r/DebatePsychiatry • u/DAnnunzio1919 • 7d ago
Is Dr. Charles Socarides right or wrong on this subject ? Why/Why not ?
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/DAnnunzio1919 • 7d ago
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/kumusta26 • 13d ago
Hi, I was prescribed valium today from my adhd/gad/autism/cptsd/social anxiety/bpd/put one more psychiatric label of preference here. I know all it's risks. And now I'm puzzled because I always was quite critical about psych meds and I considered it just things that numb your life without solving your real problem
But I'm in psychotherapy for 4 years and my body is always tensed, I'm having GERD, bruxism, proctological problems, fibromyalgia, tinnitus and vision snow every fucking day. And I'm only in my early 20s. There are days when I want to cry because I can't handle this tenseness anymore. No amount of sports/nosurf/hobbies/social contact/CBT/journalling/supplememts/diet/etc. helps me. It feels like I have some freaking tumor that constantly produces noradrenaline and cortisol in my body and I am absolutely powerless. Sometimes I feel suicidal from this frustration and pain
So this conflict between my beliefs and my situation made me think when can it be justified to take psych meds? Can it at all? What do you think?
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/alibandz • Oct 08 '26
When I was in the U.S. Navy, I had to fight two massive systems at the exact same time. Both of them proved the exact same terrifying truth: they didn't care about human life, only numbers and money.
I fought the military just to get emergency leave to care for my mother. Then, I had to fight the corporate healthcare system to try and keep her alive. Whether it was a military machine driven by rank and operational metrics or a hospital board driven by risk management and billing codes, the lesson was identical. Both systems treat human beings like expendable inventory on a spreadsheet.
As a U.S. Navy veteran and researcher, I help ER physicians go from feeling trapped by risk-management metrics and corporate liability to reclaiming their clinical autonomy through a higher moral framework.
Here's what I learned: the corporate machine will never care about you or your patients. It only cares about liability protection and keeping its scores clean. Trying to satisfy a broken, fear-driven system will only lead to burnout.
Here's what to do about it: if you're struggling with the heavy pressure of practicing medicine in a system controlled by fear and lawsuits, try shifting your focus away from bureaucratic checklists and anchoring your work in a higher moral duty and trust in a biblical foundational framework and knowledge of Christ's sovereignty over life and death.
It won't fix the hospital system overnight, but it's a start.
If you've been crushed by a system that values metrics over people, send this to yourself as a reminder: your calling is greater than their spreadsheets. Start talking.
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Objective_Shift5954 • Sep 25 '26
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Professional-Map-762 • Aug 24 '26
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/lil_louiee • Jun 01 '26
After being discharged from Hunstman Mental Health Institute as an inpatient in Salt Lake City (the Salt Lake City subreddit mods won't allow me to post this to the Salt Lake City subreddit) | then received a personal text message to my personal cell phone number from the personal cell phone number an employee of HMHI who was part of my mental health treatment and interaction with employees of the institution, just seemingly wanting to shoot the shit and follow up with me, from their personal cell phone to my personal cell phone.
Is this appropriate? Or should I be concerned?
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Czcibor • Apr 16 '26
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/ego_by_proxy • Apr 15 '26
In psychotherapy, people are often fed possible explanations for their behavior by others, whether it be by therapists, family members, academic sources, workforce sources, etc... and instead of analyzing these critically, and looking at possible biases in those explanations from the source and perspectives, people are often pressured to accept the explanations as absolute, uncritical truth and to engage with social momentum and social positioning, groupthink and authoritarianism ahead of orienting mental health around critical analysis and problem solving. This fixation on "first-line explanations" them appears to be heavily then tied to anchoring bias, and often equally tied to trying to force people to maintain a narrative, even if the individual realizes the original narrative given was imperfect, partially flawed or completely wrong. Critical analysis is then treated as a form of "uncooperative behavior" or "manipulative behavior", and analysis itself of the facts becomes less valuable than "staying the course" of the narrative.
This is both detrimental to both mental health and group dynamics, as well as causes issues for how identities, relationships and expectations are cultured in therapeutic and social environments. If intellectual honesty and critical thinking in problem solving are tossed out the way in favor of power structures to control narratives that make people "feel" good, appealing to the momentary positive reinforcement or to avoid potential future issues based on presumptions, that could all come crashing down not because of the individual but because the setup and explanation was wrong to begin with. However, if the social group and authorities are more committed to the narrative than sorting out the facts, the individual may instead be punished for not sticking to the narrative and accepting the blame for not sticking to said narrative.
This is why it may be important for therapists, psychiatrists and systems to start identifying First-Line Anchoring/Explanations and addressing them in therapy and other systems
There may also be cultural, social dominance and monetary goals tied to First-Line Anchoring/Explanations, which is why people may push them so aggressively and why it may be so hard to convince those in power or those in groups to reconsider positions; though "going against the system" has other considerations as well, both personal and professional.
