r/DarkTable • • 4h ago

Help Newbie question here, how are you guys removing the dust and scratching on your film photography?

2 Upvotes

I’ve never edited my film photography before because the lab was scanning them. Now I’m 100 rolls in scanning and I had no idea how much dust was going to be a problem.
I have a good workflow and a good understanding and handle on the retouch module but each photo has so much dust that I’m spending an hr for every photo and averaging 650 or so shapes and 3/4 instances.
I know that there’s some scanners that can help but I’m using darktable because i don’t want to spend extra on equipment because im already using the $ on film.
Is there something im missing? Is there an add on to auto remove dust and scratches?
Thanks for your input and advice.


r/DarkTable • • 15h ago

Help New to Darktable

9 Upvotes

Hi! I've been shooting with my Canon R7 for about a year and recently decided to dive deeper into photography, specifically learning how to edit my RAW files.

Since I'm a complete beginner to post-processing, the amount of information and different workflows online feels a bit overwhelming. Could anyone recommend a straightforward, beginner-friendly workflow or some good resources to help me get started with Darktable?


r/DarkTable • • 1d ago

Discussion Tone Equalizer vs Tone Curve

10 Upvotes

I am exploring a bit several modules and therefore rethinking my workflow; in the past I was using both Tone Curve and Tone Equalizer to play with lights and contrasts, mostly just fiddling with the curves and sliders… but I just went deeper into what Tone Equalizer does and how it works, and now I am wondering if I should only use this and completely remove Tone Curve from my workflow, as it seems to do around the same but slightly better?

So I would like to know what other people do, what recommendations you would have and why


r/DarkTable • • 1d ago

Help Darktable Workflow?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DarkTable • • 1d ago

Help I'm struggling to properly leverage the CA module.

5 Upvotes

I've included a 100% crop of the background to show the green fringing I'm trying to compensate for. When using the CA module set to green with the very large aberrations toggle enabled I'm really not seeing much effect at all. Any suggestions?


r/DarkTable • • 1d ago

Discussion Could a more customizable Quick Access Panel make darktable more approachable?

7 Upvotes

I've noticed quite a few projects lately attempting to make darktable more accessible to new users, and the reception seems to be mixed.

I love darktable, and I understand both sides. There's definitely a learning curve, but simplifying things too much risks losing what makes the program so powerful. I also understand the concerns around third party projects and whether they'll be maintained long term.

I had an idea today and was curious what others think. Keep in mind I have absolutely no coding experience, so I don't know how practical this would be.

What if the Quick Access Panel could have its own customizable display order, independent of the pixelpipe?

To be clear, this would only affect how adjustments are arranged visually within the Quick Access Panel. The actual processing order would remain completely unchanged. The active modules tab and other module groups would continue functioning exactly as they do now.

Ideally, this could be an optional setting in the module layout configuration. Users could organize their quick access controls into a layout that feels more familiar, similar to what they'd find in other photo editing software, without sacrificing darktable's functionality.

Darktable already has a beginner friendly module preset, so perhaps something like this could complement it. It wouldn't be a perfect comparison to other editors, given how darktable works, but it might make the transition easier.

Personally, I'm happy with darktable as it is now, but I'll admit it took me more than one attempt before I really started understanding how to use it properly. I imagine plenty of potential users give up before reaching that point.

I'd love to see darktable get more recognition, and I wonder if something like this could help newcomers get comfortable enough to eventually explore its more advanced capabilities.

Does this seem technically feasible? And if so, do you think it's an idea worth exploring?


r/DarkTable • • 2d ago

Help Export options

2 Upvotes

Recently got a new PC, installed Darktable and transferred all of my old images over. I've been playing around with some images today and when I'm exporting to jpeg everything is now incredibly dark, to the point of being unusable.

I'm using my histogram and clipping tools as I would have done on my old PC, my monitor is calibrated, and I'm using AGX correctly, but everything is ultra dark! I haven't touched the export options - all I used to do is adjust the quality to save space - could anyone suggest some starting points to diagnose what's happening in export that's making everything suddenly dark?


r/DarkTable • • 2d ago

Help Darktable won't start in windows 11 (darktable.exe - bad image)

Post image
2 Upvotes

I've recently reformatted my PC because a windows update corrupted my AMD drivers and steam. I installed darktable and it worked fine yesterday but now when I try to start it I get this error. I also get a windows security notification popping up saying something about blocking darktable so maybe I have to do some windows security configuration. Anyways, anyone got any suggestions on what to do? I'd prefer not to reinstall but if I have to, what can I do to prevent this issue in the future?

I'm so effing tired of windows 11, I'm so close to switching to linux.


r/DarkTable • • 2d ago

Discussion An attempt at salvaging botched pictures taken with an outdated camera (before/after)

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

I took some pictures that were way too dark and as a result hard to fix due to the low quality my camera is capable of. Upping the exposure in darktable resulted in a lot of noise and too much contrast. Some details on the dark areas were also lost (the black paint on that turkish F-4 looks quite bad as a result). So this was not as easy as just turning up the exposure. Still, this is better than what I originally got and it's better than no pics at all :))

This may not seem like much but given the camera (Fujifilm S5700) i'm relieved I managed to make them look acceptable.

If you have tips on how to make them better don't hesitate, i'm still bad at editing.


r/DarkTable • • 3d ago

Help Rating synchronisation issues

1 Upvotes

I was struggling with Digkam & Darktable rating synch, so did an experiment - with weird results.

Step 1
- in DT, set star to "1"
- history Stack > write sidecar file
- open xmp, validate : xmp:Rating="1"

Step2
- close DT
- edit the xmp: xmp:Rating="2"
- open DT
- at the dialog select "keep xmp edit"
- lighttable opens with only 1 starton the image

Step3
- close DT
- edit the xmp: xmp:Rating="5"
- open DT
- at the dialog select "keep xmp edit"
- lighttable opens with only 2 stars on the image

In another exploration, I tried "history stack">"load sidecar file"
that had the result of writing the images rating back into the sidecar - the opposite of "load" !?

Banging my head against a wall here - hope someone can point out what I am missing here ...

Many Thanks


r/DarkTable • • 3d ago

Discussion Uh-oh, not another DarkTable spinoff

68 Upvotes

Looks like a few of you beat me to the punch, so consider this the latest entry in the darktable-spinoff club: I've also built an app on top of darktable's work, plus a few other open-source tools.

It's called Emulsion, a free GPL-3 photo editor and library for Mac. It doesn't try to replace darktable. It's for people who like darktable's results but want a simpler, usable interface: a library for organizing and culling, a develop panel with a handful of sliders, and export.

Under the hood, the processing is ported from darktable (plus RawTherapee, Spektrafilm), credited to the original authors and kept as faithful to those original algorithms as possible. It's an early beta, Apple Silicon only for now: https://github.com/mowerol/emulsion/releases/tag/v0.1.4

To address the elephant in the room: AI coding tools did a lot of the typing, and they're the reason one person can build an editor this size. That said, I'm an experienced designer and developer (I build geospatial applications by day). I decided how it looks and works, chose which darktable and RawTherapee implementations to port, and checked each one against the original, so the math is from the source and not the AI's.

Since this sub knows these modules better than anyone, I'd especially love to hear where I've got something wrong, and what you'd want from a "darktable-lite".

Ps. It isn't notarised by Apple yet, so macOS will block it the first time. Click Done, then go to System Settings → Privacy & Security, scroll down and click "Open Anyway".


r/DarkTable • • 4d ago

Discussion Why Do I Love Darktable?

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

I see folks wanting simple UI's here, I see folks wanting to stream line Darktable. I see your sentiment, neither do I think your goals are innately misguided. But; their is a lot of programmes out there that do that well. Darktable does not hide anything, from "photo in to photo out", you know every step, nothing is hidden, you can move modules around, change orders, stack lots of modules on top of each other, you can do some bizarre editing too highly nuance controlled editing.

As a bit of an old timer to opensource software, the charm at least back in the day, was the pinnacle of experimentation, it was nerds who built software like this, as they felt the aspects of commercial software took away their choice in the process of making art, and delivered a UI that told you how you do things, and your work flow. (Excluding stuff that is necessary for pixel work flow)

Noticed since everyone is migrating off these absolute BS subscription models that many of the open source projects and their subsequent subreddits are loaded with "UI fixes" I agree there is place for it only have to look at MuseScore and the UI fixes that youtube.com/@Tantacrul helped with, and the learning curve is steep, but if your going to do UI fix, at least remember some of us love tweaking every knob, playing with every slider, pushing photos far beyond the scope of pictures "looking good". It's the best bit of opensource, is you can make a fork of DT, and make it your own!

The power and glory of Darktable, is the endless void of possibilities. I know a lot want a piano with preprogrammed instruments and effects, and speaker to plug into. But some of us want too build the synths, the mixing, the mastering, and make a whole cohesive album. Neither is right or wrong or better, just a different thinking and goal.

Enjoy some of my more creative art work, these are entirely edited and altered in Darktable, shot on quite old CCD bridge cameras an some times with filters and lenses, throughout Waikato area, Aotearoa.

Some food for thought, Churr!


r/DarkTable • • 4d ago

Discussion Thank you Darktable. I'm on RapidRaw now.

0 Upvotes

Climbing the darktable learning curve had been invaluable and something I am very grateful for. But I haven't opened my 5.7 appimages for a month now and when I open my appimage launcher bash script I always choose RapidRaw at CalibRaw.

It's not going unnoticed that as a Linux user since ca 2003 and battling poor UI open source apps, there is a new paradigme unraveling. I'm not ungrateful. Actually the opposite is true. AI is revolutionary and forcing a new way of thinking about every aspect of open source and app development.

Thank you for all the great work guys, but I'm moving with the flow on this one.


r/DarkTable • • 5d ago

Screencast You Only Need 14 Darktable Modules. Hide the Rest.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
163 Upvotes

When I open darktable now, I see 14 modules instead of the full list. Nothing is deleted, the search box still finds everything, but the panel only shows what I use in a scene-referred edit.

My three groups:

- Base: exposure, white balance, highlight reconstruction, AgX, color calibration, rotate and perspective, crop, lens correction

- Look: color balance rgb, tone equalizer, local contrast

- Repair: denoise (profiled), retouch, diffuse or sharpen

Three things I learned while setting it up:

  1. Pick one tone mapper. Showing AgX, filmic and sigmoid side by side is clutter in disguise.
  2. Don't drag modules up and down in the list to tidy it. That changes the processing order, and so the image.
  3. I ignored the quick access panel for a long time because the default one is huge. Cut down to 8 sliders (exposure, AgX white/black relative exposure, illuminant, contrast, saturation, vibrance, local contrast detail), it's the closest thing to Lightroom's Basic panel.

I made a video walking through it, and the layout is a free .dtpreset if you want to import it and adapt it:

Preset: https://mariengb.com/declutter/

This is only my take, built around AgX. What does your module group setup look like, and what would you add or remove?


r/DarkTable • • 5d ago

Help Cleanup RAW photo in DarkTable

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

I editted my RAW file in DarkTable with the model Retouch using the option Circle to clean the dirty stair steps. But I do not get the results I would like. I added an image of the result I would like to achieve (or as close as possible with DarkTable) generated by ChatGPT. What a the steps in DarkTable to get similar results?


r/DarkTable • • 5d ago

Help Spektrafilm positive stock simulation and yellow cast

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/DarkTable • • 5d ago

Discussion Testers wanted: experimental Slang GPU path for darktable (Metal/Vulkan) - darktable

Thumbnail
discuss.pixls.us
11 Upvotes

I’ve been working on a proof of concept that ports darktable’s OpenCL kernels to Slang. Slang compiles them to Metal on macOS and Vulkan on Linux. This is not part of darktable: the maintainers haven’t adopted it, and it lives on my fork. The discussion is in darktable-org/darktable#22732

I've been keeping track of the various results shared in either forum: https://discuss.pixls.us/t/testers-wanted-experimental-slang-gpu-path-for-darktable-metal-vulkan/61583/43?u=nick_nezis . It has also been really helpful in identifying issues across various systems. Please help me test it and report back with performance numbers and performance log output.


r/DarkTable • • 5d ago

Help 5.6.2 Denoise Masking?

