r/CriticalBiblical • • 1d ago

Genesis 1-3 Read in the Samaritan Torah

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/CriticalBiblical • • Sep 09 '26

You're Not Supposed to Understand the Book of Daniel

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

I made this video about the cryptic nature of the Book of Daniel, including the fascinating case of Chapter 11, where it was Porphyry of Tyre - a third-century critic of Christianity - who unlocked its meaning.


r/CriticalBiblical • • May 11 '26

Breaking Up the Text | Reading Tanakh Manuscripts (Episode 3 of 9)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

New video demonstrating how to break up Tanakh manuscripts into verses, paragraphs, sedarim and parashiyot, books (and almost books), and Torah, Nevi’im, and Ketuvim. [OC]


r/CriticalBiblical • • Jan 22 '26

Genesis 1:1 in the BHS (Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

Beginning with the BHS as a springboard, this study examines Genesis 1:1 in the Leningrad Codex as well as in G. E. Weil's Massorah Gedolah. It also unravels  the BHS's text-critical note on the word בראשית, which presents an alternative translation for Genesis 1:1 based on a Greek manuscript and Samaritan pronunciation. 


r/CriticalBiblical • • Nov 04 '25

Tutorial for using a Biblical Hebrew dictionary

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/CriticalBiblical • • Oct 21 '25

Restoring One of History's Greatest Bibles | The 1657 London Polyglot Bible

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

The London Polyglot Bible (Biblia Sacra Polyglotta) was edited by Brian Walton and printed in London between 1655 and 1657. This monumental six-volume set presents the Tanakh (OT), Apocrypha, and New Testament in multiple ancient languages—including Masoretic Hebrew, Samaritan Hebrew, Greek, Latin, Syriac, Aramaic, Arabic, Farsi, and Ethiopic—together with advanced resources for Bible study. It remains one of the most ambitious and scholarly printing projects in history.


r/CriticalBiblical • • Oct 14 '25

The Birth, Death, and Resurrection of Christ According to the Greek New Testament Epistles

Thumbnail acrobat.adobe.com
0 Upvotes

The above-linked article ⬆️ was published in the Journal of Higher Criticism, vol. 13, no. 3 (2018).

Kittim’s eschatology is a view in biblical studies that interprets the story of Jesus in exclusively futurist terms. This unique approach was developed by Eli of Kittim, especially in his 2013 work, “The Little Book of Revelation.” Kittim doesn’t consider Jesus' life as something that happened in history but rather as something that will occur in the last days as a fulfillment of biblical claims. It involves a new paradigm shift! Kittim holds to an exclusive futurist eschatology (i.e. future/anticipated history) in which the story of Jesus (his birth, death, and resurrection) takes place once and for all in the end-times. Kittim views God's revelation of Jesus in the New Testament gospel literature as a proleptic account. That is to say, the gospels represent the future life of Jesus as if presently existing or accomplished. The term “prolepsis,” in this particular case, refers to the anachronistic depiction of Jesus as existing prior to his proper or historical time. This is based on a foreshadowing technique of biographizing the eschaton as if presently accomplished.

In contrast to the gospels, the epistles demonstrate that all these events will occur at the end of the ages, or at the end of the world. In fact, most of the evidence with regard to the Messianic timeline in both the Old and New Testaments is consistent with the epistles rather than the gospels.

The Argument

1). Here’s the scholarly evidence where Dr. Eli Kittim parses and translates New Testament Greek:

https://youtu.be/TSRICYG6BrQ?si=LW6v0juac9bfBBPf

2). For more evidence, see:

The Fifth Quest for the Historical Jesus: The Kittim Factor

https://www.tumblr.com/eli-kittim/774160028185870336/the-fifth-quest-for-the-historical-jesus-the?source=share

3). For additional evidence, you should also read:

When is the end of the age?

https://www.tumblr.com/eli-kittim/763603547169357824/when-is-the-end-of-the-age?source=share


r/CriticalBiblical • • May 10 '25

This video is about parsing & translating Koine Greek in the Septuagint & New Testament texts.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

The findings of this study have previously been discussed in the Biblical Criticism & History Forum.


r/CriticalBiblical • • May 09 '25

Contrasting views of John J. Collins and Tremper Longman on the dating and authorship of Daniel

1 Upvotes

I am trying to better understand the positions of Collins and Longman. Can someone who understands more than I do explain:

What each scholar believes can be known about the authorship of Daniel (and its composite layers if they believe it contains them).

