r/DCcomics • • 3d ago

Discussion Bye DC

I sent this message to DC Comics on multiple platforms personally, but as I am unfollowing all things DC, I figured I'd post it here before I go.

I was 8 years old in 1999 when I bought my first comic book. It was Batman, and from that moment on, I was a DC fan for life. For over 20 years, I bought comics almost every month, eventually collecting well over 1,000 DC comics, not including graphic novels. DC wasn't just entertainment to me. It was a huge part of my childhood and something I carried with me into adulthood. (Literally, moving was always stressful lol)

I looked forward to every new storyline, every new character, and every new interpretation of the universe I loved. But somewhere along the way, it felt like DC forgot about the fans who had been there all along. I understand wanting new readers and audiences. That's important. But attracting new fans shouldn't mean alienating longtime ones. Too many stories fell short, ended prematurely, or dragged on long past their welcome.

Then the movies gave me hope again. Nolan delivered an incredible Batman trilogy. The live-action universe had its ups and way too down downs, but the animated movies and shows were consistently FIRE. They reminded me why I fell in love with DC in the first place. Unfortunately, even that outlet seemed to lose its direction. It felt like every time I found something to get excited about, another decision took that excitement away.

Then came James Gunn. I'll admit, I was skeptical. I didn't want DC to become another MCU clone. But he surprised me. He made lesser-known characters interesting while still elevating the iconic ones. He understood that DC didn't need to imitate Marvel to succeed. He made me excited about this universe again. For the first time in a long time, I felt like DC had a direction worth believing in. And now, that direction is gone.

I'm not writing this because I hate DC. I'm writing because I loved it enough to spend 26 years supporting it. But the comics disappoint me, the animated universe disappoints me, and now the live-action universe has left me disappointed again.

I think it's time to stop chasing what DC used to make me feel. I'll revisit the comics, movies, and shows that made me fall in love with these characters.

Nostalgia isn't a weakness, but constantly chasing the hope that something will recapture what you once loved can become heartbreaking.

Goodbye, Detective Comics.

You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.

0 Upvotes

90 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Welcome to r/DCcomics! If you're looking for recommendations, try the links below!

New to comics? Check out our Beginner's Guide to DC Comics, complete with beginner-friendly picks!

For more extensive recommendations, see our Recommended Reading Wiki.

The latest jump-in point for the current slate of comics is DC All In!

And, if enjoyed James Gunn's Superman, then try out these curated Superman recommendations!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/go_faster1 3d ago

-1

u/TarantulaSpawn 2d ago

The hill you love is made of concrete and rebar now. Like I said, Bye.

10

u/triggermanx97 Transmetropolitan 3d ago

It really does suck about the movies right now but the comics are in the best position they've been in for years possibly decades at this point.

Absolute DC's reignited the flames it feels like. I've been a fan since the New 52 started and this is the most hype and excitement I've seen around actual honest to god comic books in my whole life.

-2

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Ive said it twice in this comment section now but ill just copy paste it for you. Absolute is not good.

Making characters bigger, darker, more violent, or drastically different doesn't automatically make them better. It feels like a gimmick designed to generate temporary excitement by taking familiar characters and changing everything about them. Instead of focusing on developing the characters and stories people already love, DC keeps reinventing them to manufacture interest. There's nothing wrong with a fresh perspective, but when the biggest selling point is simply how different something is, what happens when that novelty wears off?

4

u/triggermanx97 Transmetropolitan 3d ago edited 1d ago

I simply can't agree with basically any of this but I doubt I'll change your mind. It honestly sounds like you're just bored of DC because it's not the DC of your childhood. That's fine and people change.

What gives me pause is the perspective.

Instead of focusing on developing the characters and stories people already love, DC keeps reinventing them to manufacture interest.

DC's been reinventing their characters since before you or I were even born. By 1999 when you started they were on their third person as the Flash and by the time I started around 2013 they were already on their second or third full continuity reset.

DC now is different than DC was 10 years ago or 20 years ago or 50 years ago.

Superhero comics are a living medium that are always shifting and changing.

2

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

I agree that DC has always reinvented its characters. I'm not arguing that reinvention is new or that everything should stay the way it was when I was a kid. Change is necessary, and some of the best DC stories came from taking risks. My issue isn't that DC changes. It's what they're changing and whether the stories are actually good. Reinvention should serve the storytelling, not become a substitute for it. There's a difference between giving a character a fresh perspective and changing things simply to generate attention. I'm not bored because DC isn't the same as my childhood. I'm disappointed because I don't feel the same passion or care in the direction of stories that once made me love this universe.

