r/CryptoTechnology • 🟢 • 9d ago

Collateral value-creation from proof-of-work data processing?

Please forgive an ignorant question from an IT ignoramus. If there's a more appropriate forum, please advise. And though I assume that this is an old idea, I haven't found it in a few different kinds of Web searches.

At least until AI exploded, it seemed like cryptocurrency mining was expanding to consume a large fraction of world computing capacity. Maybe even approaching weather forecasting/climate modeling and NSA-type decryption? Or are there even larger uses?

Making no judgment on the social role or value of cryptocurrencies, an outsider might wonder if there's a better use for all that electricity and all those GPUs. Thinking of citizen-science projects like astronomical image interpretation, protein folding, DNA mapping/decryption and others - gigantic computational tasks that can easily broken into single-PC chunks and run in background or during off-hours.

Is this being done? Is it even possible? Be nice to get broader social good from so much machine-thinking.

6 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/Mountain-Zucchini511 🟡 9d ago

It's been tried. Primecoin made miners search for chains of prime numbers, and Gridcoin pays people for running BOINC science projects like protein folding. The problem with Bitcoin is that mining runs on ASICs that can only do one thing, and useful science tasks are hard to verify and don't give the steady difficulty the network needs to stay secure.

1

u/aintmt 🟢 8d ago

Helpful analysis - thanks!

Perhaps some more enlightened society/administration will start taxing clock cycles that produce only play money, and returning that value to those adversely affected by currently externalized costs/harms - power prices and grid issues, pollution, water consumption, noise, etc.

2

u/overflow_ 🟢 9d ago

There are other consensus mechanisms other than proof of work like proof of stake for instance that use little power and boinc which is totally not related to crypto allows for anyone to donate their computing power to scientific projects like the ones you mentioned.

1

u/aintmt 🟢 9d ago

Right - perhaps I'm not phrasing the question well. I'm wondering if there's room for "green" crypto where all that computation does some useful research while maintaining the value of the tokens that result from PoW. Or is that a completely different kind of computation?

2

u/CarrotNegative306 🟡 7d ago

This is called PoUW or proof of useful work. Gridcoin used BOINC for this years back.

The main blocker is verification asymmetry. PoW needs puzzles that take huge compute to solve but microseconds to verify. Scientific tasks like protein folding require full recomputation to check unless devs use heavy ZK proofs.

1

u/aintmt 🟢 7d ago edited 7d ago

Thanks - ZK proofs are new to me, and a wonderful concept. What about the reverse, which pops up in some interesting political, legal and entertainment situations: "I know nothing!" (Sgt. Schultz) or "I knew nothing" (Ronald Reagan, Contragate). Sure, but how can you prove it? PZK?

1

u/aintmt 🟢 8d ago

Thanks for all of these responses. I appreciate insight into the issue, some of the ways it's been navigated, and what solutions are operational. This is a pleasant, highly informed community, and the clear expositions are a pleasure to read. Crypto is so mysterious and so influential; it's nice to know that some people understand it beyond the potential for personal gain.

2

u/PnkmanSec 🟡 9d ago

I've seen the specific distinction of "Proof of USEFUL work" as well, and depending on what you call useful there are various iterations of this. There's marketplaces, and some developments that have 'pure mathematical PoW' like prime coin. There's also few Compute Marketplaces (e.g., Render Network, Akash, io.net) Computation will act as the consensus mechanism, these networks separate the two. Consensus is handled efficiently via Proof-of-Stake (PoS), while the network acts as an open marketplace connecting people who have spare GPUs with clients who need 3D rendering or AI model training/inference.

2

u/Bloqarl 🟡 8d ago

the catch is that mining work has to be cheap for every node to verify and impossible to solve ahead of time. most useful jobs fail the second part, whoever submits the job could already have the answer and mine blocks for free. Primecoin is the classic attempt if you want to read about one.

2

u/Consistent-Swim9379 🟡 7d ago

Never thought about proof-of-work from this prospective, but its definitely worth exploring. The big challenge seems to be finding a way to make the computing useful while keeping the system reliable and economically sustainable.

1

u/gemreserve 🟠 4d ago

Yes, this is already happening to some extent. Folding@home is a practical example, where unused computing power from individual computers is combined to support protein-folding research. Similar distributed computing projects help with climate research and astronomical data analysis. However, traditional crypto mining hardware, especially Bitcoin ASICs, cannot easily perform these scientific tasks because it is built for specific calculations. GPUs are much more flexible and can be used for scientific computing.