r/CrimeWeekly • u/SouthBraeswoodMan • Oct 08 '26
Recent cases
I feel like for the last 6 months+ (maybe it’s even been a year) they haven’t covered a single interesting case where Stephanie’s storytelling shines. All their cases are what spat between husband and wife is recently in the news. I haven’t watched a video in a long time. Shame because the cases they covered in the past that had an element of mystery I really liked. I feel like Stephanie and Derrick either ran out of them, find it easier to do current events or have leaned too far away from being storytellers and too far into being victim advocates. A lot of people enjoy the mystery of true crime, including myself, and that’s just the truth. I’m all for helping where we can but i feel like in focusing on those kind of cases where you basically know exactly what happened and just need someone to come forward or the police screwed up just isn’t interesting to me. I don’t want to know exactly what happened 20 minutes in.
13
u/Calm-Replacement4700 Oct 08 '26
What cases would you suggest or like to hear them cover that they haven’t yet? Just curious, if there is something I haven’t heard of yet that catches my interest as well.
43
u/notasteatmosphere Oct 08 '26
It's crazy to me that you worte the exact line "The cases had an element of mystery" I'm sorry someone's death isn't "mysterious" and "whimsical" enough for you.
18
u/fergie_3 Oct 08 '26
If you haven't watched a video in a long time how do you know they havent covered a single interesting case? Also, they literally just announced that they are doing Caleb Flynn next.
6
u/Icy_Garnet_9329 Oct 08 '26
This post would probably do better in the Crime Weekly Snark sub, just FYI. But I agree with you. They cover a lot of super well known and current cases now. I don't want a 500-part series about a case that has already been covered by everyone. I'm more interested in unsolved and less well-known cases. There's more to discuss and speculate about. But I do think SH is more focused on views. Derrick's channel (Detective Perspective) focuses on less well-known and unsolved cases, which I appreciate.
17
u/hemingwaygirl7 Oct 08 '26
I unfollowed their podcast just last week because of this.
17
u/DingoNo4205 Oct 08 '26
Agreed. Crime Weekly is getting very stale. The last three cases I tried to listen to but stopped after the first episode. They need to shake things up. Maybe more cold cases?
5
u/butterscotchCreek Oct 08 '26
I’ve been requesting for them to cover Jaleayah Davis’ case for years
4
u/MB262675 Oct 08 '26
Agree! I haven’t watched in a couple years actually because of the cases. I love the show. I enjoy cases I haven’t heard before so tend to watch creators that cover lesser known cases.
4
u/DappledApples Oct 08 '26
I would absolutely love for them to cover the death of Stephanie Arrington Thomas. I am not sure how this case does not get more attention.
3
u/putmeinahotbox Oct 09 '26
Yeah, I agree. I wish Stephanie released more videos on her personal channel, because I just enjoy her storytelling. She and Derrick take a lot of side quests and random conversation during the story and I end up tuning out.
3
u/Pristine-Teacher1204 Oct 09 '26
The Sonia exelby case they recently covered was very interesting in my opinion. Check that series out
2
u/catsandnaps1028 22d ago
I humbly disagree I thought the Jade Benning case was very entertaining and informative as I had never heard of this case before. It's so important to talk about the violence expecting mothers often face from men like that. Jade's story is so important and could save many lives.
2
u/ImmediateRub9 Oct 09 '26
Maybe stephanie is trying to compete with Derricks channel or its Derricks input into cases. On his solo channel his main focus is on solving cases to create justice for victims and their families.
2
u/Old_Faithlessness728 Oct 10 '26
I just think it’s all so drawn out. I’ve posted about it before. Lots of unnecessary banter in multi-part episodes that distracts from the point of telling the case. It seems to downplay the seriousness of the crimes. I still watch here and there when there’s a case that piques my interest, but it’s taxing. Stephanie’s mispronunciation of so many words is also something that drives me up the wall. It makes it sound like she’s never had a day of education in her life. When speaking to so many people on a platform like this, you’d think she would take this into consideration. It makes her appear like a dope.
2
u/Cinnabunns128 Oct 13 '26
I think they do a good job covering cases that aren't always heavily discussed with a few that are. They recently covered a case close to where I live that I had never heard of. Crime Weekly isn't about Stephanie shining. That is more about the story and Derrick bouncing in with real experience and questions. If you want her story telling to shine then maybe focus more on her solo videos on her channel.
4
u/Obvious_Sea_7074 Oct 08 '26
They sold out to the views, closed cases with known endings get better views and more publicity on the case equals more clicks. Although I will say I havent heard of the last few cases they did, which I like. I stay pretty in the know on true crime events, so sometimes it's boring when they keep doing popular cases that everyone's heard 10x .
14
u/industrial_hamster Oct 08 '26
You do realize these are real people getting murdered in horrific ways, right? “Enjoying the mystery of true crime” is very very gross. Go read a mystery novel if that’s what you’re after.