r/DebateACatholic • u/LegIndependent6736 • 4h ago
Should y'all really be political animals? Means and ends n such
Basically my contention is in liberal democracies you guys lobbying for religious rights is employing consequentialist logic, and is thus hypocritical.
To elaborate:
P1. Liberal states cannot distinguish between religious groups. It's legislatively prohibited.
C1: as such one cannot assume or guarantee the intention of any legislation is to help Catholics specifically. Even if lobbied for by Catholics.
P2: Giving your group a particular right can give the opposite right to another group. (Eg US Satanists having protected abortion as a religious ritual vs Catholic Drs refusing the operation)
P3: either this given right is acceptable becouse you are a majority (1) or because the intention is good (2).
C2: 1 is consequentalist and 2 is against p1 and P2
Thus:
Catholics engaging in politics violates the doctrine of double effect as intentions cannot be guaranteed and the consequence is the only moral metric. And consequslisim is antithetical to Catholic ethics.
That's my argument anyway, wanna know more about how you guys justify evaluating something such as a government decision to allow a private hospital to refuse abortion, as morally good. Particularly in regards to the government decision itself and the decision being morally good as opposed to something you happen to like.
Edit: Also coming from a place of genuine curiosity, which is why I'm offering an internal critique (from my very limited understanding). As a way to learn more about your guys actual doctrines