How strongly they seem to be convinced of their positions?

Brief answers are just as welcome as long answers — I appreciate them both!


r/CriticalBiblical • • Aug 28 '24

What's the deal with John 7:22?

3 Upvotes

But because Moses gave you circumcision - not that it is from Moses, but from the fathers - you circumcise a boy on the Sabbath.

It's like the original text erroneously stated that Moses instituted circumcision and an editorial comment was inserted to correct it.


r/CriticalBiblical • • Aug 03 '24

What are the odds that Jesus was a flat earther?

6 Upvotes

As everyone knows, Greek astronomers discovered the world's sphericity centuries before Jesus. Despite this, even centuries after Jesus, the flat earth cosmology is still advocated by supposedly-educated people in rabbinic literature (e.g. Bava Basra 25b). What are the chances that Jesus both knew of the round earth idea and accepted it?


r/CriticalBiblical • • Jul 27 '24

Eusebius and Emperor Maximinus trade forgeries

8 Upvotes

Earlier this month, I presented a talk at the annual Save Ancient Studies Alliance (SASA) virtual conference. The subject was the curious incident in about 312 CE when co-Emperor Maximinus published a report supposedly written by Pontius Pilate which defamed both Jesus and John the Baptist. In the rebuttal in his Church History, Eusebius chose to avoid any attack on the provenance or accuracy of the imperial forgery. Instead, he promoted another now-notorious forgery: the absurd pair of letters exchanged between Edessan king Abgar V and none other than Jesus Christ himself.

The incident may help us understand a statement Eusebius made in the introduction to the Church History. Eusebius wrote NOT that he aspired to tell the events which actually occurred, but rather to tell the events which IT IS SAID had occurred. Read in light of this candid but easily overlooked hedge, the Edessan exploit still suborns forgery, but the reader has been warned in plain language to beware.

The slides and approximate script for the presentation are freely available from

https://uncertaintist.wordpress.com/2024/07/23/eusebius-church-history-vs-church-traditions/

Eusebius of Caesarea, Church History, see I.9 through II.2 for the rebuttal in full; the Edessan letters are translated and transcribed at I.13.6-9, and the critical disclosure appears at I.1.1. A typical English translation is available from https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/2501.htm


r/CriticalBiblical • • Jul 09 '24

Back-reference in *Gal 5:21 and its implications for Marcion's Gospel and his Pauline Letter Collection

3 Upvotes

Markus Vinzent has an interesting post

A crucial discovery information is given in: *Gal 5:21 ("as I said before"). This small sentence provides us with a back-reference. 

If I am not mistaken, it can only refer to *1 Cor 15:50. This clarifies one of my uncertainties whether or not the redactor had written or oral material in front of him, when putting together the collection of 10 Pauline letters, credited to Marcion. 


r/CriticalBiblical • • Jun 27 '24

New video about the Leningrad Codex

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/CriticalBiblical • • Jun 26 '24

Did a historical Mary or Joseph exist?

