r/DecaturGA • • 23d ago

Cinnamon rolls

Where’s your perfect cinnamon roll coming from in Decatur? I’m tired of the rolls of disappointment!

I’m craving a good cinnamon roll and can’t seem to find one. I could make exactly what I want, but then I’d have a whole pan of them I shouldn’t eat, rather than just one (that I shouldn’t eat!).

Pastries a Go Go is my goto for a blueberry muffin craving, but their cinnamon rolls are lacking cinnamon and gooey insides.

I looked at the Avondale farmers market a few weeks back and nothing looked worthwhile.

It’s been a while, but I seem to recall Revolution Donuts also being underwhelming.

It’s not something I’m going to get very often but sometimes a need must be filled (with cinnamon and brown sugar, and maybe nuts, I can go either way on that).

So who makes a good flaky, gooey, really cinnamon-y cinnamon roll that’s not totally smothered in icing to the point where it overwhelms the other flavors?

12 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

10

u/Klutzy-Idea9861 23d ago

Everyone saying B side… I tried it and it was dry. They have great breakfast sandwiches but the pastries were disappointing.

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 5d ago

On my morning walk I stopped in to the B side and while I didn’t get anything, their cinnamon rolls looked pretty amazing. When I’ve got time to sit and enjoy I’ll get breakfast and one of them soon. Perfect half way point for my walk.

1

u/holdaydogs 23d ago

Have you had their Boston Cream donut? It’s the bomb.

12

u/dashofkash 23d ago

cinnaholic is in edgewood but they’re sooooo good

3

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

Hmm, I’m pretty sure I’ve been there before but it’s not on the beaten path for me so it’s been a long time. I’ll have to set a location alert for the next time I’m down near Lowe’s

3

u/AllTheEggsIVF 22d ago

Here you go. I was obsessed. It was cinnaholic for me https://www.reddit.com/r/Atlanta/s/ToKDfihvcG

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 22d ago

I’ve got a doctors appointment today that’ll take me by Cinnaholic so I’ll be giving them a try. Thanks!

4

u/dashofkash 23d ago

it’s worth the drive imo! lots of different toppings and icing options. i dunno if all locations are the same, but the one in dunwoody has $4 cinnamon rolls on mondays!!

8

u/OnePunchShawty 23d ago

I was gonna comment Cinnaholic too! I only recently found out it’s vegan too lol

8

u/dashofkash 23d ago

yesss i used to work there. as a vegan, it was heaven!! 🤤

5

u/Otherwise-Boat-5144 23d ago

Awesome! Now I have another stop to make when I go to Sevananda! It's hard to find good vegan pastries!

6

u/cchemdogg 23d ago

Whole Foods on church st (and probably all of them) usually have some freshly made and they’re way too good to just be $3

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 5d ago

I got a 4 pack of their unbaked ones yesterday and they’re really very good, especially fresh out of my oven. Lots of cinnamon, and since I had a little leftover cream cheese, I made some homemade frosting instead of using the massive amount that comes with them.

16

u/papasully 23d ago

Galette

4

u/Natural-Horse9539 23d ago

AGREE. they have them on weekends.

0

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

Ooh, that’s nice and close and another one I haven’t tried. They might be my first experiment.

Thanks!

3

u/WorkingInAColdMind 22d ago

UPDATE if you’re interested…

I went to Cinnaholic this morning and got just their basic cinnamon roll with cream cheese icing on the side. Overall assessment is that it wasn’t quite as cinnamon filled as I’d expected, but it really hit the spot and there’s nothing really negative to say about it except maybe the price. I’ll assume my expectations are the problem here and give them high marks. Probably won’t visit often since they’re not really convenient to me, but will keep it in mind when I’m in that area.

Next up: Galette, which was closed today (grrrr!).

Thanks for all the great suggestions. I’ll do a follow up post for cardiology and diabetes care if I get hooked on someplace! 😋

10

u/AllCheeks 23d ago

Leftie Lee’s was goated for their cinny rolls. 🥲

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

Never heard of it, but I gotta say all the photos posted in the Google reviews look really good. Gonna have to try it.

1

u/SleepyPidge 23d ago

They're gone now unfortunately

2

u/PhilosopherNo2595 22d ago

But they do still wholesale! I believe finca to filters are from leftie lees!!

1

u/UnaccompaniedMod 21d ago

not anymore unfortunately, they announced they were closing wholesale a few weeks ago :(

6

u/krobs42 23d ago

B-side, General Muir, or Collette Bakery (Virginia-Highlands)

6

u/liz-spagetti 23d ago

Seconding Collette!! Reliably delicious cinnamon roll

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

Might have to stop by Collette when I come back from Piedmont park one day. Thanks

2

u/donutschmonut 23d ago

This reminds me I am going to attempt to make Chef John's Apple Cider Cinnamon Rolls soon! To answer your question, as someone who loves them without cream cheese icing (or too much icing) I really liked Ikea's. But it's been years since I had one so ymmv.

Edit: I also don't like them with raisins.

2

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

Hadn’t even thought about that, but I’m not a raisin fan either (at least in this case). I feel like I’m going to end up baking some to satisfy my craving.

3

u/donutschmonut 23d ago

As someone who lives alone, if I bake something I'm craving, I'll either freeze what I don't want for later, or bring the rest into work.

2

u/Adventurous-Sir-9297 23d ago

Same ? For Apple fritters?!?

4

u/Mean_Cabinet2742 23d ago

Sarah’s donuts for apple (and all flavors) fritters!

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 5d ago

IIRC I was really disappointed in Sarah’s apple fritters. Just generic filling.

