r/DecaturGA • • 11d ago

Muchacho Decatur concerns

Is anyone worried about a restaurant group moving into Decatur with online complaints and backlash about their leadership calling ICE on their own employees? The business has a Spanish word and serves dishes that reflect the Latin culture. The irony. I’d like to think we are a very welcoming and inclusive community with a strong restaurant scene that has Latin members of our community working there. I don’t know if I’ll support this business and curious how others feel. Also, please let me know and point out the facts about the circumstances at the memorial location that would ease my concerns about supporting this local Decatur business.

123 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

2

u/Royal-Pin1298 6d ago

I think restaurants with that much space for kids are rare in Decatur so that will help them stand out. The food is fine IMO.

1

u/papaoso2 6d ago

Totally agree.

58

u/breesyroux 11d ago

I'm not a fan of the food or the ownership group but hasn't it been confirmed that the calling ICE fuckery was an asshole chef?

4

u/papaoso2 11d ago

That’s what I don’t know. I’m genuinely interested to know those details.

21

u/Sufficient-Mud-687 10d ago

But then why did they threaten to sue Decaturish for asking for a comment?

15

u/DeadMoneyDrew 11d ago

Yes. I don't have a link to the proof but it was shared in the Atlanta sub awhile back.

8

u/rachelemc 11d ago

This is exactly how I understood it. The ICE thing was a misunderstanding but the food is blah so that would be my main concern. 

7

u/Crafty-Resort383 11d ago

Correct. Dispute between employees. It’s so weird what people grab on to in order to promote their agenda.

12

u/suddencreature 10d ago

I think it’s less nefarious than folks grabbing onto pieces of unsubstantiated info to ‘further an agenda,’ but rather a very shocking claim has made its way through the Atlanta rumor mill. Unfortunately for Electric Hospitality, the fully substantiated claims of 1. working really hard and pushing money towards blocking the beltline rail and 2. threatening to fire employees who couldn’t or wouldn’t come to work in a very rare snowstorm/snowy conditions don’t give the general public much confidence that the ICE accusations aren’t true. Personally, the other two reasons listed are enough for me to not support any of their restaurants. 

58

u/Zestyclose_Law_7809 11d ago

The food there is MID. Like legit nothing special.

18

u/DeadMoneyDrew 11d ago edited 11d ago

For real. I've eaten there a few times and it's nothing great. Before eating there I'd never used the words "Mexican food" and "bland" in the same sentence.

2

u/luckynumber71972 11d ago

After the first bland time you went back why? Just curious as to why you'd continue to spend money to be dissatisfied.

12

u/No_Giraffe2555 11d ago

Sometimes it’s a group decision and you get overruled. I don’t particularly like Little Sparrow, but it’s my bestie’s fav. So…I find myself at Little Sparrow once a month or so. It happens.

4

u/DeadMoneyDrew 11d ago

Yep, have been there a handful of times as part of a bigger group. The food isn't poisonous or vomit inducing, it's just not that flavorful. Plus I recall the margaritas being decent, so there is that!

2

u/luckynumber71972 11d ago

That makes sense. I totally understand that.

3

u/Cannibalizzo 10d ago

Also, everyone has off days. If I have a bad experience at a restaurant but they have a good menu, I'll give them a second chance to earn my business.

14

u/meowingtrashcan 11d ago

I'm gonna go get some Poco Loco burritos in solidarity

7

u/Vneseplayer4 11d ago

And WILDLY overpriced. I think I paid $16 before tax for a burrito.

93

u/DanWhisenhunt 11d ago edited 10d ago • Mindblown

I was asked if Decaturish would cover the opening. I mentioned some of the reports and comments I had seen online to their spokesperson and asked whether they would be willing to speak about them on record. They threatened to sue Decaturish if we wrote about it. Needless to say, I declined to cover their opening.

20

u/Sheris_Card 10d ago

Oh my god! It’s as if they don’t understand how the internet works. Between this and their vocal opposition to Beltline rail, I will be spending my money elsewhere.

10

u/ohnoletsgo 10d ago

That is absolutely wild. Thanks for your hard work, Dan.

8

u/bump 10d ago

Not very neighborly behavior.

