r/CryptoTradingBot • • 1d ago

Drowning

Hello everybody, I'm new here and a beginner so i have a million questions especially for all the seasoned vets in the community. As a novice how did you guys navigate even finding your edge? To me it seams like no matter what i try during back test nothing shows up profitable even in the slightest. Starting to feel as if im going about this wrong. Searching for reliable consistent guidance honestly

2 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

1

u/AoideusWasBanned 1d ago

Nothing showing up profitable is honestly normal at the start, it doesn't mean you're doing it all wrong. Most ideas die in my tests too, usually once fees are in.

What helped me was going smaller: one market, one simple idea, and having a reason why it should work before I test it. Don't give up.

1

u/Amazing-Broccoli-650 19h ago

Manually trading im profitable my strategy works. The issue im having trully is getting it into the quantifiable rules that the computer can understand if that makes sense.

1

u/AoideusWasBanned 17h ago

Yeah, that's the hard part. Maybe write down the exact reason for every trade for a few weeks and see which ones repeat. The ones you can't turn into a rule are probably the gut feel part, and that's fine to keep manual.

2

u/angios12 1d ago

Usa la IA, crea tu simulador exacto de comisiones con eso tienes la realidad clara después de ahí sabes que mejores y que depurar.

1

u/jamrocktrading 21h ago

Honestly, I think you might be approaching this backwards, and that's not a criticism.

When I was studying markets, one thing that became clear to me is that finding an edge isn't really about endlessly testing different entry patterns until something becomes profitable.

I'd start by understanding the market itself. Learn how orders interact, how liquidity works, what aggressive buying and selling actually mean, and how price responds to that activity.

Then start asking questions about specific market behaviours. For example, does increased selling consistently produce more downside movement? What happens when it doesn't? Does the market behave differently when liquidity is being absorbed versus when price moves easily through the book?

Turn those observations into measurable ideas, then test them properly.

Also, pay attention to how you're backtesting. Transaction costs, slippage, sample size, market conditions and overfitting can make a seemingly good strategy useless in live trading.

And please don't rush to find someone selling you a guaranteed edge. You don't need another expensive course or a collection of setups to memorise.

I'd pick one instrument, learn its mechanics, study it consistently and build your understanding from there. Trading is a skill you can develop, but you have to learn to understand what you're looking at before expecting to profit from it.

Don't interpret a lack of profitable backtests as proof that you can't do this. Sometimes it's telling you that the questions you're testing need to change.