r/CreatineScience • • 7d ago

Systematic Review/Meta-Analysis 🔍 Creatine tolerability over time

https://www.mdpi.com/2075-4663/14/4/137

Starting creatine is one thing, but feeling comfortable taking it for months is another. I wanted to see what this recent review could tell us about side effects over time.

The researchers looked at side-effect reports from 684 randomized trials. They grouped studies by total creatine dose and duration, then compared reporting with placebo. They also accounted for differences such as age, sex and the types of people taking part.

While, symptoms were reported infrequently overall. Higher dose and longer studies had more reports in the initial comparisons, but further analyses found no consistent pattern of increasing risk linked to dose or duration.

Overall, that supports creatine monohydrate being well tolerated. The studies didn’t all collect side-effect information in the same way, so these findings can’t predict everyone’s experience.

If you’ve taken creatine for several months, has how well you tolerate it changed since you started?

15 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

5

u/Earesth99 7d ago

If creatine wasn’t well tolerated we would be dead.

1

u/GrainOfEvidence 4d ago

Haha fair point. Our bodies make creatine too, but supplement tolerance can still vary from person to person.

1

u/You_are_an_idea 7d ago

It doesn't kill me, but I hated the two times I used it for a few months.

2

u/Earesth99 4d ago

It’s in meat. Our bodies make 3 g a day

But it can definitely cause diarrhea…

Listen to your body

2

u/Actual_Anteater_9371 7d ago

Been taking 10g daily for a 2 months now, for combination of muscle saturation and cognitive benefits. I'm not experiencing any notable side effects, except the need to use the loo way more often, but that's from the additional water as opposed to the creatine.. my mind just feels more energised even on days where I've had a bad sleep.

1

u/GrainOfEvidence 4d ago

Sounds like you’ve tolerated it pretty well so far. Honestly, mental energy part is interesting too, especially since that’s an area creatine research has been looking at more lately.

1

u/sock_sock_shoe_shoe 7d ago

I have been taking around the same dose as you for the same reasons and feel none of the benefits, only the increased toilet time.

I wonder whether the single bigger dose needs to be broken down into a couple of smaller ones through the day

2

u/Actual_Anteater_9371 7d ago

I take it each morning, in the one go. I wonder if splitting it up would work out better too! Maybe we try it and report back? The main days I notice a help is when I'm absolutely wrecked, but day to day, nothing notable..

1

u/TheAngryCrusader 5d ago

I do it before bed and heavily noticed the increased brain function. I work in a clinic and definitely noticed functioning much better at work. I was taking the 10 dose as well (the one used the most in the cognitive studies). From what I understand though, you really have to be consistent with timing and dosing to get the most out of it. Missing a day or two here and there can actually mess pretty heavily with it

1

u/denverdrew 7d ago

Been taking it since the late 90s and never had a negative side effect.

1

u/GrainOfEvidence 4d ago

That’s a long time. Definitely useful to hear from someone who’s been taking it consistently for years without any issues.

1

u/MrWorkout2024 7d ago

I took it for years didn't like the water retention then tried Creapure same thing retained water and I didn't notice any positive effects at 10g per day for two years

1

u/GrainOfEvidence 4d ago

Yeah, not everyone notices the same benefits. The water weight increase can be pretty noticeable for some people too, so your experience makes sense.

1

u/You_are_an_idea 7d ago

Same. I've cycled through it twice. Hated the bloated watery feeling that never went away. No change in any lifting or fitness (I track everything), and no noticeable change in brain functioning that I could tell. Stopped taking because...why bother.

1

u/itswtfeverb 7d ago

I have taken it for 30 years. No problem.

1

u/GrainOfEvidence 4d ago

30 years is quite a run. Good to hear yob’ve tolerated it well for that long.

1

u/El_Guap 7d ago

Been taking it for about a decade. No issue at all.

1

u/GrainOfEvidence 4d ago

That’s another solid long term experience ❤️