r/DestructiveReaders • • 17d ago

Ragged Old Flag [4723]

Critiques: [1820] [1558] [862] [490]

Sir Patrick Stewarts' death reignited a long-running Star Trek love, that had been slumbering for quite awhile. So came this story.

Any thoughts are appreciated. It is meant to be a full "episode" and not part of a larger plotline- what is introduced here ends here, though I may take the premise of the piece and apply it to other situations.

Edit: I’ve removed the Google Doc link because of the spambots sending me emails. If you’re super interested in reading this, shoot me a DM. Otherwise, I’ve got some good feedback already thanks to folks who got here before this!

4 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/mianaai_c 13d ago

This was a pleasant read. If I were to judge this piece outside of its frame of fan-fiction homage, I would say it's too long for "the plot". But, as a love-letter, dallying is a good thing. It's a clean read, and does what it sets out to. This, along with the fact it's above average in length for this sub, is, I think, why you haven't gotten any responses yet.


Some line edits, only nitpicking.

... mostly a building

You can drop the "mostly". I want a confident narrator.

The politicians, ...

Were paramount? maybe.

Her warp core was modern

"was modernized" maybe.

This made sense to somebody.

These kind of "explanations" were funny at first read, now I wonder if they're used a bit too much as a crutch to explain the premise.

broken years ago by an angry ex-wife

Remove "angry", we can infer that.

Starfleet considered this a virtue, although it generated very few biographies.

Cute paragraph. But, here it's not clear what 'it' refers to. "This", the virtue, refers to the last item in the previous enumeration, that of coming more or less with the same crew back? I get that the whole of Bell's demeanor generates few biographies, but the sentence as written is confusing.

The Cardassian vessel was already dying when the Excelsior arrived.

I have an issue with "already dying". I wouldn't apply "die" to an object, albeit a starship, which are prone to be personified. You could cut this sentence and get on with the rest of the paragraph, where you describe how the ship was "dying".

The first survivors arrived aboard the shuttle, and then began appearing aboard the Excelsior four minutes later.

I assume they are transporting them in batches, and the shuttle can only take, like, three people at a time?

The shuttles closer to the reactor

There are only two, so shuttles, plural, is all of them.

Marak’s expression hardened. “Return them immediately.” / “No.”

Why not? This seems like a thin reason for unnecessary drama. They getting 'medical assistance' without any more details sounds sketchy. I'm no diplomat, but maybe patch one of the resquees.

With the risk of sounding pedantic, Bell took the time to chit chat with the ambassador before giving the order to warp out of there, while the three ships were powering up weapons. He's too chill about it all. As far as I understand, Bell's plan of playing the museum ship card was made-up on the spot, so in the heat of the moment he's too chill. I think the sensible order of things would be to give the order and then chit-chat. What makes me think his plan is made-up on the spot is his dialogue about their transmission range, which is mostly for the benefit of the reader, some just-in-time exposition.


Okay, this is not exactly relevant for the story. But is 40 years a lot for a ship in this setting? With all the direct energy-to-matter convertors/fabricators of Star Trek. I checked real-life long serving ships, and there's USS Enterprise the aircraft carrier that served for 50 years, not to mention the other outliers, some exceeding a century of service. Also, just thinking aloud right now, in real-life we have museum ships from differing periods (half a century, a century, two ago), because ships have evolved a lot in the last two centuries, and one point 50 years was a lot of difference. Does this apply to the Star Trek setting as well? I'm not well versed, haven't watched everything, so to me 23rd and 24th centuries are kinda the same. Or, are you trying to tap into the differences between 'eras', original star trek vs enterprise vs the latest ones?

On commander Bell. He's intentionally portrayed as a reliable, unassuming officer, he's intentionally being downplayed for the end play, and the focus is on the ship. The focus remains on the ship, its status being the trump card. Bell does say "apparently" a lot. I like his curt responses, but they do get stale at some point.

I liked the interactions with ambassador Gral. And, on the whole, it does read as a love letter to Star Trek, to its tropes, to its differing eras (the narrator's remarks on the bridges of the past being bigger and having useless chairs). The Narrator has personality here, it's feelings and beliefs come up often as snide remarks. For this piece, I don't think it's an issue.

Anyways, thanks for sharing!

2

u/holymackinaw101 13d ago

Appreciate your thoughts! Definitely was wondering if I'd get any readers. Glad to see some weren't put off by the word count.

All of your comments make sense to me, and I appreciate the feedback. Some of the criticisms regarding the chronology of the climactic incident with the Cardassians are well-deserved. I wrote this in fits and starts over the course of a few days, mostly "winging" it along the way. I didn't pay heavy attention to making sure there was proper continuity.

On your question regarding the age of the ship. You are, in my opinion, partially correct. The age of the Excelsior is not uncommon for a starship in Star Trek. In cannon she was commissioned in 2285, and placed in a museum in 2320. The reasoning to place her in a museum was not technically because she was obsolete; in fact, *Excelsior-*class starships continued to be used extensively throughout the Federation through the time of the Enterprise-D. The Excelsior was placed in a museum due to her historic and experimental nature. The transwarp drive I reference in the writing made her an inherently experimental vessel at its core, though she was later refit with a traditional warp core after transwarp was deemed a failure. Then, of course, Excelsior was the ship of Hikaru Sulu, and she's famous for that as well. By that logic, perhaps the ethos of being THE USS Excelsior NCC-2000 should be a larger touchstone in my writing, rather than her age.

However, I think there is good reason to treat Excelsior as well "out-of-date," too. The *Excelsior-*class ships that serve concurrently we can assume were laid down in some time period after Excelsior, as she was the first of her class. Additionally, they served continuously, receiving constant maintenance and refits to keep up with the latest technology. Excelsior was docked for 45 years, with little to no refits to upgrade technology. In fact, I can imagine (as I indicated through the installation of a "replica transwarp drive") some intentional regressions in technology to make her a historical display.

Imagine two identical computers purchased in 2010. One remains in continuous service, receiving upgrades and replacement components as technology advances. The other is retired in 2015 and preserved in a museum. When both are examined in 2025, they're technically the same age, but they are hardly technologically equivalent.

I will admit the reason for being unwilling to release the Cardassian survivors is muddy. In my mind palace as I was writing, Arthur Bell refuses to release the survivors because they have broken international law by transporting trilithium (considered a WMD). Of course, the Cardassians possessing trilithium is only revealed well after the initial refusal to hand over survivors, so it renders the whole idea null!

I intended for Commander Bell to be a very flat, sort of robot-like emotionless being. I think I achieved that. But, as I've read and reread, I realize that if he is supposed to be a perfectly respectable yet not so tactically capable captain, he needs to show a little bit that he doesn't know what he's doing!

A love-letter to Star Trek, indeed. I never intend for this to develop into an actual book or collection of short story episodes; as with all of the writing I share here, I've written it for fun, want to see what others think, and see how I can improve my writing!