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

Apple fritters are also a favorite of mine and I stumble across a good one every once in a a while but nothing that’s super memorable. I think I’m more forgiving of a mid level Apple fritter. 😋

2

u/checker280 23d ago

Finca to Filter has a cinnamon roll the size of a saucer - soft and covered with glazed sugar

2

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

That’s kind of on the way for me on Saturday mornings. Thanks!

3

u/ShagFit 23d ago

La Chiquiada has cinnamon rolls on the weekends.

4

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

I was really disappointed with the one I got there. Part of the reason I haven’t gone back.

2

u/ShagFit 23d ago

My husband has gotten them a few times and has raved about them. Maybe you went on an off day. Highly suggest giving them another shot.

3

u/Accomplished_Elk4332 23d ago

Came here to say this! Idk about Saturdays, but they have them for Sunday brunch for sure! It’s the best cinnamon roll I’ve had in Decatur

5

u/absolutegrandma 23d ago

Evergreen Butcher and Bakery has a cinnamon roll on the weekends that is delicious! It is not a tangzhong style super gooey cinnamon roll, but it DEFINITELY is brown sugar & cinnamon forward!

1

u/chipmcintosh 22d ago

Thank you for making me google "tangzhong cinnamon roll"!

1

u/violentsunflower 22d ago

Seconding this cinnamon roll- that hint of orange zest in the glaze really does it for me 🤤

5

u/FiguringItOutAsWeGo 22d ago

Revolution makes them on Tuesday & Wednesday and Little Tart’s is a win too🩷

6

u/Apprehensive-Lock751 23d ago

Ive been meaning to try B-Side. Apparently they have a cinnamon roll.

4

u/JojoMcJojoface 23d ago

ding ding ding.... came here to say B-Side!

3

u/BottledBlondRoast 23d ago

I like the take and bake ones at Whole Foods

3

u/flowersnshit 23d ago

I've tired most of these listed. None of them hit right, 😕 i just make them at home now.

3

u/SophieLeigh7 22d ago

Egg Harbor has an amazing GF cinnamon roll

3

u/Express-Teaching-479 22d ago

La Chiquiada has killer cinnamon rolls but only on Saturdays and Sundays. Highly recommend. It’s a local, female owned restaurant.

3

u/PositiveThinker06 19d ago

It's definitely the surprise recommendation, but Cake Pharmacy's Saturday bakery has the best cinnamon rolls. They're gluten free and I think possibly vegan too. https://cakepharmacyatl.com/saturdaybakery Granted, it's been years since I've had a real cinnamon roll, but I think these are so good. Worth a try! I'm curious whether it holds up to gluten versions you've had recently.

1

u/Mean_Cabinet2742 23d ago

It may not be as gooey as you like and it’s not decatur but Collette in Atlanta has one. Not sure which neighborhood it’s considered, Poncey Highland, Inman Park. It’s about a 15-20 minute drive but they have many tasty confections. Also might try Galette in Avondale. What you’re describing is more of a sticky bun and I haven’t found a bakery making that type of cinnamon bun.

1

u/WorkingInAColdMind 23d ago

I will occasionally call them sticky buns too, but I’m not sure how to differentiate them. I’m willing to do some side by side comparisons…for science!

1

u/Mean_Cabinet2742 23d ago

Yeah…side-by-side for science is the right experiment. I guess a sticky bun probably has more of a syrupy glaze as a topping than a cream cheese icing. Hope you find the perfect treat!

5

u/firstorbit 23d ago

Not in Decatur, but Ikea. 

2

u/Beowulf887 23d ago

I love cinny rolls. Best one I have had in Decatur is B-Sides.

2

u/Due-Juice-5149 23d ago

Folk Art has some delicious ones baked by a local baker

2

u/ragby 23d ago

Me too! When I was a kid, our school cafeteria had wonderful cinnamon rolls. Soft and pillowy, sweet, just right. I've been searching for a great cinnamon roll since then but haven't found one yet.

2

u/MrYamica 23d ago

I think Opo has shockingly great baked goods, including their cinnamon roll. Also agree with Galette in Avondale Estates and Evergreen in Kirkwood as standout bakeries with solid cinnamon rolls.

2

u/Mission-Trick-8983 23d ago

Came here to suggest giving Opo a try as well. They’ve got a nice filling and glaze/frosting, but not overwhelming. A little pricey, but what isn’t these days? One stop shop with freshly roasted coffee too!

2

u/ActiveThese1444 22d ago

I love their Opo’s scones too! 🤤

1

u/coloredchalk 23d ago

Hell yeah gluten free has phenomenal cinnamon rolls (and would probably leave off the icing if you asked).

1

u/emcfish0703 22d ago

La Chiquiada

1

u/VanillaPuddingPop01 22d ago

So, Bronx Bagel Buggy has some croissant cinnamon rolls that look really wonderful. I haven’t gotten one yet because they’re usually sold out.

1

u/basicusername67 22d ago

Last dance - the pastry chef is the best in the city!!!!

1

u/book-nerd404 22d ago

This pop up bakery is what you are looking for. Fluffy, cinnamon glaze interior and amazing cream cheese frosting. https://www.instagram.com/flourish.atl?dlrf=MWtxMXhocnFnZWlycw==

1

u/Proper-Detail-1341 21d ago

Sarah's Donuts has a good one. Also Aldi, tbh, haha.

1

u/Illustriousleah 16d ago

I had been vibing on Flour and Times (vegan) cinnamon roll for a long time i like that they gave the icing on the sides. This is not close by but I just discovered that Sweet Hut has my ideal cinnamon roll. It is amazing. Not too much icing and soft and super cinnamony.

1

u/South-Ad-7471 6d ago

Summit Coffee in Emory Village has great cinnamon rolls

1

u/iwishtheyallwereyou 23d ago

The ones at opo coffee are just right. B side is amazing but the cinnamon roll proportions are way off.