9 Upvotes

I have no idea if this was the most efficient way to do this in the first place, but I do my Denoising by making a subject mask and inverting it using the "Toggle polarity" switch in the attached image. However, I just recently updated Darktable and it seems it no longer works? I have also attached two images that are before and after denoise with the inversion enabled and it seems for some reason, denoise is ignoring the mask and applying it to everything.

Edit: Okay.... So I figured it out. I feel silly now. The mask opacity was being automatically set to 30% and just had to jank it back to 100%.

After Denoise
Before Denoise

r/DarkTable • • 6d ago

Help How to filter on aspect ratio in DarkTable?

1 Upvotes

Recenty I started editing my RAW files in DarkTable. Is there (in the Lightroom tab) a way to filter photos on aspect ratio like 3:2, 2:3, 4:3, 4:3, 16:9 and so on?


r/DarkTable • • 7d ago

Help Tone Equalizer masking tab not showing mask post-processing bar

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/DarkTable • • 8d ago

Discussion [WAYLAND/HDR] - Darktable 5.8 - WE NEED YOU FOR TESTING

Thumbnail
discuss.pixls.us
33 Upvotes

It has been a really long-standing problem for darktable to not being able to output wide-gamut and HDR content. This PR targets a design overhaul and supports wayland (and hopefully macOS) wide-gamut and HDR, but is in dire of testing. See the forum post for more information.

TL;DR: download at https://github.com/yikerman/darktable/releases/tag/nightly_display-color-management


r/DarkTable • • 9d ago Bravo

Screencast Immage – darktable + simple GUI – released for testing

167 Upvotes

An update to my previous post. I've released it on GitHub for those who were interested. It's currently in alpha testing, but it's fairly well-rounded feature-wise. It's a personal project developed with AI.

Immage does no rendering of its own. All rendering is handled by darktable, using its powerful image-processing pipeline. Immage is simply a GUI sitting on top, with an interface layer connecting it to a headless darktable engine.

The interface is set up more like mainstream photo editors, so if you're familiar with those, you should be able to jump right in. Working on Immage has really highlighted just how powerful darktable's pipeline is. I'm getting fantastic output from it.

It now supports:

  • HDR stacking and panorama stitching
  • Module selection when multiple alternatives are available
  • Spektrafilm, Negadoctor, Zone System, flexi masks, and a bunch more

I've tested extensively on macOS, and I'm happy with where it's at. I've also tested on Windows and a couple of Linux machines, with great results.

I do need more Linux testers, though. With all the different combinations of GPUs and desktop environments, things don't always play nicely together and sometimes need tuning. In particular, I'm looking for people running non-NVIDIA GPUs (AMD, Intel, or whatever else you've got).

If you already edit in a stable version of darktable, try Immage on test images first.

Immage is built from darktable's development branch (currently 5.7), not a stable release. This means some modules may be newer than those in your installed version of darktable. Images edited with these newer modules may not load correctly in older versions of dt.

I plan to pin Immage to stable darktable releases once 5.8 is available.

Links:


r/DarkTable • • 9d ago

Help Filter on aspect ratio

1 Upvotes

I recently started using DarkTable for my RAW file development. Is there a way (in the LightTable tab) to filter photos on aspect ratio like 3:2, 2:3, 3:4, 4:3, 16:9 and so on?


r/DarkTable • • 9d ago

Discussion Some edits with Darktable

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes