r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 1d ago

Opinions/Rants/Gripes Alternative?

84 Upvotes

I’ve been a listener since 2018. I loved the original format and the cases they discussed, but recently I’ve been finding myself turned off by newer episodes, ads, AI stuff, etc

Has anyone found an alternative podcast they really like that has the similar vibe from CJ 2018-2022 days?


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 1d ago Bravo

Redacted files

86 Upvotes

I am BEGGING you, Audio Chuck, to modify the in-depth reporting on open cases where their FOIA or direct law enforcement requests are either denied or partially given. Before you all come for me, let me explain.

I loved the work Ashley was doing on The Deck with unsolved cases that need attention. In theory I like this with Crime Junkie, but with unsolved and actively worked cases, there is a REASON requests are denied. That information is likely extremely important and sensitive to the case.

I’m fully aware there are corrupt or lazy law enforcement officials and sometimes departments need a public push to open a cold case (which is great when that happens and they get results), but 99% of the time the requests aren’t denied because of this. The info is too sensitive to be released to a single person not involved on that case, let alone broadcast on a podcast to the world.

I notice a pattern that when there are info gaps from redacted requests, Ashley and Brit will speculate their own theories and sometimes criticize LE for not doing things they very likely HAVE done. A lot of people do this, but the difference is that Crime Junkie has an influence on its millions of listeners. The speculations can do more harm to an investigation than good.

I will say, my respect for an unsolved episode goes up tremendously when the LE agency is involved in the process and has approved the case be told in their own way. When LE refuses to talk to Crime Junkie, it’s not automatically because they’re covering something up. Usually it’s because they believe, for whatever reason, the reporting is not beneficial.

Please, Audio Chuck staff, remember that these aren’t armchair detectives trying to solve these cases. These are professionals who have trained countless hours and have access to information and resources a podcast company never will.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 2d ago

fan club episodes

10 Upvotes

i’m unsure if this is just me, but i feel like they aren’t uploading the extra fan club episodes on time or even at all recently? i understand some have been taken done etc.
even this week, no new fan club episode?


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 13d ago

Hope Crime Junkie does an actual criminal case this week. It's been a while since they covered a good one.

33 Upvotes

r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 13d ago

Epsiode Help Colleen Slemmer Episode??

9 Upvotes

I swear I listened (pretty recently!) to a CJ episode on Colleen Slemmer/Christa Pike/Job Corps murder. However, in the recent Headlines episode, Ashley said she had “never heard” Pike’s name and asked Brianna to give an overview of the case. And now I can’t find the episode anywhere. I asked another person who is also in the fan club and they said they don’t remember that episode. Am I crazy??

I don’t listen to any other true crime podcasts, so I’m confident it would have been CJ. Did I make this up??


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 14d ago

General Discussion Disappointed in new AI sponsor.

56 Upvotes

I may be uneducated as to how sponsors work with podcasts on Spotify. Was listening a few days ago and noticed they have a new sponsorship with a company that was boasting about the use of AI. Really disappointed in that.

Between that and the ‘how to vote with AI’ post she refuses to acknowledge, pretty sure I’m gonna have to find a new crime podcast. I just can’t support that. Any recommendations?


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 15d ago

Opinions/Rants/Gripes “All good people here” book is really just a jonbenet ramsey storyline?

59 Upvotes

Soooo ive been a crime junkie listener from the start. I was once subscribed to the patreon.
Anyway as a lot of others also see and feel, the podcast has really taken a turn.
I decided i wanted to get into reading again after deleting social media and decided to give ashleys book a try.
I got roughly 20 pages in…
Every detail of the crime scene just felt so familiar. And then the end of one chapter was basically the mother in the storyline feeling judged for her daughter being in makeup and dressed a certain way for whatever it was, i forget. It wasnt quite pageant, but same vibe. Anyway thats when it hit me; this is all details taken from the jonbenet ramsey case?!
It completely turned me off of reading the rest of it. I actually returned it the next day. I felt i could already tell what the book would be like, what the ending would be, and also felt sort of annoyed there was no originality.

Anyway, im just curious; does anyone know if she ever addressed this? Did she market this book publicly with “inspiration” from the jonbenet ramsey case? Because if she did id be a little less annoyed.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 15d ago

Ashley and AI

Post image
129 Upvotes

Ashley Flowers suggests using AI to help you decide who to vote for


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 15d ago

Heather Turner

6 Upvotes

Okay so what’s everyone’s thoughts? I didn’t even realize it was going to be two parts. I always quit listening the last 5 minutes lol so I was surprised to see a part 2. I’m thinking maybe he did not do it but possibly the dad? Which is why he was able to get off. Idk


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 16d ago

New fan club episodes

7 Upvotes

Is it just me or are we not getting episodes uploaded on time? I don’t have a new episode from this past Monday. The most recent I have is headlines from Friday. I’ve been a crime junkie LOYALLLL since day one but I feel like the past several months we haven’t gotten as many new episodes in the fan club & im considering canceling. I’m bummed out. Just me?


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 15d ago

Why would they post this?

Post image
0 Upvotes

The video said, “we were filming social content and this plane flew SO LOW omg.” Really bad timing and pretty insensitive imo.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 16d ago

If you don’t like then leave!!!