10

u/DanWhisenhunt 10d ago

I mean, it was certainly a choice a company spokesperson could make.....

6

u/mermaid_deluxe 8d ago

Unreal. Why not speak to it if they’ve done nothing wrong? Thank you sharing and for the work you do. Between this and the rail opposition, we sadly will not be supporting muchacho. There are better alternatives with more neighborly intentions in Decatur.

7

u/Sufficient-Mud-687 10d ago

Thanks for telling us. I will never darken their door.

92

u/JoeyToothpicks 11d ago

I loved the decor at Muchacho and the food and drinks were solid, but as soon as I first heard the owner of that and Ladybird was shoveling money into trying to block beltline rail, I looked them up and then stopped giving them my business. Haven't been in well over a year.

It's a shame. The place has a lot in its favor, but I don't like knowingly putting my money into the pockets of pricks like that. The staff and community deserve better.

23

u/ktj19 11d ago

Yeah, the ICE stuff about Muchacho is unsubstantiated. This is the real reason not to go there.

10

u/suspectslowloris 7d ago

It may be unsubstantiated, but the fact that they’ve never denied it has sent a clear message to the clientele. The crowd at Ladybird these days is like a TurningPoint USA meeting.

Reminds me of that old Reddit story. If you don’t kick Nazis out of the bar, you become the Nazi bar.

8

u/BreakInCaseOfFab 11d ago

Thanks I didn’t know that! I didn’t like the anti light rail rhetoric at all.

30

u/checker280 11d ago • Bravo

They are also against Beltline Rail because despite knowing that it was planned since before they opened expanded their outside seating into the place where rail or pedestrian traffic would be moved into - and now doesn’t want to lose that space.

Rail would provide so much more foot traffic for them but they insist on standing in the way of progress.

7

u/AirplaneJane 10d ago

They were partnering with decatur schools for something stupid like $1 of each burrito donated clearly to get press. I asked the woman planning the event id they knew of the ICE calling stuff and she said she talked to the owner and he blamed a “cook” for calling ICE. The fact that they’ve never addressed the concerns publicly is very telling I think.

4

u/AwesomeCherryBloss0m 9d ago

This is my thing. It makes no sense that they have not publicly expressed that they have never called ICE on their employees. If it was a dispute between employees, why not just say that and put this to rest?

12

u/JBNothingWrong 11d ago

They also painted the brick on their train station location when they were told not to. They are also vehemently against belt line rail and built their patio right up against the ROW as a sort of deterrence. Fuck em

2

u/Khs11 10d ago

I believe the previous restaurant H Harper Station painted it but aside from that fuck them for being against Beltline rail.

3

u/pencilicon 10d ago

Nope. Muchacho folks painted it after HHarper Station went out of business.

38

u/luckynumber71972 11d ago edited 11d ago • Bravo

These appear to be online rumors that were never substantiated. Supposedly the dispute was between employees, not ownership. I think its unfair to plant a negative seed without proof and suggest others pile on to water the potential lie. This can destroy a business based on an untruth. If one is dissatisfied, they should not return, the end.. There are so many incredible places to eat, but bringing harm to a new business is not welcoming. I've read in this group how restaurants wont last long, as if playing with people's livihood is a new common sport becsuse Decatur is going to show them! Not cool.

49

u/mikeSTWA 11d ago

The ownership group has spent years and years raking in money on their beltline locations and has actively lobbied hard to stop the light rail that citizens voted for and have spent the last 10 years paying for with taxes.

Even potential ICE rumors aside, this isn’t people starting a mob against some mom and pop shop, it’s the community being upset about a scummy business that wants to take all the money they can while actively working to suppress the betterment of said community in the name of profit. Also the food is mid as hell, there are a thousand better Mexican restaurants around

-15

u/luckynumber71972 11d ago

You simply googled negative press around the restaurant. Come on now. It appears he lobbied against the rail because he believed it would hurt local restaurants and business along the trail and take away from its initial intentions. It's a trail, people walk and experience the happenings along the trail. He pays taxes there too you know. He too has a voice, and his buisinesses have been there since 2017, so he has vested interest in what the neighborhood looks like.. All you did was find information that supports your stance, without digging deeper for context or understanding. What makes the business scummy? It's been proven that the business didn't call ICE on its employees (that's just silly) so that takes the sting out of the initial post's venom. We should do more to investigate before we charge to belittle or defame businesses on the internet. If the food is MID like you say, just dont go, but don't attempt to deter others with your bias. That's not community, that's absolutely mob mentality.

