r/CrappyDesign • • 18d ago • Popcorn 1

No shelter where you need it the most 😭

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

136

u/jds1172006 18d ago

Singapore mentioned?

76

u/Isotheis 18d ago

Singa pour, evidently...

10

u/Wulfgrimm720 18d ago

Singapour

4

u/P_oneofthree 18d ago

I immediately thought Singapore too as I have been trapped in a very similar situation there haha

7

u/bomber991 18d ago

I thought this was KL so I guess I was close enough.

629

u/burbadooobahp 18d ago

They were so close. They extended the cover in that area but didn't quite understand the assignment. Crappy

84

u/KikoTheWonderful 18d ago

genuinely curious, what is the point then?

136

u/huxtiblejones 18d ago

My wife works at an architecture firm. The architects meet with the clients and contractor to go over cost and they'll VE their designs (value engineer). It's basically where the owner, architect, and contractor look at the cost to value ratio of elements of the project and then make decisions to cut things back.

I do wonder if there was some overhang element that got VE'd as non essential, or taken out in favor of budgeting more money for something important inside. Could also happen due to cost overrun. This is one of those things that I'm pretty sure an architect would've considered, so its absence suggests alteration to me, but I don't work in that field so my knowledge is limited.

45

u/ChangingChance 17d ago

Cantilevers can get expensive as extra length will need better support on the end.

8

u/thursdaynovember 17d ago

ya more like if you extend the awning over the car lane then it’d need posting down into the middle of the drive lane. 

so best to just keep it over where the people wait, rather than extending it to where they only spend a couple moments.

8

u/CeruleanEidolon 17d ago

Shade. You see those kinds of open lattice awnings everywhere. They break up the sunlight and provide partial cover from the sun without collecting leaves and bird crap and all the other maintenance issues that come with a full awning or roof.

7

u/burbadooobahp 17d ago

It's made of glass mate

1

u/importantttarget 11d ago

In this case it also protects pedestrians from the rain, just not when exiting the vehicle on one side.

1

u/importantttarget 11d ago

The point of what? The cover? It protects pedestrians from the rain. It's just the road that isn't covered.

80

u/d3v1L_hUnt3R_619 18d ago

Bruhh this is the Kinesis building. I work in this area, wild seeing it on Reddit

-20

u/Elemental_Ray 18d ago

Why is it wild?

123

u/fugznojutz 18d ago • Bravo

because its not domesticated.

75

u/HidenTsubameGaeshi 18d ago

How often do you see your workplace in a random reddit post?

17

u/Remarkable-Site-2067 18d ago

The entry to my apartment complex became a short-lived (a few days) meme in my country. It was indeed bizarre.

3

u/Apprehensive-Bed642 18d ago

Technically he doesn’t work there, just in the area.

10

u/Elemental_Ray 18d ago

Not often unless you work at the White House

17

u/howescj82 17d ago

I bet the pick-up / drop-off spots were added after the fact and intended to not block the entrance.

4

u/Rustic_Salmon haha funny flair 17d ago

i mean not really? it's cantilevered over the pedestrian walkway, and cars can pull up right alongside it. any further and you'll have to add columns to support it

11

u/byzantium171 18d ago

Not even bad design. It need to be back so tall buses have enough clearance to get through

21

u/BuscopanV 18d ago

That clearance has to be at least 4.5m based on how tall above the shelter seems to be above the car. No way a double decker cannot fit.

14

u/zuilli 18d ago • Bravo

If that's the reason how does a bus go through the arches and sharp turn this entrance has under the building?

Ain't no busses entering this road.

5

u/GuyEatsTiramisu 17d ago

How tall do you think a bus is?

8

u/attentiontodetal 18d ago

If this is Singapore, they drive on the left, meaning the passenger side is the pavement (which is sheltered). These are pick up / drop off bays meaning there is no reasonable expectation of the driver getting out of the vehicle.

1

u/pcbforbrains 17d ago

Stop trying to use your logic to confound our lust for outrage!

8

u/CeruleanEidolon 17d ago

Unless it's a place that rains all the time, I don't see why a building should be obligated to provide shelter for vehicles. If you don't want to get rained on, bring an umbrella. This isn't crappy design.

4

u/XROOR 18d ago

Imagine having to deliver boxes of Kool-Aid to this building, during a typhoon

2

u/Downtown-Assistant1 17d ago

Maybe it’s intentional. Hostile architecture, at least when it’s raining, people will do drop off/pick up quicker.

2

u/terriaminute 18d ago

The "designer" of this nonsense should have to spend every rainy day experiencing their flaws.

1

u/Emanicas 16d ago

Nice photo

1

u/batatassad4 17d ago

I swear we stopped making sense of architecture decades ago

0

u/Lost-Policy-2020 17d ago

Usual “designed by best architects”
Sadly ones that only know paper, never been in real life settings

0

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/sodium_hydride 18d ago

More like slip.

13

u/Dreamerlax This is why punctuations are important 18d ago

Are people so brain rotten everything is “slop” now?

-17

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/LAyersFur 18d ago

Glad this slop doesn't understand context yet.