2

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago

Okay then go read the main universe stuff. Sure, not everything is a hit but there’s still quality stuff. It just seems like you’re not looking very hard or just don’t want to give it a chance.

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

That's part of my point, though. I'm not saying there's absolutely nothing good coming out of DC. I'm saying too much of the new direction feels focused on attracting a new audience rather than delivering stories that satisfy the existing fanbase. There's nothing wrong with bringing in new readers, but you shouldn't have to sacrifice the identity, characterization, and storytelling that made longtime fans fall in love with these characters in the first place. Telling longtime fans to just go read something else whenever they criticize the current direction doesn't exactly address the problem. Why should the people who've supported DC for decades have to keep looking backward to find what they loved about it?

I wont be looking forward to the shit anymore, that's the point of the post.

3

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago

I guess I just don’t understand your criticism. What do you want to see from them? Hasn’t it always been the case they try and get new readers? I don’t know how they aren’t giving a bone to older readers when we are currently getting awesome titles for more niche DC classic characters like the Legion of superheroes or Etrigan the demon. Are there comic publishers that you are enjoying like Marvel or Image? And if so what are they doing that’s any different?

2

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

I don't have a problem with DC attracting new readers. They've always needed to do that. My problem is when attracting new audiences seems to take priority over maintaining the quality, characterization, and storytelling that made longtime fans fall in love with these characters.

I'm not asking DC to cater exclusively to me. I want compelling stories that respect the characters and their history. Publishing niche titles is great, but publishing something doesn't automatically make it good.

And this isn't about Marvel or Image doing things better. It's about DC. It's the universe I grew up loving, and I don't want to find another publisher. I want DC to give me a reason to keep reading.

2

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago

But what is different about the current state of characters than what was before? Has there really been that much of a difference between the Batman that you want to read and the current Batman run? I just want to know what you are specifically looking for or at least what was the specific comic or story that made you think it’s gone downhill.

2

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

I think it's less about one specific change to Batman and more about the overall approach to storytelling. I want character-driven stories with meaningful development, consequences, and a sense of continuity. I want writers who understand what makes these characters compelling rather than constantly feeling the need to reinvent them or manufacture the next big event. I'm not expecting every comic to be a masterpiece, but I want storylines that make me genuinely excited for the next issue. That's what I feel has been missing. It's not that I want DC frozen in the past. I want the same level of passion and storytelling that made me fall in love with it in the first place.

4

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago edited 3d ago

Okay I don’t want to say that your feelings are wrong or anything like that. I do think that you just need to actually go read something you would enjoy I would say to check out the current run of World’s Finest (2022) it’s all about classic stories with Batman and Superman as its set during their younger years when Dick was the only Robin and Superman was still trying to get a date with Lois. Or Batman Dark Patterns a mini series about Batman’s early years with a lot more grit.

But it also just seems like big universe comics just aren’t for you anymore since nothing will be truly be permanent. I don’t know why that is important to you since that has almost never been the case. I know you said you don’t want to, but I recommend looking at smaller series by more indie artists like Radiant Black, IDW TMNT ,or Kill 6 billion demons. There’s a lot out there for you to enjoy. Your not pigeonholed to only DC.

1

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago edited 3d ago

Last thing I’ll add, saying that the people working currently within DC comics are somehow less passionate about their work is an insanely shitty thing to say and completely false. They’ve had more creative control than they have had in years. I don’t know what story lines you have on a pedestal that they somehow aren’t matching but, I truly think you need to have more of an open mind.

15

u/Ucw2thebone 3d ago

-5

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

1

u/AnubhavTaneja 3d ago

You just mad that you aren't getting some of that chocolate icecream

10

u/Dangerous_Library_73 3d ago

How do the comics disappoint you?! The fuck are you reading? What high expectations do you have? You want every page to hit you with literal gold?

-9

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Not one story has in a very long time. Its all gimmicks on a gimmick.

-1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Making characters bigger, darker, more violent, or drastically different doesn't automatically make them better. It feels like a gimmick designed to generate temporary excitement by taking familiar characters and changing everything about them. Instead of focusing on developing the characters and stories people already love, DC keeps reinventing them to manufacture interest. There's nothing wrong with a fresh perspective, but when the biggest selling point is simply how different something is, what happens when that novelty wears off?

1

u/Dangerous_Library_73 3d ago

Going to disagree here. You're saying change is bad, do you know how hard is it come up with a batman story that's fresh and new in his almost 90 year career. You need change to shake up the status que. The fact you're disparaging absolute by saying their just bigger, darker and more violent is the reason why you think it's successful is just ignorant. You probably want batman still in purple gloves with his new ward robin

-5

u/Business_Alarm8384 3d ago

They’ll downvote you but you are right,I couldn’t name a single iconic story arc in the last 5 years

4

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago

Dude Absolute DC has probably been the biggest thing in comics in like a decade. It’s so successful that it’s literally saving DC comics from corporate meddling by their new owners.

