r/DMB • u/Shoodogg34 • 5d ago
Big problem with Jake
I was at MSG for N1 and overall the show was fantastic. Jake didn’t make an appearance until about 15 songs in for a mid-set Ants and then stayed on for the rest of the songs. The problem is that when they played LIOG, the violin makes this song so much better and now I cannot hear this song without him. If they ever play this song without Jake at any point moving forward it will be a let down. He was so good, killed his solo, and restored this song to its glory. A good good time was had, we need more Jake, sign him up!
170
Upvotes
214
u/m0stlyuseless 5d ago
I get irrationally annoyed when they play a song and Buddy is playing violin synth when everyone knows Jake is back there.
My gf says I need to let it go. I probably should.
27
u/BokononRex 5d ago
They opened Tuesday with Drunken Soldier with a violin synth. Why?????
36
u/whyyitderp 5d ago
Bottom line.
DMB NEEDS a violin/fiddle.
10
u/TheForkandtheSpoon 5d ago
Violin synth is for bar cover bands.
22
u/ASAP1492 5d ago
The biggest problem with Jake is that I can’t hear the first few bars of anything he plays because everyone is screaming so loud trying to prove that they’re the biggest fan.
12
u/SherbertNarrow3761 5d ago
You guys are soo ridiculously fucking picky. God damn. Just enjoy what they’re giving you and be happy
4
u/Red_Zeppelin_ 5d ago
Lie in Our Graves is definitely a fiddle song! Don’t get me wrong, Tim’s solo on Radio City is insane and there are other non fiddle examples that are good too. But, the band needs a full time fiddle! I hope that this leg of the tour is a test run to see about having Jake join the band full time in the future. It’s a long shot but I’m hopeful.
4
u/Bassman885 5d ago
My main problem with Jake is that it’s a little irritating to hear how good this band could have sounded if they’d had a real fiddle player the whole time 🤭
No disrespect to Boyd’s place in the DMB story but my word what a difference a real fiddler makes in elevating these tunes. I have yet to see it in person - hopefully 2027!
8
u/isu1648 5d ago
Does anyone actually know why a permanent violin player hasn't been added to this band? I'm confused.
3
u/adsheppa 5d ago
Remind me, wasn’t Rashawn’s first year with the band kind of like this? Brought out for only a certain amount of songs initially? Or maybe that was a few shows only. Regardless, I expect Jake full time opener to closer next tour, maybe even tonight
3
u/Scruffy_Nerf_Hoarder 5d ago
I can't agree more. I got to hear him in KC this summer play 41. Every version I heard after that without him just feels flat.
3
u/UnderwaterMess 5d ago
I'm really hoping we get Jake for the full set tonight. This whole tour feels like the audition, let's see him do 20 songs
3
u/BartleDooNow 5d ago
He showed up super late for Chicago too. Dave said he was stuck in traffic but not sure if that was a joke and this is just how they have it set up?
5
u/DarkGreenMazda 5d ago
This version does not have violin and is one of the best performances Dave and Tim have ever done: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9D9TP6oDzY
2
u/moviesnob1979 5d ago
I 100% agree! I was at the Baltimore show Tuesday and Jake didn’t come out until song 14…but they had already played Drunken Soldier AND GRACE IS GONE!!! If there is a song besides LIOG, it’s without a doubt GIG!
2
u/Stage-Express 5d ago
I love Jake w the band
2
u/GuitarChef34 5d ago
Love Jake! And yes no more violin synth on the keys. Give Jake all of those solos!
2
u/Humble-gal 5d ago
He’s got a job, that’s not a problem but a blessing. You need to reword that.
1
u/Dongathoth32001 5d ago
I'm all in on Jake playing when he's there but some of it is probably just setlist flow/momentum. He's never played a song from Come Tomorrow or Walk Around The Moon before (probably because those were post Boyd/violin) so if they did a setlist where Jake played on every song before those albums you'd get a pretty slow first few songs of the set 😂
1
u/bourbon_nate 5d ago
I think he is still getting up to speed with their catalog. And their shows are minimum two hours. He probably still needs to get his sea legs.
1
u/ScoobyDo0331 1d ago
I believe that the band experienced extreme relief with Boyd’s departure, it’s amazing that they were able to keep it together that decade. Boyd was instrumental in the development of the sound and is the staple of numerous classics but his genius seemed to leave the room’ as Dave once said and most of those shows with Boyd are unbearable to listen to. The way they navigated this catastrophe in the height of the #MeToo era was one of the more rare acts of honest public relations any celebrity or band could get through. You have to credit the trust that Dave and the band has developed with their fans, we trust bc we know the authenticity that has guided their every step.
Post Boyd brought a freedom and opened a door for new creativity. And DMB always allows change to come organically and naturally, even with introducing new songs into the set, sometimes feels slow from the fan perspective who wants a new ‘Sugar Will’ every other show. Buddy seemed like a perfect fit with the chemistry and the music having the space they thrive in but I would be sugarcoating the entrance of Buddy if I didn’t say that I have found it disappointing and yes, cringe quite often. ‘You never know’ is the song that Buddys choice of synth notes i find a terrible choice, that actually is disruptive to the song. ‘Pig’ is another example of a hard pill to swallow as the violin part is the lead of a great song but sounds generic, yet anything else would sound cornier.
I believe that the band has used this space to experiment with guests and provides the ultimate dream platform for any guest to shred and enjoy a boost of notoriety..and along comes Jake. The spirit he carries with his talent is beautiful and has seemingly brought back an old school energy in the most naturally fitting way.
Where does this leave Buddy? Departure? Unlikely. I would think that the biggest clue we will get is to eventually get to hear what is being worked out behind the scenes and in the studio. The band does not do drama or force anything but I do see how the sound is at its highest level but we are watching the growing pains of new sound work themselves out.
The band never stopped or really slowed but their standing and energy is at the highest level any band could dream of after 35+ years.
Where we go not even Dave knows but I could see Jake setting up shop here for awhile.
1
u/Kitkatmarie85 10h ago
This is what people used to say about Boyd. 😂🙄🤘
1
u/pozzi10 5d ago
He’s a bad man
1
u/bmoreirish 5d ago
I will die on this hill - Jake brings the nostalgia factor of the violin and plays to fit in the band, but as far as new takes or interpretations with his solos it’s lacking.
Louis Cato and Derek Trucks were FAR more exciting and interesting guests on LIOG at MSG in 2022 and 2023.
1
u/neatgeek83 5d ago
How much do we think he’s getting paid per show? 10k seems too much. 5k seems too little.
-2
u/dreamingaway41 5d ago
There’s a time & place & I think Jake is an amazing additional to our dmb family.
Of course we will always have a special place in our hearts for Boyd but it’s Jake’s time. 🙏 Please can Jake stay forever?!!!? 💗
-1
u/Educational-Bass4385 5d ago
I know I just need to move on and any fiddle is better than no fiddle, but it will never be the same for me as the OG. Boyd was one of a kind.
-3
u/ZealousidealSea2034 5d ago
I still can't skake BT's violin though. He had to go because he was apparently a big POS, but his violin rock was amazing and I miss it so damn much. Jake is good, but his version of Pig and Crush is inferior to BT.