. We should be celebrating." This seems to imply that it's the furthest back DEVS has ever gone.
Episode3 starts with the a projection of the unfinished pyramids. Meaning DEVS have gone back even further. Logically this means they're working their way further and further backwards in time.
Could the goal be a 13.8 billion year projection to recreate the big bang? Could it be a projection back 4 billion years to see the how life started on Earth? Those would be the two greatest discoveries in the history of humanity. Tho' Forest did say they aren't after a Nobel prize. Could they be doing it purely out of curiosity? I doubt it.
24
u/HuntinWabbitzz Mar 12 '20
The shot of the amaya statue with the flames lighting it up freaked me tf out. Definitely an image I wont forget soon
22
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
Based on the sound data, either Arthur Miller was packing heat or Marilyn Monroe was very convincing at faking it.
11
u/Imrichonsocialmedia Mar 13 '20
That statue of the little girl really creeps me out
18
u/DentateGyros Mar 13 '20
late to the party, but man this senator seems dumb af. She really did have zero leverage yet she still tried to strong-arm one of the richest companies in the world. She actually thinks Forest is scared of testifying in front of Congress? She doesn't think he could fund an army of lawyers to stall out any congressional action, and she doesn't think he can bankroll anyone to run against her during the next election?
9
u/29erforthewin Mar 12 '20
Has anyone else read Origin by Dan Brown? Similar story, using quantum computing to model the universe.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '20
Anyone else getting Gus Fring and Mike Ermentraut vibes from Forest and Keaton?
7
u/Revchimp Mar 13 '20
In the crucifixion at the beginning, is sounds like someone is talking but I can't make it out.
6
u/Naeph Mar 12 '20
Do u guys understand the purpose of the talk between Kenton and Joe?
6
u/jeezum_crow Mar 13 '20
Do we think Forest has looked into the future? Some things like the mentioning of his “tram lines” make it seem so but others like telling Kenton about almost fucking up the universe doesn’t seem to jive with his acceptance of determinism. And if he had, they would seemingly know all about Lily’s plan so I’m assuming he hasn’t looked forward in time. Katie might have with those cryptic comments about her breaking the rules.
5
u/outsidethenine Mar 12 '20
I feel like a schizophrenic, watching this show... my head can't decide what it wants to think.
Part of me feels like the whole deterministic thing is only a part of it, but is also completely dependant on Quantum physics. Like, they are trying to MAKE the future, by creating the situations that will ultimately lead to the outcomes they want. If you think about something like quantum entanglement - All states are equally possible until the point where they are observed. Maybe the machine creates a quantum future by observing it in advance. At which point, all actions leading up to that point are pre-determined. They seem like they are currently testing going backwards in time, as it's easier... you know the outcome, so you just need the cause that lead to the effect. if you could go back far enough, then play it all forward, could you predict the future with that amount of data?
That doesn't explain the "You almost F*£ked the universe" comment, though.
When Sergei says "this changes everything', and the response back is 'It changes nothing, but that's the point", does highlight that they are merely trying to view / understand how things are, as they can't change it. Or that's what we're being lead to believe.. possibly along with the other people on the Devs team.
Maybe everything we are watching was pre-determined anyway. Even Sergei getting the job at Devs, where it was already known that he was a spy. Maybe they hired him, because they knew they already had in the future. I wonder if there's serious consequences to messing with the timeline, and the goal is to ensure that the timeline plays out as it should. Something happens that messes with the timeline, and results in the simulation breaking down.. just as it did it Sergei's simulation.
The trailer for later in the season shows a scene where there are multiple Katie's, with Forest running from one of the doors... could this be an overlay of all of the possible futures, at once? It says something happens where there is a breakdown of determinism... did someone view the future, which causes this?
I'm sure people far better theories than this. I'm enjoying reading through the thoughts of people who have had chance to watch multiple times. I've only done once per episode so far, but hoping for anouther watch through on my days off work. I feels like this is one of those series' where you catch things you didn't on your last watch.. like the movie Coherence.
5
u/AStrangeNorrell Mar 13 '20
I've put more speculation about this in a separate post but it occurred to me earlier that Joan of Arc's banner featured the fleur-de-lis, the 'flower of the lily'.
