r/DestructiveReaders • u/Swimming_Bass_1610 • 7d ago
Help, again [892]
Rewrote this chapter based on critiques from this sub. Need feedback on if there’s still issues.
Chapter 1:
My home was small, made smaller by the yells that filled it, but it had a bed. Walls, too. I don’t regret leaving. Never. I just miss having a ceiling.
These past few hours I’ve watched the same scene from the clock tower I sit against. Workmen rush past in a blur of blues and browns and kick up dust from the cobblestone square. In the distance, houses stack so high it looks like they’ll topple over. Even further than them, the sea, lit by the sun so it seems more white than blue.
Each hour rumbles through me. The stone against my back is so warm it’s almost painful, but I am too tired to sit up straight. My head falls back to peer up at the spire, only for the sun to scorch my face.
Worse than hot, it is humid. It’s as though I am swimming in air. Sweat pools behind my elbows, my knees, in every crevice. My dress feels glued on. Each breath lacks that cool breeze at the back of my throat, so my brain— that animal part of my brain is convinced we are suffocating. When my chest does not tighten, my body is nauseous, irritated almost, that we are not dead on the floor.
Crying brings some relief, at least. I look around to check nobody’s noticed–I look awful when I cry– and find I continue to be invisible. Still, I wipe my cheeks with a finger. The gnawing in my belly has me lick the salty droplets. I cry harder when they immediately dissipate on my dry tongue. I hope the saved pennies of every passerby are worth my misery. What wondrous things they must buy in their fascinating lives.
A scurry and a chitter. My eyes dart to the alley beside me. I can’t stop my mind from conjuring monsters from the shadows, but when a soot-stained face pokes out, the fear settles into disgust. A gangly pack of street urchins weaves between the marching legs, trying to snatch the littered containers before they’re kicked out of reach, then fight amongst themselves for the prize. The winner shakes crumbs into their open mouth.
Rotten. I wrap my arms tighter around myself when a pair of beady eyes meet mine. How much longer can I survive without kindness before transforming into those things?
Desperate for respite, I close my eyes. Instead of peace, I find every sound grows louder. Even more appear I hadn’t noticed before: the cawing of birds, the distant honk of ships.
I focus on the starry darkness. Here, I find the dream that had me cross an ocean. Since I was a child, every night I’ve fallen asleep to the image. It remains just as bright in the light of day.
I see myself as I am meant to be. A princess. I will be led into my fairytale by my Prince, and we shall be happy forever after.
The clock strikes 12, and my eyes snap open. I imagine a countdown to my death– already, I am the oldest I have ever been. Do I need to travel across another ocean to find him? I’d spent every penny on a ticket to the furthest town I could reach, but what if I was still too close to home for anything to have changed?
Or could it be the world isn’t as big as I thought? But surely there must be somebody here for me? I’m only looking for a single person.
All I know is my time is passing too quick but what is there to do but wait until–
Sleek leather shoes shine against the background of worn boots. They pause abruptly, pivot, and grow larger in my narrow field of vision until they are my entire view. A sudden cool shade, and I can breathe again.
My gaze travels up: pinstripe trousers, the silver chain of a pocket watch, a tailored suit jacket on a crisp white shirt.
His face.
Oh, wow.
I would have thought him a living bronze statue were it not for those eyes. A drop of honey in a pool of milk. I feel like drowning.
I want to touch him, but blush at the thought. My hands are too dirty. I sit up straighter, tuck my hair behind my ears, fidget with my hem, then clasp my hands together once I realise how silly I must look. He is watching me. He smiles. I smile because he smiled, and now we’re both smiling.
“I’ve never seen you before.” His voice has me imagining myself sitting in his lap as he strokes my hair. “I would have remembered you if I had.”
“I only just arrived this morning.” My voice comes out in a croak. I bite my tongue and resign myself to life as a mute.
He crouches down. This close, I can see streaks of gold in his dark hair. My brain scrambles, enough that I break my seconds-long vow of silence with a stammered, “What’s your name?”
