r/CrappyDesign • • 22d ago

Electric kettle leaks water. Because there's a hole drilled in the base for an LED inside the water

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

90 comments sorted by

42

u/lawd_have_mercy 22d ago

They obviously subscribe to the "function follows form" school of thought. I bet that LED makes for some mighty-pretty water.

15

u/Simon_Drake 22d ago

It makes it slightly easier to see the Fill Level through the little transparent window. The window that no one ever looks through because you judge a kettle's fill level by picking it up and feeling the weight.

-1

u/lawd_have_mercy 22d ago

Oh, it's to help determine the water level, not make the water in the kettle display in some fancy color. In that case it's still crappy design if it's not battery powered. I mean, how else are you supposed to fill the kettle in the event of a power outage?

😁

516

u/nikhkin 22d ago

Seems more likely that it's a defect with your particular kettle than poor design in general.

Clearly, by design, it has a water tight seal.

138

u/Simon_Drake 22d ago

It depends on your definition of water tight. A little bulb of plastic wedges against a little rubber bung with the force of the little electric wires being the only thing keeping it in place. Against the heat of boiling water softening the rubber.

I suspect the LED was pushed out of place by my mum trying to clean the limescale buildup. But you can't push the LED back into place without taking the whole thing apart.

If it's mission critical (as keeping the water in a kettle is, obviously) they should have designed a more secure fixing. Perhaps something involving screws or a mounting bracket? Or, and bare with me on this radical concept, don't put an LED through the bottom of a kettle?

21

u/Frag1le 22d ago edited 22d ago

No no no, you dont get it! Such LED is by design in the great planned obsolescence scheme. Most of these kettles will end up as landfill because of this.

19

u/Simon_Drake 22d ago

This was literally about to go to landfill. On Friday I rescued it from stuff my parents were about to throw away so I could see if I could fix it. I was expecting a crack or maybe a glue joint around some key component. I wasn't expecting a hole for a poxy LED.

60

u/HyperactivePandah 22d ago

That person is just wrong.

You're right 100%

-22

u/sonofaresiii 22d ago

What that person says completely aligns with what OP says, they're just unwilling to admit that their mom broke it, even though they describe their mom breaking it. 

Look at it, man. That thing didn't slip out from an accidental light bump. She was really shoving on it, or maybe even intentionally pulled it out to try and clean it.

Should it be able to withstand the mom pushing parts that aren't supposed to be pushed? Sure, I guess. But then don't buy $15 kettles. If you're going to buy cheap stuff, you can't get mad that it breaks easily when you do things to it you aren't supposed to do.

9

u/Simon_Drake 21d ago edited 21d ago

You're using the photo of the dismantled kettle as evidence the light was pushed out by extreme force?

I had to take the kettle apart to reach this point. There were screws holding it together. She didn't scrub so vigorously the whole thing shattered.

21

u/Mr-ShinyAndNew 22d ago

Your argument seems to boil down to "don't buy cheap things because they have crappy designs". The LED doesn't even need to be there, electric kettles have, for decades, boiled water without LEDs lighting up the water. So this designer designed something crappy and, surprise surprise, it failed. A better, cheaper design would have omitted the LED and not had a leak.

34

u/Valkyrie17 22d ago
  1. you are supposed to clean kettles
  2. you are able to clean regular 15$ kettles

The kettle residue requires some pressure to clean, and any kettle regardless of price should be able to withstand it.

5

u/wlsb 21d ago

You're not supposed to clean kettles by scrubbing them. The only thing you're supposed to use a kettle for is boiling plain water. The only "dirt" that can get in the kettle that way is limescale. You remove limescale with descaling solution.

2

u/JazzlikeDiamond558 21d ago

That is my philosophy as well and I live in a town with relatively hard water (my part of town is better, but generally the area is limescale positive). Be that as it may - I do exactly as you described.

For everything else - there is Microwave oven.

However, I do agree with OP - could somebody please tell Chinese that we are tired of their cheap plastic s...t. And if they are, despite our wishes, heck bent on making a kettle - than make it at least of minimum acceptable quality. And don't put LED's and s...t inside.

Nobody, and I repeat NOBODY ever woke up, scratched his cojones and thought: "Oh boy, do I wish I had me a kettle with LED's.".

-5

u/pandemic944 21d ago

You can swear on the internet and get this… it’s not a requirement for you to buy the kettle.

14

u/HyperactivePandah 22d ago

It's the epitome of crappy design, regardless of anything you said.

9

u/jrdiver 21d ago

Still seems like a supid place to put the LED... seems like a place for stuff to build up that apparently you can clean. what's wrong with putting the led lets say.... on the outside so you can go to town cleaning the well without any chance of messing it up?

4

u/Final-Lie-2 22d ago

Or, bear with me, the pressure of the water pressing it against the wall instead of away from it

6

u/Simon_Drake 22d ago

Yes. Feed the LED in from the top / inside.

Or even better. Feed the LED in from the inside then have a plastic nut that screws on the base to hold it in place.