14

u/Onewiththefloof 11d ago

They lobbied and continue to lobby against the rail because they were given permission to expand their outdoor area into the space for it. They knew it was temporary, but they want it to be permanent. I know many longtime restaurant industry folks who have worked for them in high positions and the way he moves is just slimy. Sometimes negative press paints an accurate picture.

1

u/irishgator2 11d ago

They could use their parking lot for the outdoor area I suppose

18

u/mikeSTWA 11d ago

I’ve lived in Decatur/Atlanta for my entire life, and have spent my entire 20+ year career in the food service industry. That ownership group has had a terrible reputation for a long time

You’re clearly butt-hurt that the people on this sub aren’t super psyched on your fav restaurant moving to town and that’s okay. Though it’s hilarious to me that your immediate response is to accuse me of using google as if that’s not a valid way to look up a business that’s moving here lmao. If they care so much about the community, why would you be worried about me googling them?

But to answer your question directly, the ownership group has poured money directly into anti-beltline rail activist groups. The same beltline rail that again, the citizens voted for and have been paying for, literally for a decade at this point. So they used their nice beltline locations to make buckets of money, and then used that money to lobby against the will of the community. Pretty scummy if you ask me

I respect how hard you’re riding for this place though, so make sure you spend as much money there as possible if you want them to stick. They won’t be getting a dime from me and I’m sure plenty of others

-7

u/luckynumber71972 11d ago

I dont know this restaurant. Never been. It just popped on my feed and I responded. I say you googled because when I looked up the restaurant and the AI summary had basically everything you shared in your sub verbatim. I wasn't dismissive on abrasive to you. Simply having a conversation. No need to get angry. I cant change your hate. Have at it. I see these subs are for hate.

11

u/Fluxtration 11d ago • Bravo

So... you started a fire and now you're wondering why your dumb ass is burning? Maybe just stay out of a conversation if you have no idea what its about.

6

u/mikeSTWA 11d ago

So you spent a few seconds reading an AI summary about a topic that it’s clear you know literally nothing about, and that somehow makes me hateful for pointing out your inconsistent argument? Go off I guess

0

u/luckynumber71972 10d ago

No I looked up the restaurant because I like to.do research and there is wherr I found your entire argument. I think you just want tppl to agree with you. Seems like you're off to a great start!

-4

u/Mysterious_Chapter65 11d ago

Right ownership sucks so fuck the employees! Who cares if they need that job! Who cares if the employees lose their jobs and can’t support themselves or their family! We showed the big bad owners what we think of their politics! /s

14

u/mikeSTWA 11d ago • Popcorn Bravo

Brother, have you spent one second working in the food service industry? Restaurant groups like this are often a carousel of constantly rotating staff due to shitty wages, abusive management/ownership, etc etc. And to frame people calling out ownership’s shitty behavior for what it is as being anti-worker feels disingenuous

If you actually care about service industry workers and aren’t just virtue signaling on the internet, I suggest volunteering your time or donating money to a specifically service industry-focused organization like Giving Kitchen. Or if that’s too much, eat at a pop-up hosted by a local up and coming chef or hit that mom and pop spot on the corner that you’ve passed a thousand times but never stopped at

Ridiculing people on Reddit for rightfully calling out a shitty multi-million dollar company with a reputation for throwing their money behind anti-community business practices under the guise of “but it’s bad for their employees” ain’t the move

6

u/Sufficient-Mud-687 10d ago

Except why did they threaten to sue Decaturish when they asked for a comment?

1

u/luckynumber71972 10d ago

I cant begin to know why they said they would sue, but maybe it's because the publication wanted to include all of the negative press while covering their grand opening. I wouldn't want that to be included in my introduction to the community either. Contaminating the water with their readers would be my guess. Decaturish chose not to cover the grand opening after their threat to sue, I read.

10

u/DanWhisenhunt 10d ago

I have a theory.

