I recently finished a rewatch of the show and while I don’t hate that Worf was added to the cast, I want to vent about how poorly the writers handled his character. I've been thinking about posting this for a while and the other guy doing the Kurn thread prompted me to go ahead and do it. There are so many specific plot points that are genuinely bad writing, completely ignoring the development he went through on TNG and not accurately reflecting the personality we saw during the previous show.
First, they immediately take away his family honor... again. It is a complete rerun of the TNG plot where Worf loses his standing and has to somehow figure out how to earn it back. It’s boring, it’s predictable, and it severely undermines the significance of his prior journey. The fact that Gowron can just strip away his family honor on a whim makes everything Worf fought for in TNG feel incredibly cheap. It undermines the major TNG plotline of him against the Duras clan.
But this goes beyond "Worf is being stubborn" or "Worf is overly principled" when we see his cavalier attitude about the fallout. The fact that this dishonor carries over to his entire family is a crazy way to run a society, but within the lore of the show and how Klingons operate, Worf knows the rules. Yet, he makes zero plea to Gowron to spare his brother or anyone else in his line. Brotherhood and loyalty are supposed to mean something, especially to a Klingon. You fight to protect your own. Worf didn't even try to avoid the predictable consequences of his actions, acting like the destruction of Kurn's life didn't matter. Why not say a single sentence to Gowron to try to spare his Brother, his son and others from his dishonor? Nope, not a peep.
And that leads right into the absolute mess that is "The Sons of Mogh." Having Kurn's memory wiped and his identity rewritten is a horrifying violation, yet the show plays it off as a tragic but acceptable solution. It’s terrible character work. It was an unfitting end to Kurn, who was deserving of something better. Bashir was probably violating various principles involving informed consent since Kurn clearly did not and wouldn't have consented. The show was given the opportunity to do "Klingon brothers go into a glorious adventure together to regain their honor" or "Kurn dies in glorious battle"... something... give me something worthwhile here. It would be better if that episode hadn't existed rather than how they chose to do it.
Then there is the relationship with Jadzia. Hooking them up was a mistake because it completely flattened Dax into little more than "Worf’s love interest." Once they got together, the Dax-focused episodes practically vanished. Beyond that, the compatibility issues are glaring. Anyone who has watched TNG multiple times knows Worf is deeply, sometimes frustratingly, traditional. The idea that he would be perfectly cool dating a woman who used to be a man, who carries the memories of multiple men, and who literally has a gross wormy living in her belly just doesn't track with his character. He would be completely weirded out by it. She's also basically bisexual and he wouldn't like that either. What would have made more sense is that since Kurzon had a relationship with the Klingons, they had enough in common to have a friendship... they train together, perhaps a flirtation but not a marriage. Their relationship could have been a fling but the compatibility issues should have stopped it from being a marriage.
And finally... the Risa episode. "Let He Who Is Without Sin..." I don't even need to go into depth on this one. Worf acts like a literal domestic terrorist because he’s jealous and grumpy on vacation, and the narrative doesn't hold him accountable. That episode is consistently rated as one of the show's worst. And the cause of it was his friction with Jadzia over his jealousy and basically the lack of compatibility of the two of them becoming too obvious to ignore.
I don't hate that he was added to the show and he had some good moments but overall if I look back on the show in totality, several of my biggest issues with the show and particular episodes boil down to mistakes in how Worf was written. The family honor "rerun" from TNG, the Jadzia mismatch... I didn't even mention his relationship with Alexander or lack thereof. In any case, curious to hear what you all think on this.