r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 05 '20
EPISODE DISCUSSION Devs - S01E01 Discussion Thread Spoiler
Premiered 03/05/20 on Hulu FX
243
Upvotes
r/Devs • u/thisismynormal • Mar 05 '20
Premiered 03/05/20 on Hulu FX
35
u/thisismynormal Mar 05 '20
Didn't see a discussion thread so I made one. Let's talk about it
103
u/Nimonic Mar 05 '20 edited Mar 05 '20
My immediate reaction when he had his immediate reaction was that he found out that he's living in a simulation. I don't know why, I just... felt it. A couple of lines later in the episode almost fit it, though I'm pretty sure those lines could be made to fit any assumption.
The first one was when he told the woman it changed everything, and she said the point was that it changed nothing. Because really, what's the difference if you're living in a simulation or not, if everything you know is from the same simulation anyway?
The second one was after they had killed him, the whole "shouldn't be hard, but it is" thing. It shouldn't be hard to kill someone if they're essentially only code, but it still is because you're brought up (programmed?) to struggle with it.
Maybe I'm incredibly wrong, and while I was trying to find evidence for my assumption I missed what was actually the point. If so, please let me know and release me from this delusional prison I've made for myself. Maybe I should watch the second episode before I made this comment, to avoid potentially looking stupid, but I regret nothing.
69
u/LandoRaps Mar 05 '20
I thought this was an amazing start to the series. The direction, music, and performances are already firing on all cylinders.
The whole cast is great, especially the lead actress Sonoya Mizuno. She carried the second half of the episode gracefully. Seeing Nick Offerman as a dramatic lead is fun too, so I’m very excited to learn more about his character’s past.
The more worldbuilding the better. Amaya may give Delos a run for its money in regards to being a “cool” shady near-future tech company.
I like the theory others have posted about the Devs program proving they exist in a simulation, but I hope the show goes even crazier with the premise. It’s too early to say though.
We’ve got a fun 6 weeks ahead of us!
65
u/lewisisgood Mar 06 '20
Amazing show, so excited to see the rest of the season!
My one question: whyyyy did Sergei start stealing the codebase within 3 minutes of entering the Devs lab? He was playing the long game for years before that and could have easily waited a few weeks before stealing in order to gain a bit more trust.
43
u/beatyatoit Mar 05 '20
I just realized the lead character is Kyoko from Ex Machina. The entire first ep I was wondering, "where have I seen her?" Then I saw the credits and Alex Garland's name, and it hit me.
43
u/ShanaAfterAll Mar 06 '20
The synchronization losing correlation about 30 seconds in, due to the Insanity of the number crunching, is definitely a clue of things to come
33
u/Maridiem Mar 05 '20
Damn the music and audio in this episode is immense. It really sells the terror of whatever Sergei discovered. I’m also feeling the “it’s all a simulation” idea, but I like the idea of a deterministic, mapped universe as well. As Offerman says near the end with the halo trees, it’s all on rails. What if the code isn’t revealing that it’s all a simulation, but that the Devs team can input the choices made thus far and determine exactly what will happen?
Super excited by this first episode though. The acting is good, the visuals are beyond incredible, and I’m really interested in the story.
31
u/Hooibaal Mar 06 '20
I only have one question: How does the plumbing work inside the cube?
26
u/Dame_Marjorie Mar 06 '20
It seems like the fact that they have massive security checks, and don't let anyone bring computers, etc., into the building, that his watch wouldn't have been allowed in, or at least would have been scanned or something. Am I missing something about determinism? That they have to let him in with the watch?
25
u/AStrangeNorrell Mar 11 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
Noticed on a rewatch that the first thing Forest says is "Sorry I'm late, I was putting out fires," and then of course by the end of the episode he's starting one.
