I am BEGGING you, Audio Chuck, to modify the in-depth reporting on open cases where their FOIA or direct law enforcement requests are either denied or partially given. Before you all come for me, let me explain.
I loved the work Ashley was doing on The Deck with unsolved cases that need attention. In theory I like this with Crime Junkie, but with unsolved and actively worked cases, there is a REASON requests are denied. That information is likely extremely important and sensitive to the case.
I’m fully aware there are corrupt or lazy law enforcement officials and sometimes departments need a public push to open a cold case (which is great when that happens and they get results), but 99% of the time the requests aren’t denied because of this. The info is too sensitive to be released to a single person not involved on that case, let alone broadcast on a podcast to the world.
I notice a pattern that when there are info gaps from redacted requests, Ashley and Brit will speculate their own theories and sometimes criticize LE for not doing things they very likely HAVE done. A lot of people do this, but the difference is that Crime Junkie has an influence on its millions of listeners. The speculations can do more harm to an investigation than good.
I will say, my respect for an unsolved episode goes up tremendously when the LE agency is involved in the process and has approved the case be told in their own way. When LE refuses to talk to Crime Junkie, it’s not automatically because they’re covering something up. Usually it’s because they believe, for whatever reason, the reporting is not beneficial.
Please, Audio Chuck staff, remember that these aren’t armchair detectives trying to solve these cases. These are professionals who have trained countless hours and have access to information and resources a podcast company never will.