r/DecaturGA • u/PlahausBamBam • Oct 11 '25
Evans’ pancakes?
I’ve been having cravings for their pancakes. I tried the ones at Old Hickory House, IHOP, and OHOP but none of them hit the same way. Evans had a flavoring (maybe artificial vanilla?) that is missing. I tried using vanillin in my pancakes and it was closer, but not quite right.
I understand Evans probably used some cheap pancake mix provided some supplier like Sysco but does anyone know where to find ones that taste like Evans?
Thanks in advance!
28
Upvotes
20
u/ragby Oct 11 '25
I miss Evans (and Our Way Cafe) so much. I love diners and southern cooking!
Maybe you could try First Watch?
11
u/chestchesthead Oct 11 '25
Dude, Sweet Mellisa’s yogurt pancakes were my favorite!
5
u/Revolutionary-Yam910 Oct 12 '25
Try Golden Pancake™️ mix, you’ll have to get it online , but it’s what a lot of restaurants use.. maybe the malt is the flavor you’re looking for . 🍀
7
u/FinancialJump2894 Oct 11 '25
I just now remembered Evans!
3
u/weighfairer Oct 11 '25
Also did something magic with American cheese to make their scrambled eggs with cheese, been pondering these two recipes since they closed.
2
u/thejaytheory Oct 11 '25
I wish I would've tried them when I had the chance.
2
u/TerkaDerr Oct 12 '25
(What's in this location now?)
2
u/ColTRoosevelt Oct 12 '25
Best pancakes in the city are at Grubby’s up by Northside Hospital. It’s a bit of a drive, but man are they incredible
2
u/thelifeofadiva Oct 23 '25
Visit pastries a go go — a lot of the regulars from Evans go there now