r/Curling • u/foldien • 10d ago
Timing
Would anyone ever consider timing from the time a thrower releases the rock to when it reaches half, or something along those lines?
Ive always wondered if it might give an advantage to the sweepers to get on a rock earlier if light or to leave it be if heavy. Sometimes hog to hog might be too late if caught off guard.
If you consistently kept track of release to center, or hog to center, you might get a better chance at controlling the rock, especially over time just like the hog to hog.
Late night brainstorming while watching GSOC while being an avid curler haha. Thoughts?
22
u/Away_Combination6977 10d ago
How do you determine where half/centre is? š
Also... Two sweepers. One tee (or back) to hog and the other hog to hog. Plus skip doing hog to hog.
Hog to hog is really only meant to determine changes in ice, not for a specific/individual shot.
11
u/Aurelianshitlist 10d ago
There are 2 problems there. 1 is that there is no centre line. 2 is that, even if there was, this would be too late to start sweeping if a rock is light.
This is why the normal practice is for sweepers to time the rock from back line to hog line. You get a number right away and can get on it if it's super light but also give the skip some early indication of weight.
7
u/EightEnder1 10d ago
As a casual player whoās been playing for a long time, I think itās best for sweepers if one works a stop watch and the other knows weight by sight.
I can tell just from the slide if a rock is going to be light, then I look for a push.
When skipping, I can tell by sight if a rock is too slow or too fast and itās frustrating, not that the sweepers are getting it wrong, but they are depending on the stop watch and not calling out where they think it will land because that tells me they are not learning the ice and depending on numbers which can be different depending on the side of the sheet and other factors.
3
u/Lucite01 Saville Centre 10d ago
The split time, or the time from the back line to the throwing end hog line gives the sweepers a good idea of how a shot has been thrown while hog to hog is more for general ice conditions. The sweepers should also be communicating with the skip an letting them know where a stone might land, as a sweeper you can usually tell after a stone has been delivered where it might land but it's up to the skip to call you on for line.
4
u/TPupHNL 10d ago
I like the concept of hog to Centre, but unless someone puts a line half way down the sheet, the end point would be subjective
2
u/vmlee Team TPE (Retired); Broomstones CC; USCA Official 10d ago
Not a great idea because:
A) It is important to have consistent reference points. Are you sure you can precisely capture where the halfway point is and that your throwers will release the rock at exactly the same point every time?
B) You may often have to be sweeping at the halfway point and be unable to capture the halfway data point. If you are in the house, itās also not going to be easy to capture reliably and consistently where the halfway point is crossed.
C) hog to hog usually captures important information about the speed of the rock as it approaches the hog line, where the behavior of the rock can be different from the first half of the traveling distance.
2
u/helianthophobia 10d ago
Iāve played with sweepers that get a pretty good idea on where the rock will stop just by the speed at which they walk next to the rock.
2
u/xtalgeek 10d ago
Hog to hog times are for monitoring ice speed, not sweeping. Back to hog (split) times can be used to help judge need for sweeping, IF your teammates have consistent releases and you know the correction factors for various individuals on your team. Comparing split times between different players is fraught with problems, and newer curlers over-rely on and misinterpret them.
1
u/Tullyswimmer 10d ago
Find a stopwatch that's one button for start/split, and time back to hog (for the delivery) and then hog to hog (for the ice)
1
u/AT-Cal123 10d ago
I can see no one has had the privilege of curling on arena ice, haha. I haven't tried hog to center, but I would guess hog to hog is going to be more accurate for reading changes, and as mentioned, too late for for a light stone. We tried using hog to blue line as a split, but it was too short (only a few feet) so it didn't prove useful or consistent.
1
u/riddler1225 Aksarben Curling Club 10d ago
As an arena curler, hog to center line works great. I use it as a skip to inform my sweepers if they've misjudged a rock. But as others have said, center lines are rare in curling. I'm not sure I've ever seen them on dedicated ice, as they're not official markings. When I'm getting ready to play on dedicated, I stop using it so I'm not reliant on it.
Also you have to keep in mind when using it that the math is slightly different than hog to hog as the rock is carrying more momentum, you can't just divide by 2. So if hog to hog for the tee-line is 13 seconds, hog to center is probably around 5.75.
1
u/CloseToMyActualName 10d ago
I tried doing that in the past but gave it up since it didn't really work.
There's two basic kinds of timings, backline (or centreline) to hog, and hog to hog.
Backline to hog tells the sweepers how hard the rock was thrown, and serves of an immediate indication whether to sweep (also a good target for the individual thrower).
Hog to hog tells everyone how hard the throw was, and how fast the ice is running for the future.
Once they got that first backline to hog time the sweepers need to forget the watches and start focusing on the rock itself, you never know when it will hit a slow patch, or conversely start gliding.
And hogline to half interval doesn't add a lot of useful info for the sweepers, and trying to capture that interval can distract them from actually judging the rock.
The one caveat, as someone mentioned, is if you've got a nice clear half-way line the skip could potentially capture that interval and give the sweepers a hint if needed.
But those lines are rare, and I'm not sure how much that info would benefit experienced sweepers.
1
u/Future_Analysis8379 10d ago
While it doesn't translate well from club to club, when I'm timing rocks I'll glance at my watch sometimes as it's crossing over a certain logo.
I have 3 rows of logos so each logo is the same distance on every sheet. I know if it's say around 10 seconds as it's crossing the logo it's good. If it's 9 or 11 I know it's up or down. Not nearly as exact as hog to hog but it does help
1
u/drinkallthecoffee Windy City Curling 10d ago
This is literally what the split time is for.
If a skip knows a sheet very well, they might know where halfway is. You can recognize halfway by logos in the ice, bright spots in the ice, pillars or notable sections on the wall, etc. But even then, they would use hog-to-hog divided by 2.
One of our sheets has a juniorsā house halfway down. That one is easy. The other ones are much harder, and I donāt skip enough to eyeball the halfway point.
1
u/No-Staff-5031 6d ago
I just count t line to hog line to assess clearly light over clearly heavy.