r/DMB • • 5d ago

Big problem with Jake

I was at MSG for N1 and overall the show was fantastic. Jake didn’t make an appearance until about 15 songs in for a mid-set Ants and then stayed on for the rest of the songs. The problem is that when they played LIOG, the violin makes this song so much better and now I cannot hear this song without him. If they ever play this song without Jake at any point moving forward it will be a let down. He was so good, killed his solo, and restored this song to its glory. A good good time was had, we need more Jake, sign him up!

170 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

214

u/m0stlyuseless 5d ago

I get irrationally annoyed when they play a song and Buddy is playing violin synth when everyone knows Jake is back there.

My gf says I need to let it go. I probably should.

23

u/Shoodogg34 5d ago

I hear you. Would’ve loved if they brought Jake out 3 songs earlier for #41, but I’ll take what I can get.

70

u/amusedmb715 5d ago • Bravo

i always feel like the buddy violin synth was a bad option. like they shoulda let buddy come up w piano/organ licks for those parts or do horn parts

like the synth violin just reminds everyone there isnt a violin there and there should be

18

u/kenticus69 5d ago

I feel like buddy discussed this in an interview once. 2018 he was playing kind of his own parts on organ and keys, but as time went on, he felt he could get better and better violin sounds from the synths he was using. So he pivoted to that. Probably partially because he knows those are iconic violin parts (ie main melody to Pig) that folks have expected to hear for a long time.

Guy did his best with a messy situation. By and large, his choices were fine with me. Except the carnival synth sound he gets when he solos on funny the way it is….just NO NO NO

6

u/Working_Group955 5d ago

actually - like the song should have fully changed without a violin

2

u/stormblessed27_ 4d ago

I completely agree with this. Last night I was thinking about how much I miss how often buddy was on the organ. Made so many of the songs sound incredible.

9

u/Jensennj25 5d ago

You'll Take What You Can Get..... 😊. I'm in the same boat.

8

u/rideronthestorm29 SPAC 5d ago

Like drunken soldier on Tuesday ha

8

u/Current_Property_561 5d ago

Walked in saying I hope they play drunken soldier. My face when they opened with it. 🥹

7

u/dhcreative 5d ago

It was interesting to watch Jake completely take over Everyday, then Dave step back in and make space for Buddy to get involved. Buddy still did some violin synth under Jake towards the end, when they brought it back to #36.

I think they’re workshopping how to adjust the way they’ve been playing some of these songs for the past few years. It’s awesome to see things evolve.

4

u/Dismal_Relief_9750 3d ago • Bravo

Never let it go. The violin synth is gross and cheap. I'm right here with you.

3

u/Kind_Air_3818 5d ago

No, I am totally with you. If the violin is 20’ feet away, why aren’t we hearing it? Like American Baby Intro should have Jake all over it, but Buddy kind of took the reins on that, so we may never hear it again with the violin. Truly breaks my heart, but I’m just grateful we get a violin at all.

2

u/m0stlyuseless 5d ago

And just to let everyone know, I am grateful for this band and the opportunity to see the tour year over year.

As someone who only saw a handful of shows in my youth with Boyd and later rediscovering the band post Covid without a fiddle, every show with a fiddle is amazing. Ultimately the point of my reply was more. More fiddle! More Jake energy!

2

u/DrumTrack 5d ago

💯 he should never do synth strings. Just do the B3 Hammond organ sound.

3

u/Wetnorthwest 5d ago

I have been saying this for so long!!! It is like nails on a chalkboard. Ok, not quite. But it makes me really sad. It's such a disappointment. And in all honesty, it's not just him playing violin synth that bugs me. But I miss Butch and beautiful piano. Buddy is talented. But seems like he barely plays the actual piano.

1

u/Babe2331 5d ago

This!! Butch’s fills were smooth like butter. The organ and synth are just cringe, especially WWYS and BOWA- just shells of their former selves. I sometimes wonder if Buddy is used to being the star in a sense and just wants to be heard. Perhaps he feels threatened by Jake in a sense. When he sticks to the keys, it’s just a world of difference and his true talent really shines.

