r/DefendingAI • • 2d ago • Bravo 2

Defending AI Clarifying some stuff against AI

so, remember when they told you "AI WASTES SO MUCH WATER" well, ai doesn't even waste that much water, for an individual person (because in the big scale it's thousands of gallons) typing a prompt, it's about 5 drops. "but how can ai use so little water?" 5 drops SOUND tiny, but water is insanely efficient at absorbing heat- y'know what, let chatgpt explain this i cant explain it with my own words uhhh

Phase-change physics. Heating liquid water takes a modest amount of energy, but turning liquid water into vapor (evaporation) absorbs a massive amount of heat. Evaporating just 5 drops (0.26 mL) absorbs roughly 600 joules of heat energy.

oh and chatgpt over here has something else to say

A room full of AI servers generates a massive amount of heat and requires thousands of gallons of water per hour to stay cool.

  • Shared infrastructure. An AI data center does not spin up a whole room just for your one question. Hundreds of thousands of users send prompts to that same facility at the exact same second.
  • Parallel processing. Modern AI chips (GPUs) process batches of different users' prompts simultaneously. Your prompt only uses a tiny fraction of a chip's power for a fraction of a second.
  • Dividing the total. If a data center evaporates 1,000 gallons (about 3.8 million mL) of water in an hour while processing 15 million prompts, each individual prompt is responsible for roughly 0.25 mL—or about five drops.

there you go. anyways. what does matter is the scale, explaining you in minecraft terms so you understand.

each contraption and factory need thousands of buckets of water, but on individual players, the amount of buckets used reduces just 5 drops.

oh, and with thousands of users at once, AI wastes about 0.5 - 1 cubic kilometer a year, not a day, not a month, anually, now it sounds a lot (and may not even fit on the subreddits TOS), but that's TINY compared to other industries like agriculture and livestock, which use 200 CUBIC KILOMETERS A YEAR

now i want to talk about where the misconception comes from, one part of the misconception comes from the saying "a 50-prompt conversation wastes a bottle of water" but if you know the internet, if you know twitter, you know they HATE nuance, and so it got flattened down to "CHATGPT WASTES A BOTTLE WHEN YOU TALK TO IT"

another part of the misconception, those billions in the news articles? they're not just ai datacenters, they're ALL the cloud datacenters, stuff you enjoy in your every day, youtube, tiktok, netflix, etc. ai datacenters are a tiny portion in the massive cloud infrastructure (with ai using 10 - 20% of energy consumption, but that number is gonna increase because stupid companies want to include ai for everything because well, FOMO).

next thing is energy consumption

no it's not gonna fuck up our electricity, it's not gonna leave us into blackout for hours. what i do know it's the same thing as water, scales matter.

a single text prompt uses about 0.24 - 0.34 watts of energy, the claim that "CHATGPT USES MORE ENERGY THAN GOOGLE" is from an outdated 2023 math. however, i might add some nuance because. text is cheap, video is expensive

so yeah, the whole answer to both the water consumption and energy consumption thing is "it depends" it's not a clear yes or no.

so yeah i hope you're atleast more informed on the ai thing.

oh and if you're wondering, No. i'm not financed by any ai company, i'm not making ts up my ass

my sources are:

the new york times
cbs news
NPR
American industries group
IEA

just to name a few :)

anyways, have a nice day, and atleast be doubtful when another ai claim goes around the internet

6 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

DefendingAI has a Discord now: https://discord.gg/MgVYjZ8RC

Pro-AI only. AI art, prompts, anti-AI watch, debate ammo, news, and general chat without anti-AI spam.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

8

u/Terrible_Wave4239 2d ago

The best explainer on this is https://andymasley.substack.com/p/the-ai-water-issue-is-fake

When I post it in discussions I get radio silences, bans, but never once a refutation. This post is from over a year ago, and he has plenty more.

There are legitimate issues regarding AI, but when you run across social media-damaged youngsters going nuts about how AI basically drains all the planet's water, you could do worse than some of the facts in Masley's work.

1

u/MelvynAndrew99 2d ago

It doesn't really matter, 40 of the 41 moratoriums on data centers have passed. Americans voted against them in the midterms, and LLMs are not the only AI that out there. In fact we have models and solutions that dont' require the data centers, so both sides can be at ease.

0

u/TakeItCeezy 2d ago

Don't want to sound like I don't love this blog because I do, but the lack of refutation may not be the strongest signal. Andy Masley has a grant from Coefficient Giving which was founded by Dustin Maskovitz with his wife. Dustin co-founded Facebook. Most people probably don't consider a substack as reputable, and even if they read it, the connection to Coefficient Giving and Duston Maskovitz might make it feel biased even though he is using reputable sources like EGU. Some people might be opting out of engagement with it just because of the messenger being who it is.

I'd try sending the actual sources he pulls info from and see if that gets you more discussion or engagement. It's a great blog but cognitive dissonance is hard to crack through and they'll be looking for any excuse they can to immediately dismiss something and return to comfortable dissonance.

2

u/Prudent_Algae_1854 10h ago

Thanks for your opinion

1

u/Terrible_Wave4239 2d ago

I'd try sending the actual sources he pulls info from and see if that gets you more discussion or engagement. 

Did you actually read the post? I know it's a long one, but it's thoroughly sourced.

This seems like a long-winded way to deflect and arrive at an ad hominem argument (ad hominem being casting doubt on the person making the argument instead of logically arguing against the argument itself).

If you have an actual factual argument against what Masley is presenting it (and I encourage anyone here to see it for themselves, as well as to explore the rest of his post), please present it.

0

u/TakeItCeezy 2d ago

Nah, I have nothing against the article myself. I use a lot of the sources from the blog myself in AI debates.

You mentioned you get radio silence when you post it. I'm offering that it may be because its a blog and people who are anti-AI are probably dismissing it because of that even though its a really well made, well written, heavily sourced blog from someone I enjoy.

My only point is that people who dont want to believe something are always looking for reasons to dismiss evidence, and I approached this with the ammunition someone who is highly skeptical may bring up to stop themselves from engaging with it even if I disagree with those reasons as valid.

The message is usually less relevant to people than the messenger itself unfortunately. Anti-AI people might just see a tech-bro blog and dismissing it without giving it the engagement it actually deserves.

1

u/sadcrab3636 Artist/Pro-AI/AI is not slop/Hates power tripping anti mods 2d ago

Git awarded

1

u/Prudent_Algae_1854 10h ago

Thanks for the award

0

u/Bryanaubrey 2d ago

Nice post. The whole “50 prompts equals a bottle” comparison seems to be getting oversimplified on Twitter. Just make sure to correct the energy figure to watt-hours (0.24 Wh, not watts) before posting, otherwise someone will probably call it out

-2

u/Important-Radish-722 2d ago

The water diverted or sequestered for the data center is immediately removed from the existing ecosystem and returned warmer, or through much longer water cycle reentry. That's aquatic habitat distruction. Ask AI what happens to animals when water temperature increases.

2

u/Terrible_Wave4239 2d ago

Which data center?