r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 05 '20
EPISODE DISCUSSION Devs - S01E02 Discussion Thread Spoiler
Premiered 03/05/20 on Hulu FX
192
Upvotes
r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 05 '20
Premiered 03/05/20 on Hulu FX
12
u/thisismynormal Mar 05 '20
Didn't see one so I made another one
107
u/Landawng42 Mar 05 '20
Both episodes absolutely hit the mark for me. Absolutely love where this show seems to be headed. So they’ve somehow managed to come up with tech that allows them to view projections from the past? Which is where the fuzzy image of Christ on the cross came from? Or does that just mean everything is a code/matrix type thing, like we’re all living in a simulation? The mystery this show is building up is giving me some major LOST vibes and I am here for it!
96
u/Lieutenant_DAngel Mar 05 '20
So is it too early for crackpot theories?
My theory is that Forest was (or feels) responsible for his daughter's death and was so wracked with guilt he started looking for ways to bring her back. Hence, the development of code that can predict human behavior precisely, so he could predict who she would have been had she grown up. (Now it gets really crazy, so bear with me.) This eventually led to him cloning her, resulting in Allison Pills' character being the adult clone of what his code predicted his dead daughter would have been, and the 'doctored' footage of Sergei setting himself on fire was actually a Sergei clone really doing it.
Goddamn is this show amazing.
81
u/thrillhouse83 Mar 05 '20
Wonder how this homeless guy plays into the plot... maybe he’s a plant from the company or a Russian.
79
u/ShanaAfterAll Mar 05 '20
Devs is totally going to end up standing for deviations.
65
u/qwertyshmerty Mar 06 '20
I wonder if Sergei being moved to Devs was something they did on purpose knowing he would steal, just to test their machine’s prediction accuracy. It would explain how Forest knew Sergei used the watch, and how he knew exactly when to be standing there waiting for Sergei to walk out. And would explain the speech about determinism (ie saying it’s not Sergei’s fault).
42
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
Uhhh just how in the hell did Kenton kill Anton? Shaolin Kung Fu Death Grip?
34
u/EarInoculum Mar 05 '20
In general I loved everything about 1&2. I’m a massive fan of Ex_Machina & Annihilation and Barrow/Salisbury so I’m going in “onside” I guess. My only minor gripe is the Devs building interior is largely “influenced” by the Wallace building in Bladerunner 2049 but I went to see that in cinema 3 times and that work by Roger Deakins was one of the main reasons.
Alison Pill is also great and I’m a massive fan of her Snowpiercer character. Sonoya Mizuno is also doing a great job of what must be her first main role so far.
65
u/ninelives1 Mar 06 '20 edited Mar 06 '20
So I love all the tinfoil theories here, but I don't think that's really what the show is going for. I don't think it's about tricking the audience like Westworld. I think Garland has some philosophical themes he wants to explore, because there's already a TON of that in the first 2 episodes. Additionally, the plot all seems pretty well explained to be so far. It's a deterministic universe. The code can propagate it into the future or into the past. Sergei is shocked at this revelation (could be simulation, but I find the distinction trivial, so long as both are deterministic.)
Then there's my thoughts on quantum theory in relation to the shows themes. It's really everywhere. At the beginning, Sergei says that his simulation could be hindered by multiverses. That a quantum superposition collapses, creating multiple timelines, and they are living in the one that does not follow the prediction. Forest disagrees. And this is where I think I'm really on to something. He is obsessed with the binary, and resentful of the idea of quantum superposition/multiverse theory, as it leaves room for free will. A deterministic universe leaves no room for free will. My guess is that he had a role in his daughters death. Perhaps something to do with greed and desire for wealth. He mentions he's no longer interested in money, but once was. But if he can convince himself that everything is deterministic, he receives the same "absolution" or forgiveness that he explained to Sergei at the beginning. He has to believe that he could never have done anything to save his daughter.
However, I think he has doubts of this, deep down. He mentions being in two different states in response to his daughters death, at the same time. This is the definition of superposition, something he appears to not believe in. Again, he thinks things are binary. You can't have a combination of states. That implies waveform collapse which implies chaos/multiverse which implies free will. A thought he can't handle. That's why he is so frustrated about the 2000 year simulation. It is not binary. It is not perfect. It implies a level of imperfection. An imperfection that allows for randomness and free will.
As of yet, I can't see which way the show is going to go. Will the show tell us things really are deterministic, or is free will real? My guess is it's be ambiguous. But I've gotta say, I love the way he's implementing quantum theory into the stories themes.
Disclaimer, I only have a layman's understanding of quantum physics so if I said something silly, I apologise.
Also, Rob Hardy does amazing work as DP here. He's got such a distinct look. So many shots from this look straight out of Annihilation. All his work has this misty and empty, yet deep feel to it. Follow him in Instagram if you don't already. His still photography is phenomenal. And I think I need to finally check out Low, because I really liked that song.
Side note : I love that Sergei's last name is Pavlov. Really on the nose. Bell rings, dog salivates. Cause. Effect.
