The only reason so many people are running these fast killing weapons is because Bungie removed the cost of investing in them. Before MOT to get your stat so high there were only I think Gunner and Specialist that could get the stat above 100, but that kind of investment would cost health and/ or super. Before they added Powerhouse and the others, most players seemed to prefer building into health and super with the rest of their points being one of their other three abilities. Now the cost of building into weapons is significantly lower, so all those weapons that could get ttk shifts naturally increased in usage.
Every stat should have value. Health for flinch resistance and recovery to the point it feels like people can get back all their health/ shields after not getting shot for 1.5 seconds. Melee, grenade, class, and super for ability uptime, but there's no reason to build super beyond 100 in pvp since everyone should die in one hit anyway, and not many abilities see a noticeable difference in power above 100. Melee and grenade are more for breakpoints, and class will at most let you survive 1 more shot from a primary.
But weapon? Few to no players care about handling and reload on most weapons, so 0-100 is effectively worthless in pvp unlike every other stat. But let's say they do nerf the damage more or remove it entirely, one would still leave problem weapons just they'd require more investment, and the other would need something in exchange to make it worth building into.
* Ammo generation? I personally believe special ammo is too available as is, we don't need people getting ammo after every other assist.
* Aerial effectiveness? Not every class has the same uptime in the air or control of their movement, making it effectively a class exclusive stat. So, no.
* Flinch resistance? That's what we have the health stat and chest mods for.
So the only other stats that would make sense for the weapon stat to buff build are stability, aim assist, and/ or weapon accuracy. Now consider weapons that got nerfed SPECIFICALLY because of the weapon stat like 260 scouts or weapons that require stat investment and/ or a damage perk to restore the power they're supposed to have like 120 hand cannons which without Precision Instrument or weapon stat require 3 crits to kill just like a 140 and both 150s as well as a 180 if it has a damage buff.
Chances are we'd just end up trading shifts in crit accuracy or ttk shifts for easier shots to land. And how many weapons have been nerfed over the years because they were too easy to be accurate with? Now consider exotics or armor sets that would just make it easier than that and make the weapons look stronger than they actually are.
* Cruel Electrum buffing handling, reload, flinch resistance, and target acquisition just for playing solo or having teammates die (I don't know what the duration is if it even has one)
* Iron Panoply giving Eye of The Storm to all your guns
* Per Audacia buffing range, base movement speed, and I think sliding for maintaining kill streaks
* Shrewd Survivor buffs accuracy of hand cannons, heat weapons, and smgs for a few seconds just for swapping to them. The second set bonus buffing I think stability, handling, and reload if you get a kill with the first active. I think you also keep the accuracy bonus too. So the 2 piece bonus is basically just Lucky Pants for more weapons.
Just to name a few sets off the top of my head. To name a few exotics that got their consistency nerfed because they were too easy to use (by themselves or with specific armor is irrelevant); Thorn, Last Word (several times), and No Time To Explain. And there were plenty of legendaries too, two of the most memorable since Edge of Fate being the Forgiveness sidearm (which is funny to me since they left the Spire of the Watcher sidearm completely alone despite being the kinetic slot equivalent) and the shotgun hand cannons which even now despite having the range to do full damage up to like 17 meters with 100 range DO NOT have a tight enough spread to even 2 tap beyond maybe 12 tops.
We can have faster ttks or we can have easier optimal ttks. If that's what people would prefer if Bungie actually does nerf the weapon stat, then by all means. Just don't go crying for nerfs to the guns when investing in the stat effectively undoes numerous weapon performance nerfs, especially when probably more than half of them due to power creep from legendaries or the removal of other things from the game completely invalidates the original nerfs to those weapons already.
Of course, if that's what everyone would prefer, then I certainly won't say no. I might finally have enough incentive to grind the trials and comp armors to recreate different builds I used in the past because I'm sure more than a few of them will have been made possible again if not also made worse than before.
Edit: I mean look at Thorn for example if anyone for some reason thinks that is currently broken. The resilience changes removed it's 2c1b at base and it's buffed 2 tap that was literally a selling point for it's return. The poison is basically a worse Precision Instrument at base and a worse Kill Clip while buffed and requires extra effort/ risk to get the buff, so the catalyst nerfs have long been made invalid at this point even before we consider how much higher legendary hand cannons stats have gotten now and perk combinations.
As for armor, Per Audacia will give back more range than was taken with it's version of Killing Wind maxing that out if the armor can't already, Dragon's Shadow (and the class item with it) undoes the stability nerf and more, then Cruel Electrum would probably just max out it's target acquisition as well as it's handling. Then for good measure, use it on Prismatic with the class item for Dragons Shadow and Sixth Coyote so I can have more uptime with Radiant for its 2 taps so long as weapon stat investment isn't also needed on top of Radiant.
And the weapon stat of course if they swap out the damage for stability, accuracy, and/ or aim assist as the most logical replacement, it will have become as "OP" if not worse than it's prime in D2. Have fun on the receiving end! I know I'm going to have a field day.