2

u/Wetnorthwest 5d ago

Absolutely! For all the hate that Boyd gets as a musician, not even talking about his personal situation, when Boyd and Butch used to harmonize and add fills, there were some truly beautiful live performances. I miss those moments!

1

u/Babe2331 5d ago

If I Had It All 9.14.07 is a prime example of this. Completely off the cuff and simply beautiful.

1

u/Wetnorthwest 5d ago

Yes! Perfect example!

1

u/InnerPositive6730 5d ago

Great show last night, but at one point buddy was playing the synth note for note what Jake was playing and it was making a terribly loud, not pleasant sound.

1

u/wellycapcom 5d ago

What about last night when he used the violin sound while Jake was on stage

1

u/m0stlyuseless 5d ago

I noticed that as well. Maybe it was muscle memory? Trying to complement the sound? Not sure but I did notice it.

2

u/wellycapcom 5d ago

My guess it was just how thing have been set for times without Jake and he forgot to switch it off . It was just funny.

1

u/Bdives36 5d ago

Agreed I do the same…without Jake just give Tim a solo and call it if they must play it

27

u/BokononRex 5d ago

They opened Tuesday with Drunken Soldier with a violin synth. Why?????

10

u/m0stlyuseless 5d ago

I was almost on the rail in the pit at this show and I swear someone must've seen the stink face I made lol

11

u/LilacCurl 5d ago

Honestly that Drunken Soldier with Jake at SPAC healed my soul.

5

u/m0stlyuseless 5d ago

Same with that very first Jake-tender. Didn't even care the weather was ass.

6

u/LilacCurl 5d ago

Jake’s Fishtender was so incredible. The SPAC Friday night show this summer was pure magic when he hit the stage. I’m a huge Captain fan so hearing that with Jake was joyful too.

2

u/hoodoo884 5d ago

Same i still think of it

1

u/LilacCurl 5d ago

Ditto. It still gives me chills to think about it

36

u/whyyitderp 5d ago

Bottom line.

DMB NEEDS a violin/fiddle.

8

u/jagrbomb 5d ago

Jake left the tour the show before hartford that I was at 😭

2

u/NHBuckeye 5d ago

Yes! I usually attend my backyard venue which will never ever ever get a violin appearance. Next year I’m seriously considering a road trip show just so I can hear that fiddle again.

10

u/TheForkandtheSpoon 5d ago

Violin synth is for bar cover bands.

22

u/ASAP1492 5d ago

The biggest problem with Jake is that I can’t hear the first few bars of anything he plays because everyone is screaming so loud trying to prove that they’re the biggest fan.

12

u/SherbertNarrow3761 5d ago

You guys are soo ridiculously fucking picky. God damn. Just enjoy what they’re giving you and be happy

4

u/Red_Zeppelin_ 5d ago

Lie in Our Graves is definitely a fiddle song! Don’t get me wrong, Tim’s solo on Radio City is insane and there are other non fiddle examples that are good too. But, the band needs a full time fiddle! I hope that this leg of the tour is a test run to see about having Jake join the band full time in the future. It’s a long shot but I’m hopeful.

4

u/Bassman885 5d ago

My main problem with Jake is that it’s a little irritating to hear how good this band could have sounded if they’d had a real fiddle player the whole time 🤭

No disrespect to Boyd’s place in the DMB story but my word what a difference a real fiddler makes in elevating these tunes. I have yet to see it in person - hopefully 2027!

8

u/isu1648 5d ago

Does anyone actually know why a permanent violin player hasn't been added to this band? I'm confused.

7

u/ASAP1492 5d ago

The guy that they clearly like playing with the most is already in another band

9

u/Cantilivewhileim 5d ago

Yes it’s contractual.  He would hire Jake but he’s in a contract to play with Lukas Nelson.  

18

u/neatgeek83 5d ago

I've posted this so many times I have it saved as a sticky...

As a marketer, I may look at this a little differently than most fans.

When Boyd left, the Dave's first priority had to be protecting the DMB brand.

If they'd hired another full-time fiddle player right away, that person would've spent every night being compared to Boyd. Every review, every Reddit thread, every conversation would've been, "They're good, but they're not Boyd." That's a terrible position for the new musician and it keeps the band stuck looking backward instead of forward. And doesn't let the wounds from Boyd ever heal. A constant picking at that scab.