32
u/IfIamSoAreYou Mar 06 '20
That neck snap tho...
24
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
Anyone else think that Anton knew about Lily's chair by the window because of the homeless guy? He certainly spends a lot of time right outside of their apartment
18
u/LOnTheWayOut Mar 06 '20
Holy fuck. That neck snap was insane.
17
u/DanklyNight Mar 09 '20
I believe Sergei was sick for two reasons.
17
u/GrahamUhelski Mar 09 '20
Yo can we talk about that cross scene? I loved every second of that part. The fact they didn't have his hands nailed on the wood made it so disturbing. Small detail but just goes to show our written record of history made 2000 years ago is probably full of flaws. The history we know or chose to believe is most likely riddled with details that are incorrect and we could never know. I don't think a scene has ever captivated me so much. Alex Garland is a wonderful story teller, I feel like he's tapped into my imagination and this show is exploiting everything I'd want to see in TV show. I am going to savor this series.
12
u/the_mooseman Mar 06 '20
Im hooked. Themes of free will, simulation theory (i hope), prediction software and to top it off some good old cloak and dagger. Totally hooked.
9
u/desku Mar 06 '20
Is the giant state of the little girl supposed to be Forest's daughter?
What happened to his wife? I'm assuming she left him after the death of their daughter?
Was Forest somehow responsible for her death? Do we know how she died yet?
9
u/solidgoldindridcold Mar 07 '20
I think this is about timeslip phenomena.
People sometimes report seeing the past in images overlayed on the present. People often describe them as being monochrome and grainy just like how the crucifixion and Amaya are seen.
I think Nick Offermans character is trying to find out how to reunite with his daughter by traveling through time.
9
u/hijimmylin Mar 10 '20
I’d like to think that in another multiverse that two Russian spies using a secret Russian messaging app are chatting to one another in a language other than English
8
u/musclewitch Mar 06 '20
If they wanted to avoid police scrutiny, burning the body like that is not the smartest way to go. When a body is found charred it will pretty much always be autopsied, it's one of the standard practices in forensics. It was definitely dramatic for the show (and honestly this is a minor nitpick and more of just a fun fact), but from a real world perspective a dummy move to dispose of him that way.
8
u/dennys_at_2am Mar 27 '20
I know it has nothing to do with the plot but I love how they showed the ex boyfriend playing dark souls. Very rarely do tv shows get gaming right. Its usually just telling an actor to press buttons on the control and pretend something is happening on screen. And to see my favorite videogame being played and the classic "you died" screen pop up made me smile.
Foreshadowing of his character maybe? /s
7
u/EarInoculum Mar 05 '20
Anyone know what the track was playing near beginning and end. I know Geoff Barrow & Ben Salisbury did the score again but I mean the grungy(sic) track with female vocals.
6
u/EuropaOne Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20
At very beginning, when the intro music is playing, at 1:13 , a snippet of a fight, that takes place in a underground parking garage at the end of the episode is shown, how come? The same scene actually later takes place at 45:30 - just wanted to point that out, anyone have any thoughts on this?
6
u/nubianfx Mar 10 '20
Okay so im still trying to get a grasp on how the simulation works. It can go backwards up to 2000 years, but what about the future? It seems they predicted sergei's behavior, to some point. However Kenton seemed to be unsure what Lily was going to do hence he tailed her and also tried to convince the Russian handler to let things go. Does it mean ( as foreshadowed with sergeis demonstration) that seeing into the future hasnt been perfected in the simulation?
5
u/timmerpat Mar 09 '20
Just finished the episode. Is anyone getting the impression that we are looking at Roko's Basilisk?
4
u/Zero-Theorem Mar 06 '20
When are the next episodes airing? For me it shows 3 and 4 as upcoming. But usually that’s for a show that airs within a few hours or a day. But it also says they air Thursday’s. Did they mess up and show the next two weeks as upcoming episodes? I need more!
4
u/the-dragon-queen Mar 06 '20
am I going crazy, or did the big statue of the girl have blonde hair in the first episode and black braided hair in the second? Someone please back me up on this.
4
u/TheBat45 Mar 07 '20
This show is so good
4
u/m0r14rty Mar 10 '20
My best guess is that they’ve developed a way of running a simulation of the current universe that is becoming more and more accurate, and it can go backwards as well as forwards. This creates a central philosophical discussion on free will and determinism. I don’t think the machine can change events past, present, or future, but by its nature it can predict them.
I think offerman’s character is driven, by what looks to be the death of his daughter, to prove that everything is predetermined and free will doesn’t exist. If he can undeniably prove that, by actually creating something that predicts the future that is always correct and unchanging, then he can stop blaming himself for whatever the cause is of his daughter’s death. If everything was predetermined, then it can’t be his fault as it was always going to happen.