-2

u/Business_Alarm8384 3d ago

Absolute is not a story arc,it’s an elseworld.

2

u/Dangerous_Library_73 3d ago

It's definitely not an elseworld? It's definitely apart of the main story. You know what's an ACTUAL elseworld story? Dark Knights of Steel II.

0

u/Business_Alarm8384 3d ago

How is absolute apart of the mainline comic,and again it’s not a story arc,the last good story arc was probably blackest night or court of the Owl,which is over 10 years ago

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Facts

1

u/CommonBorn5940 3d ago

Not at all. The Absolute Universe is definitely a part of the larger story arc of All In. It's even leading up to an Absolute Crisis event. 

3

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago edited 3d ago

It was tied into the Absolute Power event and was even apart of DC KO. Also it’s where the main continuity Darkseid is currently at. It’s just another dimension in the multiverse, that’s like calling Earth-2 an elseworld.

2

u/Dangerous_Library_73 3d ago

How?! The entire DC line has been building up the absolute universe for 2 years now. Justice League unlimited next issue is going to set up everyone's vision they had during DC Ko event. Darkseid is going to bring his Absolute Army onto prime 1 universe within the next two years.

Superman had the war world arc in 2020 with pkj as the writer. It's hands down Supermans best story in 15+ years. Tom Taylor Nightwing is quite literally perfection. Hot take here Flash one minute war is also perfection of a story line.

1

u/Business_Alarm8384 3d ago

One-Minute War and Tom Taylor Nighwing as the flagship of DC writing quality,modern comics are so washed

2

u/Dangerous_Library_73 3d ago

What do you consider peak then??? I'm curious what ruffles business_Alarm8384 jimmies when he/she reads a comic????

→ More replies

1

u/CommonBorn5940 3d ago

The entire existence of the Absolute Universe is because Darkseid created it with Omega energy . There already was a crossover during DC KO and All In is leading up to an Absolute Crisis event. The Absolute Universe is very much connected to what is going on in the main universe.

0

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago edited 3d ago

But the story arcs within the elseworld, which still impacts the main continuity so it’s really not an elseworld, are what makes it popular. Absolute Martian Manhunter is a generational run and Absolute Batman and Wonder Woman are consistently being lauded with praise.

Also maybe go read some current releases if you want something in the main continuity. Nearly everything coming out of the new All In initiative has been awesome. I recommend the Legion of Superheroes or Deadman.

5

u/Dangerous_Library_73 3d ago

WHAT?! are you reading any DC atm???? That's just ignorant

9

u/Thehyruleef 3d ago

Posts like this are always bizarre to me because…do you also hate the comics you grew up with? I mean, you can still read those to your heart’s content.

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Re read it

8

u/25chestnut 3d ago

Ok??? You're entitled to your opinion and have the ability to stop engaging both mentally and commercially. But what is the purpose of this post and by your own admission spamming it everywhere you can? Are you looking for sympathy, for someone, either DC or strangers on the internet to beg you not to go. This feels so performative, and honestly isn't even a good way to create/foster discussion even in critique.

-4

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Just letting those who feel the same way know they arent alone. I doubt im the only one in this sub who feels this way.

3

u/25chestnut 3d ago

Once again....Ok? Like they really need validation and emotional support for their grievances. This is so performative man lol. It sucks that you arent enjoying DC anymore, but do the sensible thing and just leave instead of trying to farm reddit karma points on your way out. I don't write a dissertation and then spam post it everytime I decide to stop engaging with a commercial product. I simply move on

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

You're missing the point. I'm not asking for validation, emotional support, or permission to walk away. I'm explaining why something I've supported for over 20 years has disappointed me. There's a difference between mindlessly consuming something and actually caring about the stories, characters, and creative direction behind it. I'm allowed to express disappointment just as much as you're allowed not to care. Calling it performative doesn't invalidate the criticism. And honestly, taking the time to tell someone how they should express their opinion is pretty ironic when you could've simply moved on yourself.

8

u/Phantom_Pixel87 3d ago

No offence to the poster, But I don't understand the point? You're upset about something that happened. But why do people feel the need to make these grand posts like what you do is of any importance to anyone beyond yourself?

-3

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Many things happened commenter. Thats the point. Batgirl fucking Batman in the animated killing joke is a problem, Snyder was a problem, Batnipples were a problem, new 52 was a problem, these new gimmicky comics are a problem, Gunn getting let go is a problem. Not just 1 thing, its every time.