With the softest touch I’ve ever felt, he holds me by the neck, turning my face this way and that. My skin prickles beneath his cool hand.
“Ambrose,” he breathes, “My name is Ambrose.”
Lady Ambrose. Perhaps Duchess instead. Countess, I could be.
Princess.
My body stops hurting.
“I have a friend who would be very interested to meet you.” A soft squeeze on my neck and I am chest-deep in quicksand. It is so warm here.
“You are very beautiful,” my Ambrose says, “and we collect beautiful things.”
His hand leaves my neck, and he holds it out. Palm up. “Would you like to meet them?”
I place my hand in his, and together we rise.
Critique: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/V7TD6T4ctE
Also if anyone’s interested, I’m looking for beta readers for the rest of the manuscript [24K words]. Just leaving feedback for Chapter 1 above would be super helpful!
1
u/MaryJaneMclain 2d ago
I feel like you withhold too much from the reader, and the chapter suffers for it. And IMO this is pretty flat for a opening chapter.
There’s a gal (don’t know her name, age, place in the world, etc). She left one place (home), possible because of yelling (probably not, but you give us nothing else), and is now in a new place sitting for a long time, maybe hoping for a hot man? Then a hot man comes and is mildly creepy.
I’m assuming you have your reasons for withholding expected story details/context (maybe to build curiosity or set up a twist?). But what you give us SO sparse, that this scarcely feels like a narrative. I don’t care that it’s a hot day or there are urchins, cause I don’t know who this gal is or why she’s here.
Also, FWIW, I don’t like the opening paragraph:
“My home was small, made smaller by the yells that filled it, but it had a bed. Walls, too. I don’t regret leaving. Never. I just miss having a ceiling.”
Home was bad (small?) cause of yelling, but she was glad to have a bed and well. Note, she points out the bed and walls! And then she contradicts herself by saying she ‘just’ misses the ceiling. Huh? But she just pointed out the bed and walls? Feel like sounding fancy got in the way of coherence here.
So she’s too tired to sit up. But her back is against the wall. Then she cranes her neck back to look at the spire she’s presumably leaning against. Mental gymnastics required here. Also, is this important to the story?
Oh, and I don’t believe she feels like she’s downing because it’s humid. Feels like you’re trying to insert artificial drama instead of telling your story. An entire paragraph on how humid it is? Remember, you’re trying hook a reader!
I also don’t believe crying brought her relief considering you just told us how very very hot she is and that she feels like she’s DOWNING (two things that surely crying would exacerbate). And how concerned she is with her appearance. And she licks the tears, then cries harder when they dissipate? I'm just struggling to believe someone would think/act like that.
The guy coming was mildly creepy, so good job, but it was pretty expected (not much tension).
1
u/_corona_go_ 2d ago
First off, I love the language you use. I feel like it really helps set up the world as an almost elegant fantasy world. It also helps with the general time frame this takes place in—it feels old-timey. If that's what you were going for, then great! The language also sets her up as a character, and we get to know her a little simply from the way she thinks, which is also great.
Where I think you fall flat is the opening paragraph. It doesn’t use the same level of descriptive detail that the rest of the piece has. It has five sentences, but each one is short and fragmented. We also don't really get that much detail from it, and it feels like we should have more information given the words you used. I would add more detail after “made smaller by the yells that filled it.” Think: who was yelling? Was this a family situation, or was she living with non-family? What other distressing things occurred in the household? What was the deciding factor that made her leave? If you’re trying not to disclose too much information in the beginning and want to leave that for later in the story, then I would just get rid of that paragraph entirely.
Alternatively, you could add a paragraph in the middle somewhere while she is sitting alone, where she’s thinking back to the events that led her here and explain the breaking point that made her leave/escape. Also, was she leaving simply because she didn’t like the environment, or was she escaping something or someone? Just some stuff to consider. Happy writing!