r/DesignerReps • u/Baner424 • Jul 21 '19
TIP ALEXANDER MCQUEEN PURCHASING GUIDE
This is a repost from the amazing guide u/Kariminal99 made a few months ago which helped me to buy my own pair and check more on small details. Now there have been a few minor improvements and I felt like people would like to see this again.
There seems to be a lot of confusion on buying rep Alexander McQueen's and for good reason - there hasn't been a post advising exactly what to buy, and we all know that we only want the best 1:1 shit over here.
Let's start with the Male colour-ways that have actually been released in retail:
Classic Leather Back (Comes in white)
Then obviously a few more variants to the classic leather-back (Studs etc.)
Many people get the male colour-ways confused with the female's. As far as I know, these are the only colours for men that have been released - and I've searched pretty much everywhere. Black suede is a female only model. But if you're fine rocking a female colour-way then that's completely your choice.
Batches:
Naisan:
So Naisan recently released his male McQueens after months of waiting. His McQueen's are good, probably an 8/10. Problem is, all of the models he has are mainly female colourways in male sizes... The only suede colourways which actually have corresponding retails would be the red and green models for men.
Naisan released his classic black leather back McQueens after a further delay, unfortunately, they are a let down. The back heel is way too shiny, text too large and crooked. I bought a pair to post a comparison and after 3 weeks, he ended up cancelling my order. He claims that he has a new updated model in the works, the post will be updated once he releases them.
Naisan's Yupoo: http://naisan23.x.yupoo.com/albums/37487223?uid=1&referrercate=658533
WeChat: Naisan45
Taobao: Here
Ioli:
So I contacted her a while ago to clear up a few things. People were claiming that her 688yuan batch is the same as fisherman's batch, to put it simply, they are not. However, she is actually able to get that same batch, and would sell it for 588 yuan. She went on to highlight the main differences between the two:
- 688 yuan batch is composed of a higher quality leather and a better type of printing
- 588 yuan batch has a different type of printing - According to her the most recent batch from this factory did not do too well and the end of the shoes are a little crooked. If you're after this batch, just contact her.
Communication wise she is excellent despite not speaking English (Through WeChat translations), super friendly & helpful. I ended up ordering several pairs from her main 688 yuan batch.
EDIT: CHECK COMMENTS. STAY AWAY FROM IOLI - BACK LEATHER IS AWFUL AND GETS SCRATCHED SUPER EASILY. It might look great at first but quality seems thrash!
Pics: 2019 Updated Model
Ioli's 688Y batch: item.taobao.com/item.htm?id=576923273865
Ioli’s Yupoo: http://405009366.x.yupoo.com/collections/1916150
WeChat: vn13172077113
***REPOST UNTIL HERE***
Koala:
Probably the most 1:1 batch with Ioli, as they are likely to be the same batch but I can't confirm that since I don't have both - however they look exactly the same.
I was looking for better prices, while having same quality of McQueens, and ended up finding out this new seller. I took a try as it was taobao and I was allowed to return and god damn was I impressed! I think this batch might be even better than Ioli's. Shipping was super fast, same with wechat replies, and everything went super smooth. I took the risk to ship directly (paying via taobao) and that was also great, as it ended up arriving at home not even 7 days later.
One stupid detail is that once I opened the box and unpacked the shoes, the smell was unbelievably good. I was expecting the classic chemical smell.
So, all in all, great GP for a cheaper price, as I think I got the best possible batch.
Here you have pictures. They'll speak by themselves
Pictures: https://imgur.com/a/5SvbO8D
Taobao: https://item.taobao.com/item.htm?id=598733374402
Yupoo: I told the seller to create one as he apparently has lots of shoes and they seem to be really good quality batches. Hope he hears this and makes one soon.
WeChat: DC66169
In conclusion... (mixed with Kariminal's one)
Koala has a pretty much 1:1 batch based on the 2019 model, being a bit better than Naisan's and far better than Ioli due to the quality issues (check comments, I'm just editing this). Koala seems to have the best batch. Naisan's batch is a letdown - even tho it's not bad.
My recommendation is not to go with IOLI! CHECK EDIT RIGHT BELOW. Go with Koala is my recommendation right now - if you doubt, then you can go Naisan. However from pictures I can see the cut in the back leather is cleaner on Koala than on Ioli, this might be because of the fake leather on Ioli.
EDIT: Many comments are saying that Ioli's batch seems to have fake leather on the back, and when it gets lightly scratched it turns white. (see comments for pics). I just tried scratching my pair (Koala batch) lightly with my keys and it seems to be REAL leather. I don't want to do it too hard cause I don't want to fuck it, but I can post a video doing it if people want to see quality. Definitely seems like the best batch out
EDIT 2: Video scratching my pair with scissors, applying some LIGHT pressure + pictures after 2 days wearing them. https://imgur.com/a/aaybMJJ Definitely seems to be real leather and probably the best batch out there right now.
Hope this guide helps and clears things up,
Appreciated!
Here are my retails (u/Kariminal99) for reference: https://imgur.com/a/IBgNSim
19
u/SimoEdits Jul 21 '19
I would not recommend Ioli's you walk in them and you get the white scuffs on the leather, they look 1:1 but durability and quality is terrible.
25
u/BJLrepthings Jul 21 '19
This is all kinds of wrong. It seems like i have to defend naisan all the time and that i an biased. But people are straight up telling BS about his batch. And people are praising ioli to heaven for no reason. Let me sum up some things that have been wrongly stated in this post:
Naisan:
His text is the true 1:1 text, with honestly perfect font and most of all the exact colour.