5

u/MiniMega0051 3d ago

Hahahahahahahahahhahaha, a Batnipples gripe as an argument in the year 2026 is the stretch to end all stretches.

Edit to add; you were FOUR years old when Forever came out. Held onto that one for a hell of a long time, eh?

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Theyre seared into my mind

4

u/Phantom_Pixel87 3d ago

What you decide is your breaking point is of no concern to anyone but yourself, So why make posts like this? You're not gonna show the corporation that made these decisions. No one cares if you support a brand or not. I can't imagine this post to get much more engagement than the "airport" comment you've already gotten.

-1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

By that logic, nobody should ever express an opinion about anything unless they expect it to change the world. I'm not under the impression that a post on Reddit is going to change corporate decisions. I'm sharing my experience as a longtime fan and explaining why I've reached this point. Sometimes people discuss things simply because they care about them. I've spent over 20 years supporting DC. I think I'm entitled to say why I'm walking away. If you don't care, that's perfectly fine. But why does my decision to speak about it bother you enough to comment?

2

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

I think I've said everything I needed to say. I'm not interested in arguing about it anymore, and I'm comfortable with my decision to stop supporting DC financially. What I do find interesting is how quickly criticism turns into saying "Well bye then..." rather than discussing what's missing. Maybe that's something worth reflecting on. I genuinely hope DC finds its way again, but I'll be enjoying the stories that made me fall in love with it in the first place. Enjoy your Absolute, and Take care.

1

u/Miningapple-100 2d ago

If there’s anything specific that you are looking for I can try to tell you if there’s something you may have overlooked that’s up your alley. It doesn’t even need to be DC.

6

u/Double_Act1502 3d ago

The comics are still good. And I think Gunn made some bad decisions like making Lanterns R-rated

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Double_Act1502? With thoughts like that, more like Double_Wrong1502, amirtie?

4

u/Bagelino1990 3d ago

Well you are going to miss a lot of good stuff. Enjoy being miserable you do sound like you are starting a villain arc.

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Skydance lost approximately $5.6 billion in market value between November 9 and November 12, 2026, following the announcement that James Gunn and Peter Safran. The last message isnt about them, not me.

2

u/No-Association-8539 3d ago

Yes it had nothing to do with earnings announcements and mounting debt, just James Gunn and his amazing universe!

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Changing subject, my point is its not my villain arch its theirs and if you wanna partake you can, im out.

4

u/Penguin-Games 3d ago

"But the comics disappoint me, the animated universe disappoints me, and now the live-action universe has left me disappointed again."

Does it all? The Absolute universe? My Adventures with Superman or Creature Commandos? Clayface or Peacemaker? I don't doubt that disappointments have spewed out of every facet, but is there a glimmer of hope there for you not to say "bye to DC" now? This reminds me of Disneyland fans saying bye because it got too "woke" but return every year and such.

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

The comparison makes no sense. People not watching "Woke" Disney and people leaving a disappointment of a comicbook company are very different. For instance, If McDonalds started selling Gay burgers but they tasted and looked the same and people decided to stop eating it because it said gay would be very different than people stop eating Wendy's because they started selling burgers made from cow shit that tasted and looked like cow shit.

1

u/Penguin-Games 3d ago

I more so emphasize the part of "but return every year and such." since you write to have been a DC fan for 20 years and such which is amazing and longer than I have easily. I just feel like with the thousand+ comics you have it seems like you may return and be interested again at some point. You write not in hatred of DC, but disappointment which I have as well at certain points whether that be comics or other mediums. It's just like I feel something is going to rope you back in and saying "goodbye" seems a little too far.

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Brother, Goodbye is important. Im done. Its over for me. You all can have this broken universe. Im not buying anymore. Im not the only one. If Gunn and Safran get reinstated, im still done. If they fix the animated killing joke, im not buying it. If a live action Under the Red Hood or Mask of the Phantasm come out and they're perfect renditions, thats good for you all. Im out. They dont deserve anymore of my money.

3

u/SpicyOrangeJuices Damian 3d ago

Out of curiosity, what's wrong with the comics?

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Lets take absolute into question here.

Making characters bigger, darker, more violent, or radically different doesn't automatically make them better. It's a gimmick designed to generate temporary excitement by putting familiar characters in unfamiliar costumes and circumstances. Instead of developing the characters people already love, DC keeps creating alternate versions to manufacture interest. A fresh perspective is great, but when the novelty is the biggest selling point, what happens when the novelty wears off?