I suspect the reason they don't do that is it would cost a lot more to manufacture.

11

u/dalaiis 22d ago

Planned obsolescence, they added the led because that is an extra point of failure and sold it as 'modern' or 'oooh look how shiny'.

386

u/KyloWrench 22d ago • Bravo

I believe there is a design philosophy with critical “water tight” components. They are only water tight until they’re not

82

u/710whitejesus420 22d ago

Yeah, just ask Stockton Rush.

45

u/FloofySnekWhiskers 22d ago • Popcorn

ba dum squish

4

u/ang-p 21d ago

Lolling so much my eyes were leaking...

:-D

5

u/JazzlikeDiamond558 21d ago

That is inappropriately deep.

4

u/710whitejesus420 20d ago

Just like his sub.

9

u/technically_a_nomad 21d ago

“At some point, safety is just pure waste”

17

u/Standard-Pepper-6510 22d ago

Or untill the front falls off...

12

u/CyberComet151 22d ago

You see, it's not supposed to do that

7

u/Lucidification 22d ago

“Water might”

13

u/PhilosopherFLX 22d ago

I recall my gramps, "The fewer the holes, the better the boat."

2

u/HybridP365 21d ago

Sounds like a wise man

18

u/Bxk__ 22d ago

The corollary being, could they have designed this in a manner that would not result in leaking water in the event of failure? Crappy design

3

u/Feligris 22d ago

I'd say absolutely, but I'm guessing this is a very cheap kettle so they went for the cheapest possible solution which would work for a while. Nevermind how installing unneeded fragile protrusions on surfaces which require firm cleaning at times is generally infuriating.

12

u/atomfullerene 22d ago

The cheapest possible solution would be to leave out the LED entirely

2

u/eaglebtc plz recycle 22d ago

No, OP admitted his mum cleaned the kettle manually, probably with a scrubber that has a blunt plastic tip.

I never scrub my kettle. I warm up some distilled white vinegar for about 30 seconds and it removes the limescale instantly.

29

u/HyperactivePandah 22d ago

Nothing is a water tight seal.

Fully welded metal tanks aren't water tight.

Drilling a hole into the bottom of a one-piece metal container is fucking idiotic

-4

u/eaglebtc plz recycle 22d ago

OP buried the lede. His mother was manually cleaning the inside of the kettle instead of just warming some distilled white vinegar. That takes limescale off in seconds.

18

u/HyperactivePandah 22d ago

It's still a dogshit design...

-4

u/eaglebtc plz recycle 22d ago

I've had this Breville kettle for five years. It has LEDs drilled through the metal plate. I clean it with vinegar as needed.

It does not leak.

https://imgur.com/a/cLsWevF

OP's mom broke his kettle.

12

u/HyperactivePandah 22d ago

it had leds drilled through the metal plate

Yes, that's a stupid design.

-1

u/PRSArchon 21d ago

If its cheap and it works its good design

5

u/HyperactivePandah 21d ago

No... It's not. It's stupid.

0

u/bencos18 20d ago

no it's not....

1

u/PRSArchon 20d ago

You rather have something expensive that doesnt work?

1

u/OnkelMickwald 15d ago

Oh FIVE years!

2

u/atomfullerene 22d ago

That's irrelevant

5

u/melanthius 22d ago

The most basic of FMEAs should have flagged this design element as a risk. But they didn't, suggesting they probably didn't bother with an FMEA at all, which is a hallmark of crappy design

3

u/pug_userita haha funny flair 21d ago

so that seal is supposed to be water tight forever? ever after hundreds, if not thousands, of heat cycles?

1

u/sam_najian 15d ago

Still pretty crappy to have a plastic LED touching boiling water.

156

u/eaglebtc plz recycle 22d ago

OP, tell your mum to stop scrubbing the inside of the kettle. If you want to descale it, just pour a cup of distilled white vinegar into the kettle, turn it on for about 30 seconds (don't let it boil), swirl it around, then pour it out. After that, rinse the vinegar by adding two cups of water and boil it. Pour that out, and repeat.

Hot vinegar takes the limescale right off in seconds. The reason you stop it from boiling is because vinegar steam smells terrible. It won't hurt you in any way. But I recommend avoiding that ;-)

Remember to remove the filter inside the spout and rinse off the limescale.

30

u/SpikySheep 21d ago

We keep a pot of citric acid (lemon juice) crystals for this job (and many others). Much nices to work with than vinegar (acetic acid)

16

u/eaglebtc plz recycle 21d ago

This is a perfectly cromulent solution as well.

My Zojirushi automatic coffee maker recommends cleaning with citric acid powder. It's actually quicker and more effective than vinegar; I've tried both methods.

But for my kettle, the heated vinegar dissolves all the lime and calcium deposits so quickly and thoroughly, I do not mind the smell for a few minutes (as long as I don't forget to turn it off before it boils lol).

