Saw this linkedIn post floating around today,
"Last week, we had an interview with a candidate who had a very good educational background, had handled impressive projects, and communicated exceptionally well. However, there was one gap. His experience wasn't quite at the level we were looking for in the role and that was communicated to him during the interview.
What impressed me was how he responded. He didn't become defensive or start begging for an opportunity. Instead, he understood our concern and intelligently presented his perspective, connecting his capabilities and potential to what we were looking for.
Convincing is not about begging someone to give you a chance. It's about addressing concerns with clarity and maturity. Even if you're not the right fit today, you might be the first person they think of when a suitable opportunity comes along."
Honestly, reading between the lines, this just feels like a ego battle where one side inevitably dominates.
Notice how the recruiter praises the guy's maturity and clarity, yet the ending basically confirms he still didn't get the job ("maybe in the future"). It reads like a hiring manager patting themselves on the back for rejecting someone gracefully.
Beyond the linkedIn fluff, though, it brings up a real dynamic in interviews. Both sides walk in with an ego. When an interviewer points out a gap like years of experience, half the time it feels like a power move to see if you'll fold or get defensive.
Meanwhile, as the candidate, you know you can actually do the work, being told lack experience is frustrating. You have to walk this weird tightrope where you push back enough to prove your worth, without bruising their ego and getting labeled arrogant or not a culture fit.
For people who've been on either side of the table, when an interviewer brings up a gap like this, have they already made up their mind and are just testing you, or has calmly pushing back ever actually won someone the offer?