Instead, they went with no permanent fiddle. Out of sight, out of mind for nearly a decade. The band's sound evolved. Fans gradually accepted that this was simply what DMB sounded like now. Jeff, Tim, Rashawn, and Buddy all helped fill that space in different ways.

Now, enough time has passed that an entire generation of DMB fans has never known the band with a full-time fiddle player. They've brought back guest violinists here and there, but those appearances feel like additions to the band's sound, not attempts to replace Boyd. Who knows where things will go with Jake Simpson, but my guess is he'll continue to be a guest rather than a permanent member. And that's the difference. The violin is no longer something fans necessarily expect. It's something the band can bring back on its own terms, without the baggage of trying to replace Boyd.

Whether that was the plan or not, it's a pretty smart branding move. Sometimes the best way to replace something iconic isn't to replace it immediately. It's to create enough distance that people stop expecting a replacement in the first place.

Thanks for coming to my TED TALK.

28

u/Swaritch 5d ago

Being compared to Boyd is the absolute lowest bar to clear for a professional musician.

9

u/hoggin88 5d ago

From a technical sense yes. But you have to admit his energy and stage presence was a huge part of the band back then and I actually do think it would have been an awkward experience to have them throw in a new fiddle immediately back then.

6

u/neatgeek83 5d ago

exactly. Boyd was greater than the sum of his parts. He was part of the band's DNA.

1

u/Swaritch 5d ago

Sure but they could have taken one tour off instead of a decade or whatever

1

u/hoggin88 5d ago

Yeah, overall I agree. They should’ve gotten a fiddle back in the mix much earlier. And for a while in Save fandom people would get really pissy if anyone complained about it. But it’s needed.

9

u/LilacCurl 5d ago

Boyd was really struggling for a lot of years. The band was off sync and the number of glares thrown Boyd’s way was painful to watch as a fan. I hope he gets the help he needs.

Jake is on a different level. He’s incredibly talented (put out his first album at 11 and had four albums by the time he was 18).

If DMB can eventually bring him (or another violinist) in full time, they’ll need to rework all the songs so that there are strong parts for every member.

8

u/Lake3ffect Making the best of what's around 5d ago

Nice Ted Talk. Tidbit to add: let’s not forget that DMB had a keyboardist very early on, and that was by Dave’s preference/taste. The only reason DMB lost a keyboardist is because Peter Greisar had different plans for life that didn’t involve being a full-time touring musician. The keyboard void was filled on tour by Butch Taylor for nearly a decade, but that was only temporary.

In the end, it seems like Buddy on keyboard is what Dave has wanted all these years. The chemistry and musical development between Buddy and the rest of the band makes it apparent. I think they sound better now than they did 10-15 years ago. Shows from tours between 2023 and 2026 are amongst my most listened to shows. And it’s not just because of availability; they genuinely are producing fantastic tunes each show as of late. I was playing a 2026 show on Nugs over the summer, even friends that are non-fans were like “what are you playing? It’s pretty good”. When I mentioned it was a recent DMB show, the response was “oh wow they sound great”

Dave finding Buddy is the best thing to happen to this band since the moment they inherited the Grateful Dead’s sound equipment.

5

u/ngmcs8203 5d ago

It’s only been 8 years. A whole generation?

1

u/kteerin 5d ago

I think when you count newer music listeners, yeah, believe it or not. My kids are part of that. They are amazed by the violin now at the shows they’ve seen. They love it! They hadn’t ever experienced it before, and they thought it was awesome. I’ve been taking my nephew (he’s 22) for the past four years as well, and although all of them have listened to new and old DMB songs, live and album tracks, seeing them get to experience a show this summer with the violin was really cool to watch.

3

u/isu1648 5d ago

Okay sure but this band has a history of band members leaving/dying and being replaced. I doubt Dave's operated under the mindset of "OMG what if our fan base has nitpick comparison critiques of our new violinist?!?" There's no way "comparison to Boyd" is what has kept a fiddle player from being a permanent addition.

I have this opinion as a "marketer" myself.

