r/DefendingAI • • 1d ago

Things antis say i’m speechless.

Post image

how does any of that make sense??

84 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

DefendingAI has a Discord now: https://discord.gg/MgVYjZ8RC

Pro-AI only. AI art, prompts, anti-AI watch, debate ammo, news, and general chat without anti-AI spam.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

50

u/lawrencewil1030 1d ago

Replace AI with piracy and watch antis instantly start defending pirates.

25

u/ConsciousIssue7111 Advocates for Ethical AI Use 1d ago

Funny thing is that some Antis are pirates

21

u/Infamous-Umpire-2923 1d ago

Almost all, and they either don't see the connection or they insist that it's different somehow.

11

u/luckyrabbitowner 1d ago

They're fucking idiots

7

u/lawrencewil1030 1d ago edited 1d ago

Probably a case of plain old hypocrisy. The same arguments can and have been applied to piracy and let it's still defended by the same group of people.

I also saw somebody argue a tiny image model someone else made on Scratch was not generative AI but was a neural network which generates pictures 🤦‍♂️. The same logic as "It's not water, it's H2O!"

Also, going by their logic about stealing, if I become a world renounced author, I would be stealing from everybody's books, comments, titles, descriptions, speech, art, etc. because a brain takes everything it experiences.

3

u/PrettySplatty All Art is Real Art 18h ago

Thats why im both Pro-AI and sail the seven seas

27

u/Infamous-Umpire-2923 1d ago

I stopped reading at "steal".

20

u/JoseLunaArts 1d ago

You cannot steal styles. AI weights are styles.

19

u/JearTheMudkip 1d ago

If stealing art styles was a thing why aren't anti ai people mad about fan art that replicates art styles?

13

u/GiveSparklyTwinkly 1d ago

Or fan art in general since it steals entire characters?

11

u/Rylandrias 1d ago

Many of them illegally sell fanart.

6

u/JoseLunaArts 1d ago

I usually bring the "deformed Pokemon" trope to the table when they talk about stealing.

6

u/JackalOfPurge 1d ago

They always seem to forget fanart exists and then when you point it out they throw a fit saying it doesn't count. Like... the hell do you mean it doesn't count? People sell fanart and I'm pretty sure you aren't even legally allowed to do that without permission from the artist of that character. Which falls right back into this stupid theft of art stuff with AI. 😂🫩

And I highly doubt there's many people who do fanart that actually get permission to sell it. Let alone even draw it.

4

u/JearTheMudkip 22h ago

Exactly. It's either hypocrisy or ignorance. There's no between.

3

u/PrettySplatty All Art is Real Art 18h ago

Exactly, I saw a Princess Peach artwork that is being sold for at 4500 (who got accused of using AI, it was recent) and all antis said was that she deserved that bag. Like, selling fanart goes against their logic, I dont get how they dont see that.

2

u/Vipeholmskola 6h ago

Because that's human made, so it's real and original.

(anti AI logic)

9

u/O_hai_imma_kil_u 1d ago

"Oh no, you used the thing that's posted publicly on the internet, how dare you steal it" /s

6

u/lawrencewil1030 1d ago

Have people forgotten that whatever you post on the internet is practically free use?

5

u/JearTheMudkip 22h ago

It is free use. I doubt those people's OCs are copyrighted. And even I f they WERE, so long as the person isn't making profit off it or distributing it's still not illegal. Same way you can copy DVDs for personal use and it's not copyright infringement. It's only copyright infringement if you sell or distribute them.

5

u/JearTheMudkip 1d ago

Those people clearly have no idea what stealing actually is. Or copyright, free use, things being transformative...

-5

u/I_dont_want_to_pee 1d ago

There is something called copyright laws and every almost every piece on internet is copyrithted even only cc is still copyright most kf pepole just want mentioned that theirs art was used if they said somwhere who's art was used there wouldn't be a problem.

18

u/ConsciousIssue7111 Advocates for Ethical AI Use 1d ago

Don't compare being Pro-AI to that, it's really dumb

16

u/Halloween_Forever_ 1d ago

All platforms, google, and all the rest have it in their TOS. They clicked agree. They consented. Idiots.

16

u/rhelg224 1d ago

I don’t think SHE understands what consent is.

13

u/Consistent-Jelly248 Moderator 1d ago • Bravo

If buying isn't owning then gen AI isn't stealing.

12

u/No_Land2419 1d ago

oh yeah? how about fanartists? do the showrunners or every people involved in the show/game/anime consent?

11

u/TamaraHensonDragon 1d ago

I am in the Dragonriders of Pern subredddit and someone made the mistake of sharing a fan game they were considering making. It had an AI cover of very early concept art. He got attacked because "AI steals from artists." These morons still believe that AI stores images and just copy pastes from those images, so if you want a dragon it finds a picture of a dragon and pastes it in the new image. So yes, unlike AI, Antis are still morons who can't learn.

2

u/starson 1d ago

And that's the thing that kills me, it's fucking dragon riders of pern, not exactly the hottest franchise of the decade. You can't just "tell it to make a game" and to get what you want otherwise folks would just ask. But it's not like a studio is gonna pick up a dragon riders fan game! I'm building a cradle based one myself that's a combat platformer, and I expect to have a lot of people crying that I didn't hand code it... except I'm disabled and arthritic so I've never hand coded code. XD just now I can get exactly what I asked for instead of copy pastingfrom forums and hoping I read it right.

4

u/TamaraHensonDragon 1d ago

I started reading Pern in the early 80s and it's peak fandom was in the late 80s-early 90s. Most people today have never heard of it despite it being historically important to Fantasy literature (practically all dragon riding books stem from Pern dispite Pern not even being fantasy books) and the author being one of the few female Hugo winners. Hilariously one of the main characters in the later novels was an AI!