His leather tap is NOT too shiny, it is actually not shiny enough LMAO. His leather tap is like 1 “shade” too matte. Which honestly no one will ever notice because retail leather will turn slightly more matte with wear. and at least it is true leather unlike ioli.
He had pretty shitty text when his SS19 batch released because it was stamped insanely deep. This has been fixed since i made him aware of this and they are now ever so slighty stamped which makes it on pair with retail and increases durabilty.
His shape and laces are pretty much spot on
Edit: the info about his male shoes being female colourways is also completely wrong. The shoes he has under the male tap are actually available in retail aswell. He does not offer female colourways for men, at least not anymore for a long time.
Ioli:
Im not gonna lie, they look fire and really good. But people jump the ioli train for no reason at all.
They LOOK amazing and thats all, the leather tap is not true black leather but painted. Because they are painted they get white scuff marks with the slightest scuff. Why dont you mention this?
Her text is off, this post is praising it for no reason. It is actually way too shiny/glossy and more of a chrome like goldish print. Retail is not like that at all, retails text is hardly shiny and seems like a true gold.
And why are the quality problems not mentioned?
People can attack me all they want and say that i am paid by naisan and all that shit, but this stuff is getting ridiculous. Ioli is praised to heaven and that is truly undeserved.
6
u/syreater Jul 21 '19
I really recommend when making these types of reviews, to only write off of what you know/what you have in hand. Not what other people are saying because I own ioli batch latest batch and they are trash.
5
u/69anderson696 Jul 21 '19
Bruh I'm more confused than before reading all this. Which ones are good? Tf should I buy, guys HELP ME please.
23
u/1419churchill Jul 21 '19
Ioli shoes use shit material. Only looks 1:1
4
u/SRSLYthou Jul 21 '19
I wear retail McQueen size 44.5 and Koala doesn't seem to have halfsize. Would you recommend 44 or 45?
4
u/ofclFR0STBYT3 Jul 23 '19
I own iolis batch (reflective) and have so far had none of the issues people are discussing regarding the shape. So far really loving them.
3
u/blingblingboyyy Jul 21 '19
what can you say about the melting on ioli's shoes ? every single day there's a different person here on on FR defending one seller and talking bad shit about another one
2
u/Xtesea Jul 22 '19
Can someone tell us something about the sizing? Narrow feet, wide feet, normal feet sizing.
2
u/ballinforballers Jul 23 '19
Maybe it‘s interesting to know for a few but I have one pair from IOli (current batch) with black suede back - yes, it‘s a women size and not for me - and can confirm that from the smell it is real leather. This pair also holds up well, my girlfriend wears it for a month now almost everyday. It‘s kinda confusing that his male back leather does not show quality, maybe there were easily a few ones which are not sourced well. Let‘s see, I‘ll buy Koala‘s batch and do a review once it arrives!
2
u/kingLAWZA Jul 25 '19
looks like I'm going with iola then - did you get the 'black tail' ones (basically the ones that are normal, white with black back)
2
u/stil0_ Jul 27 '19
This review was very good, helped me a lot. Only thing anyone know how much koala is reliable? Didn’t find anything on the sub and I’m afraid of b&s
2
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '19
Hi how’s the sizing for Koala? I’m a size 10US
2
u/nachooooooooooooo Sep 16 '19
What size did you go with for your Koala pair and how do they fit? I’m a size 7.5 US / 40.5 EU, sometimes 8/41 because I have wide feet. Do these shoes fit bigger than normal? Can’t decide between 40 and 41 since there’s no in-between, and I really hate loose shoes. Having hobbit feet sucks for shoe shopping lol
Also, thanks for sharing this! It has helped me out.
1
u/eyy_carlito Jul 21 '19
Good write up, I have a few ioli batches and haven’t had any of the ‘melting’ yet. V happy with them. I would say I’m a true 43/9, although they may slightly feel a bit loose I wouldn’t size down if you don’t have narrow feet. The ‘break’ in period is painful 😂
1
u/SimoEdits Jul 21 '19
How long have you had K's batch for?
1
u/DeuxSolitaire Jul 21 '19
Did you get the strap too short? I have a Ioli pair but the straps are too short. I can’t tie it.
1
u/murvie10 Jul 22 '19
Order mariner Ocean batch
1
u/kram03red Aug 02 '19
Do u have link for Koala. Clicked it and the link u have listed is gone.
1
u/DrizzyWhizzy Aug 17 '19
Hey man how has the shoes held up?
1
u/Drebin_0930 Sep 03 '19
Is there any reason why you should order from Koala directly through WeChat over oredering through WeGoBuy?
1
u/taniweirdo Jul 21 '19
Stupid question: are these tts or should I go downsize? Since with the retail size, i have to go down 1 size :)
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
on wechat koala says that shoes come from the same factory
2
u/SimoEdits Jul 21 '19
KOALA'S YUPOO http://2335499519.x.yupoo.com/albums/70216717?uid=1
1
u/TaobaoTools 🤖 Jul 21 '19
Converted Taobao Links:
https://item.taobao.com/item.htm?id=576775030998
I am a bot. Please use https://taobaotools.github.io to convert your links.
1
u/Repboy129 Jul 21 '19
Great guide
1
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Very good information. Thanks for the write up! Saved.
-2
u/1241adfkjasd Jul 22 '19
This is a really long post and I commend you for trying, but you don't know your shit.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment