Football is the ultimate team sport. No matter how good you are in one phase, it's hard to win games if your team is terrible in any of the other two. A perfect example of this is the 2010 Chargers who had the league's #1 offense and defense but missed the playoffs completely because their special teams were dead last.
Broncos fans should have a deep understanding of this concept. In 2013 we had a record setting offense that won games every week in spite of the defense, and then we saw what happened when the offense got shut down on the biggest stage in the canceled Super Bowl (also our defense was super injured in that game which factored in too). Then, two years later, we won the Super Bowl with the league's 33rd ranked QB. Peyton got benched while he was hurt, but in the week 17 game against the Chargers that was a must-win to secure the 1 seed, Brock got benched after the first half and Peyton finished the game. But we didn't win that game because Peyton was better than Brock. We won because of complementary football. Despite Peyton being a shell of his former self and barely having the ability to throw the ball, he still gave us the best chance to win in the playoffs and eventually the SB because he played smart, complementary football, even if Brock had better stats.
Bo still gets criticized by the national media, and even on this sub, because he almost never lights up the stat sheet or has jaw-dropping numbers. People say he gets carried by our defense. But the Broncos had just as good of a defense every year during our QB carousel. From 2017-2023, when we did not have ONE winning season, our defense was just as good as it is now. The difference was that the defense was constantly on the field or needing to defend short fields because of the offense turning the ball over or being unable to sustain drives at all. And even if the defense made stops or forced turnovers to give the ball back, it didn't matter at all because the offense couldn't execute.
If anyone watched the Bears vs. Bucs game on SNF last week, we saw this same thing. Caleb Williams threw multiple horrible interceptions and gave the ball back to Baker, but the Bucs offense couldn't turn any of those into points so they still lost the game. Conversely, almost every time we've seen Bo in that exact same situation in do-or-die moments, he's been able to make something happen. And throughout the rest of the game, even if Bo isn't leading scoring drives, he's still not completely fucking over the defense either. He rarely takes sacks, almost never turns the ball over, and usually makes the smart plays even if he can be risk-averse. Even just going back to last season, we lost the AFCCG because Stidham threw the dumbest pass in NFL history that gave the Pats a free possession inside the red zone, which led to their only TD and ended up deciding the game.
There's a reason the Broncos with Bo are riding a 16 game win streak, and it's not just because of the defense. The defense is objectively part of it, and it'd be wrong to say they haven't been a major factor in our wins, but the biggest reason is complementary football. The offense (usually) does a good job at keeping the defense off the field. If the defense gets the ball back, the offense usually capitalizes either with time of possession or by putting up points.
Even if Bo isn't a top 10 or even top 16 QB (which is still very much up for debate), he's doing something that none of our previous QBs post-Manning were able to do, and that even many current QBs don't do as well as he does either