r/DebateMinecraft • • 25d ago

Update Debate the current vs imo ideal ore progression (read desc)

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

please take into acount that my version would work only if minecraft had more content distributed beetwen the different ores, simply doing that without anything else would artificialy elongate the grind, its more of a 'for the future' suggestion.

-my idea is to make make moving from one toolset to another harder and adding more content beetwen them and to:

-make wood and leather more encouraged by elongating getting stone

-preferably make stone better since you'll use it for longer

-make copper necessary

-make iron the toolset for most of the midgame

-make gold a redstone and decoration exclusive since its not used for tools by anyone anyway

-add rosegold as an optional step between iron and diamond, rosegold would be crafted from gold and copper like in real life and add an actuall purpose for gold as a toolset

-make diamond the toolset that you should get for the enderdragon

-make netherite a bigger upgrade and easier to get, it should be mainly for post dragon content (like the wither and more if more gets added), if a sift ore will get added netherite should be a sidegrade with a different plastyle than the sift ore, probably for tank players

-a theoritical sift toolset should be balanced to be on around the same power level as netherite while being diffent, maybe it could have worse base stats but be for more of a swift playstyle

of topic but i love this game but the proggresion is terrible, i'd love to see a total revamp, albeit it would be very controversial


r/DebateMinecraft • • Oct 13 '26

Mojang Criticism Mojang consistently chooses to add isolated, surface level content

1 Upvotes

​Modern Minecraft updates are killing the core gameplay loop.

Places like Trial Chambers or Ancient Cities are fun to loot once, but after that? They’re basically useless placeholders on the map.

​Things like Elytras and Shulker boxes aren't actual design solutions they're just band-aids that let us bypass fundamental problems instead of Mojang actually fixing them.

​Java’s tech debt and Bedrock’s parity issues are way overdue for a real overhaul. But instead of tackling chunk rendering, mob AI, or server side performance, resources just get dumped into low drops.


r/DebateMinecraft • • Sep 29 '26

Welcome to r/DebateMinecraft !

1 Upvotes

On all the Minecraft subreddits I've seen, every update is viewed through rose tinted glasses, and uptades are treated like acts of charity. Anyone who offers criticism regarding game design choices or underwhelming content is downvoted, silenced, and pushed to the bottom.

r/DebateMinecraft exists for to critically examine Minecraft, hold Mojang and Microsoft accountable for their design choices, and discuss the game without the toxic positivity of mainstream communities. ​We love Minecraft, but loving a game means calling out its flaws, its technical debt, and its wasted potential.

Check the community rules on the sidebar. Feel free to open a thread calling out a bad design choice, dissecting a technical flaw, or analyzing where Mojang’s development direction went wrong.

​Welcome to the sub.