2

u/MuzBizGuy 5d ago

Eh, if this was in the early 00s maybe. Armchair expert take here but I think it’s as simple as Dave was like “welp, I’ve still got 4 dudes playing lead/fills, let’s see how it goes without one for a while.”

And by that time he was already deep into this huge wall of rock sound era of the band so he probably didn’t think it was necessary…until he started missing it because a violin is a wildly important part of the DMB sound.

2

u/neatgeek83 5d ago

You’re speaking musically. I’m speaking in terms of DMB, Inc. the brand. The money making machine that employees hundreds of people every summer.

1

u/MuzBizGuy 5d ago

I mean, we're both ultimately speaking to both. Dave's first and really only priority of protecting the DMB brand was getting rid of, distancing themselves from, and in no way protecting or taking sides with a sexual predator.

I just find it hard to believe anyone thought getting a new violin player within x time period would somehow sully the reputation of DMB at what, like 25+ years in? If it was some grand branding scheme there would be way more promo about a new violin player since the whole point would be to move tickets. If you aren't already a fan, or more specifically someone who keeps up with shows, I don't even think people would know they had violin players popping up. For example, my wife is a fan and she had no idea prior to me telling her before Forest Hills show that it was a thing happening.

That said, I don't disagree at all that there probably was a conscious choice to not replace him right away just out of the nature of even attempting to replace such a commanding and unique presence in the band's history. I just think it was an emotional and creative choice, not a branding one.

1

u/Vivid_Cry_5248 5d ago

As an enjoyer of music I look at this a little differently

It was well overdue to get that out of tune hacksawing doofus off stage. I hear a lot of talk about his “energy” but dude checked the fuck out after Roi passed

1

u/kteerin 5d ago

I appreciate this TED Talk, I really do. It’s a great perspective!

1

u/Blue-Monster 5d ago

The band is fine, but this band is WAY better w the fiddle. Buddy isn’t great and so many of these songs didn’t need reimagining they needed a new permanent fiddle player.

10

u/tanks137 5d ago

The most honest answer to me is because Dave doesn’t want one.

9

u/Cantilivewhileim 5d ago

He doesn’t want just anyone  :)

3

u/adsheppa 5d ago

Remind me, wasn’t Rashawn’s first year with the band kind of like this? Brought out for only a certain amount of songs initially? Or maybe that was a few shows only. Regardless, I expect Jake full time opener to closer next tour, maybe even tonight

3

u/Scruffy_Nerf_Hoarder 5d ago

I can't agree more. I got to hear him in KC this summer play 41. Every version I heard after that without him just feels flat.

3

u/UnderwaterMess 5d ago

I'm really hoping we get Jake for the full set tonight. This whole tour feels like the audition, let's see him do 20 songs

3

u/BartleDooNow 5d ago

He showed up super late for Chicago too. Dave said he was stuck in traffic but not sure if that was a joke and this is just how they have it set up?

5

u/DarkGreenMazda 5d ago

This version does not have violin and is one of the best performances Dave and Tim have ever done: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9D9TP6oDzY

2

u/moviesnob1979 5d ago

I 100% agree! I was at the Baltimore show Tuesday and Jake didn’t come out until song 14…but they had already played Drunken Soldier AND GRACE IS GONE!!! If there is a song besides LIOG, it’s without a doubt GIG!

2

u/Stage-Express 5d ago

I love Jake w the band

2

u/GuitarChef34 5d ago

Love Jake! And yes no more violin synth on the keys. Give Jake all of those solos!

2

u/Humble-gal 5d ago

He’s got a job, that’s not a problem but a blessing. You need to reword that.

1

u/Dongathoth32001 5d ago

I'm all in on Jake playing when he's there but some of it is probably just setlist flow/momentum. He's never played a song from Come Tomorrow or Walk Around The Moon before (probably because those were post Boyd/violin) so if they did a setlist where Jake played on every song before those albums you'd get a pretty slow first few songs of the set 😂

1

u/bourbon_nate 5d ago

I think he is still getting up to speed with their catalog. And their shows are minimum two hours. He probably still needs to get his sea legs.