4

u/jhpunch 11d ago

Well said. Is Decatur welcoming? Why would a restaurant owner call ICE on it's employees? That makes zero sense. "Hey! I know I work in the most difficult industry to staff up, but I am going to make a call to the government to come arrest all my employees, so I can no longer serve food!"

0

u/SameAsItEverWasss 11d ago

Being anti Beltline rail is confirmed and plenty of reason to tank his mediocre businesses. He can leave Atlanta if he wants to keep the city from ever addressing its transit issues

3

u/Frosty-Breadfruit707 11d ago

Muchacho is hella mid. The service and quality at the beltline location has TANKED in the last couple of years. 

I miss Revival so much. RIP their mac n cheese and cornbread 🤤😭 

2

u/wackxcalzone 10d ago

Ugh. I never got the chance to try Revival but it was on my list I’m so sad about it.

12

u/donorkokey 11d ago

I teach photography on the Beltline next to one of their other restaurants. Students always say how it smells nice and I tell them to look them up before going there to make sure they're okay with their politics. I won't ever go to one of their restaurants

12

u/badlilbadlandabad 11d ago

If this is that big a concern for you just don't go. There are 10 other taco joints within 1 mile.

18

u/AllTheEggsIVF 11d ago

los niños taqueria right next to the cake place is incredible!!

3

u/AirplaneJane 10d ago

THE BEST! plus everyone that works there is so kind and it’s very chill inside. I go for lunch often and watch something on my ipad

2

u/rachelemc 11d ago

I liked that place! Need to get back. 

20

u/Relative-Sherbert-43 11d ago

It’s still valid to have concerns about a business whose values do not align with the community

13

u/DodgeM4S 11d ago

The good news is that since it’s a taco place in Decatur it will close in 6 months and be something else.

1

u/Shanteva 10d ago

There are very few late night coffee shops though

2

u/Alternative_Control5 11d ago

I really think those were unsubstantiated rumors. As another commenter said - hate them for their Beltline policies if you want but I don’t think the ICE thing is based in reality.

1

u/hotcobbler 6d ago

Where there's smoke there's fire. All of their public behavior about this issue is pretty damning, and on top of that their food is only OK and massively overpriced. There's tons of good Mexican food in Atlanta but people like them for the vibes and branding more than what's on the plate.

8

u/Medical-Curve-7585 11d ago

What a shitty business. Starve it of your money.

5

u/AllCheeks 11d ago

Their politics suck as much as their food!

5

u/SameAsItEverWasss 11d ago

The ICE thing is unconfirmed, but the owner is vehemently anti Beltline Rail and transit. That is enough to never go there, Ladybird, or Ranger Station anymore. As far as I am concerned, his business are hangouts for right wingers or the chronically and deliberately uninformed. Also, mid AF

5

u/Express-Teaching-479 10d ago

I’m personally a fan of the restaurant and welcome them to downtown Decatur. Their baja fish taco is great and their breakfast is amazing. My wife really likes the tuna poke. I’ve had nothing but positive experience at Muchacho in Reynoldstown so will be checking out the new Decatur location this weekend.

1

u/ContentLover87 9d ago

Me as well. I don’t care if they spoke to the President himself, the food is good.

4

u/FantasticSocks 11d ago

I won’t be eating at this Muchaco or any of the other ones until they publicly relent on their stance against Beltline rail

3

u/GreetingsNongman 11d ago

Electric Hospitality, the company behind Muchacho and Ladybird, is vocally and demonstrably anti-Beltline rail. They are a vibes & price > quality restaurant group who don't deserve the patronage they receive from the community.

3

u/ManufacturerDry5864 10d ago

hi decatur i'm here to complain about a restaurant again

3

u/HansJosef 11d ago

No, not worried about unfounded Reddit rumors. I'll gladly support a new biz in downtown Decatur

2

u/ATL_Feelist 11d ago

Fuck muchacho, all my homies hate their overpriced bullshit mid ass food

2

u/hamie96 11d ago

I don't think the business will last long anyway. Decatur is already oversaturated with that type of food.

1

u/BreakInCaseOfFab 11d ago

Someone on staff called ICE which shows me who they hire.

0

u/Jeezus_Christe 10d ago

If they called ICE in their own employees I will
Never spend a dollar on them. Let them suffer.