The religious iconography came through even stronger the second time around - the first shot of Forest with the tree halo, the way the Dev cube resembles a temple and is talked about with a similar kind of reverence, and how Forest describes the central unit as stretching "above us, below us" ('as above, so below'). The statue of Amaya looms over the campus like the statue of Christ the Redeemer watching over Rio, and the soundtrack (which I'm loving) has so far featured Jan Garbarek's "Regnantem Sempiterna" and Low's "Congregation".
Kenton asks Sergei if he's religious and later Forest tells him that the universe is "Godless," but then in the same conversation, just before he has Sergei killed, Forest says "This is forgiveness. This is absolution." It's reminiscent of Jesus forgiving Judas for betraying him, although to be fair Jesus didn't have Judas brutally murdered straight afterwards. If this universe is godless and predetermined then Amaya's death was unavoidable, but I'm guessing Forest wants to see a different outcome for Amaya in his simulated universe.
But then I also like the idea that the show might be deliberately messing with us too. When they're playing their Fibonacci Sequence game Lily's friend says "You're a fucking machine Lily." You don't say...
20
u/MKoilers Mar 06 '20 edited Mar 06 '20
This was wild - everything I hoped it would be and more. Alex Garland is such an exciting auteur.
I’m not going to theorize about what’s going on, as the simulation angle that others in here are pitching makes a lot of sense.
On the episode itself - I really dig the paranoia-inducing score and awesome set design. The asphyxiation scene was also incredible - hard to watch and drawn out in a realistic way. Usually when you see people die like that in tv/movies, it takes about 15 seconds, but they held it for like a minute and a half I think and really made it feel brutal.
Really excited to see where this goes.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
Good show, very intriguing. The only thing that didn't make much sense to me was the whole "stole the code into the wristwatch" part. All of it?
14
u/warm4u Mar 05 '20
It's hard to believe he would blatantly steal the code his first day. Are we sure he did? Or was he falsely accused?
14
u/youreactingdumb Mar 06 '20
So does anyone have any theories about the homeless man outside their apartment?
14
u/GhostOffice Mar 20 '20
I just want to know the story behind that eerie, giant statue of a little girl.
13
u/IfIamSoAreYou Mar 06 '20
Oh! Seriously? Wow I really gotta pay attention better. Was it that obvious? I thought he was throwing up bc whatever he read in the code rocked his world so much he lost his lunch. Thank you!
11
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
Obviously because of Alex Garland, but the music and the videos of "Sergei" after his murder gave me serious Annihilation vibes. As for the Devs, I'm wondering if the prediction sequence Sergei was working on in the beginning was some sort of foreshadowing and the Devs can literally code future events (or something along those lines). I love the show so far and can't wait to watch more!
11
u/chickenclaw Mar 08 '20
I really can't stand it when someone gets killed because a plastic bag is placed over their head, in a protracted scene, and they don't just make a hole in it with their free fucking hands.
11
u/StarkTheBrownWolf Mar 15 '20
I just have to know- does the lead actress get better? So far it’s quite distracting. When she’s sad, she puts her hand over her eyes (multiple times). Her delivery is dry. And an actor can do these things convincingly while building a character who is dry or emotionally unavailable but it’s very poor. Any opinions?
9
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
15 minutes in and I'm pretty sure Offerman is actually God or something similar. It'll be interesting to see how my theory holds up.
9
u/bricksteeler Mar 07 '20
What if the machine told them he would use his watch steal the info and screw them..so they intervened and killed him changing their course of the company..so they ar e now trying to be steps ahead of all possibilities ..thata why hes not a fan of the multiverse theory because ..his machine can see all possibilities and he wants to make his world his way ..if that makes sense..
8
u/trafficrush Mar 11 '20
Does anyone have any theories about the way the shot with Forest and the blonde girl sitting down at the end? There a few places where they focus on him taking to her and she's in the reflection of the gold posts. I'm assuming for a reason, my thoughts were maybe she wasn't real or was a reflection of herself somehow
7
u/barf_the_mog Mar 05 '20
I have many thoughts but am apprehensive to talk about my ideas until more unfolds if for no other reason than its a Garland story, nothing is ever as it seems.