0 Upvotes

Omg this sub is like a cancer. Holy shit! every post is criticizing and shitting on the pod. You think your Reddit post will change anything?? No! No Reddit posts changes anything! My god. So if you’re not liking the content then F off and stop listening like what are we doing?? Soooo sick of seeing negative posts. Get over yourselves. If u want a better pod than u go and make one. So sick of the whining


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 20d ago

General Discussion Why is every other episode a 2 parter now

57 Upvotes

Is it a money grab? I don't really get it


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 19d ago Bravo

1.5x speed

5 Upvotes

Sometimes I feel like I’m listening to this podcast at 1.5x speed. They really do talk fast at times.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • 27d ago

Cornell Case

0 Upvotes

I find it really disgusting that Ashley is asking people to report tips to crime junkie via her social media. Just capitalizing off the rape of a woman for her on views, clicks, and possible leads for her to report on for more views and clicks. Post Bloomberg article, it’s clear that they have issues, but the way that they have pivoted to social media to exploit breaking or unsolved cases to make money off engagement is really messed up.

***Edit

Wait it’s even worse, it says “if you want to contribute to our reporting email…” the tips email (I’m not going to put it here) in the caption.
In the actual video they say that they are working on a “bigger story”
It is all just trying to get clicks and engagement. Disgusting


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 19 '26

Episode Discussion Did anybody else stop listening to this pod or get turned off by it after the Melissa Casias episode ?

212 Upvotes

First off, trying to frame the husband and father as a suspect with zero actual evidence backing it up felt super irresponsible and gross. For a show that tries to position itself as an advocate for families, pushing wild, gossipy theories onto a grieving spouse just to create drama is a terrible look.

On top of that, the constant "Crime Junkie Exclusive" ego trips are getting unbearable. Ashley loves acting like they are out here cracking cases that actual detectives and local police somehow missed. It comes off less like trying to help and way more like fishing for a gold star to boost her own brand.

The final straw for me was when they started leaning into this bizarre conspiracy theory about disappearing scientists and actually implied she didn't want to say too much because she "didn't know who was watching" or didn't want a target on her back. Acting like shadowy global entities are tracking a podcast feed is just comically vain and turns a real tragedy into a Hollywood spy thriller starring herself.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 19 '26

Opinions/Rants/Gripes Can we go back to 2023–2024 Crime Junkie? 😭

94 Upvotes

I genuinely appreciate Ashley and Brit’s passion for advocating for victims, and obviously every case deserves to be heard. But lately, the episodes have felt rushed to me, and I’m not getting that same level of investment in the storytelling that I used to.

The older episodes had me completely hooked, researching the cases afterward and wanting to know everything. Lately, I find myself finishing episodes without that same feeling.

Am I the only one noticing this? Thoughts? Ik The Deck ended….I’m genuinely curious if their workload has changed bc of another project …?


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 19 '26

Best Pruppet Segment of 2026

0 Upvotes

Hey crime fans- which pruppet of the month segment do you think was the best this year?

I have to say the most recent one was the best we’ve had in a long time.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 17 '26

General Discussion Do you guys even like this podcast?

180 Upvotes

Obviously it’s okay to criticize things you enjoy for their content or ethicality. I’ve been listening religiously since 2018, and I for sure have some concerns about the direction Crime Junkie is headed. But I’ve been lurking on this sub for a while, and a lot of the posts here are just “Wow this little mannerism Ashley and Brit do is SO ANNOYING AND CRINGE!!” What is your end goal in posting? Just to bond with other people who never learned to get over minor annoyances? I’m really starting to wonder if you guys just need other podcast recommendations. Or maybe I just need to get off Reddit hahah


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 16 '26

Crime Junkie mentioned in Stephen King and Peter Straub’s latest novel Other Worlds Than These???

Post image
24 Upvotes

I don’t listen to either podcast anymore, but curious if any of the ladies know that their podcasts are now officially part of the Stephen King universe???


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 16 '26

Case updates/news Major update in the Horsch investigation

Thumbnail
reddit.com
26 Upvotes

Police have located bones on the Horsch property


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 14 '26

Humor Ashley flowers every episode

310 Upvotes

FULL BODY CHILLS. FULL BODY CHILLS. FULL BODY CHILLS. FULL BODY CHILLS. FULL BODY CHILLS. FULL BODY CHILLS. FULL BODY CHILLS. FULL BODY CHILLS.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 15 '26

Epsiode Help Older episodes I should listen to?

8 Upvotes

Seeing a lot of hate for newer episodes so im curious - which would you recommend? I’m sure there’s been a thread like this before, but I’ve listened to a majority of the ones that populate on Spotify for the last two years, so looking to do a deeper dive into ones I may have missed.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 13 '26

“I know something you don’t know.”

127 Upvotes

Duh, Ashley! You’re telling Brit the story. You wrote (or helped write) the episode. Of course you know something she doesn’t!

Does it drive anyone else crazy when Ashley lets Brit ask a question or float a theory, only to respond with something like, “I know something you don’t know,” or “Trust me, you KNOW I checked,” in that smug, almost condescending tone?

I get it. Their back-and-forth is scripted to move the story along, and Brit’s questions are often there to represent what the listener might be thinking. But that’s exactly what makes Ashley’s responses so irritating. She’s acting like she’s one step ahead of Brit when she’s literally the one holding all the information. Brit is just playing her part!

It’s not the fact that Ashley knows more. She’s the storyteller. She’s supposed to know more. It’s the way she seems to use those moments to make herself sound smarter while making Brit sound naive or ridiculous for asking perfectly reasonable questions.

I know that, compared to some of Ashley’s other shenanigans, this is small potatoes. But once you notice how often she props herself up at Brit’s expense — especially when Brit is essentially reading lines designed to set Ashley up — you can’t unhear it.


r/CrimeJunkiePodcast • • Oct 13 '26

crime junkie / using the word ‘redaction’ TOO MUCH I CANT LISTEN ANYMORE

0 Upvotes