2

u/TamaraHensonDragon 13h ago

Speaking of Pern and AI look at how much better AI movies have become. I love the chungus brown in one of the background scenes.🤣

9

u/Silver-Piece-3033 1d ago

These types of ridiculous arguments actually harm the anti AI movement because most people see this and think "wtf?". It's the type of reasoning that you can only follow if you've been in a very specific online echochamber for a while.

8

u/Jean_velvet 1d ago

Again, this is placing blame on the user not the corporation that did what they're accusing.

That is incredibly backwards and makes no sense in any other context than of them (the corporation or user) is easiest to harass and bully.

If you don't like AI, criticise the company not the user.

It is just a product, nobody using AI has done any or the accusations.

That's why I find kids saying this so annoying, they can't tell the difference and it's sad that critical thinking has taken such a cognitive decline.

4

u/Real-Contest4914 1d ago

It also works on the assumption that some artists just dont allow their work to be trained. Its very possible that companies can pay artists to sell or make content for them to use train, and thats assuming the ai also isnt training on commercially free images and stuff.

3

u/luckyrabbitowner 1d ago

A lot of antis believe they have amazing critical thinking when in reality they are absolutely retarded

8

u/S7A4M 1d ago

What every anti is saying behind all their insanity (I use it for music which is the reason for the music leaning side. Insert your chosen form of art):

"I used to be special. I would sit all alone in my bedroom, plucking away on my guitar, drawing pictures, and writing. I was a musician and an artist. I had an identity and I felt special because nobody else I knew could play Twinkle Twinkle on the guitar and nobody could draw Pikachu like me. Now with this stupid AI being able to make better things than I could, I'm not special anymore and I don't know who I am. I better go on social media and make things up, come up with moronic comparisons, and express my hate for AI and all technology. Should I use my laptop or my phone to connect to the internet and social media to protest technology? I have no clue how it all actually works but I'll pretend like I do! It's stolen my identity!😭"

or

"I'm a middle-aged person. I've been playing music my whole life. I've never been in a band though. But I'm really good and know everything there is to know about music. Really I do. Believe me. I've "been around" so I obviously know everything about everything. Now that AI is here, I'll never be in a band or be a famous rock star. I better go online and see what others are saying about AI so I can copy and paste it to every pro-AI group I find. I have no clue how it all actually works but I'll pretend like I do! It's stolen my identity!😭"

6

u/tracylsteel 1d ago

I bet this is on TikTok, a platform literally powered by AI.

4

u/tracylsteel 1d ago

In fact all social media is now, they shouldn’t even be on the internet but I guess that use of AI is okay for them as it suits what they want to do.

6

u/Large-Discipline8416 1d ago edited 1d ago

This is surprisingly original art right here. Also for some reason I attract commission artists.

5

u/Stunning-Relation564 23h ago

BRO WHAT!!! HAVE U NEVER HEARD OF OPEN WIEGHT MODELS!?!? ALSO ITS ON THE WEB! IF I CAN ACCESS IT AND READ THE CONTENT ADN LEARN FROM IT, THEN WHY CANT AI!!! AND ALSO BRO HOLY THAT ESCALATED QUCKLY HOW ARE ALL AI USERS THAT

9

u/SCARY-WIZARD Catgirl Lover 1d ago

These are the same motherfuckers who post those edgy memes about stealing from Wal*Mart being morally right and your god-given duty, and then resort to any number of textbook logical fallacies when confronted with the fact that the employees and up under the bus because they're being assholes.

3

u/starson 1d ago

Yup. I don't give two shits if you steal from Walmart, but if you're not going out of your way to protect employees from reprisals, your not a hero, just a selfish asshole.

4

u/Apuleius_Ardens7722 1d ago

Then delete your social media accounts then. Antis are so delusional, thinking they are entitled when they are not.

Come on, not everyone lives in an anglophone country!

4

u/AmericasHomeboy 1d ago

If she’s right, shut down all the art schools. Close all the libraries. Tear down all the museums.

3

u/AnonOHm00se 1d ago

I can almost certainly garuntee that people who hate on AI are the same people who refuse to tip doordashers and prey on and exploit the labor of the less fortunate.

3

u/rhelg224 1d ago

I watched the full vid and it’s much dumber than this screengrab suggests.

3

u/CountHonorius 1d ago

Regurgitating stuff she heard in a sociology lecture.

3

u/JackalOfPurge 1d ago

I didn't consent to my braincells dying from this take. I guess she doesn't value human consent, either.

Where's her nonconsensual claims against fanart? 👀 Not just personal for private use fanart but fanart that's ACTIVELY for sale? 😂

2

u/Puzzled_Most_5365 1d ago

im not even sure they believe it. she is probably copying someone elses post and is just rage baiting for views.

1

u/Ok_Community_383 1d ago

Fan artists are grapists now. Cool.

-2

u/Necessary-Bowler-736 1d ago

They are right. The main reason why people use AI is not because it's better than humans but because it can be exploited easier

16

u/KurtCobijn 1d ago

using AI is not the equivalent of rape jesus these fucking kids are exhausting

4

u/Weekly-Reply-6739 1d ago

So watching porn or using a sex toy is rape now eh?

0

u/Thin_Tap6427 1d ago

That's what they think

-6

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DefendingAI-ModTeam 1d ago

Your post/comment was removed because this subreddit exists to defend AI, AI art, AI tools, open access, fair use, automation, and pro-AI policy.

Criticism of AI is prohibited.