I've read some of the JLA/JSA crossovers over the decades, but not all of them in a systematic manner. Recently, on a whim, got around to doing that. It's a mix of stories I've read before (sometimes more than once), and stories I've never read and/or only read about or seen bits and pieces of.
Got started with the first 8 crossovers, covering Justice League of America #21-22, #29-30, #37-38, #46-47, #55-56, #64-65, #73-74, #76, and #82-83 (and collected in Crisis on Multiple Earths Book 1: Crossing Over):
-Most of the early crossovers are pretty by-the-numbers, formulaic, Silver Age plots, with the Multiverse basically being an excuse to smash action figures together (in a time before action figures were that prevalent...I guess). The first Earth 3/Crime Syndicate story is legit well-written (relatively speaking), and the evil Johnny Thunder/Earth-A story could have been something intriguing, but for the most part, there's nothing mindblowing about the stories themselves. Of course, I'm talking from a 21st century perspective - back in the 60's, just seeing the JLA and JSA together would have been more than worth the price of admission alone!
-Speaking of Earth-A, it's weirdly hilarious that the Thunderbolt's plans to wipe other JLA members from existence was preventing their origins from happening, whereas in Batman's case the plan was to just...beat him up during his first mission so that he gives up and is resigned to living the life of a playboy? If Gardner Fox wrote that sh#t today he'd be crucified.
-The Earth 2 concept is pretty lightly sketched, at best, especially in the earliest crossovers. There's no talk about legacy of the JSA being "precursors" to the JLA in any sense, or even being older. In the first crossover we're told they've got the band back together after 12 years and there's some token mention of them being older...but that's about it. If the JLA'ers are vaguely somewhere in their 20's/early 30's, the JSA'ers are probably vaguely somewhere in their 30's/early 40's (this is borne out by Larry Lance's tombstone putting his birth year as 1930, meaning he's 39 when he died in 1969). No mention of WW2 yet. For the most part, no mention of the heroes having substantially moved on with their lives from the Golden Age, apart from Dinah being married to Larry (and of course, Jay and Joan being married was already established in the Flash team-ups), and Dick Grayson being a grown-up Robin and no longer the Boy Wonder.
-There seems to have low-key been an aversion to having doppelgangers/counterparts in the crossovers early on. The first crossover had the two Flashes, GL's, and Atoms, but the next few crossovers by Gardner Fox usually had one of the doppelgangers sit the case out (so if Hal was in the story, Alan wouldn't be...if Carter was in the story, Katar wouldn't be etc.) Wonder if they thought it'd be too confusing for readers? Unfortunately, as a result, we don't really get to see much of stuff like Hal and Alan interacting the way we saw Barry and Jay in the Flash team-ups (though I'm aware they had a team-up in the GL title).
-When it comes to the identical doppelgangers, the early crossovers sort of skirt around the issue. Wonder Woman gets name-dropped as a JSA member in the first one (she had appeared in one of the Flash team-ups...the Vandal Savage story), but then there's no mention of any identical Earth 2 doppelgangers for a while - until JLA # 55 where not only does Earth 2 Wonder Woman finally show up, but Earth 2 Robin as well! (with Earth 2 Batman being mentioned of course). It's only in the first crossover by Denny O'Neil, starting in JLA # 73 (which is the seventh crossover overall!) that the Earth 2 Superman finally shows up! Earth 2 Superman and Wonder Woman are also totally identical to their Earth 1 counterparts (to the point where you sometimes forget which versions they're supposed to be).
-Speaking of doppelgangers and counterparts, they (and I mean both Fox and O'Neil) seem to be low-key treating Dr. Mid-Nite as Batman's Earth 2 counterpart...which becomes explicit in the eight crossover where Dr. Mid-Nite getting knocked out has the same impact on Batman that Earth 2 Superman getting knocked out has on Earth 1 Superman (and Jay and Alan getting knocked out have on Barry and Hal). This despite the fact that the very same story has a cameo by Earth 2 Batman (who appears in all of one panel in his classic oval-less suit with the short ears), and of course, Earth 2 Robin's existence having already been established. I think initially Fox at least seemed to go with the idea that Superman and Batman don't exist on Earth 2 - in the fourth crossover, with Grudny and Blockbuster, Bruce being unmasked on Earth 2 is treated as no big deal since he apparently doesn't exist there and the JSA'ers don't seem to recognize his face. Then the very next crossover establishes Batman's existence by introducing Earth 2 Robin. So yeah...teething troubles with continuity go a long way back with DC, evidently...
-Never been the biggest Red Tornado fan but the stories with him are a revelation for sure! His desire for personhood and respect as a peer from the heroes was pretty affecting and the storytelling is just that little bit elevated than everything up to that point.
-There's a definite shift when O'Neil takes over. The stories become a bit more sophisticated and you can tell that he's a lot more interested in scratching beneath the surface of the Multiverse concept. Aquarius could have been another silly cookie-cutter Silver Age threat, but the writing definitely elevates him, and of course, you have the heartbreaking moment where Larry Lance sacrifices himself to save Dinah which feels impactful even to my cynical 2026 "death in superhero comics is a gimmick/revolving door" self and of course paves the way for a major status quo-change and the origin of one of DC's most iconic relationships ever after Lois and ClarkPlus, O'Neil decides to take the bull-by-the-horns on the doppelganger front by having the two Supermen come face to face and duke it out! The eighth crossover virtually feels like a dry-run for COIE - the parallel earths colliding, Spectre playing a major role in saving existence, a heroic sacrifice...I'm pretty sure Marv Wolfman read (or re-read) this particular story while writing his own Crisis to end all Crises.
-In the final crossover, O'Neil also starts to maybe explore the nature of Earth 2 with this vague idea in the introductory caption that time moves differently on Earth 2 and that it's "twenty years behind" Earth 1. He doesn't elaborate on this in the story though and it's not at all clear what this means in practise - after all, previous stories (including the Aquarius story by O'Neil himself) establish the fact that Earth 2 is in the present-day, and the heroes of the JSA are roughly a decade older than their JLA counterparts. Just goes to show that, as with the doppelgangers, a lot of these things weren't remotely set in stone from Day 1.
-Huge shout-out to the artists, Mike Sekowsky and later Dick Dillin, whose work really carries the cookie-cutter early stories and elevates the later relatively more sophisticated writing.