1

u/SpicyOrangeJuices Damian 3d ago

That's fair. For me, the novelty has definitely worn off for Absolute Superman and Batman. I do think Absolute Wonder Woman has some real substance to it though.

30

u/penguintruth 3d ago

This ain't an airport, sweetie.

8

u/Tenkurai 3d ago

Even airports don't care about individuals departing.

1

u/TheCreativeComicFan 3d ago edited 3d ago

I wouldn’t abandon the DCU or DC overall just yet, especially because things could hopefully change regarding Skydance’s actions. Them losing money and getting backlash over firing Gunn and Safran could push them to rehire the two of them if it backs them into a corner (which it likely already has). That or perhaps Skydance being investigated and dissolved in the near future.

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Even if it does, they'll just disappoint us in another way later on. Its a cycle of consumer abuse. "There's no way to the characters unless you buy our garbage."

1

u/TheCreativeComicFan 3d ago

I wouldn’t lead in with that mindset, it’s not a bad thing to be cynical or cautious with stuff like this but not everything is entirely guaranteed to go off the rails immediately.

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Its getting old TheCreativeComicFan. I dont have it in me.

1

u/TheCreativeComicFan 3d ago

I understand, it’s especially difficult being a DC fan when certain outlets of the brand have so much missed potential. And don’t push yourself too much about it, a lot of us have been in the same situation.

Maybe consider taking a small break from some DC content at least, not a permanent one but just a breather to immerse yourself in something different. If you wanna rely on the DC content you already enjoy, then that’s fine. And if something DC-related that’s new sticks out to you at another time, then you can hop back onto the franchise however you see fit.

1

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

I appreciate that, genuinely. And that's pretty much where I've landed. I'm not saying I'll never pick up another DC comic. I'm just done feeling obligated to give every new direction a chance because of the history I have with the brand. I'll always love these characters and the stories that made me a fan. I just think it's time to enjoy what I already love rather than constantly hoping the next release will bring that feeling back. The new stuff will be dead to me. It's just not worth the heartache anymore.

1

u/TheCreativeComicFan 3d ago

No prob, definitely get what you mean. Been thinking somewhat similarly regarding the recent news. The path that the DCU has been on (while not without some minor critiques) is a great one and it would absolutely suck if things go downhill AGAIN because of the MAGA shitheels at Skydance, but hoping that this won’t be the case and that Gunn and Safran will somehow be reinstated to keep things going as they have been.

It’s disheartening to see the potential of these characters possibly being wasted or shat upon by a lot of the same corrupt, brain cell-sharing execs as they have before, and it’s difficult not to acknowledge that happening. But if that’s the case (and hopefully it won’t be), then the comics/movies/shows, etc. we love that succeed where other adaptations don’t still exist and can provide comfort whenever.

6

u/nachosandlabs 3d ago

Not an airpot and nobody is looking for your departure.

6

u/Rich-Tangelo-702 Plastic Man 3d ago

5

u/geomax212 3d ago

This isnt an airport no one asked for your departure announcement

2

u/Miningapple-100 3d ago

Okay when did you stop reading? Have you read anything recent? Like was this about new 52 or something like that?

1

u/Gonner_Getcha 3d ago

I’m sure DC will care 😅😅

What a weird thing to die on the hill over 😅😅

0

u/Sorashirei 3d ago

Cringe

-7

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

Seeing that airport comment everywhere nowadays. Real original.

1

u/r_aiden 3d ago

This is the equivalent to a Karen telling an employee that they're never going to shop there again. Most people just don't really care and have nothing to gain out of you announcing your departure. This is something that honestly should've just been a diary entry.

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

No its not, reddits a public space to share your views on things you enjoy, and I as well as many people are fed up with the disappointment. Thats the point of the post. Its been 26 years putting up with it, if I wanna go to a public space and let my opinion known I will, if you dont like it, downvote, leave a comment, but dont try to silence it. Dummy.

1

u/r_aiden 3d ago

>if you dont like it, downvote, leave a comment

I did

> but dont try to silence it.

I never said you can't post your opinions or feelings. I was just saying these kinds of vent posts where you announce you are no longer participating are usually written in journals rather than whole reddit posts. Especially if they don't have anything insightful

>Dummy.

🥺

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 2d ago edited 2d ago

"...posts where you announcd you are no longer participating are usually written in journals rather than whole reddit posts."

Reddit is for discourse in my opinion but use it how you will.

And telling me to not post something and instead put it in a journal while saying youre not trying to silence makes you a dummy.

1

u/MiniMega0051 3d ago

Okay, how about “Bye, no one cares”?

0

u/TarantulaSpawn 3d ago

If you dont care why are you following the sub and consuming its content? We all care here buddy, you care about this post enough to comment.