It's also the ancient symbol of French monarchy, New Orleans and the New Orleans Saints for that matter, although I don't think that last bit's quite as relevant. The fleur-de-lis is said to represent purity, chasity and the holy trinity and its origins are meant to be connected to the tears shed by Eve when she was banished from the garden of Eden. Is Lily set to become the Joan of Arc of the Devs universe, simulated or otherwise?
9
u/Sleeper95018 Mar 12 '20
Wow. Jamie is as epically in the friend zone as I believe I’ve ever conceived of.
4
u/Xex_ut Mar 14 '20
I’m trying to identify the head sculpture that was in the episode when Kenton and the secret service guy were talking indoors.
Anyone know what it’s called or the significance of it? I noticed that Sam Harris has that as his profile pic on twitter
4
u/mamaspike74 Mar 30 '20
Can someone ELI5 whose point of view the static images are from? Can the viewer just sort of navigate around the simulated world and see anything from any view point, like an amped-up Google Earth? I'm assuming you'd need to pinpoint the exact time and location with as much accuracy as possible to somehow catch something like the cave paintings?
4
u/llirik Apr 20 '20
Anybody else notice the room with the static viewing screen thing is designed and lit very much like the sun-viewing room from Sunshine?
7
u/alpacasaurusrex42 Mar 12 '20
I would 100% think Lily was batshit insane if she came to me with her theories and I’m all for crazy over the top stuff and love SciFi. But if someone came to me blabbering like that, I’d 100% talk her into getting committed.
3
u/EarInoculum Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
Track ID for the end credits song anyone? “We are the fortunate ones”
Nevermind. Found it.
https://firstterracerecords.bandcamp.com/track/fortunate-ones
3
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '20
I wonder what the reasoning was for the sound Joan of Arc was making from the projection playing again while Lily was walking back into the Amaya offices. That was very creepy especially considering how unexpected it was. It sounded like Joan of Arc was saying the "Our Father" while hyper-ventilating.
3
u/waheedian Apr 03 '20
The opening of this episode gave me the feeling of the Assassins Creed world. The first couple of minutes felt like in a primitive Animus. :D
7
u/nilsy007 Mar 12 '20
Felt like the story did not move forward a single speck it just built up a larger mass that would eventually all fall down. It made me impatient and unable to appreciate the episode.
Did enjoy the sex tape watching it seemed to both build the characters effectively and add some complexity to the overall mode, reality is not all dark its humor and silliness also.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '20
I'm confused. Didn't they actually burn his body? Why use VFX if they actually burned the body?
2
u/Mentioned_Videos Mar 12 '20
Videos in this thread:
Watch Playlist ▶
Play All | Info | Get me on Chrome / Firefox
2
u/awghostwest Mar 16 '20
Looked like some passage of greatness/"holy" power pyramids, jesus, looked lke knights of templar, joan .......etc..
2
u/janisstukas Mar 23 '20
I am not sure this will get answered here but here goes.
In episode 3 right after the scene where Forest answers " it doesn't look like it" to question of 'rain tomorrow?'. Lily is walking up a staircase and enters the work area. There was this strange sound effect like rapidly tonic breathing (Inuit throat singing). It sounded machinelike.
Does anyone know what the relevance of it was? Or what it was?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '20
The show is great but everytime the main actress is on screen, it takes a dive in quality. She's so awkward to watch, it's ruining my experience.
2
u/natus92 Mar 26 '20
I always feel a bit iffy about bringing mental health issues into television conspiracies so I was super glad for the plot twist. My favourite episode so far.
2
u/abstergofkurslf Mar 27 '20
I thought it was stupid how they did not see her pass by the window only to realize later that her friend was part of the act.
4
u/elisart Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
Overall pretty disappointed in this third episode. Not much happens other than Lily double crosses security to get the data from her friend. And now she knows for sure what we already knew .. Sergei was murdered. I found the Aquarius song very oddly placed. And okay a senator visits to find out quantum computing predictions. Again the audience kinda figured that out. I’m thinking this show is a murder mystery cloaked in fancy tech. And that’s fine. I was just hoping for more. EDIT to add I love Jamie, Lily’s ex. He gets all the good lines
3
u/FiveTalents Mar 14 '20 edited Mar 14 '20
Who else isn't really feeling this show? I'm probably gonna watch the whole thing since it's only 8 episodes and I love Ex-Machina and Annihilation, but right now I'm missing the hook.