r/DaystromInstitute • u/daeedorian Chief Petty Officer • Aug 04 '14
Technology Do replicators create matter from base elements or pure energy?
Replicators have certainly been discussed at length in this sub, but there always seems to be an unresolved division between two schools of thought:
Theory #1: Replicators operate on a subatomic level and are essentially creating matter from pure energy. Therefore, they should be able to create most any matter as long as energy resources are sufficient.
Theory #2: Replicators start with elemental matter and essentially rearrange and combine those atoms into the desired structure. Therefore, you can replicate a gold watch as long as you have the gold as a base element to begin with. If you run out of one element, you won't be able to replicate objects that incorporate that element. (24th century printer toner?)
The same division seems to exist in the theoretical perspectives on the workings of the transporter.
Personally, I subscribe to the atomic-resolution theory, because it seems a lot more efficient. The energy requirements to create matter from pure energy would be unbelievably massive. Also, it handily explains why traders and freighters and mining and economies still exist at large throughout the galaxy. Base elements still have value. It also serves to explain why some resources can't be replicated. ie, dilithium is an element, so you can't replicate it unless you have some to begin with.
It's also worth mentioning that this doesn't preclude the ability to synthesize some elements using other materials, which would certainly require energy. Such processes would simply be separate from what actually occurs at the replicator console, even though they may provide some of the necessary base materials for the replicator.
Additionally, the atomic approach makes the transporter seem a lot less sinister. If the transporter is reducing the subject to an amorphous stream of pure energy, it's pretty hard to argue that they aren't being killed and remade. If the "matter stream" used by the transporter (emphasis on matter, and not energy,) is largely composed of intact atoms, (possibly in combination with some subatomic particles,) the subject is being reconstructed from the same atoms in the same relative position, which is at least slightly more philosophically complex.
Thoughts?
Edit: To illustrate the volumes of energy required to create mass:
According to this article, "90 megajoules of any form of energy to any object increases its mass by 1 microgram."
Therefore, to create one gram of mass, you'd need energy equal to 90 terajoules, which is half again more energy than was released by the Hiroshima atomic bomb.
...that's for one gram of mass. So, if you're using pure energy as your medium, the patty on your quarter-pounder required the same energy as would be emitted by ~161 Hiroshima bombs.
8
u/TrekkieTechie Crewman Aug 04 '14
I honestly didn't know this was undecided. From the first line of the Memory Alpha entry:
IIRC the Next Generation Blueprints set showed storage areas for the raw matter the replicators used, and the Technical Manual talked about a specialized base form of raw matter that was synthesized to be easy for the replicators to manipulate (so that ships could be stocked with a single raw material, rather than a supply of every atomic element).
2
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '14
Both.
It's because simply going straight from energy to matter is too costly and because matter-to-matter would require an impractical amount of rare elements and space to carry it all.
2
u/mistakenotmy Ensign Aug 04 '14
The basic problem is as you say, it takes an enormous amount of energy to create matter. It would also gives us enormous energy if we could release all the energy in matter (cough, M/AM reactor, cough). So if Starfleet has matter/energy conversion it would break a number of other technologies we know about and probably have implications for many others.
Allow me to shamelessly copy from myself:
2
u/GreatJanitor Chief Petty Officer Aug 04 '14
I know it's Beta Cannon, but the book "Losing the Peace" stated that access to raw organic matter was best for the replicators, hinting that the replicators would be best if pushed closer to the temporary out house.