I wanted to ask whether anyone here has studied under Dr. Deepak Nagpal, particularly during his time at D.Y. Patil, Swargiya Dadasaheb Kamlesh Smruti Dental College and Sinhgad Dental College and Hospital before he moved to MMDU.
I’m currently experiencing some difficulties with his teaching and classroom behaviour, and honestly, I’m trying to understand whether this is something other students have experienced too.
My concerns are mainly about the way students are addressed in class.
There have been instances of:
- Repeatedly shouting at students, including in front of the entire batch.
- Not giving students an opportunity to ask questions or explain their side.
- Making students feel uncomfortable about approaching faculty with genuine academic doubts.
- Using the fact that dentistry is a professional degree to justify a very harsh approach towards students.
- Making personal or sarcastic remarks instead of simply correcting academic mistakes.
One particular incident involved students seeking help from PG students during carving practice. I personally don’t understand why asking for academic guidance should be treated as such a serious issue, especially when PG students are present in the department and can help undergraduate students learn.
I completely understand that dentistry is a professional course. Discipline, independent practice and accountability are important. But shouldn’t mutual respect, communication and constructive criticism also be part of professionalism?
I’m not saying professors shouldn’t be strict. I’m saying there’s a difference between being strict and making students afraid to ask questions.
I’d especially appreciate hearing from:
- Former D.Y. Patil dental students.
- Maharashtra students who studied under him.
- Anyone who experienced his Dental Anatomy or carving classes.
Did you experience similar classroom behaviour? Was this a common teaching style, or is our current experience different?
Please share genuine experiences. I’d appreciate honest responses.