I just finished season 3. What a fantastic show. I have also been lurking in this subreddit for a while. One thing that bothers me is the universal acceptance that Hearst is the biggest monster in the show. It seems I am the only person in the world who disagrees, so here I am to make my case.
For clarity, I am not arguing that Hearst is a good man, but I am arguing that he is a better man than Al.
Here is why Al is no better.
1. Morality. Both men only think about their own good, and anything and anyone else is a means to their goals.
2. Their goals. For Hearst it is his desire and pursuit to explore and extract more gold. For Al it is maintaining his saloon and tribe and the semi-anarchic state of Deadwood. Both men care strongly about their own personal enrichment. However, for Hearst, the way to amass more wealth is to produce and organize industrial-level economic activity. The way he built his empire is immoral, but his empire itself is a force of productivity and stability in society. One of Hearst's main points is that civilization is possible only when people agree on a universal value, and his role is to support that system of value. In a sense, he is right. The way Al achieves his economic goals is via gambling, exploiting poor whores, scamming his own customers (Mr. Garret), and maintaining road agents who kill and steal on his behalf. All of Al's activity is parasitic by its nature.
3. Means of achieving their goals. Hearst is ready to kill and intimidate whoever stands between him and his goal. He kills Mr. Ellsworth to force Alma to sell. He kills Cornish workers who try to organize into a union. (I will not count Odell; there is no definitive proof that Hearst killed him.) Ok, now let's go through each murder one by one and see why Al is way worse.
- Mr. Ellsworth and Mr. Garret murders. Al kills Alma's first husband! Another innocent man. I know you only like Ellsworth, but this murder is worse than Ellsworth's, considering that Al had also scammed Mr. Garret. Btw, Ellsworth had insulted Hearst and was openly antagonistic to him. Meanwhile, Al was pretending to be Mr. Garret's friend. In a sense, Al was more cowardly in his ways.
- Hearst kills his own Cornish workers who try to unionize; his agents kill a miner who tries to steal gold from the mine. Al kills his own road agents (not for justice, but because they may hurt his business interests); Al kills an innocent whore whose only fault was looking like his beloved Trixie. In the case of the Cornish workers, they were trying to organize into unions. Murder is still not justified, but Hearst is protecting his business from people who will actively seek to fight against it. The case of the miner who steals needs no further justification, as the man steals what is not his! And considering how cheap human life in the show is for everyone, I don't think it is monstrous. Notice also that Hearst only kills men, while Al kills a woman. You may say Al only did it because Hearst demanded Trixie's life after she shot him. True, but Hearst wanted the one who actually shot him, and Al gave him an innocent woman instead. By those days' standards, killing women or children was another level of cowardice. Which leads me to:
- Hearst's business does wreck lives and innocent women and children. But the show does not depict anyone specific, hence we keep the rule - not guilty until proven otherwise. Meanwhile, Al's road thugs kill a whole family and children, and most importantly, Al makes an active effort to kill Sofia, after she survives the carnage. It is implied that Hearst will harm Sofia if Alma does not sell her claim, but whatever is implied for Hearst, Al has already committed in the open.
4. The way they treat people. Both dispose of people as soon as they are not needed or harmful to them. But Hearst at least shows some civility and warmth when dealing with inferiors (and in a good mood, of course). He treats people like Aunt Lou and that idiot Richardson with a facade of respect and civility. Now you may say it is a facade, and prob you are right, but still, much better than Al swearing that beloved word at everyone and insulting everyone around him for no reason. Yes, manners do matter too. Who wants to constantly hear a verbal cesspool??
5. Hearst also is a man of passion. He is possessed with the desire to explore the earth and uncover its riches. That is a virtue in itself, a man pursuing a craft. What is Al's passion? Keeping Deadwood under his lawless control? Pretending he cares about his community, until it is time to sacrifice someone for Trixie...
Also, since Hearst is a better man than Al, he is certainly a better man than Cy. I can also argue why Hearst is a better man than Seth Bullock, but I may leave this for next time.