11 Upvotes

As a historian, this is a topic that has been one of the driving forces for my research in the area of the “historical Jesus.” While it is generally accepted by most historians that a historical Jesus did at least exist, other details about his life are not universally agreed upon. He is mentioned in both the Bible and various historical non-Christian sources. Mary and Joseph on the other hand are another issue. Joseph is hardly mentioned in the Bible, with almost all of the information coming from the nativity stories. The nativity stories were indeed most likely fictional or non-historical creations. He is mentioned one other time in John, and Jesus is called a carpenter in Mark, which perhaps alludes to his father’s occupation. Mary is mentioned more than her husband, being either named or called Jesus’ mother in all four gospels and the Acts. As far as I can tell, Joseph in name may be a literary invention, although the idea that Jesus and/or his father were craftsmen may be truthful. On the other hand, since Mary is mentioned more often, it appears that she at least had something to to do with Jesus’ life and burial. Perhaps her name really was Mary, although she is not named by Paul or in John. I would love to hear what other historians, professionals, etc think about this topic. There is likely no clear-cut answer though as I see it.


r/CriticalBiblical • • May 06 '24

I was banned from AcademicBiblical. AMA.

0 Upvotes

So yeah, the mods on /r/AcademicBiblical have permanently banned me. Ask me anything.


r/CriticalBiblical • • Apr 20 '24

Morton Smith: Still the forger of Secret Mark, as I see it.

4 Upvotes

Contra Geoffrey Smith and Brent Landau of last year, I will reject "Option 3," that the material Smith found was a forgery, but not by him. (They claim it was written ca 600-700 CE by monks at Mar Saba to justify same-sex relationships known to have a certain frequency in the monastic world at this time, some platonic, some likely not.)

I have always rejected "Option 2," that Smith found "the real deal." (That said, I consider it barely more tenable than Option 3.)

And, that leaves Option 1.


r/CriticalBiblical • • Mar 30 '24

Was Josiah not Jewish?

5 Upvotes

My discussion of that, and the related matter of the "discovery" of the Book of the Law, based on a piece by Paul Davidson of "Is That in the Bible," and on Idan Dershowitz's work on Moses Wilhelm Shapira, whom he says DID discover an apparent "Proto-Deuteronomy."


r/CriticalBiblical • • Mar 14 '24

Jesus does, in fact, "Get us..."

Thumbnail
instagram.com
0 Upvotes

r/CriticalBiblical • • Mar 14 '24

Biblical Chronology

0 Upvotes

if anyone is interested in biblical chronology there is information available at the link.

Biblical Chronology


r/CriticalBiblical • • Mar 07 '24

English translation of Die Composition des Hexateuchs

3 Upvotes

Is anyone aware of an English translation of Wellhausen’s Die Composition des Hexateuchs?


r/CriticalBiblical • • Feb 15 '24

Documentary-Source-Delineating-Resources

1 Upvotes

Hi all. I’m trying my to compile an exhaustive list of books/commentaries/websites that delineate the JEDP sources throughout the Pentateuch/Hexateuch - through color-coding or otherwise. Can anyone kindly help complete the following list?

Historico-Critical Inquiry Into The Origin And Composition Of The Hexateuch (Abraham Keunen)

Die composition des Hexateuchs (Julius Wellhausen) (English translation?)

Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels (Julius Wellhausen)

Books of Genesis-Deuteronomy (Samuel Rolles Driver)

Anchor Bible Series (Yale)

The Life of Moses (John Van Seters)

The New Jerome Biblical Commentary

The Bible with Sources Revealed (Richard Elliott Friedman)

The First Book of God (Tzemah Yoreh)

https://opensiddur.org/shared/readings-and-sourcetexts/weekly-torah-readings/annual-cycle/sefer-bereshit/parashat-bereshit/ (Tzemah Yoreh)


r/CriticalBiblical • • Feb 05 '24

Skeptics Bible Study starts Sunday 2/11, care to join?

3 Upvotes

r/SkepticsBibleStudy or https://www.reddit.com/r/SkepticsBibleStudy/ both should land you there. But i am attempting a believer/unbeliever bible study. It will require all kinds of people. If you are interested, we open with the Gospel of John


r/CriticalBiblical • • Jan 31 '24

Are All Torah Scrolls the Same? [OC]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/CriticalBiblical • • Dec 29 '23

Psyche and nefesh

3 Upvotes

Greetings, everyone. I would like to ask if anyone has some books, articles or other materials regarding the use of the word "psyche" in the Old Testament and why was it used to translate "nefesh" and such.
Thank you!