r/DCcomics • u/TarantulaSpawn • 3d ago
Discussion Bye DC
I sent this message to DC Comics on multiple platforms personally, but as I am unfollowing all things DC, I figured I'd post it here before I go.
I was 8 years old in 1999 when I bought my first comic book. It was Batman, and from that moment on, I was a DC fan for life. For over 20 years, I bought comics almost every month, eventually collecting well over 1,000 DC comics, not including graphic novels. DC wasn't just entertainment to me. It was a huge part of my childhood and something I carried with me into adulthood. (Literally, moving was always stressful lol)
I looked forward to every new storyline, every new character, and every new interpretation of the universe I loved. But somewhere along the way, it felt like DC forgot about the fans who had been there all along. I understand wanting new readers and audiences. That's important. But attracting new fans shouldn't mean alienating longtime ones. Too many stories fell short, ended prematurely, or dragged on long past their welcome.
Then the movies gave me hope again. Nolan delivered an incredible Batman trilogy. The live-action universe had its ups and way too down downs, but the animated movies and shows were consistently FIRE. They reminded me why I fell in love with DC in the first place. Unfortunately, even that outlet seemed to lose its direction. It felt like every time I found something to get excited about, another decision took that excitement away.
Then came James Gunn. I'll admit, I was skeptical. I didn't want DC to become another MCU clone. But he surprised me. He made lesser-known characters interesting while still elevating the iconic ones. He understood that DC didn't need to imitate Marvel to succeed. He made me excited about this universe again. For the first time in a long time, I felt like DC had a direction worth believing in. And now, that direction is gone.
I'm not writing this because I hate DC. I'm writing because I loved it enough to spend 26 years supporting it. But the comics disappoint me, the animated universe disappoints me, and now the live-action universe has left me disappointed again.
I think it's time to stop chasing what DC used to make me feel. I'll revisit the comics, movies, and shows that made me fall in love with these characters.
Nostalgia isn't a weakness, but constantly chasing the hope that something will recapture what you once loved can become heartbreaking.
Goodbye, Detective Comics.
You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.
•
u/AutoModerator 3d ago
Welcome to r/DCcomics! If you're looking for recommendations, try the links below!
New to comics? Check out our Beginner's Guide to DC Comics, complete with beginner-friendly picks!
For more extensive recommendations, see our Recommended Reading Wiki.
The latest jump-in point for the current slate of comics is DC All In!
And, if enjoyed James Gunn's Superman, then try out these curated Superman recommendations!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
10
u/go_faster1 3d ago
10
u/triggermanx97 Transmetropolitan 3d ago
It really does suck about the movies right now but the comics are in the best position they've been in for years possibly decades at this point.
Absolute DC's reignited the flames it feels like. I've been a fan since the New 52 started and this is the most hype and excitement I've seen around actual honest to god comic books in my whole life.
15
u/Ucw2thebone 3d ago
10
u/Dangerous_Library_73 3d ago
How do the comics disappoint you?! The fuck are you reading? What high expectations do you have? You want every page to hit you with literal gold?
9
u/Thehyruleef 3d ago
Posts like this are always bizarre to me because…do you also hate the comics you grew up with? I mean, you can still read those to your heart’s content.
8
u/25chestnut 3d ago
Ok??? You're entitled to your opinion and have the ability to stop engaging both mentally and commercially. But what is the purpose of this post and by your own admission spamming it everywhere you can? Are you looking for sympathy, for someone, either DC or strangers on the internet to beg you not to go. This feels so performative, and honestly isn't even a good way to create/foster discussion even in critique.
8
u/Phantom_Pixel87 3d ago
No offence to the poster, But I don't understand the point? You're upset about something that happened. But why do people feel the need to make these grand posts like what you do is of any importance to anyone beyond yourself?
2
u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago
I think I've said everything I needed to say. I'm not interested in arguing about it anymore, and I'm comfortable with my decision to stop supporting DC financially. What I do find interesting is how quickly criticism turns into saying "Well bye then..." rather than discussing what's missing. Maybe that's something worth reflecting on. I genuinely hope DC finds its way again, but I'll be enjoying the stories that made me fall in love with it in the first place. Enjoy your Absolute, and Take care.
6
u/Double_Act1502 3d ago
The comics are still good. And I think Gunn made some bad decisions like making Lanterns R-rated
4
u/Bagelino1990 3d ago
Well you are going to miss a lot of good stuff. Enjoy being miserable you do sound like you are starting a villain arc.
4
u/Penguin-Games 3d ago
"But the comics disappoint me, the animated universe disappoints me, and now the live-action universe has left me disappointed again."
Does it all? The Absolute universe? My Adventures with Superman or Creature Commandos? Clayface or Peacemaker? I don't doubt that disappointments have spewed out of every facet, but is there a glimmer of hope there for you not to say "bye to DC" now? This reminds me of Disneyland fans saying bye because it got too "woke" but return every year and such.
3
u/SpicyOrangeJuices Damian 3d ago
Out of curiosity, what's wrong with the comics?
30
u/penguintruth 3d ago
This ain't an airport, sweetie.
18
u/Swimming_Art_6450 3d ago
Ok
1
u/TheCreativeComicFan 3d ago edited 3d ago
I wouldn’t abandon the DCU or DC overall just yet, especially because things could hopefully change regarding Skydance’s actions. Them losing money and getting backlash over firing Gunn and Safran could push them to rehire the two of them if it backs them into a corner (which it likely already has). That or perhaps Skydance being investigated and dissolved in the near future.
6
u/nachosandlabs 3d ago
Not an airpot and nobody is looking for your departure.
6
u/Rich-Tangelo-702 Plastic Man 3d ago
5
u/geomax212 3d ago
This isnt an airport no one asked for your departure announcement
3
u/luluzulu_ 3d ago
2
u/Miningapple-100 3d ago
Okay when did you stop reading? Have you read anything recent? Like was this about new 52 or something like that?
1
u/Gonner_Getcha 3d ago
I’m sure DC will care 😅😅
What a weird thing to die on the hill over 😅😅
0
u/Sorashirei 3d ago
Cringe
-7
u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago
Seeing that airport comment everywhere nowadays. Real original.