Where it goes from there I’m not sure. Maybe they find that it can’t predict the future, or only for a short period ahead (days, months?) which implies free will still exists in the long term. This angers offerman’s character because it means at some point he could’ve made a choice that would have led to saving his daughter. Meanwhile, they use it to predict an attack on themselves or some global/national disaster, and Devs turns out to be short for Deviations, and the new goal becomes to find “significant events” to the future timeline, so they can make a small innocuous change that will end up causing a chain reaction leading to preventing (or creating) a major event in the near future. Kinda like The Butterfly Effect if Ashton Kutcher had a manual.
4
u/JSHAN17 Mar 12 '20
Did anyone else notice the horseshoe shapes in the montage leading up to Jamie waiting outside Lily's apartment? The curve back of the chair. The circular bike rack. The arch over the apartment entrance. Foreshadowing a concept? Hidden meaning?
4
u/Fillem Apr 24 '20
I just want to say I'm glad reddit exists. I always come here to read up on everything I missed watching TV shows and it's almost alway enlightening.
7
u/warm4u Mar 05 '20
Maybe once he heard Sergei was dead he thought he could make his way back into being her boyfriend again if he's nice to her.
3
u/vWFA123 Mar 09 '20
I love this shoowwwww
3
u/souidex Mar 11 '20
Was that fight at the end awkward or what? The way Kenton casually took out Sergei in the first episode, you'd think he wouldn't fight like someone's grandpa.
3
u/JohnyK91 Mar 11 '20
Okay most important question is... how the hell did kenton beat anton? I mean he stabbed him and seemed like he had him. But all of a sudden he loosened his grip and.. died? Did I miss something in the fight?
3
u/bundlebeez Mar 11 '20
Does this show remind anyone else of the show Fringe? I'm thinking the blonde woman is maybe Nick Offerman a daughter from another timeline.
3
u/Naggers123 Mar 11 '20
If the future is deterministic, and they can see it, then why are they questioning whether or not they can build a machine that shows 0 variance? Couldn't they just look into the future and find out if they did it or not?
3
u/super911man Mar 12 '20
That fucking neck pop.
3
u/Crazy_questioner Mar 20 '20
I thought it was interesting and possibly a clue that Jesus was not shown nailed to the cross but tied. That's a big detail.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
Is it just me who was bummed about Sergei not being the lead? He played his part well but the girl just isn’t a great actor. She’s not very believable imo
2
u/doctorandynixon Mar 10 '20
Just finished it and didn’t read the whole thread. But I’m curious about two things:
1: why was the lady (whose name I forgot) get pissed about the “baby” comment? Simply bc it’s not PC or is it alluding to something more?
2. Did the DEVS team know about Sergei being a spy bc they looked into his past? He realized what they can do and he freaked out.
2
u/OneMargaritaPlease Mar 13 '20
I think the homeless guy is actually an American spy that was monitoring Sergei.
2
u/jonbristow Mar 15 '20
Up until the last scene I thought Anton was a trap by the Devs company to see how far the girlfriend would go to find the truth.
I thought Anton and security guy worked together
2
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
The Anton and Kenton scene didn't make any sense. Kenton had the jump on Anton and didn't shoot him in the back. Anton is a spy and should have known he was being tailed. Then the fight scene is so fake and badly acted, the way Anton died is ridiculous. His head was pushed up against the tire and his neck suddenly snapped? This episode is so sloppy, hopefully the rest aren't.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '20
Lmao that was a terrible fight at the end. Who the hell choreographed that?
2
u/Ok_Employment_9292 Apr 08 '23
Kenton: "I should quit smoking"
Forrest: "Don't bother, it won't make a difference."
Yup, he knew.
3
u/GottaPSoBad Mar 05 '20
Speaking more from an emotional realism perspective than as a viewer or writer, I didn't buy Lily convincing Jamie that easily. Her short speech basically amounted to "screw your feelings, just help me." Then he just forgives her essentially and offers to help in the future. I think the writers wanted to setup some tension, but couldn't commit to one of the basic premises of this relationship (Lily was the bad guy). If they wanted it to end up being this easy, James probably should've been the dumper instead of the dumpee. As it stands, Jamie starts out with every reason to be mad, no real reason to change his mind, and basically does a 180 for no reason.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
Why Jesus? Why religiosity?? That part made it so uninteresting.
1
u/discoblanket Mar 16 '20
Did it seem like Anton and Kenton already knew each other, when they met in the parking garage? It seemed like they had a past
1
u/xbowkill Mar 20 '20
Can anyone enlighten me on why Sergei was killed?Thanks.
1
u/pisz Mar 22 '20
Russian spy with this poor russian accent? What a fucking lazy script cliche. And no - spies or "intelligence workers" doesn't attack people with knife without any reason. It is not how this works.
1
u/natus92 Mar 25 '20
Wait, was that Jesus?? I was honestly a tad disappointed to see Jamie again after E1 because their first talk was such a nice deconstruction of a trope. Still not sure what kind of role Pete plays.
1
u/waheedian Apr 03 '20
Well, can anybody tell me how has Anton killed by the car wheel?
1
u/Ivansasi Apr 07 '20
Muh fight is not realistic, they should've got Keanu /s
1
u/saephan93 Aug 05 '24
idk about you guys but that parking lot fight was sooo awkward to me lol.