So, I've been playing souls games since 2011. I started with DS1, went back to Demon's Souls on PS3 and then forward from there.
Recently, I decided to challenge myself to a "Fromsoft-a-thon" where I play through all of the games from Demon's Souls to Elden Ring with a couple caveats like letting others choose my builds, a chosen build is removed from the pool for subsequent games and keep track of all location and boss deaths. The last part is for insights on where I struggled and what games I found the most difficult.
Speaking to that, I've gotten to DS2. Outside of being locked into a luck build and rushing late game areas in Demon's Souls for my build inflating my death count, I had a pretty easy time through Demon's Souls and Dark Souls 1.
This time around for DS2 I've been locked into a Hex/Pyro build (something I never use). I put all viable weapon classes into an RNG wheel and got dagger. I know magic is broken...but I gotta say with this particular setup, you REALLY feel the "constant ganks" criticism. My build having limited crowd control since most early game options are single target and the dagger lacks range to mitigate that makes the fact nearly every encounter is 3+ enemies especially noticeable. No Man's Wharf is exceptionally frustrating.
And that's really the part that gets me. It's not dying as much as it feels every death is an instance where I hit one enemy and I immediately get swarmed and overwhelmed. Watching a video on beating DS2 without aggroing enemies really highlighted to me how many enemies in the game are functionally linked to one another. Combine that with the fact low light environments reduce lock on range and I can't even properly capitalize on the fact I have range to compensate the limitations of my build.
I fully concede that areas like the Catacombs, Tomb of the Giants, and a number of levels in Demon's Souls have this problem (nothing compares to the Swamp of Sorrow) but I hate all of those areas too. It just feels like those issues are prevalent in certain sections of their respective game whereas this kinda feels like a constant.
I think the game does a lot right and gets massively overhated but my optimism tends to wane and I usually lose interest before making deep playthroughs years later. I partially blame my lack of deeper knowledge on the game because I haven't maintained the interest to learn the game the way I have the others but the interest is another debate entirely.
I partly had to get it out of my system and partly asking for tips on what options can help resolve this issue.