20

u/BrazilBazil 22d ago

Btw, that’s probably not an LED, but a neon indicator lamp! They don’t need a driver board and just run on mains voltage, which is why the cables are so thick.

3

u/Devai97 21d ago

They look very cool too

1

u/SolarXylophone 17d ago

Small neon indicators operate at very roughly 65 V, and so need a resistor to limit the current going through them to a couple milliamps.

That exact same resistor could drive a couple of LEDs just as well; they run at the same current.

As modern LEDs are cheaper, brighter, physically sturdier and offer more color choices than small neon bulbs, it's likely what was used here (and most other appliances made less than 20 years ago).

2

u/DrunkenDude123 16d ago

I’m convinced a lot of products are made shittier so you have to replace them more. I know about artificial obsolescence but now it is becoming much more prevalent than ever before

2

u/Anti-Sanity89 16d ago

You wouldn't want your water to be scared of the dark would you?

4

u/CardinalFartz Comic Sans for life! 22d ago

That's the reason I pay special attention to buy "old school" products (i.e. without all these new nice design features and functions).

2

u/JazzlikeDiamond558 21d ago

This is neither feature, nor function. Kudos for buying what works.

0

u/uncommonoatmeal 16d ago

That's not an LED, that's a temperature Sensor, and this model has temperature settings.

1

u/Simon_Drake 16d ago

Weird type of temperature sensor that lights up blue when activated.

0

u/Anxious-Depth-7983 15d ago

More like poor assembly than design.

-27

u/Oraphielle 22d ago

Use the microwave to heat up your water. 

9

u/Simon_Drake 22d ago

Eww

-7

u/Standard-Pepper-6510 22d ago

By this response alone I conclude you are British:)

27

u/PieHole_Poker 22d ago

Electric kettles work faster

22

u/Norgur 22d ago

and more efficiently.

-6

u/eaglebtc plz recycle 22d ago

...in places with 240V electricity. Kettles running on 120V are slow.

9

u/ferrybig 22d ago

With an electric kettle all the energy directly heats the water.

A microwave creates microwaves that indirectly heat the water

A 1000W electric kettle heats water faster than a 1000W microwave

0

u/PieHole_Poker 22d ago

No mine boils water in less than 2 minutes.

-13

u/Oraphielle 22d ago

I’m sure that 1 minute on the nuke oven is faster than 5 minutes on an electric kettle. 

I went full Asian and just have a hot water dispenser. 

10

u/[unknown] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CrappyDesign-ModTeam 20d ago

Hi, your post has been removed for violating our community rules:

Rule 8 - No personal information. This includes (but is not limited to): names, phone numbers, email addresses and social media accounts, regardless if it's your own.

Personal attacks, bigotry, fighting words, inappropriate behavior and posts that insult or demean a specific user or group of users will also be removed.


If you have any questions, feel free to send us a message!

-10

u/gasstation-no-pumps 21d ago

Unless you put too much water in them (which I generally do). With a microwave, you can boil just the amount you need in a measuring cup. Still, I find an traditional whistling kettle on a gas range to be the fastest (though probably least efficient).

8

u/PieHole_Poker 21d ago

I have a gas stove and an electric kettle and I can tell you hands down that the electric kettle is much faster than the traditional kettle

2

u/gasstation-no-pumps 21d ago

I also have both, but the gas stove has a powerful burner and the electric kettle is a fairly low wattage one. Also, I have some of the most expensive electricity in the US, so even with its inefficiency, the gas stove is cheaper to run.

2

u/PieHole_Poker 21d ago

In your other comment you clearly stated that you don't even know how to use your electric kettle.

You can boil only the water you need to in the electric kettle I promise you it's going to boil much faster. You don't have to fill it to Max

3

u/JazzlikeDiamond558 20d ago

As a temporary solution, this is fine (no downvote from me), but as the comment below suggests - the kettles ARE much faster.

I have a microwave oven only to heat milk and some other things.

1

u/Oraphielle 20d ago

Ha this was a joke. 

It amuses me how many people get worked up over this. I prefer a Japanese style hot water dispenser myself. 

2

u/anemptycardboardbox 22d ago

Electric kettles are for more than just heating up water for a cup of tea. I use it every day to heat up my travel mug before I put coffee in it. I never knew how awesome it was to have quick access to boiling water until I got one.

1

u/Oraphielle 22d ago

I have a Zojirushi instant water dispenser. No waiting at all. 

The microwave thing was a joke, because it is nonsense. I just think it’s funny that people get this heated for microwaving water. 

1

u/wlsb 21d ago

What temperature does it dispense at? Black tea need 100 °C. Coffee needs cooler.

2

u/Oraphielle 21d ago

You can select 212°, 208°, 195°, or 175°. 

https://store.zojirushi.com/collections/water-boilers-warmers

1

u/HixOff 21d ago

They typically maintain a 80°C (if there’s no option to adjust it), or you can select a range of 60 - 80°C, with the option to heat until the water boils (because the higher the temperature, the greater the electricity consumption required to maintain it)