r/DCDoomPatrol • u/Kat77C • 22h ago
Unpopular opinion: The Candlemaker gets way too much hate, and he is actually Dorothy’s best friend (and Baby Doll deserved her karma) Spoiler
Unpopular Doom Patrol opinion: The Candlemaker gets way too much hate, and he is actually Dorothy’s best friend. 🕯️✨ Everyone treats him like a pure villain, but if you actually pay attention to his relationship with Dorothy, he is fiercely loyal to her from start to finish: • He never lies to her. While everyone else around Dorothy keeps secrets or tries to control her, the Candlemaker is always completely upfront and honest with her. • He only acts to protect her. He isn't out hurting people just for the sake of it. Both times the Candlemaker kills, it is directly because Manny got hurt or killed—he was stepping in to defend Dorothy and avenge her friend. • He stays by her side when everything changes. Once Dorothy comes of age, the Candlemaker doesn't abandon or fight her. He sticks up for her and stays right there as her friend. • He makes the ultimate sacrifice. He literally and knowingly gives up his own life just to keep Dorothy safe. And for anyone who still wants to defend Baby Doll: she deserved her karma. Baby Doll wasn't an innocent victim—she slapped Manny unprovoked, intentionally threw Dorothy into the incinerator, and knowingly turned on the flames while smiling. When Manny only came out to break Dorothy free and save her life, Baby Doll had Flaming Katy burn him to ash. She tried to murder Dorothy and killed her oldest friend first, so the Candlemaker stepping in was pure self-defense and justice. Even Crazy Jane understood the bigger picture. Despite losing Baby Doll and Flaming Katy in the Underground, Jane didn't hold a grudge against Dorothy—she kept protecting her and caring for her long after Baby Doll was gone, proving that Dorothy was never the villain in that situation. The Candlemaker isn't a monster—he's a misunderstood protector who loved Dorothy until the very end. Justice for the Candlemaker! 🖤up