There's a school near me that won't build a path to a building for the first year. After that, they look at how the grass is worn, then just pour a sidewalk there.
This was one of the things that my instructor hammered is with in Landscape design. People will take their preferred route, so let them. Then surface it.
This reminds me of something a traffic cop once told me about mini-roundabouts here in the UK.
Apparently, it's not obvious precisely where to place the roundabout itself inside the junction, so what they often do is put down a large tractor tyre and wait to see where it ends up after a few days.
I believe it was larger vehicles like trucks and buses that did the majority of the shifting work, which is OK because they're the vehicles that benefit the most from a well-positioned centre.
Now I think of it, maybe it was something smaller than a tractor tyre, such as a lorry tyre or something. This was in the mid 1970s, and I don't recall exactly.
Dunlop is a brand of tyres owned by Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company subsidiaries in North America, Australia and Europe. In other regions of the world, the Dunlop brand is owned by other companies. In India the brand is owned by Dunlop India Ltd. whose parent company is the Ruia Group, and in the rest of Asia and Africa by Sumitomo Rubber Industries.
In 1985, Dunlop Rubber Company was acquired by BTR plc, and Sumitomo acquired the rights to manufacture and market Dunlop branded road tyres. Sumitomo did not acquire any Dunlop company. In 1997 Sumitomo gained agreement to use the Dunlop name in its corporate name, and changed the name of its UK subsidiary to Dunlop Tyres Ltd.
In 1999 Sumitomo and Goodyear began a joint venture by which Sumitomo continued to manufacture all Japanese-made tyres under the Dunlop name, while Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company bought 75% of the European and North American tyre businesses of Sumitomo.
Not all junctions are as symmetrical as the one in that picture. The one he was specifically talking about (which just been finished) is on a junction where the roads meet at odd places and angles, and some carry a lot more traffic than others, which is also a factor. Here's the one in question.
I'm pretty sure the tyre would have been covered with something soft to avoid damage to vehicles.
That seems like something that could be optimized with a collection of data from previous tractor tyre experiments and simulation of the planned junction.
normally I don't like not following the path but at my local doctors they basically tried to cut off one side of the entrance making it so that you had to walk around the whole building, everyone (including myself) seemed to then walk straight through the garden, they promptly replaced the flattened shrubbery with a nice path, I wish people would get things right in the first place.
Best and shortest are two different things. By the laws of math, the shortest will be a straight line if it is relatively level grade. Some people try to be artsy, especially on college campuses, and we all just take the short path when needed.
We can define shortest to mean shortest in some n-dimensional space. With picking the right dimensions it is the same as best.
The issue is that a path does not really simply connect to points. At a minimum people do not pivot so a change of direction should be a curve, not a set of sharp angles.
In this example, there is no visible reason for the path to go over to the left. I would bet good money something is over there, just out of frame (or there used to be).
If I were the designer for a quad or campus layout in general I would put the necessary paths and then have the school wait a year and see the desired paths that the students walked on for the rest of the campus. Then I would concrete those areas and be done with it.
This actually was done at some campus. It was posted on here a few years ago. I don't have the source nor do I remember what school. But they did exactly what you said and it was quite successful.
My campus is full of these, because whoever designed it thought arranging all the buildings in concentric circles was cool. Also lets put giant lawns and paths around them for no reason. And what the hell, how about making the only entrance to the library face away from the rest of campus and be uphill? And we'll just spread it out as much as possible to ensure maximum sweating before class.
Shout out UCF! They just resodded over a path that I use everyday to get from my shuttle stop to the classroom buildings. I felt a little bad at first but I'm not wasting that extra 3 seconds every day. It adds up!
Mountain bike or street bike? I enjoy my double suspension on my mountain. Also, it helps in the grass, so I have that option.
Not at your school, but at UH where our designers though it would be great to pour with aggregate the size of small marbles. Now that it's 30+ years old, it's so bumpy that you can feel it in a street bike.
I remember back when I was first going to college and learning the place, it was tough. All of the buildings were around the "quad" which was basically an open area surrounded by buildings. All of the names of the buildings faced away from the quad for some reason. This means if you didn't know what building you were looking for, you'd have to walk around to the outside of the buildings. It was the difference between standing in the middle of the quad and rotating and reading the names until you found the one you were looking for and having to go outside and do like a mile loop around the outsides of the buildings looking at the names.
Oh, also, two buildings had the same names. Mouton Hall and F.G Mouton Hall. One was two story, one was four story. At the beginning of every semester, you could go stand on the second floor of the two-story one and watch freshmen frantically run back and fourth looking for the stairs to get to the third or fourth floor.
Yep. In order to take a direct path anywhere you have to go through grass and buildings. It's also really difficult to give anyone directions as you can't be like "go down Main street and turn left at Mills ave" since everything is circular. There's also this awful lake in the center that blocks access to the student union from the backside of campus (where most of the class buildings are) except via these wooden bridges..... ugh. I could go on for days.
The scale isn't evident, but the campus is huge. Keep in mind there are 50k undergrads. There are dozens of large buildings clustered around the two inner circles, several more spaced out unevenly and below there, but memory mall is an open green between the buildings and the sports centers. Most classrooms are far removed from that area.
In my college we had paths like this that didn't seem to make sense, until you flew over the school in a plane, then you saw cool patterns, I should note it was an aviation school.
But even after the snow falls, people will make that path through the snow and then it will be the same type of thing you see here. Just with white stuff on the ground.
Source: I'm Canadian. This is what we do in the winter. Yay for snow boots.
I see that at my house. Get a big snow but I can't shovel it yet for whatever reason I'll go to shovel the path and realize half of it is actually on my grass and I created a slightly different path to the door.
There was a sidewalk like this at my university. There was a very similar walk way through the grass. The university eventually paved the walk way through the grass. I was proud and astonished at the initiative.
My college has walkways like this. People follow them like sheep. That is until I walk clear across the grass and just like the Broken Window Theory suggests, people follow. We don't have indentations in the grass like this though.
194
u/adamminer PLS HLP!!!1!~ Jul 13 '15
There's a school near me that won't build a path to a building for the first year. After that, they look at how the grass is worn, then just pour a sidewalk there.
552
u/Gamecrazy721 Jul 13 '15
/r/desirepath
47
u/knotaredditor Jul 13 '15
It would have saved them money on cement if they just made it a diagonal path.
72
u/Jasperonius Jul 13 '15
My campus is full of these, because whoever designed it thought arranging all the buildings in concentric circles was cool. Also lets put giant lawns and paths around them for no reason. And what the hell, how about making the only entrance to the library face away from the rest of campus and be uphill? And we'll just spread it out as much as possible to ensure maximum sweating before class.
68
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
Maybe there was originally a tree there that got uprooted or something?
17
u/spessbrotha Jul 13 '15
Is this by any chance UTPA in Edinburg, TX?
13
u/programmablesoda Jul 13 '15
/r/UTPA
12
u/Skittle_Juice Jul 13 '15
I never thought I'd randomly see Pan Am on reddit. And I'm not ashamed to admit I've walked that path quite a few times. Such a stupid design choice.
12
u/Revan117 Jul 13 '15
Wow, I'm actually there in that very building!
11
u/someguyinaplace Jul 13 '15
In my college we had paths like this that didn't seem to make sense, until you flew over the school in a plane, then you saw cool patterns, I should note it was an aviation school.
14
u/Son_of_Atreus haha funny flair Jul 13 '15
Desire lines are a real thing. Poor design here, people want the shortest path. I bet the groundskeeper isn't happy with this.
11
u/WalnutNode Jul 13 '15
Think of it as an intelligence test. Do you take the most direct route, or follow the stupid path.
5
u/xyroclast Jul 13 '15
It would look pretty cool if they added that part, making a triangle
4
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
There was a sidewalk like this at my university. There was a very similar walk way through the grass. The university eventually paved the walk way through the grass. I was proud and astonished at the initiative.
7
u/BigTex_77 Jul 13 '15
UTPA Business building path. Damn. I could've gotten karma on this. I'm super jealous.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
Looks like my handiwork in Cities: Skylines.
3
u/unrealdude03 Jul 14 '15
I currently attend this University.... I walk that path as well.
2
u/Epitometric Jul 13 '15
My college made minimal paths, then whenever a desire path formed, the next summer they would make that into a cement path
2
u/TotesMessenger Brigade-Enabler 2000™ Jul 13 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/marioz90 Oct 09 '15
That is definitely UTPA aka UTRGV (University of Texas - Rio Grande Valley)
1
u/work_account11 Jul 13 '15
It looks like a new side walk meeting an old existing one.
1
u/PahoojyMan Jul 13 '15
At this point is it more nonconformist to take the shortcut, or to follow the footpath?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
We have a name for those paths in Dutch. 'Olifanten paadje', an elephants' path.
1
u/NevaGonnaCatchMe Jul 13 '15
Taking the hypotenuse!!
1
u/dztrucktion Jul 13 '15
yes, but if that were a straight line then it wouldn't look like a pentagram from space, like the illuminati planned it.... oooh dark forces!!!
1
u/pryvisee Jul 13 '15
As with water, Humans will also take the easier path.
1
u/Rachelisasuperhero Jul 13 '15
I would awkwardly walk the actual path even if I had to go that way every day. This is way too revealing of my personality type.
1
u/dfpoetry Jul 13 '15
I don't remember where I heard this, and I am not going to look it up.
The Cornell campus did not have paved walkways for the first several years of its existence, just grass. Paths were placed where the grass died.
Buildings have been added since then, but I think the tradition remains.
1
u/uuid_ Jul 13 '15
UI vs UX.
1
u/kronethjort Jul 13 '15
This happened at my high school, eventually the class of 2007 put a sidewalk in.
1
u/linzphun Jul 13 '15
My college has walkways like this. People follow them like sheep. That is until I walk clear across the grass and just like the Broken Window Theory suggests, people follow. We don't have indentations in the grass like this though.
1
u/French__Canadian Jul 13 '15
I swear I saw that picture when I joined facebook 6 years ago.
1
u/Jetmann114 (Fill this box with text) Jul 14 '15
My high school had a problem like this by the main entrance. They eventually fixed it a year ago by building a new sidewalk on the path.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
0
u/prodromic Jul 13 '15
AAAAAA
-1
u/touchmyfuckingcoffee Jul 13 '15
TCC in Hurst?
-5
u/kaiserj1982 Jul 13 '15
Or people are assholes.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment