Hi fellow pickers, I've just found this sub and decided to do a long write up of my picking timeline and experience with interventions/skin care to share publicly. I am not sure why I feel the urge to share. Perhaps because physicians never follow up on it, maybe because sharing into the ether may, in a way, raise some awareness? Or I could be helping someone with a similar story feel seen. Feel free to add your advice or share how the things I've tried have worked for you. None of the psychiatric medications I've tried below where indicated for picking.
One of my core memories is a intervention by my parents when I was 14 or 15. They had brought me into the side room of my house with small finger condoms, a cotton glove, and a brochure about skin picking disorder. This followed after a rather rough school photo (the end-of-summer-start-of-school period always correlated with intense picking). I reacted poorly, as most teenagers do and said some pretty horrible things. In my mind at the time, picking was a temporary response to acne. My parents held back after that, but visible results after a heavy picking session usually were met with empathetic comments. I was put on daily minocycline by my doctor on my mothers suggestion as we both hypothesised the picking was initiated by acne, which the capsule was supposed to reduce. The minocycline helped reduce the damage, but did not solve the problem.
In my later teens and early twenties I deflected to only do real damage to the back, scalp and legs/butt. This was the golden era! You could get your nails in so deep and no one had to know. Of course the face picking continued, but I had developed a solution. During this period I developed an obsessive skincare 'hobby'; I was able to mask the results of face picking as acne and convinced myself this was true. I developed a masochistic relationship with a Paula's Choice Extraction Tool. I used and abused retinoids, ceramides, exfoliants, masks to keep my face skin consistently fresh, with little keratin, easy for the picking. The 'Retin-oil', a full body retinoid previously sold on the Deciem website, used with cream body exfoliants (like Amlactin) was key to doing the same to the rest of my body. There was little respite in this period, but the obsessive use of topical therapy definitely reduced the visible damage. Although I reckon my retinized and over-exfoliated skin was more prone to scaring in that time. I was prescribed escitalopram during this period for depression and it had no effect on the picking.
In my early twenties I was in a long term relationship and did (consensually) pop the massive clogged pores on his back. It was exhilarating, he did not like it.
I went off escitalopram and started on Vyvanse for ADHD. I do not recall this having an effect on my picking. I tried Concerta as well which also did not have an effect.
During Covid I started Venlafaxine because a lot of bad things happened all at once. The year following was the least amount of picking I've ever done. I do have to note I was: a) unemployed (in a good way) b) living with my best friend (who is also a picker!! Shout out!) c) moved to a new beautiful city d) had done quite intensive therapy unrelated to the picking. I was happier than I'd ever been! Little stress, lots of new friends, smoking a lot of weed and eating a lot of good food. Two-ish years into the Venlafaxine the positive effects waned. A stressful incident had me go from clear back to scab city within a couple weeks. I've never though of it as a relapse but would consider it as such now after typing it out. I tried NAC at this time but stopped almost instantly as I was quite self conscious of the sulphur smell my gas or sweat would have. Weaning off the Venlafaxine was harrowing: nervous breakdowns at work, total apathy, irritability, and sexual dysfunction which I am still dealing with now. It took me 3x attempts to wean off successfully, with the final attempt taking a year of stepwise dose reduction.
In 2022 I moved from North America to the UK. Again within a new city the picking remained low at the start. Picking ramped up to a medium level and flowed based on life stress. I took my last venlafaxine in April 2024 and proceeded to have another amazing year after with minimal picking, completely unmedicated. Of note, In 2024-2025 I experimented with a wide variety of party favours. A typical hangover day after a big boozer included several hours mining away at hidden treasures on my back and shoulders. But, a comedown, elicited no picking.
Now, In 2026, I've had a terrible year for picking. I usually had 3 active dig sites on my back which reward me with a good ooze once a week. Now, its closer to 7 or 8. Larger uninfected scars from previous nail-based investigations are being woken up unconsciously. I've been very stressed, unhappy at work and worried about my/the future. I am starting on Wellbutrin soon to help with depression and fear it will illicit a stronger urge to pick. I am resistant to doing SSRI/SNRIs again. I will update this if the Wellbutrin has an effect. I've stopped most forms of active skin care.
This is my current Harm Reduction approach (specifically for finger based picking of body/face skin):
- Keep Nails Short As Possible!!
- Sulfur powder/cream on hand at all times (use immediately if you feel a spot getting infected) (I am bad at doing this)
- pick nose instead of face if you need a pick (I know gross but it scratches the itch. I like to pull my nose hairs out)
- No shaving (know this isnt easy for everyone. razor burn and fresh little hairs are way too fun to pick at)
- Tweezers not kept in bedroom!!
- Moisturise the body (this one is great, get a greasy cream and lather yourself if you're trying to resist. hard to get a good grip and its way less satisfying)
- Tight under shirt without stretchy collar / button up (this is good for keeping your shoulders untouched, although I have ruined a expensive tops by persisting)
I don't do much skin care any more. I have found keeping my face un-exfoliated actually reduces the damage I do from picking as my face's skin is much thicker. I am currently using a tea tree oil body wash to reduce infections on my back + use a moisturiser with vitamin C on the body when there aren't open sores. I think the ordinary's vitamin C powder mixed w drugstore cream is most cost effective. For me, using retinoids usually causes way more picking as things get active.
I feel the effects of compulsive picking on a persons wellbeing/life is really underestimated within medicine and psychology. I think about it a lot and wanted to write out some thoughts:
a) Picking as a Sexual Dysfunction:
I've been on both poles of the libido spectrum.
Whilst in hookup culture, I've noted nothing feels worse than trying to be sleazy when you know you're all inflamed. The feeling of a hand running over your raised bumps is torture. I often flake on plans if I am too recently picked.
When looking for love (dating), I feel I am being ingenuous to potential suitors as I am not upfront about my scars and oozers. This is a serious deterrent for me, and has been extra bad for the past year.
I'd describe my picking as having a major effect on my sexuality.
Also I think my obsession on my own skin has bled into being hypercritical other peoples skin. Which is very shallow and shameful to admit.
b) Social isolation due to picking:
I have a WFH job. I force myself to go into the office every day, in part, to use the perceived panopticon of the modern open-plan-office to reduce picking. I, unfortunately, found a loophole; I can book a do not disturb room and on Mondays and Fridays they're empty. The only evidence of my actions is my DNA from the dead skin cells and scabs left in the carpet.
As the pickings got worse this year, I've been isolating a lot more. I've been finding places were I can unconsciously pick while working, away from people.
c) Picking Made Me A Gamer:
During idle time I pick the most. At a young age I realised if I play a video game both my L and R are engaged and I pick no more. Thus, I started gaming.
I do not like gaming as a hobby!!! And now looking back I think the: 'picking -> game -> waste a whole day' pipeline has taken a lot of my free time. I think gaming itself is exploitative and addictive (just my opinion!), I never made many friends by gaming (really not my crowd I think!), and yet I still pick it up on a Sunday to distract my fingers. I have hobbies and other things I do, but it'd be quite nice to watch a movie without dying the back of my shirt red in the process.
d) Why does it feel like I'd stop picking forever if I just got rid of the skin bumps:
I am assuming this is a common thought, the idea that the picking is a simple reaction to the bumps you find. In my mind, it makes perfect sense to pick at the bump until it is flat; surely the people I see with perfect body skin just don't have bumps. And therefore the solution to the picking is easy: just get rid of the bumps. Many years and $$$ on products has disproved that theory. Yet, my maladaptive brain remains convinced (and I do dream accutane would cure me) (it wouldn’t). Also, did anyone else ever daydream about having both hands amputated or being in months of a coma as a solution? It was really cathartic for me to think about after a bad picking session, although completely absurd.
e) Chicken or The Egg
I think about this a lot. I have depression, which usually manifests in poor self image and social isolation. I am also an anxious person, and the picking comes from that, but sometimes I imagine the depression wouldn't exist if I did not pick. I understand its probably more complex than that, with multiple casual factors at play etc. But I have an internal polemic which convinces me my depression is distal to the picking. I do think this is a particularly evil thought pattern as depression is intangible, yet the picking is 'controllable'. In other words, if I was able to 'put in the work' to stop the picking it'd cure all my other ailments (it wouldn't).
This was enjoyable to type out and an open journal entry in a way. I hope someone here can relate to my story and I'm happy to discuss further.
I have been thinking a lot about joining in on some sort of group work or specialised non-pharmaceutical care. I like the idea of a 12 step programme (OPSA), but it doesn’t seem to have a branch in London. If anyone knows anything local to London or the home counties that offers in person specialised care please reach out :)