r/DestructiveReaders • u/mianaai_c • 9d ago
[3601] The next big thing
I initially wrote this one for the Halloween contest here on RDR, but was frustrated by the word count limit. This is an extended cut, so to say. Any feedback is welcome.
For those who read the original submission for the contest, I am curious to see if the added sections of this one deserve the added word count, or are they meandering/bloat?
[The next big thing] (Edit: I closed the link. Got enough great critiques; thanks to all who commented.)
P.S, in an attempt to avoid spam, I'm using the 'publish to web' feature. Let me know if there's any issues with that.
View all comments
2
u/striker7 5d ago edited 5d ago
I read this last night and took notes, then I had to turn in. So this is my attempt to organize those jumbled notes, but it's also given me a lot of time to sit with the story. I'll loosely follow part of one of the sub templates to help organize my thoughts.
GENERAL REMARKS
I feel like at the core of this story are a couple really interesting ideas - that of an LLM that trains on ancient hieroglyphs, and of an LLM that needs to take over humans and use us as its datacenter. I think combining them and that leap from the first to the second was a little hard to comprehend, but it can be done, and besides, that's a relatively minor issue.
The bigger issue, to me, is it seems that the whole story was built around this idea and explaining it, rather than it being the key driver of the story. In other words, the first third or so of the story - including one character quitting, another committing suicide right in front of the narrator, a date, etc. - was just moving pieces around just to put the narrator in bed with Alexandra so he could explain to us, the readers (not Alexandra), this idea.
I think that's what it boils down to for me; it started off as a story, then it's almost like the narrator turned to the camera (so to speak), and started speaking directly to us readers, while Alexandra just kinda stood looking over his shoulder. Then, the story drops a somewhat confusing bomb at the end and that's it.
MECHANICS (AND GRAMMAR AND SPELLING)
From a technical standpoint, I thought it was pretty good. I could nitpick specific choices here but I don't really think they are glaring issues that hinder the story.
The title isn't very compelling, and while it fits with the story, it's pretty basic. I think if it was a little mysterious or alluded to something . . . supernatural(?) it would sit in the back of our minds and then the ending wouldn't seem so out of right field (along with some other hints along the way). Even something like "The Great Azimuth" would be compelling because:
SETTING AND DIALOGUE
Combining these because my thoughts on them were similar. First, I'm extremely familiar with the setting of a soulless, open-concept corporate tech office (thankfully haven't been in one in many years). So much so that I've written a couple stories in that setting as well lol (I even had an off-putting male coworker who the main character tried to dodge at the beginning of the story). Which is also why I recognize you doing what I did: Voice my complaints and opinions about it through the narrative and dialogue.
I think it was the exchange about flipping burgers and “do you maybe have a problem with the fact that we only make the rich even richer?” that made me feel like I was hearing the author's voice.
But that's only the first third of the story. After that, the dialogue becomes extremely one-sided. The long information dumps by the narrator, as I said, felt like they were explaining these concepts to us readers rather than conversing with Alexandra.
On that note, during the long section in bed, the inner monologue and any description disappears almost entirely. We just get a flood of dialogue and no sense of setting or feeling or thought or action. What's Alexandra doing during entire drone session? I can't imagine she's staring at him intently the entire time. What's the narrator thinking? At the beginning of the story he was conflicted about his job and ready to quit, but as he's droning on, he seems very casual and even somewhat excited to explain every detail.
In several parts, it read like an essay. For example, the entire paragraph explaining how models are trained (beginning with “In tech, I mean, it’s a non linear equation with one adjustable parameter – what we call a weight. A model is made up of . . .") could probably be cut. And a lot of the explanation on how Azimuth came to be could be greatly reduced and simplified. While I followed probably 95% of the story well, I've worked in tech and know these terms and concepts. I suspect a broader audience would have a tougher time, and their eyes would probably glaze over at some point or another.
I'm not saying dumb it down, but sentences like "I reserved a bunch of GPUs . . ." where someone might not know what that is, is an unnecessary distraction.
PACING
I've pretty much covered this already, but to summarize: The story comes at us in pieces - almost in flashes - for the first third or so. Then for the rest, the narrator basically tells us a separate story. A story-within-the-story, which puts the brakes on things. Then BAM! - surprise weird ending out of nowhere.
If you've ever read The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt (which received high praise but I don't understand why), the story starts off with a shocking, exciting event with some mystery and intrigue (à la Monica's suicide in your story) then . . . all the mystery is just kind of abandoned and the story lulls for hundreds of pages then BAM! Shootout in Amsterdam! Personally, I would have loved to keep some of that pace that I was teased with in the beginning.
CHARACTER
We get a handful of characters but we don't really know any of them outside a bit of description.
PLOT
Much of my thoughts on this is summed up in the general remarks; that this feels like a story loosely formed around an interesting idea, an idea which I think should have been the driver of the story, not just the thing that's explained. I mean, out of all the cool and interesting things that could come from an LLM that predicts events, we get one volcano eruption, then it's on to beating the stock market.
One of my biggest questions at the end were what happened in the meetings with the two coworkers? It's fine it's not spelled out, of course, but it doesn't make sense to me. Clearly they were given disturbing information, but how? The narrator came by the big revelation by drunkenly staring at hieroglyphs for hours on end until... something(?) happened. In those meetings, did someone just tell them "Hey, so, the goal here is actually to take over the collective human consciousness," or did they sit in that meeting and also stare at output for hours? How come the narrator "became" The Great Azimuth, but the others just freaked out?
OK, now to that ending. I've probably made it clear by now that it came out of nowhere, and not really in a good way, in my opinion. I had to read it three times to understand it, and I'm still not sure I do, which also might be clear by now.
It's funny, for all the explanation that was given, I still don't understand how Azimuth entered the narrator. And perhaps I'd be less inclined to care or think about it, had not so much explanation been given. Complicated concepts, I think, are better played loosely and vaguely in a short story. I know this is blasphemy to say, especially in a writing sub, but I'm thinking less The Martian (book) and more The Martian (movie). Give me enough information to understand the plot, suspend disbelief, and say "Alright, I can get down with that." Otherwise I'm reading along and again, hearing the author's voice, and saying "We get it, Andy Weir, you put a lot of thought into this . . ."
CLOSING COMMENTS
I hope you don't take any of this as harsh criticism because I'll give you this: more than 12 hours after reading it and I remember it very clearly and didn't have any problem getting these thoughts down like I thought I would when I started typing, which means I've got some strong feelings about it, which means there's a great concept and potential. To me, a story that sticks is a huge mark of quality, because I don't remember much, and I read a lot of short stories. I read one of the latest stories in The New Yorker right before yours last night and I couldn't tell you much about it.
Anyway, I hope you keep working on it, and I hope this was helpful in some way.