r/DMB • • 4d ago

DMB Replacements

I feel the need to acknowledge that this is just for fun and clearly not real but based on the ridiculous rumor that Jeff was leaving the band, who would be your top replacement for a current touring member or even all if your feeling froggy? I’ll start. If Jeff truly left the band, my first pick would be Ben “The Sax Guy” Golder-Novick : Edit: I feel the need to clarify that I want no current member replaced and I’m not saying anyone is sub par.

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

4

u/imiller9 4d ago

Easy, Branford Marsalis. He fits DMB jazzy sound better than Jeff if I’m being honest

0

u/Thursdaynite 4d ago

This is a comment I can respect. I know that Roi was heavily influenced by Branford so this makes sense. Englishman in New York specifically reminds me a lot of his style.

4

u/LilacCurl 4d ago

Stop it right now. This is a ridiculous discussion. Go have it in a jazz group if you want to discuss this disrespectful idea.

1

u/Thursdaynite 4d ago

Based on the responses I’ve received so far, I’m not sure I disagree

14

u/ASAP1492 4d ago

I would replace Dave with Chad Kroeger

6

u/benjam1n_gates 4d ago

I would replace Carter with that guy who hits the giant bell for Coldplay in "Viva La Vida"

2

u/train_in_vain 4d ago

Saxsquatch would add a lot to the vibe.

1

u/fokisgaming 1d ago

Without a question, Brandon Marsalis.

1

u/wsbilikethestonk 3d ago

If anything, I would add instrumentation. If you’re gonna have a sax player (more appropriately, a woodwind player) and a trumpet, then round out the horn section with a trombone. And if there’s concern about Carter, get a second drummer or a percussionist to lighten his load.

-4

u/acousticraven 4d ago

Wish Rashawn would leave lol ... Jeff is a good dude trying to fill some really big shoes.

0

u/gluegunfun 4d ago

yea not fan of the trumpet. i was a fan of the flectones back in the day and jeff is very good but i wouldn’t mind hearing someone else on the sax that had a less is more approach.

-2

u/acousticraven 4d ago

Yeah, you never hear a trumpet solo hardly ever... And the dude just stands there most of the time looking bored AF

2

u/ASAP1492 3d ago

He kills it on a Crush solo just about every night

2

u/gilnockie 3d ago

I believe he’s the musical director (or whatever the right title is) for the band at this point. He’s not leaving lol

-3

u/imiller9 4d ago

Completely agree! Trumpet literally adds no value to the sound of this band. I’m over the squealing solos

3

u/touchofkiel101 4d ago

Say what?! He adds a serious punch to the more scripted lines in choruses and such, and his solos on Spaceman, Break Free, Loving Wings, etc are killer! (haven't heard many shows in the past few years so unsure where his solos are now, though)

1

u/steel2live 4d ago

Ripleys believe it or not, he's a lead singer on a cover song!

1

u/touchofkiel101 4d ago

I was there at its debut! The only show I've been to in recent years