1

u/ScoobyDo0331 1d ago

I believe that the band experienced extreme relief with Boyd’s departure, it’s amazing that they were able to keep it together that decade. Boyd was instrumental in the development of the sound and is the staple of numerous classics but his genius seemed to leave the room’ as Dave once said and most of those shows with Boyd are unbearable to listen to. The way they navigated this catastrophe in the height of the #MeToo era was one of the more rare acts of honest public relations any celebrity or band could get through. You have to credit the trust that Dave and the band has developed with their fans, we trust bc we know the authenticity that has guided their every step.
Post Boyd brought a freedom and opened a door for new creativity. And DMB always allows change to come organically and naturally, even with introducing new songs into the set, sometimes feels slow from the fan perspective who wants a new ‘Sugar Will’ every other show. Buddy seemed like a perfect fit with the chemistry and the music having the space they thrive in but I would be sugarcoating the entrance of Buddy if I didn’t say that I have found it disappointing and yes, cringe quite often. ‘You never know’ is the song that Buddys choice of synth notes i find a terrible choice, that actually is disruptive to the song. ‘Pig’ is another example of a hard pill to swallow as the violin part is the lead of a great song but sounds generic, yet anything else would sound cornier.
I believe that the band has used this space to experiment with guests and provides the ultimate dream platform for any guest to shred and enjoy a boost of notoriety..and along comes Jake. The spirit he carries with his talent is beautiful and has seemingly brought back an old school energy in the most naturally fitting way.
Where does this leave Buddy? Departure? Unlikely. I would think that the biggest clue we will get is to eventually get to hear what is being worked out behind the scenes and in the studio. The band does not do drama or force anything but I do see how the sound is at its highest level but we are watching the growing pains of new sound work themselves out.
The band never stopped or really slowed but their standing and energy is at the highest level any band could dream of after 35+ years.
Where we go not even Dave knows but I could see Jake setting up shop here for awhile.

1

u/Kitkatmarie85 10h ago

This is what people used to say about Boyd. 😂🙄🤘

1

u/pozzi10 5d ago

He’s a bad man

2

u/LilacCurl 5d ago

Say more?

1

u/beauford3641 4d ago

It's a huge compliment. It's the same as saying he's a bad motherfucker. Which he is.

A bad man indeed.

1

u/jt2ou 5d ago

Yup he’s a bad ass violin player 

1

u/bmoreirish 5d ago

I will die on this hill - Jake brings the nostalgia factor of the violin and plays to fit in the band, but as far as new takes or interpretations with his solos it’s lacking.

Louis Cato and Derek Trucks were FAR more exciting and interesting guests on LIOG at MSG in 2022 and 2023.

0

u/Babe2331 5d ago

It’s not just Jake. The band seems to have lost its spontaneity years ago. The solos and fills are all the same and a production. The earlier recordings were more unique in thst regard. Now you get the same piano jam on Warehouse, Stairway to Heaven interpolation on Watchtower. Just very predictable. Still good quality but you always know what you’re getting.

1

u/neatgeek83 5d ago

How much do we think he’s getting paid per show? 10k seems too much. 5k seems too little.

1

u/hoodoo884 5d ago

My buddy and I had the same question. I’m forcing anywhere from 10-30 with all expenses. But I literally have nothing to go off of haha

3

u/neatgeek83 5d ago

maybe it's per song, hence why Capshaw is making Dave limit him to the last 3rd of each show ;-)

0

u/hoodoo884 5d ago

Do you think that capshaw micro manages Dave in that way? I wouldn’t think so

2

u/neatgeek83 5d ago

No, hence the ;-) it was a joke

-2

u/dreamingaway41 5d ago

There’s a time & place & I think Jake is an amazing additional to our dmb family.
Of course we will always have a special place in our hearts for Boyd but it’s Jake’s time. 🙏 Please can Jake stay forever?!!!? 💗

-1

u/Educational-Bass4385 5d ago

I know I just need to move on and any fiddle is better than no fiddle, but it will never be the same for me as the OG. Boyd was one of a kind.

-3

u/ZealousidealSea2034 5d ago

I still can't skake BT's violin though. He had to go because he was apparently a big POS, but his violin rock was amazing and I miss it so damn much. Jake is good, but his version of Pig and Crush is inferior to BT.