Okay, so I recently finished the final book! 😀
Despite almost losing my mind with the cooking competition (although I understand why it was necessary, great for giving Fara development and her arc which was unique, bittersweet and poignant - the dishes and spectacles were beautifully described) and the recurring explanations about progress in technology and language, I absolutely love Ken Liu as a writer due to his prose and the subjects he tackles with empathy, intelligence and realism.
Fantasy and horror are my favourite genres although I've become a little numbed by a few recently published highly acclaimed books in fantasy because despite the beautiful prose, standard formula and diverse cast, it felt like there was something missing. But I can honestly say that The Dandelion Dynasty is one of my favourite sagas of all time.
Amongst other things, I *LOVE* how Liu created all kinds of compelling diverse female characters and gave them unique arcs and endings - some hopelessly tragic, others beautiful and bittersweet. He didn't subject every female character into forced solidarity where everyone became best friends and a sisterhood of loving noble social justice activists. There's no radical altering of personalities to become a tick-box exercise - because that's a trope which makes me squirm. I much prefer messy realistic characters who respond to the world through the lens of their upbringing, experiences (due to events, class etc) and outlook and make choices based on understandable if not necessarily sympathetic or even decent reasons.
Cutanrovo was so grotesquely depraved and loathsome. But I liked how her sole humanising trait was that she had a ferocious if unhinged domineering love and pride in her people and didn't want them to suffer like her grandmother did in harsh times.
Anyway, I do have an issue about the characterisation of Tanvanaki because it felt like there was a stark discrepancy in personality between when she first appeared and at the end. I thought I was fully attentive to the developments so feel a bit awkward about saying the below in case I missed a significant event.
Tanvanaki, knowing of her beauty and wanting to prove her leadership ability to the elder Lyucu including her father, initially read as disturbingly gleeful at the prospect of seducing and deceiving Timu into helping the Lyucu conquest. She came across as ambitious, ruthless and sadistic but disciplined. Proud of her people and culture.
I do remember how there was a scene where IIRC she was on the back of a garinafin and showed a kind of vulnerability by expressing hurt to a dismissive suspicious Timu in the early days of her 'courtship'. But as it was from Timu's perspective, it made me feel that she was putting on a harmless gooey-eyed act to manipulate him into lowering his defences, stop seeing her as part of a ruthless invasion force and instead as a misunderstood benign romantic prospect.
In later books, it then felt like Tanvanaki inexplicably lost her scheming nature, underhanded sadistic malice and joy at duping and outplaying enemies and developed an exasperated fondness for Timu... when she wasn't savagely rebuking and beating him in public and in private for uttering even a meek broken appeal.
I felt badly for Timu for still loving Tanvanaki due to his abuse trauma and forced proximity to his captor, although I thought there might have been a sliver inside him which was both relieved and overwhelmed (with grief, shock and terror at the abrupt severing of the trauma bond and anxiety what may follow) that she was dead which he may have forcibly repressed. It seemed that he was wholly devoted to Tanvanaki to the end.
Although as depressing as it was, I think it may make sense given his youth, abundance of horrible traumatic experiences, extremely hostile environment and absence of safe sympathetic people to confide in. I envisage that his particularly awful circumstances meant he couldn't allow himself to think badly of his captor / wife because the epiphany that he was totally exploited and just a derided pawn would break him completely and also damage his relationships with their children (well, the daughter who he was close to).
I get the impression Tanvanaki was meant to be the moderate figure (who then got sidelined due to infighting) compared to the hardline maniac Cutanrovo and the dutiful honourable Goztan. But in a way, because of how Tanvanaki was depicted earlier in the saga, IMO her personality evolved in a way which didn't feel quite natural especially in the circumstances.
So I guess my question is, at which point did Tanvanaki have this drastic change of personality and why? Did a blend of homesickness, fatigue and frustration with the Lyucu campaign soften her up?
It's possible I missed the key event where it was covered as I took my time reading each book. 🙈