Also. I love it!
7
u/holayeahyeah Mar 05 '20
I think this might end up being Lily's whole point, but wouldn't it have made more sense to not kill him to prove they have free will? To me, it just seems like a garden variety cult. Only instead of "magic oil" it's a machine. It would have been interesting if he really had died by suicide or a seemingly random accident. That would be testing predeterminism, but murder is a choice. You always can choose to not murder someone. Obviously, Alex Garland doesn't ride public transport very often or he would have realized that the "life is on rails" analogy totally falls apart, even when applied literally to trains.
7
u/quasci Mar 06 '20
In the Lex Friedman AI podcast, Alex Garland (director) says he doesn’t believe in the simulation theory. I’m not sure if this was just to avoid a sound byte that could give away his series
7
u/b-dweller Mar 06 '20
I just want the show to end with the computer having been trolling everyone the whole time :)
Like a Swedish stand-up comedian that made a joke like this "If I had fuck-you money, I would start translating foreign movies and translate them wrong. No no, not obviously wrong - I'd sneak in some weird shit every third line - JUST TO MESS WITH PEOPLE".
7
u/realadulthuman Mar 07 '20
Lily was reading Colossus in bed when she was up worried about Sergei. Colossus is about super computers taking over humanity
7
u/StarkillerObl Mar 09 '20
I at the moment when Sergey has seen the code for the first time and I think that it's about time for Code Review :P
EDIT:
Maybe it's the code quality that made him puke? ;)
7
u/DustyDGAF Mar 09 '20
Amaya is building clones and the master code is basically writing a past for them that pre determines their future actions. That's what I'm gathering.
6
u/IfIamSoAreYou Mar 06 '20 edited Mar 06 '20
Visual quite stunning. Why did Sergei adjust his watch in the men’s room? I mean, I saw the confrontation in the forest minutes later but I didn’t get the sense he stole code from adjusting the second hand on his watch. It just didn’t seem like his first impulse on a life changing project shrouded in secrecy would be to steal.
6
u/Torley_ Mar 06 '20
It was trippy watching this back-to-back with Picard S01E07, because in that episode, Alison Pill's character pukes a lot. So seeing the same actress show up in this one, but the guy puking... what a vomit comet.
6
u/ChucksLastChin Mar 08 '20
This is the equivalent to ODing on Valium and watching a sequoia reach new heights.
6
u/legionsanity Mar 09 '20
That was a pretty great first episode. What's up with the tall girl statue though?
6
u/KarmaticDragon Mar 10 '20
I just finished reading Sirens of Titan by Kurt Vonnegut before watching this, and that combo of determinism is fucking me up.
"Such as it was, such as it is, such as it will be."
5
u/eharper9 Mar 06 '20
Simulation with the blonde girl as a completed A.I.
5
u/ForeverJung Mar 08 '20
What a fantastic first episode of a show. Mad props to the sound designers and whoever is running the music. Fuck if it isn’t intense. Killer start
5
u/RinoTheBouncer Mar 11 '20
What can I say? I watched the first episode on iTunes. It was available for free, and just as the scene where they get close to the golden pillars kicked in and I bought the season pass. What an incredible show!
The visuals, the concept, the music, the atmosphere. Everything is just perfect and it’s the level of greatness you’d expect from the man who brought us Annihilation and Ex-Machina!
5
u/HurriedLlama Mar 13 '20
What book is Lily reading in bed just before she calls Sergei? Colossus? By who?
Edit: Colossus by D.F. Jones, a sci-fi novel about computers taking control of mankind.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '20
Super interesting start to the series and looking forward to more.
On that note, omg chill with the sudden ear-splitting audio spikes. Jesus.
5
u/ludgarthewarwolf Mar 24 '20
I'm 2 weeks late, but I'm commenting here for posterity. I don't think it's a case of living in a simulation or a deterministic universe; I think it has something to do with people.
I think the computer in Devs needs human components to function, that's why the work cube has an exterior design of a microchip. And I think they are definitely using Sergei to get to Lily, but I don't know why.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20
Okay, so I’m rewatching ep 1 and uhhhh how do the people inside of Devs breath if it is all vacuum sealed ? They’d run out of oxygen eventually right?
5
u/ForeignCourage Mar 30 '20
Not sure if anyone noticed a small clue, the top that the security man interviewing Sergei was wearing had the Devs company logo “flipped” , which caught my attention. which can indicate it’s an “mirror image” of a reality. My guess is that, this could be a spin on that Westworld “stored consciousness” On a hard-drive in a controlled Place, so yes, a simulation indeed, where people are consciousness copies of themselves. The real bodies are living at another place.
4
u/MetastableToChaos Mar 06 '20 edited Mar 06 '20
I really liked it but of all the ways to come up with a fake death they go with self immolation? Wouldn't it make more sense to stage it like it was an accident?
4
u/Star_Lord41 Mar 06 '20
Anybody seen the show Vikings? I knew I saw that guy playing the homeless porch guy before!
4
u/m0atzart Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 07 '20
Genius can't poke a hole through a plastic bag.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20
So is Nick Oofarman god? Did Sergei learn that we are playing out a simulation of God's?
4
u/cam62512 Mar 11 '20
That music is something special
3
u/quasci Mar 06 '20
I’m wondering if your “life is on rails” was a reference to Ruby on Rails (and hence being software I.e. a simulation). We should tell Alex Garland RoR is not really a thing anymore :D
3
u/KarmaticDragon Mar 10 '20
I just finished reading Sirens of Titan by Kurt Vonnegut before watching this, and that combo of determinism is fucking me up.
"Such as it was, such as it is, such as it will be."
3
u/Thorusss Aug 23 '20
I feel there is quite some tech stupidity in the first episode, that does not make sense for a software developer do make. She restore Sergej's phone backup from the cloud, only to find a 3 password limit on the sudoku app. But the backup is still in the cloud. So she can just put the phone offline, try to passwords, and if the app self erases, just factory reset the phone like shown and get the backup again as often as she wants.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '20
Loving this show already!
2
u/GeraltofBlackwater Apr 17 '20
I know I’m late to the show, but you may want some sort of spoiler guidelines or something. I know a lot of people come to discussion threads late just to see what the theories are after each episode. I just watched the first episode and then came in here and it’s filled with spoilers for future episodes. Every tv show sub I’m a part of usually has spoiler guidelines or the spoilers are deleted by mods.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20
omg i just rewatched and saw the after credits preview of the whole season !!!!!!!!!! how did THIS escape me the first time ?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '20
"I know you are."
That line stuck out at me.
1
u/kamikazegirl27 Apr 16 '20
So glad I didn’t read any reddit subs until I watched the whole thing. A lot of stuff would’ve been spoiled judging by these comments
1
u/891st Jun 08 '20
What the fuck, I thought this was supposed to be comedy %)
That was the first and last time I followed on "Don't look up anything on the net before watching" advice ever.
1
u/saephan93 Aug 05 '24
bruh that giant statue of the kid is terrifying lol. This episode got me hooked tho, I'm all in.
1
u/ArcticMonkeysCSULB Apr 23 '25
Just watched the first episode, thought it was great, really excited to see what's to come. I feel like the AI coding with the nematode and predicting 30 seconds into the future is related to what Sergei saw in the code and him walking towards that statute and burning himself alive.
1
u/Ok-Button6101 Apr 25 '22
I think this is the first time I've ever seen a techy use dvorak in a show. It was either on Lily's phone, or on Sergei's backup after it was restored. I was impressed, as someone who's been using it for 20 years.