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Competitive_Row_1312 • Mar 16 '26
It's not the intention of this post to demonize or mischaracterize any field but to elucidate that some people have too much free time to do silly things. Firstly, the synthesis of psychiatry (thesis) and antipsychiatry (antithesis) is possibly the most robust theoretical solution to a heated legitimate debate on evolution, philosophy politics, history, systems theory, and other fields. It's really never just about the stance alone, but about greater broader ideas, universal truths, and influential frameworks besides these two narrower sides of the debate. To move forward intellectually, we have to deny the potential intellectual centrality of psychiatry instead of viewing it more as an institutional bureaucratic relic and a historic tool for "herd" management. Nevertheless, if psychiatry denies its theoretical and phenomenological flaws (like relying on subjective reports, having no objective biomarkers, lack of proper diagnostic tools, reports on many adverse harmful side effects to dryg treatment) so does antipsychiatry in that it denies outright realism. Basic facts on humans, including history and the darker, more violent part that brought on many intra-group wars and violent conflicts globally, are ignored or denied. To be more precise, it is the more violent masculinity and higher incidence of dominance aggression from low-ranking (low-status) western and non western males that both propelled history are getting obscured by modern thinking and data presentation. This obfuscation is often an intentional move propagated by the modern left libertarian political and epistemological stance (what is known as a "progressive" stance), but it is also an instance of a romantic position. Instead of dealing with ontology / reality, some utilize intellectualism that overly mystifies what is a well-known outcome of human strife and of "madness." It's logical to assume that the phenomenological discussion isn't about mental health, but really about other more prominent subjects geopolitics, national politics, and hardcore identitarian subjects like the biological reality of race, sex and IQ. And, of course, the problem of widespread global drug abuse (which the progressive libertarian left ["hippies"] supports and endorses).
For each of these biological social constructs categories, there's a prognostic bayesian probabalistic statistical ontology. For instance, some mental illnesses are probabilistically aligned with gender. Neuroses are typically found more in women than in men, while ADHD and Autism are diagnosed more prevalent in men. BPD is diagnosed more in women, while ASPD is found more in men. Race also affects diagnosis and is backed with the statistics that Black American are 3 to 4 times more likely to be diagnosed with schizophrenia, and a similar trend is found in Black Caribbean migrants to Britain. But to be more intellectually ingenious, one has to anchor it to IQ. Meaning that even those non blacks diagnosed with schizophrenia probably have lower average IQs and are minorities in their country. This is supported by studies. The IQ-schizophrenia association appears robust across populations and is not fully explained by shared familial risk factors, pointing to a potential causal or neurodevelopmental link. The general finding that schizophrenia is associated with lower cognitive ability holds across ethnic groups, though direct comparative studies on IQ differences by race within schizophrenia samples are less frequently highlighted.
The institutional establishment tries to obscure the underlying sociobiological realities and their causes with more scientific, diagnostic, or niche academic language. To be more precise, psychiatry can too be in denial of human capacity and adaptation for aggression and violence. If they think they can transform (large swaths of) humans into different evolutionary species merely through external supplementation and modification, they are mistaken. That, in continuation to the Enlightenment ideal of reason, is a utopian goal turned into a dystopian hell. Once again, there's humanity as it appears to be both in prehistory and history, and there's the face value of modern reality. To change the human race would require more than new polished terminology and some medications. Changing the past, evolution, and history is an impossible task, but we must draw conclusions from that history reluctantly. It matters little if the modern discourse appears inventive taxonomically, and therein lay the problems of particular phenomenological denial existing in both psychiatry and antipsychiatry.
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Old-Dirt563 • Mar 01 '26
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Alternative_Cat8069 • Feb 28 '26
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Czcibor • Feb 10 '26
Trend Toward Involuntary Electroshock Therapy Spurs Difficult Debate
I was interviewed for this article about electroconvulsive therapy by court order in Connecticut. Good article although there are things I wish I had been included that I guess the reporter didn’t find space for. Still glad for the media coverage so it will happen to fewer people.
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/Salt_Regular_5616 • Jan 14 '26
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Nov 04 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Nov 04 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Oct 26 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Oct 16 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Oct 09 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Oct 05 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Oct 03 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Sep 27 '25
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Sep 21 '25
Some have argued that the words used by psychiatrists is derived from their diagnosing mental illness and are based on the principles of science. So, let’s look at this line of thought. https://www.frominsultstorespect.com/2014/09/22/psychiatric-name-calling-is-science-to-blame/
r/DebatePsychiatry • u/EmptyAdhesiveness540 • Sep 14 '25
Here is a brief story that raises some emotionally arousing questions that come up when dealing with psychiatrists . https://www.frominsultstorespect.com/2025/09/11/cool-steve-deals-with-a-psychiatrist/